9 WWE Gimmicks That Are Totally DEAD

Welcome to WWE's very own island of misfit toys and company irrelevancy!

Viking Raiders
WWE.com

Let's be clear about one thing first and foremost: It must really suck to struggle for house room on WWE television and know the creative team would rather you kindly buggered off to catering so they could deal with the important people instead. That, despite still being a paid gig, must be a quite-miserable existence at times.

Some current acts are living it.

They're all talented men and women for sure, but their on-screen gimmicks? Totally knackered and in dire need of change. Another two questions. Where do they go from here, and what characters should they play next? Well, that's something for the writing staff to contend with.

One thing is obvious though - enough is enough for these personas that only occasionally sneak onto Raw, SmackDown or NXT like somebody in creative horrible misspelled "Roman Reigns" when formatting scripts. Others on the list are already undergoing changes like they're Ozzy Osbourne and this is a 1972 Black Sabbath piano ballad (...not the horrible redo with Kelly!).

So, which WWE gimmicks are past their sell by date? These, these gimmicks are past their sell by or are already history...

9. Los Lotharios As A Flirty Tag-Team

Los Lotharios Angel Garza Humberto Carrillo
WWE

Messrs. Garza and Carrillo haven’t worked a match since losing to Dragon Lee and Nathan Frazer on the 18 July NXT. Angel and Humberto argued afterwards, but later acknowledged that they haven’t been living up to the legacy of Hector Garza on the 8 August episode and seemed to put tensions behind them.

Something new is likely in the works then.

Being totally honest, their flirty love machine gimmick had been in the clearance bin of WWE ideas for a while now. It didn't gain any steam to speak of on the main roster, and that struggle has continued on the developmental brand. Now, it's being wiped out by the mighty pen.

Handsome sods for sure, Garza and Carrillo will be repackaged as dudes attempting to restore some family pride. In short, they'll aim to make the late, great Hector smile down from above. Fingers crossed WWE treats this sort of topic with the respect it deserves, and this isn't just another false dawn.


8. Madcap Moss = Dad Joke Machine

Emma Riddick Moss
WWE

WWE used the 2023 Draft as an excuse to quietly rename Madcap Moss back to Riddick Moss and act like nothing had happened. Then, the cheeky blighters had the temerity to relegate Moss to company wasteland Main Event. No, no that is not a good thing. Like, at all.

It's actually bloody rubbish.

Cast your minds back to Madcap's turn on Baron Corbin and very, very short-lived singles push. The guy seemed to have some momentum behind him, but it didn't last; he must've donned a comedic big nose around Triple H backstage or sneezed in front of Vince McMahon.

Sure, Madcap was on life support as a character for a while before it was axed, but you’d think creative would plot something (anything!) else before bothering to change his name. A real-life romance with Emma coming to TV hasn't exactly lit the touch paper on either's career.

There must be a ton of frustration in that household, and rightly so.


7. Xia Li The “Great Protector”

Xia Li WWE SmackDown Heel
WWE

Behold another one in Main Event purgatory.

WWE has chucked it with Xia generally, it seems. She’s another who has started frequenting 'C' level programming with alarming regularity, and her old “Great Protector” idea has been totally downplayed. It’s dead, people, and it's time everyone admitted that then tried to move on.

File that "Protector" guise under 'WWE ideas that were never given a fair shake'. Xia was originally envisioned as somebody who'd stand up for the put-upon babyfaces of the roster, but apparently receiving a revolving door of going-nowhere tag-team partners was a much better strategy instead.

Where does Li go from here? Presumably, she keeps her head down and works hard whilst optimistically hoping she'll catch someone with power's eye backstage by putting on top matches. That's easier said than done when you're stripped of any character and given four minutes with Candice LeRae on a show few watch.


6. Rick Boogs As A Rocker

Rick Boogs
WWE.com

Slick Rick's switch from Van Halen-style wannabe 1980s rocker to old timey strongman was...random. It'd be akin to Damian Priest ditching Judgment Day's killer vibes to take some time off then return as a 19th century philosopher whilst still keeping the same name.

OK, maybe not.

Besides, the 80s rocker side of Boogs' character was wiped away pre-injury. However, some figured WWE would come back to it eventually. They didn’t, so he’s some kind of generic weightlifter now and doing sod all of note. Dark times are these for the one-time beneficiary of booming “Boogs! Boogs! Boogs!” chants that now feel like ancient history.

Creative don't even play up to Rick's strongman persona anymore. He's just sort of there as a peripheral figure who's chucked into random Battle Royals or pops up when somebody higher profile needs an easy win. It's been a strange tumble from grace for someone who once seemed on the right path to stardom.


5. Hit Row As…Anything!

Hit Row
WWE.com

This isn’t said lightly or with any glee, but Top Dolla, Ashante Adonis and B-FAB are surely on the chopping block. Their return is now one year deep, has been a miserable flop, and they haven’t connected with fans as babyfaces or heels. Bummer!

If they are all kept around (fingers crossed WWE finds new roles for all three), then it’ll need to be as something else, ‘cause Hit Row has a stink attached to it now. People hear that name and either laugh or recognise that they should laugh lest they be verbally beaten senseless by a horde of social media addicts who gave up on the gimmick a long time ago.

It turns out that Vince McMahon didn't fail Hit Row. They failed him, and time spent under the watchful gaze of apparent fan Triple H has proved that. Sorry, but this is worse than the Mean Street Posse or The Social Outcasts (remember that?!).


4. The Street Profits As Happy Go Lucky Faces

Bobby Lashley The Street Profits
WWE.com

Here's a rare example on the list of when ongoing change looks like it might work.

Montez Ford and Angelo Dawkins are being retooled as part of Bobby Lashley’s reimagined Hurt Business/yet-to-be-named faction. It’s a refreshing change that’s long overdue, because they were starting to feel staler than week old bread as happy go lucky babyfaces.

There were only so many times the pair could chime in about WWE's latest sponsorship campaign or rain Solo Cups down from the heavens before everyone went, 'Right what's next?'. What's next is becoming even better backup to Bobby than Shelton Benjamin and Cedric Alexander ever were, and that's a step in the right direction.

Unlike say...New Day, who built a natural charm all of their own over years of top performances as faces, The Street Profits can never go back to the borderline mediocrity they experienced towards the end there. It just isn't compelling enough, and doesn't need a reprise 18 months from now.


3. RK-Bro's Odd Couple Dynamic

Randy Orton Matt Riddle
WWE.com

WWE is finally ready to move on from RK-Bro.

Randy Orton has been benched through injury since May 2022, but Matt Riddle fans have been clinging on to faint hopes that he'd return and the team would be good to go again. That increasingly looks less likely as time marches on. Besides, Riddle has started a new team with Drew McIntyre.

'Glas-Bro', 'Edin-Bro' or whatever creative chooses to call them might not experience the same success as Riddle's team with "Raaaaaandy" did, but it's worth a shot. Besides, contrasting reports say Orton is good to go one minute then possibly retiring the next. In short, RK-Bro is a thing of the past now.

If Randy does return after all, then there's every chance he'll do his own thing or actually end up feuding with Riddle to try and reheat someone who has definitely lost his way since Orton got injured. Sorry, RK-Bro lovers - it seems the odd couple gimmick is toast.


2. Maximum Male Models

Mace Mansoor Maximum Male Models
WWE.com

Being fair, the sudden shift from plucky babyface (who was only really useful when WWE visited Saudi Arabia) and physically dominant heel Mansoor and Mace lived respectively seemed to be something both could work with when Maximum Male Models launched.

Sadly, WWE’s disinterest is clear for all to see in August 2023. MMM also lost the best thing about them when Maxxine bolted to join Chad Gable and Otis. Almost overnight, she improved her standing on the roster exponentially, and there's no going back.

The writing’s on the wall - a repackage job is incoming yet again for Mace and Mansoor. Their torturous decline from having two managers to having none, then watching both LA Knight and Maxxine get over under different circumstances, must be hellish for the boys as they chow down potato salad in catering.

Actually, models wouldn't eat all those carbs would they? That'd be better than the garbage Man.soor and Ma.ce have been fed creatively for too long, at least.


1. The Viking Raiders

The Viking Raiders Valhalla Alpha Academy Jacket
WWE.com

Good lord, end their pain.

Erik and Ivar showed signs of life when WWE had them go “Vicious” in 2022, but that feels like an eternity ago. The former War Machine have been too stop-start since moving up to the main roster in April 2019, and everyone’s f'n sick of it - probably/definitely including The Viking Raiders themselves.

Think about it: The Raiders have been reduced to stealing jackets like this is 1995, they're Jean-Pierre LaFitte's relatives, and Vince McMahon is seeking a way to keep Bret Hart involved whilst simultaneously taking the mick out of his value. Just what is going on here, and why?!

These vikings are talented and work well as snarling heels. Unfortunately, they've been recently shunted to one side yet again so creative can tickle the fancy of (their latest thrown-together tag) Drew McIntyre and Matt Riddle. It's a real crying shame that The Raiders are viewed with such apathy by the folks penning telly.

They deserve better, but their longstanding gimmick needs the boot now.


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.