9 Ups And 9 Downs From WWE SummerSlam 2018

New champs galore, MITB briefcase gets involved in the main event... sort of.

Roman Reigns Universal Champion
WWE.com

SummerSlam had a tall order to outdo NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn IV, and while it produced several notable and memorable moments, the WWE PPV left a lot to be desired.

Things started out well, and we got a couple nice surprises along the way. We got to see a couple smart title changes, and a smart non-change. There were a couple clever booking decisions, but also some that left you seriously wondering that the agents and producers were smoking.

And then there was the main event, where Roman Reigns and Brock Lesnar were supposed to tangle in an epic match as the next step in their historic rivalry… only that’s not quite what we got. What we did get was a horrific bait-and-switch moment and a hugely disappointing conclusion to the feud that dragged down the entire show in the span of 10 minutes.

Overall, SummerSlam wasn’t bad, and the four-hour show didn’t feel as insufferable as other lengthy PPVs have felt. But it was nowhere near on the level of TakeOver, and it definitely ended on a low note that probably is coloring this review pretty strongly.

With that said, let’s take a look at the moments that worked and the ones that were broken. Let’s get to it…


Downs...

9. Cruiserweights Still Exist

cedric alexander drew gulak
WWE.com

Even if you’re a diehard WWE fan, it can be quite taxing to stay current on Raw (3 hours), SmackDown (2 hours), NXT (1 hour) and 205 Live (1 hour) each week. Something’s gotta give, and odds are the cruiserweights get shorted in that grouping.

So when there’s a WWE Cruiserweight Championship match on PPV – even the kickoff show – you’d think they’d bring their A-game. There was nothing wrong with the title bout between Cedric Alexander and Drew Gulak, but if you were looking to wow the fans and really stand out, this match wasn’t it.

It was a perfectly serviceable match, but it was probably forgotten by the time the opening match of the PPV proper ended. That’s a problem, and that’s a disappointment, because opportunities to impress a larger audience aren’t there too often, and this was a missed chance.


8. B-Team Falls Backward Into Win… Literally

b-team revival
WWE.com

Oh, come on.

What started out as a comedy tag team trying to become a legitimate threat has given way to comedy champs, as the writers now are actively looking for ways to have the B-Team stumble into victories to hold onto their Raw Tag Team Championships.

Sunday, The Revival had things well in control, taking out Curtis Axel early and dominating Bo Dallas. But after a tag to Axel, the complexion of the match changed. However, Scott Dawson grabbed a small package for at least a five count. But the referee was tied up, and then Bo Dallas stumbled backward into the rollup, reversing the small package and allowing the ref to count a victory for Axel.

And just like that, the two-time NXT Tag Team Champions lost due to a clumsy partner. Compare that to the NXT tag title match Saturday night between Undisputed Era and Mustache Mountain… and then groan.


7. The Hardest Part Of The Ring

Dolph Ziggler Seth Rollins DDT
WWE.com

It’s hard to keep track, but the superstars had a near-obsession with the ring apron at SummerSlam.

Almost every match had a highspot on the apron. Just off the top of the head on the apron:

    Jeff Hardy crashed and burned with a Swanton Bomb attempt.
    Dolph Ziggler hit a DDT on Seth Rollins.Samoa Joe wiped out AJ Styles.
    Shinsuke Nakamura hit a kneedrop.

It felt like the superstars saw Velveteen Dream hit a DVD and Purple Rainmaker on the apron at TakeOver and decided that it looked like a good idea. But aren’t there supposed to be agents who prevent repetitious spots throughout the show?

They must’ve taken the night off.


6. Nakamura, Hardy Don’t Click

shinsuke nakamura jeff hardy
WWE.com

On paper, a match between Jeff Hardy and Shinsuke Nakamura should have show-stealing potential.

But in execution, their PPV matches have been huge disappointments. The first was a six-second affair courtesy of a low blow, but this one just never got out of second gear. It felt like they were moving in slow motion, with Nakamura sleepwalking through it and Hardy going through the motions.

Worse yet, the ending consisted of Hardy whiffing on a Swanton Bomb on the apron, allowing Shinsuke to hit a Kinshasa for the win. It was a foolish move that killed off the former United States Champion, and he lost clean.

And then Randy Orton wandered out, walked to the ring… and then walked back up the ramp. Just a pointless moment that added nothing other than to remind us that Orton was there.


5. Rewriting Women’s Evolution

Bellas Alexa Bliss
WWE.com

Fair warning to those who like the Bella Twins: This writer is no fan of the sisters.

The Nikki and Brie made their return to WWE at SummerSlam in a backstage interview where they were asked if they would show up at the all-women’s PPV Evolution, and they instead talked about all the TV shows and YouTube channels they are on.

But the cardinal sin was Brie referencing that the Bellas were at the forefront of the “women’s evolution.”

*ahem* Let’s call everyone’s attention to the match that really started everything, a 30-second tag match involving… the Bella Twins.

They literally were the poster children of everything wrong with the Divas division, more reality TV stars than wrestlers. They were dragged along in the Divas Revolution/Women’s Evolution movement by everyone else (Paige, Charlotte Flair, Sasha Banks, Becky Lynch).

So for them to come back and try to glom onto the women’s evolution deal as being pioneers… no way.


4. Much Ado About Absolutely Nothing

kevin owens braun strowman
WWE.com

So after weeks of playing up the stipulation of how Braun Strowman could lose his Money in the Bank briefcase if he lost in any capacity, the Monster Among Men went out and squashed former Universal Champion Kevin Owens in about two minutes flat.

What the actual hell?

Look, if WWE was trying to make Braun look really strong for later on, then that’s one thing. But when you do something like that, it makes fans wonder if there’s some punitive measure being taken against KO, who literally got one offensive move, a superkick that Strowman shrugged off.

One match won’t indicate that Owens is being de-pushed, but it’s worth noting that aside from his fluke win against Braun at Extreme Rules, KO’s last televised win came three months ago. Remember when this was the guy who beat John Cena in his debut match? Yeah.

And this is coming from someone who is a big fan of Braun Strowman, by the way.


3. An ‘Epic’ Main Event

brock lesnar roman reigns
WWE.com

On one hand, it’s safe to say that fans didn’t care to see another lengthy WWE Universal Championship match between Brock Lesnar and Roman Reigns that played out more like a video game than a real wrestling match.

But still, the main event of one of the company’s main PPVs of the year was largely a joke, with the offense consisting entirely of three Superman punches, three German suplexes, two guillotines (and two slams to escape) and four spears. Any other offense was waged on Brawn Strowman (more on that later).

And just like that, the epic three-year feud between Brock and Roman is seemingly over, as is Lesnar’s mind-numbing 504-day reign. The match was awful, with fans appropriately chanting, “You both suck!” at them. But hey, we got that great sit-down interview with Paul Heyman that ultimately meant absolutely nothing, so there you go.


2. While We’re On The Subject…

Brock Lesnar Return
WWE.com

If this is how WWE was going to end Brock Lesnar’s 16-month Universal Championship reign, then why the hell didn’t they pull the trigger sooner?

If this was the best they could muster, then it’s obvious that the company’s decision at WrestleMania 34 was a colossal mistake. Everything was primed for Roman Reigns to have his big coronation and finally topple Lesnar, ending a year-long reign as champ. Instead, we got two more matches, each one shorter and more disappointing than the previous one.

WM 34 was bad in that it was just a series of finishing moves, and with fans resigned to accept Roman’s title win, Brock won in a shocker. Then at Greatest Royal Rumble, Brock retained in a cage match in the most backhanded way possible, with Reigns running around for four months telling everyone his feet hit the floor first, so he was the uncrowned champ.

It’s obvious now (as if it wasn’t four months ago) that WWE’s idea bin was empty when it came to this feud, but that didn’t stop them from stretching it out and throwing every curveball they could (Paul Heyman’s sit-down interview, pepper-spraying Roman, Brock attacking GM Kurt Angle) to make fans care.

Ultimately, Lesnar directly telling fans he hates them and not showing his face for months made them want him to go away, and thus “accept” Reigns by default. That was it.


1. WWE Actively Trolls Fans

Braun Strowman Brock Lesnar Roman Reigns
WWE.com

Maybe Vince McMahon should just come out onto the stage and moon the crowd for four hours if he wants to show fans how he really feels.

After Braun Strowman demolished Kevin Owens to retain his Money in the Bank briefcase, the Monster Among Men came out before the main event started and declared that he was going to cash in the contract on the winner of the WWE Universal Championship match. Fans in Brooklyn were delighted, as most weren’t too keen on Brock Lesnar or Roman Reigns leaving SummerSlam with the title.

But then during the match, Reigns and Lesnar wiped out Strowman, and he was never heard from again. Seriously, Brock hit him with an F-5, the briefcase and steel chair and that was it for a guy booked as nearly invincible for two years. And then the PPV ended with Roman celebrating his “hard-fought” victory in a complete troll job of fans.

They bait-and-switched on a MITB cash-in from one of the most popular wrestlers on the roster and closed with one of the most despised babyfaces victorious. At least with Vince mooning you know WWE is showing you their arse.


Ups...

9. At Least The Men Didn’t Lose

andrade cian almas zelina
WWE.com

A mixed-tag team match on the kickoff show shouldn’t be graded on the same scale as the main event of SummerSlam, so with that low bar in mind, we’ll give an “up” to the match pitting Rusev and Lana against Andrade “Cien” Almas and Zelina Vega.

The match itself wasn’t anything special, with the men handling the bulk of the wrestling before turning it over to the women. Lana dominated with some basic moves and looked to be closing in on victory before Almas provided a distraction, allowing Vega to get a rollup (with the ropes) for the win.

Even though it’s a loss, it doesn’t really reflect on Rusev, but it really is crazy to think that he’s gone from a WWE Championship match to a mixed-tag match on the kickoff show in one month.


8. Ambrose Neutralizes McIntyre

Dean Ambrose Drew Galloway
WWE.com

For all the talk that Dean Ambrose was going to turn on Seth Rollins and cost him the Intercontinental Championship, that thankfully didn’t happen Sunday night.

Ambrose did his job perfectly, keeping Drew McIntyre at bay. The Scottish Psychopath has been the deciding factor in the ongoing Rollins/Dolph Ziggler feud, and Seth brought his Shield brethren to provide backup. Rather than pull the “shocking” swerve of Dean turning on him, Ambrose simply did his job and kept McIntyre from interfering.

And that neutralization allowed Rollins to defeat Ziggler and win the title. It was a pretty simple, straightforward storyline, but when you throw in the quality of the match (more on that later), it works just fine.


7. Women’s Triple Threat All Action

becky lynch charlotte flair carmella
WWE.com

Carmella as SmackDown Women’s Champion has been a poor man’s version of the Honky Tonk Man’s Intercontinental Championship reign. She clearly was outmatched by her opponents but managed to hang onto her title in bouts that underwhelmed.

But with Charlotte Flair and Becky Lynch challenging ‘Mella in a triple threat, it was a recipe for success, with the two veterans guiding the fast-paced match through a series of near-falls and submission holds. Lynch hit a top rope legdrop to break up a Figure-Four, and Charlotte nailed a twisting moonsault to the floor. Carmella even busted out a suicide dive and held up her end of the bout.

In the end, it was Charlotte hitting Natural Selection on Becky while she had Carmella in a Disarm-her. Just like that, Charlotte is a seven-time women’s champion. That was all good, but even better, it led to…


6. Becky’s Breaking Point

becky lynch charlotte flair
WWE.com

After playing the happy-go-lucky babyface for a good while, it was finally about time for Becky Lynch to lose it.

Lynch might be the first-ever SmackDown Women’s Champion, but she hasn’t sniffed the gold in a loooong time. So with title shots not going her way, she was clearly upset that Charlotte Flair found a way into her SummerSlam match against Carmella.

Worse yet, Flair broke up Becky’s Disarm-her on Carmella, hitting Natural Selection to pin Lynch for the title. That proved too much for the Irish Lass-kicker, who hugged and then attacked Charlotte, leaving her down and out.

Becky needed an edge to her, and this was a perfect reason for it. One thing worth noting is that Lynch doesn’t need to go “full-on heel.” This could work just as well with Becky showing more shades of grey, just outright hating Charlotte and only caring about winning the title. They’ll probably just have her sneer and be a villain, but it’s worth making the case here.


5. Demon Squash City

Finn Balor Baron Corbin
WWE.com

Well, we have to give it to WWE: They at least followed through on a storyline properly.

For a good while, we’ve had to endure Baron Corbin making size jokes at Finn Balor’s expense, despite Balor being a world-class wrester and Corbin being a world-class underachieving choke artist. It all seemed to be building to a head, but their match at SummerSlam wasn’t anything anyone was really looking forward to.

Enter The Demon.

Without warning, Balor unleashed his war-painted Demon side on Corbin, sending the Barclays Center into a frenzy at the unexpected surprise and causing Baron to likely soil himself. Finn ran over the constable in rapid fashion, obliterating Corbin and defeating him to pay off the storyline of Balor being too small and not measuring up.

And for those saying it’s hypocritical to applaud this squash and boo the other, the storyline for this one worked perfectly, while the other was just a straight squash out of nowhere that didn’t fit the storyline going into the match.


4. Miz, Bryan Finally Clash

Daniel Bryan The Miz
WWE

One of WWE’s longest ongoing storylines, the rivalry between The Miz and Daniel Bryan finally collided in the ring Sunday, and it didn’t disappoint.

The story is fairly well known: Miz was Bryan’s pro during the contest phase of NXT in 2010, with the Awesome One berating his rookie regularly. Fast-forward to SmackDown with Bryan as the retired wrestler-turned-GM and Miz laying into him on Talking Smack. They’ve been at odds with each other for eight years and only have clashed in the ring a handful of times.

At SummerSlam, we got what has to be the first of this reignited rivalry, with Miz and Bryan going toe-to-toe. Miz hung with Daniel, who was on fire through much of the match. At one point, the two traded Yes Kicks, but Bryan leaned into Miz’s copycat version and dropped his former pro.

In the end, Miz grabbed a pair of brass knuckles (or some other foreign object) from wife Maryse at ringside and laid out Bryan for the three count. It was disappointing for the Yes Movement, but it was necessary for the feud to continue. And this is one feud you want to continue.


3. Rollins, Ziggler Pick Up Where NXT Left Off

seth rollins drew galloway
WWE.com

After NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn IV ended, the one question coming into Sunday was whether WWE could follow that act.

The first match on the main SummerSlam card sure as hell tried to do just that, as Seth Rollins and Dolph Ziggler had a pretty good opening match for the Intercontinental Championship. The two see-sawed back and forth throughout, with Rollins’ athletic prowess on full display. Ziggler dropped Seth with a jumping DDT on the apron and later turned a frogsplash into a pin attempt.

But it was Rollins, who hit an inverted superplex/side slam combo before winning with a superkick/curbstomp duo, who managed to pull out the win, capturing his second IC title.

It was a solid opening match that got fans into the PPV and guaranteed at least one bout rose to the level of TakeOver the night before.


2. Familiarity Breeds Contempt… And A Good Match

Samoa Joe AJ Styles
WWE.com

AJ Styles and Samoa Joe have traveled in the same circles for a long time, so it was no surprise that their match for the WWE Championship at SummerSlam was bordering on a classic before it ended abruptly.

The two unloaded on each other with everything in their arsenal, pitting AJ’s speed against Joe’s brute strength. The match started a little slow but quickly ramped up. No one would have been surprised if Joe had walked out the with the title.

But Joe had been tormenting Styles for weeks about his family, and then taunted AJ’s wife in the audience before the match… and then again during the bout. That proved too much for the champ, who clotheslined Joe off the announce desk and through the timekeeper’s area, then waffled him with a steel chair for the DQ.

A disqualification finish in a world title match on PPV typically would garner a “down” here on its own, match quality be damned. But considering that this was their first WWE encounter and Joe’s mindgames were central to the storyline, it actually made sense. This likely means we’ll see a no-DQ match between them next, which is just fine with us.


1. Rousey Dominates Bliss

Ronda Rousey Alexa Bliss
WWE

While the WWE Universal Championship was a booking disaster, they got the Raw Women’s Championship match exactly right.

“Rowdy” Ronda Rousey basically ran through champ Alexa Bliss, offering Bliss an opportunity to attack her from behind (Alexa grabbed a chinlock to no avail) and then destroying her with her spinning Samoan drops and judo throws before locking in an armbar for the submission victory.

Sure, there’s a legit question about whether Rousey is “ready” to be champion, but there’s also the adage about striking while the iron is hot. Ronda is probably the most mainstream superstar WWE has right now, and waiting until she is “ready” to carry the division wasn’t an option.

Truth be told, WWE has done a good job protecting her thus far, and if they can continue to do that, then more power to the company in moving forward with Rousey as women’s champion.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.