9 Wrestling Gimmicks That Took YEARS To Get Over

They all got there in the end, but 'Megastars', Gunns, and 'Monsters' all took YEARS to get over!

LA Knight WWE
WWE.com

Outside of the odd celebrity or crossover star here or there, it often takes stars years and a ton of trial and error to get a gimmick properly over in this ever-changing wrasslin' industry.

Before he was whippin' ass and stompin' mud holes dry, Steve Austin was going nowhere as the 'Ringmaster'.

In the time pre-'Doctor of Thuganomics', John Cena's "Ruthless Aggression" schtick almost got him fired.

And even 'The Man' only came around after a few years of trying and failing to really get anywhere as a 'Lasskicker'.

However, there are those performers who simply refused to give up trying to make one particular character/gimmick work. And after years of perseverance and creatively tweaking a persona they knew would one day help them stand out from the crowd, this lot only went and bloody did it!

So, get ready to be inspired, folks, because this bunch of anything but overnight successes all managed to eventually establish themselves as some of the most dominant, exciting, and popular stars in the game after years of hard work... or being crammed down fans' throats.

Either way, they all got there in the end, and that's all that counts!

9. Boogs Was Occasionally Turning Heads In Developmental And On YouTube For Years

Eric Bugenhagen Rik Bugez
WWE

He may have largely disappeared from WWE programming recently, but coming into WrestleMania 38 Rick Booooooogs had remarkably become one of the most entertaining mid-card performers on the roster, teaming with Shinsuke Nakamura as the two battled The Usos.

And while it may have taken years for WWE to finally realise what they had with the meaty ball of guitar-shredding charisma that is this moustached titan, the folks taking in weekly episodes of NXT back in 2019 quickly knew there was something special about this lad.

The Full-Sail crowd were well up for the Eric Bugenhagen party, rocking out with the screeching hero when he occasionally popped up on the black and gold brand.

When he wasn't given the chance to pop NXT crowds in the ring or be the most distracting main roster extra the PC had to offer during the pandemic, Boogs was also turning heads with his explosive personality on his YouTube channel; his "I NEED A HERO" workout is a work of hulking art.

Boogs then only went and ended up in a couple of random WWE Old Spice commercials, with that latest reminder of how captivating this 'Night Panther' had always been giving Vince McMahon no choice but to call the massive talent up immediately. And from there, it didn't take long for the main roster crowd to fall in love with the charming powerhouse, too...


8. The Gunns Are Finally Up After Being All Elite Since 2020

Gunn Club
AEW

Having Billy Gunn has a father always ensured that both Austin and Colten would be somewhat popular with the All Elite faithful during their early days with the company.

However, despite clearly being two lads who boasted the same sort of giddy energy and personality as their old man, the pair never really found their own identities whilst working as part of the Gunn Club.

And it was only after walking away from an alliance with The Acclaimed a few years into their run on the AEW roster when the brothers started to really grow and find themselves as a tag unit.

Sure, they definitely weren't ready to hold AEW World Tag Team gold when they shockingly bested Max Caster and Anthony Bowens for the belts in February of this year.

But that victory helped give the two heelish siblings the confidence to further commit to being a set of gloriously cocky pr*cks who are only getting more brilliantly annoying by the week alongside Jay White and Juice Robinson as part of Bullet Club Gold.

It took them a few years to step out of their degenerate father's shadow and cement themselves as one of the most entertaining teams on the AEW roster, but their always outrageous Collision antics were well worth the wait.


7. It Took Braun Strowman A While To Shake Off His Wyatt Family

Braun Strowman Roman Reigns
WWE.com

It's pretty clear what WWE were going for when it came to Braun Strowman's initial main roster debut in 2015.

"Here's an absolutely MASSIVE bloke!"

"Watch him man-handle the mighty Roman Reigns and Dean Ambrose!"

"Look at how terrifying his cold, dead eyes are!"

'The Monster Among Men' didn't really do much to convince audiences that he was anything more than Vince McMahon's latest monster of the month during that first year alongside Bray Wyatt, Luke Harper and Erick Rowan, though, with Strowman then being unceremoniously split from his family during the 2016 Draft.

And while many understandably assumed that this could be the beginning of the end for the powerful giant, Strowman remarkably began making an impact in more ways than one on Monday Night Raw as a singles worker.

His thrilling squashes were dynamic and quickly became weekly red show highlights.

As the weeks turned into months, the new-hairstyle-sporting juggernaut eventually became an unlikely fan-favourite as he tore through the likes of Sami Zayn and Roman Reigns before ultimately colliding with Brock Lesnar over the Universal Championship.

He may not have set pulses racing during those early Samwell Tarly with a Superman tattoo days. But once he was given the chance to roar his way through the roster on his own and flip a few vehicles, fans soon couldn't resist boarding the Strowman Express.


6. Roman Reigns Finally Becomes The "Top Guy" After Six Years Of Trying

Roman Reigns black and white
WWE.com

Throughout The Shield's run as the main roster's 'Hounds of Justice', it was painfully clear exactly who WWE felt was their undisputed top guy of tomorrow.

And for a while, fans were quite happy to back Roman Reigns during his days of wrecking The Wyatt Family and Evolution. However, once the unit dramatically split in 2014, fans quickly grew tired of the 'Big Dog' character and simply would not accept the new chosen one as their top babyface in the years that followed.

Even after announcing that his leukaemia was back in remission, that respectful period of support for the Joe beneath the tactical vest eventually evaporated as Roman once again settled back into being a bland weekly attraction during his awful war with Baron Corbin towards the end of 2019.

But his decision to step away from the ring again in 2020 due to the COVID-19 pandemic finally set the stage for the character tweak that would finally turn him into the undisputed biggest star in the industry WWE had wanted him to be all along.

Gone were the cheesy one-liners, cringey hand gestures, and lazy Shield-esque presentation.

'The Tribal Chief' that appeared at SummerSlam 2020 quickly established himself as a badass heel force you couldn't help but get behind during the ThunderDome era, even when he was battering his own family, bulldozing fan-favourite legends, and annihilating other popular full-time babyfaces.

And after years of wanting nothing to do with him, fans now couldn't wait to acknowledge Reigns when they finally returned in 2021.


5. Elias Drifts On NXT For Years Before Being Called Up

elias samson.jpg
WWE.com

Long before he was mysteriously absent from TV while his brother Ezekiel was stealing the show on Raw, and then disappearing once again after his eventual return in 2022, Elias Samson first popped up on NXT programming alongside a certain House of Black figure: Buddy Matthews.

The two would be obliterated by Ascension on that night in May 2014, and after spending the next year or so getting some reps in on the black and gold show, Elias finally debuted his intriguing second album.

Wandering down to the ring with a guitar over his shoulder, this 'Drifter' didn't exactly demand your attention from the get-go back in August 2015 when taking on Bull Dempsey. But there was certainly something there.

And while the gimmick he continually plucked away at over the next few years didn't ever really find its audience on a developmental brand full of compelling super-workers, Elias finally appeared to have found his stage when he first strolled onto the red brand in April 2017.

This unassuming debut very quickly turned into an unexpected movement in the months that followed, with the bearded acoustic star's weekly concerts regularly producing deafening reactions as he tore down the various hometown teams of those still happily "Walking with Elias."

One of the rare NXT call-ups that led to a far more successful run than the one he'd drifted through in Full Sail.


4. Seth Rollins Didn't Become A Popular Visionary Overnight

Seth Rollins WWE Hall Of Fame
WWE.com

2020 was a rather dull year for WWE's resident 'Architect'.

After winning the Royal Rumble and eventually lifting the Universal Championship as one of the hottest babyfaces in the company the year prior, Seth Rollins' return to the dark side saw him eventually join forces with the likes of the Authors of Pain, Austin Theory, and Buddy Matthews as he morphed into Raw's droning 'Monday Night Messiah'.

But that obsession with 'the greater good' did actually produce one flicker of hope: some rather stunning and outrageous choices of attire.

From that pretty cool leather jacket to his stunning all white clothing at WrestleMania 36 and Rey Mysterio-inspired Phantom gear at the following SummerSlam, Rollins would eventually take these ridiculous outfits and use them as the foundation for a character that would eventually take him right back to the top.

In the lead-up to his WrestleMania 37 battle with Cesaro, this 'Visionary' not only began ordering folks to embrace the vision, he also continued experimenting with his increasingly insane look.

The fiery suits and other barmy jackets/attires, combined with a slightly more unhinged, "Joker going through a mid-life crisis" personality, all eventually led to Rollins then becoming an undeniable fan-favourite once again by the time he was battling with Cody Rhodes and Riddle in 2022.

And now, a few years on from those dark pandemic days, it's impossible to get through a single episode of Raw without the sound of his song being roared back at him by thousands of believers.


3. Orange Cassidy Has Been Squeezing For Years

Orange Cassidy
Twitter, @orangecassidy

One of the greatest success stories of the first few years of All Elite Wrestling, Orange Cassidy has managed to go from relative unknown to one of the most popular and impressive performers on TV.

This wasn't just a case of 'Freshly Squeezed' turning up for his first day of work as part of Tony Khan's new company and deciding to randomly stick his hands in his pockets, though.

Cassidy had been getting in his opponents' heads via his half-arsed antics since 2010 before signing with AEW, with Chuck Taylor noting to ESPN how he remembers seeing crowds turn on the "lazy" worker and being confused by his bold gimmick during the time before becoming All Elite.

After years of figuring out what parts of the gimmick worked and which needed to be adjusted to elicit the biggest responses, though, the Andy from 'Wet Hot American Summer'-inspired persona eventually grew into one of the most popular talents on the independents by the time The Young Bucks decided to bring him to their exciting alternative in 2019.

And though everyone from Tony Khan, to Chris Jericho, to a great many All Elite fans once again didn't fully understand what made this slacker - who can out-work just about anyone on the planet when he tries - so special initially, Cassidy inevitably turned all those doubters into believers in the wonderful years that followed.


2. Mark Henry's Hall Of Pain Wasn't Built In A Day

Mark Henry World Title
WWE.com

It's a good thing Mark Henry signed a 10-year contract with WWE back in 1996 because it pretty much took him the length of that entire first deal to finally find a main event-level character that worked.

Most of those years were spent working within the Nation of Domination, experimenting with a 'Sexual Chocolate' gimmick, testing his strength on WWE programming, and being managed by none other than Teddy Long.

None of those personas ever really led to the 'World's Strongest Man' becoming a real player on the WWE roster, though, and it wasn't until his violent return from a torn quadriceps in 2005 when the pieces finally started to fall into place for the intimidating powerhouse.

After taking out Batista on SmackDown, this new heel force went on to collide with the likes of World Heavyweight Champion Kurt Angle and The Undertaker before unfortunately going down injured again in 2006.

And while the next few years would see the savage big man whooping ass a little further down the card and even messing around in the tag team division with various partners as a babyface for a spell, Henry was eventually given the chance to fully grow into the dominant heel he'd shown glimpses of being during that impactful 2005/6 run.

In 2011, The Big Show, Kane, The Great Khali, Sheamus, and Randy Orton were all brutally inducted into a 'Hall of Pain' he first starting building six years earlier.

During this period of long-awaited supremacy, the destroyer also went on to finally lift World Heavyweight Championship gold as his helpless adversaries crumbled before him and those watching on were regularly left picking their jaws up off the floor.


1. LA Knight Has Been YEAH-ing Since His Triple H Workout DVD Days

LA Knight WWE
WWE.com

While "EVERYBODY!" is now very much talking about SmackDown's one and only 'Megastar', it took a solid decade of trial and error to create the version of LA Knight seen blowing the roof off of arenas around the globe today.

As Knight himself noted in a recent appearance on the After the Bell podcast (via WrestlingInc), he's been playing a pretty similar character for around 13 years at this point. And a lot of the things he'd play with and attempt to add to his gimmick were taken from his personality in real-life.

On top of the "EVERYBODY!" part of his schtick coming from his time working in a restaurant years ago, with Knight shouting that instead of "corner!" whenever he was walking around exactly that, his iconic "YEAH!" has also been a part of his personality since his first run in WWE all the way back in 2013/14.

With Knight appearing in a Triple H workout DVD in the time before eventually showing up as Eli Drake in Impact Wrestling and the NWA, someone recently spotted him actually uttering one of his unmistakable "YEAH!" cries as he finished off a few crunches.

It took almost ten years for this first "YEAH!" movement seed to grow into the most over word in the industry, of course. But even all the way back in 2014, this charismatic lad was proving he had the ability to upstage one of the biggest names in WWE history with something as simple as a "YEAH!"


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Gareth has 6 years experience writing and presenting articles/videos covering all things professional wrestling within the fantastic WhatCulture team. Gareth is also a life long wrestling fan, so is clearly living the dream!