9 Ways WWE Owes A Debt To UFC

These days a work has to pretend to be a shoot in order to work.

Tazz Tazzmission Kurt Angle.jpg
WWE.com

Regardless of what your Vince McMahons, your John Cenas and your Triple Hs have to say on the subject, the rise of mixed martial arts as a credible sporting spectacle in the last twenty years or so has had a profound effect on professional wrestling.

That’s not to say that professional mixed martial arts haven’t stolen liberally from pro wrestling, just like boxing did back in the day. The fighters that make the most money tend to be the ones with catchy nicknames and catchier catchphrases, good hype artists who can trash talk at a press conference and start a believable ruck at a weigh-in.

Every time I see a Conor McGregor or a Chael Sonnen mouthing off and getting everybody talking, I see the shadowy outlines of CM Punk, ‘Rowdy’ Roddy Piper and The Rock standing behind them like dead g*ddamn Jedi. 

But to say that it’s a one way street is ridiculous and patently false.

In 2016, pro wrestling in general and the WWE in particular owes more than a little to mixed martial arts and the UFC. Here’s a few examples of how that debt has expressed itself onscreen and in the ring.

9. The Clothes Make The Man

The Undertaker Pose
WWE.com

Before MMA, and UFC in particular, the in-ring gear for pro wrestlers followed one of two patterns. It was either the usual variations on tights and trunks (the kind of gear that wrestlers have worn since the year dot) or it was a variation on the kind of clothes that people wore in real life, customised for the ring - suits, jeans, uniforms, you know the kind of thing.

The look of a character is key in establishing certain basic assumptions about them, and when elements of legitimate fighting gear are used in a professional wrestler’s attire, you can bet it’s because they want the crowd to make those associations with legitimate competition.

In moving towards that appearance of legitimacy, plenty wrestlers now ape the functional and stylistic conventions of mixed martial arts in their gear.

Rusev went barefoot for some time (representing the character’s supposed Muay Thai roots), Brock Lesnar still dresses for the Octagon, and Kevin Owens, the so-called prizefighter, also wears baggier boxing/MMA style shorts.

Wrestlers have been taping their wrists for additional support for a long time now, but relatively recently there’s been a spate of performers who - like CM Punk - taped their wrists and fists for both support and grip, and also for the appearance of legitimate toughness.

The idea is that, just as with boxers, the taped fist/wrist protects the hand from injuries that might be sustained while punching someone a whole hell of a lot.

Similarly, The Undertaker first began wearing MMA gloves at the end of 2001 to help denote the transition between his American Badass babyface character and the bullying heel Big Evil character.

Since then, plenty of others have followed suit: the gloves are designed to protect the hands while punching yet still allow grappling.


8. Something In The Way You Move

Triple H Undertaker WrestleMania 27 XXVII Finish Hell's Gate
WWE.com

Because MMA is legitimate fighting, certain of the more vicious or dangerous moves (like punches to the back of the head, groin attacks, eye gouging and more) are banned and can result in the match being stopped temporarily or permanently, points being deducted, or in a worst case scenario a disqualification and career ramifications for the fighter concerned.

WWE, like many other pro wrestling organisations, often makes a big deal out of banning certain moves. Some are legitimately outlawed - in WWE, wrestlers wanting to perform moves thought of as high-risk, like the piledriver or the shooting star press, have to prove that they can be trusted to perform it on a regular basis in order to get the green light. It’s just basic common sense, as with the banned moves in MMA.

Then there’s the storyline ‘illegal’ manoeuvres. Unfair positioning is censured, with the aforementioned five-count - if you have your opponent backed into the ropes or against the turnbuckle, you have a five-count to back off and allow them to move.

Similarly, Orton’s punt to the head was kayfabe banned, as was the Undertaker’s Hell’s Gate submission move, because they were supposedly too dangerous and could do far worse than end a match.

That’s the WWE using pro wrestling storytelling to sell a move as being legit and lethal, and to therefore sell the bout taking place as being as legitimate as a mixed martial arts bout.

The big one, of course, is the simple punch. For decades, the closed fist was supposedly banned by the WWWF/WWF/WWE, as well as many, many other wrestling promotions.

That’s the reason for replacement moves like the forearm smash. Throwing a punch usually mandated an official warning by the referee before any potential disqualification.

Around August 2008, about when the Big Show began using the KO punch as a finisher, it became apparent that WWE had quietly legalised punching with the closed fist.

With the massive rise in MMA’s popularity disallowing a punch seemed ridiculous, and hadn’t been cause for a disqualification for some time.


7. The Shoot Fight To End All Shoot Fights

brawl for all
WWE.com

Literally, in this case, because the WWE were never stupid enough to allow idiocy like the Brawl For All to take place again.

I’ve already gone into a fair amount of detail about the tournament itself, which was conceived in 1998 as an attraction, nothing more. Scuttlebutt (like gossip with a good right hand) had it that it was created to get incoming wrestling legend ‘Dr. Death’ Steve Williams over quickly with the WWF crowd, in order that he could be slotted into a feud with ‘Stone Cold’ Steve Austin.

That’s something that all the boys felt, anyway, although it’s been strongly denied by those who worked in the office at the time.

With the rising popularity of mixed martial arts and the UFC, the Brawl For All was originally intended to be similar to an MMA-style set-up, although it was quickly decided to change a good deal of the rules in order to avoid falling foul of the local athletic commissions that were giving the UFC such a hard time in those days.

It ended up being a lot like a local ‘Toughman’ competition: the ‘rules’ (if you can call them that) allowed for one minute rounds and points for takedowns, with no submissions allowed. The boys wore massive 16-ounce gloves, which made anything more complicated than basic brawling-style grappling an impossibility.

Even today, people are divided over how much of the scoring was worked, with participant Bob Holly recording in his memoir The Hardcore Truth that he was convinced that, if the fight was legit, then none of the judge’s scoring was.

Regardless, the whole idea was a horrible mistake. It’s saying something that the guy that proposed the Brawl For All to Vince McMahon, professional wrestling muppet Vince Russo, still thinks that it was a great plan and would do it again tomorrow if he had it over again, while everyone else involved still can’t believe it was greenlit to begin with.

When Russo likes it, it’s a guaranteed turkey.


6. The Rise And Fall Of The Fake Submission Hold

Brock Lesnar Kimura Shawn Michaels
WWE.com

Back in the day (and I mean long, long ago), wrestling was less fake than you might think. The most famous wrestlers were ones with extensive grappling and submission experience - what people called ‘hookers’ - rather than big, flashy-looking guys.

Wrestling began the move towards being a fully worked performance with the prominence of the Gold Dust Trio: Toots Mondt invented so many of the moves we know today that he’s pretty much the father of modern pro wrestling.

That said, it was television that demanded style over substance, it was cable television that demanded flash and panache, and it was the globalisation of that larger wrestling audience that demanded bigger, better, faster and more of all of it. That’s one of the side effects of increased exposure: familiarity breeds contempt, creating a constant need to up the ante.

Submissions didn’t escape this shift into nonsense, with great looking but ridiculous moves becoming the norm: for example, Frank Gotch’s vicious toehold developed a spinning motion and exaggerated heaving actions under Dory Funk and his sons.

That’s what characterised the ‘fake’ submission hold in wrestling from that moment on: an elaborate, theatrical set-up, and large, gonzo facial expressions and movements to appeal to the cheap seats and those at home.

MMA, and the huge rise in popularity of UFC continues to change all of that. Grandiose fooling about is less and less acceptable with submissions, simply because far too many people have seen real submissions applied now, and a simple armbar winning Ronda Rousey her title fights in seconds.

These days, Brock Lesnar’s kimura is one of the most feared submissions in wrestling, and the Undertaker’s Hell’s Gate - a gogoplata variation - has been portrayed as being pretty much unstoppable.

Both moves are slapped on in seconds, and the drama comes from the legitimate appearance of the move, not the ostentatious way in which they’re applied.

Substance has made a comeback over style.


5. The Real Extreme Rules

brock lesnar john cena extreme rules
WWE.com

Brock Lesnar’s debut match upon returning to the WWE was at Extreme Rules in April 2012, against John Cena, the face of the company.

Cena might have come up at the same time as Lesnar, but when Brock left WWE in 2004, Cena stayed. By Extreme Rules in 2012, Cena had been the top guy in the company for seven long years, crushing the backbreaking schedule that had defeated Lesnar.

It mirrored the situation in 2008 at UFC 81, in Lesnar’s first ever UFC bout against Frank Mir. Back then, Lesnar was a fearsome monster from the pro wrestling world, a decorated amateur wrestler, a natural athlete and a brute in the flesh, abnormally fast and strong... but his UFC debut was only his second ever pro MMA fight.

This contrasted with his opponent, who had a 10:3 professional fight history, and had already commanded some impressive record-setting performances in the octagon.

The narrative of the match was identical to his WWE comeback match against Cena. It was the unstoppable challenger with the intimidating reputation, setting foot into an unfamiliar situation against a veteran opponent: the arrogant overconfidence in his own ability, the ruthless dominance that bore that confidence out, and the upset victory of the wily veteran over the challenger right at the last minute.

And just as happened in his second bout against Mir over the UFC Heavyweight Championship at UFC 100, Lesnar’s SummerSlam 2014 match against Cena for the WWE World Heavyweight Championship was pretty much a one-sided mauling.

Neither man would get much of a look-in against Lesnar in these much-fêted rematches - Mir was pounded to hamburger, and as for Cena, Los Angeles hadn’t seen that many Germans in one place since Oktoberfest at the Fairplex the previous year...


4. Stop! Hammertime

Chris Jericho Shawn Michaels Great American Bash 2008.jpg
WWE.com

There’s a worldwide misconception that, in boxing, when things are going spectacularly badly for one of the parties involved, all his trainers have to do is throw a towel into the ring to forfeit the match, regardless of whether that’s what their fighter wants.

That’s not actually the case: it’s the referee, and only the referee, that makes the decision to stop a boxing match, and there have been occasions when the ref has simply thrown the towel straight back at them and ignored the plea.

In the same way, only the referee has the authority to stop a mixed martial arts fight. However, fights are ended via stoppage as a matter of course in MMA.

On at least two occasions the old ‘throw in the towel’ trope has been used in the WWF/E as a direct reference to the supposed practice in boxing: it’s how Bob Backlund lost the WWF Championship to the Iron Sheik at Christmas 1983, ending a near six year title reign, and was the basis for a submission-gimmicked Backlund vs. Bret Hart match at Survivor Series 1994.

‘Stone Cold’ Steve Austin’s loss to Bret Hart at WrestleMania 13 was by referee stoppage: the referee in question was former UFC champion Ken Shamrock, who awarded Hart the victory when Austin passed out in the Sharpshooter rather than submit.

In WCW in 1999, Sid Vicious’ US title was awarded to Goldberg after the referee stopped their match at Halloween Havoc due to Sid’s excessive blood loss - although, to be fair, that’s probably because it was the first card Vince Russo booked for the company, and the man’s more clueless than a blind policeman with no hands.

The WWE’s inconsistent application of kayfabe rules for disqualification has made this kind of finish a waste of time until recently, as a stoppage finish, by definition, cannot occur if the damage was caused illegally.

Stoppage occurred in Chris Jericho and Shawn Michaels’ incredibly personal feud in 2008: Jericho targeted HBK’s previously injured eye at the Great American Bash, and Michaels simply wouldn’t stop beating an unconscious and helpless Jericho during an Unsanctioned blow-off match at Unforgiven, causing the referee to intervene even though the bout’s gimmick allowed it.

In both cases, legal damage caused the stoppage, so the win was awarded to the damaging party, just as in MMA.

Upon his reintroduction to the WWE in spring 2012, Matt Bloom’s Lord Tensai character was said to have crushed his opponents in Japan so badly that referee stoppage was the norm. He proceeded to do so to several of his initial opponents in the WWE before the company gave up on his monster heel push.

Of course, the most famous examples of referee stoppage due to TKO in recent WWE history are Kevin Owens’ definitive defeat of NXT Champion Sami Zayn last year to win the title, and the Undertaker’s heelish victory over Brock Lesnar at SummerSlam a few months later, where Lesnar passed out in the Hell’s Gate submission.


3. Putting A Shoot Over A Work

Ronda Rousey Stephanie McMahon
WWE.com

One of the ongoing effects that the popularity of mixed martial arts has had on WWE storytelling is a little more subtle, but far more alarming and wide-ranging.

It’s the emphasis of MMA in WWE, and it’s been going on for years without anyone really realising it.

You’ll have heard Jim Ross, in particular, listing the pre-WWE athletic credentials of certain WWE performers while at the announcer’s desk, citing the amateur wrestling careers of people like Jack Swagger and Dolph Ziggler.

It’s something that’s done with worked experience, too: CM Punk’s fake Muay Thai experience was lauded upon his debut in WWECW in 2006, and Wade Barrett’s bare knuckle boxing career was so thoroughly set up in interviews and biographical information that there are still thousands of fans worldwide that believe that it’s real.

Of course, until very recently WWE had a blanket policy of refusing to acknowledge a performer’s prior professional wrestling experience and accolades. If it was referenced at all, it would be with a condescending sneer, such as the many occasions when CM Punk and Daniel Bryan were contemptuously referred to as ‘internet darlings’.

The problem, of course, is that within the television storylines and the continuity they generate, the WWE is a professional fighting league the equal of the UFC.

Within the context of those storylines, someone with a dozen years of worked WWE experience - like John Cena at Extreme Rules in 2012 - should be treated as senior to someone like Brock Lesnar, who in 2012 had five years pro wrestling experience and eight MMA fights over a four-and-a-half year period.

The WWE’s insistence on emphasising real and worked mixed martial arts credentials - Muay Thai, BJJ, collegiate wrestling, etc etc - of their stars over their pro wrestling experience simply makes the WWE itself look weaker by comparison.

In kayfabe terms, Brock Lesnar’s UFC Heavyweight Championship isn’t any bigger a deal than the WWE World Heavyweight Championship, yet it’s consistently mentioned with far more reverence on WWE television.

Similarly, Ronda Rousey fronting up to the Authority with The Rock at WrestleMania 31 was loudly proclaimed by Dwayne Johnson to be the WrestleMania ‘moment’ of the night, and Triple H bumped out of the ring for her improvised judo throw like he’d been shot out of a cannon.

One of Vince McMahon’s main criteria for pushing a WWE performer is if he believes that they look like they could win a fight. Back in 1998, ‘Stone Cold’ was booked to appear to be on the same level as Mike ‘baddest man on the planet’ Tyson.

Well, now the goalposts have shifted: mixed martial artists are officially the baddest men and women on the planet, and thanks to the company’s insistence on bigging up these shooters over their own stars, the worked hardcases of the WWE are looking pretty weedy in comparison.


2. The Tap Out

Jamie Noble Submission
WWE.com

For a long time now, the officially mandated ‘correct’ way to submit in a WWE ring is by tap out - but that wasn’t always the case.

In point of fact, it’s only been for the last two decades that the tap has taken precedence. In the old days, the performer would have to tell the referee that they quit, or nod. That’s why old school guys like Jericho still scream “Ask him!” at the ref when they have the submission locked in.

Although some point to former UFC champion Ken Shamrock’s arrival in the WWF as the time that the tap out first began to be used in pro wrestling, it’s actually Taz - radio host, wrestling announcer and former baddest man in ECW - who has the distinction of being the person to introduce tapping out from the world of MMA into the world of professional wrestling.

Taz himself brought in his lethal submission move, the Tazzmission, from judo, where it’s called the kata ha jime. The move was so violent and controlled the neck and jaw so completely, that a traditional submission simply wouldn’t work. The audience couldn’t see the victim speak and he couldn’t nod.

As they frequently did in those days, WWE saw something they liked that worked in ECW, and a year or so after Taz began to do his thing in ECW, they brought in a version to make some money for themselves.

Their ‘version’ was former pro wrestler and genuine MMA megastar Ken Shamrock, who broke new ground in portraying worked variations on MMA disciplines in a pro wrestling/sports entertainment context, part of which was the tap out as a more legitimate-seeming way of acquiescing to a submission hold.

As Tazz in the WWF/E, Peter Senerchia never really got a chance to show the world what he was capable of, and people who never watched the real, original ECW may not have seen what others did in him.

It’s a shame because the guy was money in the ring, and a true pioneer.


1. The Return Of Professional Wrestling

shinsuke nakamura
WWE.com

With the massive popularity of the UFC, the death of kayfabe and the audience for WWE’s version of professional wrestling beginning to dwindle, there’s an ever-greater need for WWE to assist the casual audience in suspending their disbelief, to be able to enjoy a pro wrestling match without automatically thinking that it looks ridiculous.

The additional realism that pro wrestling needs to maintain has always been a part of the sport. It's only in the last couple of decades that the flashier, more cartoonish moves have removed part of that realism from wrestling.

But wrestling has always been adaptable: and just as the advent of cable television required wrestling to add still more flash and panache to sell it to an increasingly jaded audience, so now the ubiquity of MMA and the UFC may be necessitating a move away from some of the more nonsensical traditions of sports entertainment, narrowing the perceived gap between legit competition and worked competition.

Back in the days of kayfabe, pro wrestling was treated as a genuine fighting challenge - Bruno Sammartino famously didn’t want to take on his protégé Larry Zybysko in 1980 because the man was family, and to fight him, Sammartino would have to want to hurt him.

Sports entertainment will always be a part of the WWE: but professional wrestling is also making a sneaky comeback within the organisation, as performers with a grounding in other disciplines and from non-WWE backgrounds are coming up in the organisation without having to stick to the generic punch-kick WWE house style that used to be the focus of all WWE developmental training.

And that’s down to the influence of MMA, of the astonishing popularity of the UFC. WWE is nothing if not versatile. The evolution of professional wrestling isn’t over yet.


Contributor
Contributor

Professional writer, punk werewolf and nesting place for starfish. Obsessed with squid, spirals and story. I publish short weird fiction online at desincarne.com, and tweet nonsense under the name Jack The Bodiless. You can follow me all you like, just don't touch my stuff.