AEW All Out 2023: 10 Things That Must Happen
Is this when The Elite proves to Tony Khan that AEW doesn't need CM Punk?!
Sunday's pay-per-view could be a sobering evening for AEW.
The company produced a stadium show worth celebrating last weekend in London. All In wasn't perfect by any means, but it did showcase some of Tony Khan's best on a grand stage, and nobody in attendance will ever forget it. All Out? Well, All Out is already struggling due to the suspension of hometown boy CM Punk.
He'll skip the show due to more backstage fighting, and that'll sound familiar to anyone who has paid attention to All Elite business for the past 12 months. All Out 2022 was hilariously dubbed "Brawl Out" in the media, and yet here we are - somehow, that behind-the-curtain nonsense is still plaguing Khan's organisation.
TK has to try to focus on the task at hand though. He's still got a PPV full of matches that require some attention, and it's important the boss begins to move on in the final quarter of the year. To do that, Tony will need to get match results correct, keep various stories purring, and maybe ask some on the roster to give him a breather from all the chaos.
Here's what must happen in Chicago!
10. ROH Tag Titles Open
Spoiler alert incoming for Rampage, so apologies if you're reading this before Friday's episode.
OK, ready. Here's a line break just to give you more time.
-
Dark Order members John Silver and Alex Reynolds won the Battle Royale on Rampage, and they'll challenge MJF and Adam Cole for the ROH Tag belts at All Out. Whilst that does feel like a lacklustre combo, the same cannot be said for Max and Adam. They've been gold together, and they proved that yet again at Wembley.
Fans in London were right into the duo, and it's safe to assume Chicago's wrestle-daft masses will be the same. So, why not run with MJF and Cole defending vs. Dark Order as the launching point for Sunday's show? This is a nothing challenge from Silver and Reynolds, to be fair, but the champ’s dynamic will help it.
Chicago would roar with appreciation if the snazzy Better Than You Bay Bay theme blared over the speakers early. Yep, this sounds like the perfect way to kick things off and get the audience onside ASAP. Why not?
9. Jon Moxley Becomes International Champ
Orange Cassidy has done a superb job as AEW’s championship workhorse since winning the International Title, but he needs something different and so does the belt. Sticking it on Mox might lead to the strap getting lost in the BCC shuffle, but it’s worth a go in the short-term.
He's a big name anyway, so at least the strap will stay on TV.
One can see Orange moving up the pecking order heading into 2024. Is he World Title material? Hmm, that's up for debate (does Cassidy even need that at this point in his career?!), but the guy is some worker and one of the most reliably efficient on those All Elite roster sheets.
Moxley hasn't been up to much other than bleeding all over the place recently. Perhaps winning the International Title will put more respect on that title's name and give him something more to focus on. Star-making title defences against young stars await.
8. The Outcasts Implode…Again!
AEW missed the chance to hammer home what happened at All In on Dynamite. Sure, Toni Storm’s shoe-launching promo was great telly, but more is needed. Tony Khan can't afford to let things lie dormant between Storm and Saraya too long. Where Ruby Soho fits in must be thrashed out too.
Having Soho grab the mic post-loss to Kris Statlander and tear strips off Toni and Saraya for their issues would be a fun vibe. She's been stuck in the middle between warring wrestlers before, but thought she had things sussed by linking up with The Outcasts.
Honestly, give a p*ssed off Ruby the floor to develop the story.
Then, on Dynamite going forward, Storm or Saraya can offer a rebuttal and we can get this party started. Toni vs. the new champ is obviously AEW's plan. That's cool. However, there's no need for Soho to just breeze along pretending everything is fine and dandy.
7. The Numbers Get To Darby Allin
One Christian Cage has done a masterful job of reinventing himself as a despicable heel who delights in being cruel. The fact he's been hiding behind legit TNT Champ (and human brick wall) Luchasaurus whilst claiming to be the real champion has also been a hoot.
There's simply no need to end that run on Sunday.
If anything, Cage and Lucha should make it impossible for Darby Allin to properly get going. That'd mean the classic underdog doesn’t win his third TNT Title at All Out. Being totally honest, he doesn't really need that at the moment, because he's over like rover anyway by chumming around with Sting.
That's settled then. Keep the belt exactly where it is, and have Christian chip in where possible. Unlike some others on the card, this match won't suffer from outside interference - it's not that Luchasaurus needs it, it's that Cage is just a sadistic jerk.
6. Sting Rides To The Rescue
Then, post-match, Tony Schiavone can lose his voice yelling: "IT'S STIIIIIIIING!".
Question marks could be raised on commentary about why the Stinger didn't accompany Darby to the ring despite knowing Christian Cage would interfere. Later, someone can say Allin asked his mentor not to be there so he could win the belt on his own. That, as the Icon would acknowledge, was a huge mistake.
Sting would get a nice pop if he rushed out to save Darbs from a mauling at the hands of the heels. Then, AEW can move towards some more tag matches on a special edition of Dynamite or Collision in the near future. This all hinges on whether or not the ex-WCW favourite will be active for too much longer, of course.
Retirement rumours are rife for Sting, but that's his choice. Regardless, having him run down the ramp to save his protege sounds like a solid piece of booking for Sunday night's pay-per-view.
5. Samoa Joe Retains
There's no point in ignoring the obvious.
Shane Taylor is a puzzling choice to challenge Samoa Joe for the ROH TV Title here. The Ring of Honor influence is starting to creep back onto mainline AEW programming, which is slightly worrying overall, but Taylor doesn’t feel worthy of a spot on All Elite pay-per-view generally.
This should be a relatively easy title defence for Joe then. What's the alternative? That Taylor shocks the Samoan just one week after he kicked off AEW's biggest show ever vs. CM Punk? Tony Khan surely doesn't want to put any bullet holes in Joe's armour so quickly after a sparkling Wembley showing.
Joe also reportedly showed off his leadership skills behind the scenes when Punk was scrapping with Jack Perry too, so taking the TV Title off him here would come across as a bizarre punishment. Honestly, this should've happened on ROH TV, not AEW pay-per-view.
Next, please!
4. The Young Bucks Walk Out On FTR
The fact these duos are teaming together so soon after The Bucks ignored an FTR handshake in London is weird, haphazard booking. AEW rushed through the set up for it with one backstage skit on Dynamite, and that has some scratching their heads.
It's another multi-man match for the sake of it.
Perhaps the only logical play here is having Matt and Nick Jackson leave FTR high and dry against Bullet Club Gold. Some believe The Bucks are heading back to heel territory anyway, so it'd be cool if All Elite got the ball rolling on that at All Out. Otherwise, this is house show-tastic fare.
If The Jacksons leave FTR for dead, then either Jay White or Juice Robinson pins one of the reigning AEW Tag-Team Champs, the winners can claim their right to a title shot. That opens things up further, and breathes new life into The Bucks.
They need that.
3. Omega Vs. Takeshita Headlines
Being honest, Kenny Omega and Konosuke Takeshita probs should’ve had a one-on-one at Wembley instead of the divisive trios battle AEW booked. That’s gone now though, and the pair can still have a banger match in Chicago. They've told a decent story going in, and should be primed to tear the house down.
Let them main event.
All Out doesn't have a ton of options to work with here. CM Punk likely would've headlined, but his suspension takes him out of the running. Jon Moxley vs. Orange Cassidy is another that could end the show with a bang, but...nah - give the spot to Omega and Takeshita.
AEW fans have been ready to see this clash on pay-per-view for a while now, and there's even more intrigue going in due to Konosuke beating Kenny in London. This is the biggest marquee bout on the card in some way, so just put it on last and watch them fly.
2. And Kenny Omega Wins It
Don Callis laid out Konosuke’s strategy on Dynamite, which was typical wrestling heel stupidity. Omega, banged up or not, should overcome that, defeat Takeshita and celebrate by shouting, “F*** CM Punk” into the hard cam.
OK, maybe not that last bit.
Seriously though, a loss won’t hurt Takeshita if he’s allowed to look great during the meat of the match. Omega is a true master of making opponents look like killers, and he'll be able to elevate Konosuke even if he's the one going over. That, ladies and gents, is why Kenny is regarded as one of the best grapplers on the planet.
He's at his best in singles outings too, especially if they're on the lengthier side. A solid 30 minutes or so would be enough for Omega and Takeshita to take fans on a ride, then rock the house with a popular win for The Elite man.
That'd represent something else too...
1. AEW Starts To Move On From CM Punk
That "something else" being AEW's plans to move on from CM Punk.
Look, Punk is a big star and creates a ton of chatter, but a lot of that talk is negative. His backstage fighting record is getting so out of hand that Shane McMahon might be giving the dude a call to be on 'Raw Underground'. Punk is the common denominator in all of that behind-the-scenes tension too, and it needs to stop.
Sunday is a big night for The Elite. It's a chance for someone like Kenny Omega to turn in a world-class performance, then pin down Tony Khan backstage and suggest ol' CM ain't the future of AEW. Yes, yes All Elite Wrestling should endeavour to move on from Punk again.
Whether or not it works this time is anyone's guess, but things cannot go on like this. All that negativity has a stranglehold on the company, and it's making a laughing stock of Khan's ability to lead. All Out must bring about change.
What else do you think must happen at AEW All Out? For more wrestling, check out 10 New Directions For AEW After All In 2023 and WWE Payback 2023: 10 Things That Must Happen!