AEW Double Or Nothing 2023: 10 Nightmares That Could Come True

A world in which CM Punk finally returning to AEW is an absolute NIGHTMARE.

CM Punk AEW Double Or Nothing 2023
AEW

Tony Khan must be feeling pretty good about things right now.

The AEW boss has a UK stadium show that's selling incredibly well, his company will soon launch a brand new Saturday night TV weekly, and recent reports from the wrestling media suggest things are finally smoothing over with one CM Punk - he's expected to play a part in Collision's launch if talks progress.

Wait...this intro opened up with positivity, and there's no room for stinking positivity when the title literally says "nightmares that could come true". This weekend's Double Or Nothing pay-per-view has the potential to make TK mad, and have him staring around at a bunch of media types like he's angling for a fight.

Or, perhaps more accurately, it has the potential to make pro wrestling fans angry. After all, they could see unwanted title changes, matches the live crowd blatantly don't care about, pre-taped cinematic-style brawls that fail to ignite, and Punk returning early as a secondary concern.

It's unlikely, but unlikely isn't the same as impossible. Here are all the things keeping AEW enthusiasts awake at night heading into a bumper weekend of PPV/PLE goodness.

10. 60-0 Strangles The TBS Title

AEW Battle of the Belts V Jade Cargill Leila Grey
AEW

"Cargill hits Jaded, rolls Taya Valkyrie over for the 1...2...3!".

That line could come from play-by-play man Excalibur at DoN, and it could herald the arrival of yet another win for Jade Cargill. Unfortunately for the unbeaten TBS Champ, going 60-0 could be a death knell for the belt she holds. Why? Well, AEW has done a crap job of prepping wrestlers to challenge for it.

Valkyrie is almost the last gasp in that respect. If she loses to Jade again, then fans will start rolling their eyes wondering why they should be expected to care about the next scrub lined up for Cargill to mow down. After all, she's probably going all the way to 100 if she reaches 60-right, right?

This stranglehold Jade has on the TBS gold got old a while ago. Her whole act requires spring cleaning, and that TBS Title needs a new home. Taya Valkyrie, it's over to you.


9. This Contractual B*llocks Rolls On

Matt Hardy Ethan Page
AEW

The Firm owning Matt Hardy and Private Party's contracts should be considered one of the worst storylines in modern wrestling. It was abominably bad, and made a mockery of the talent involved. Worse, AEW seems keen to continue with it now Matt has the chance to order Ethan Page around.

Do you really think Page and The Gunns are winning this one?

That'd be a huge surprise, because this has easy babyface victory written all over it. Then, fans will be "treated" to months of Ethan fetching The Hardys coffee as Isiah Kassidy moans in his ear. Questions must be asked about exactly why this is still going on when it sucked to begin with.

Even Jeff Hardy said his brother had to "get over all this contract stuff" on Rampage recently. The wrestlers involved are taking aim at the creative! That's how bad it is. Prepare to suffer through more of it on TV after Double Or Nothing.


8. Nobody Cares About The Battle Royal

AEW Double Or Nothing 2023 Orange Cassidy
AEW

Double Or Nothing must be akin to AEW's WrestleMania, because TK is stuffing as many wrestlers on the main card as humanly possible. That's been a 'Mania trope for decades, and it makes sense; workers want that sweet, sweet pay-per-view payday, and promoters want to reward them for hard work.

Fair enough, but it does sometimes lead to matches few give a hoot about.

Sunday's "Blackjack Battle Royal" for Orange Cassidy's International Title is one such bout. It's set to be a 21-man fray that's supposed to sell just how hardworking and game for defending his belt Orange is. That'd be fine if Vegas could be relied upon to care. Instead, this one could be the designated p*ss break.

That's a shame considering how hard Cassidy has worked to make that International belt mean something. He's had more title defences on TV than most AEW champs, so this doesn't feel like much of a reward. It could get even worse for him too...


7. Powerhouse Hobbs' Latest False Dawn

Powerhouse Hobbs QT Marshall
AEW

...because he could lose the thing suddenly.

QT Marshall has been bragging about Powerhouse Hobbs being featured on promotional materials for Collision recently. Pretty much all of the QTV gang will be involved in the battle royal, which means there's a fair chance they'll join forces to toss loads of other workers over the top rope.

Remember that dire, all-too-short TNT Title reign Powerhouse had? Yeah, well AEW could be ready to do something similar with Hobbs and the International gold. That'd lead to several battles between QTV and Best Friends, then some sort of rematch between Powerhouse and Orange Cassidy on TV...which Orange would win.

That's the nightmare presented here: Hobbs winning yet another title, holding it for a short period again, then dropping it back to his predecessor. Sounds a bit sh*t, doesn't it? Absolutely, but no-one should rule it out for Sunday's pay-per-view.

Powerhouse is one of those wrestlers AEW struggles with.


6. Wardlow’s Problems Continue

Wardlow AEW TNT Title
AEW

Recently, walking man mountain Wardlow has been the same.

His second TNT Title reign will forever be considered a missed opportunity for All Elite's creative minds. The first was milquetoast enough at times, but the three-day reign he had in March was downright insulting to everyone watching. Honestly, why did they even bother?

Wardlow won at Revolution, then dropped the belt to Powerhouse Hobbs a few days later at Dynamite. Then, to compound the misery, MJF's old bodyguard won the TNT belt again in mid-April. Since then, he's launched into a feud opposite Christian Cage. You can totally see where this horror show is going.

It wouldn't be abnormal (given how up and down his booking has been to date) for Wardlow to lose the title at DoN. Cage could be considered a steadier hand, and the presence of one Luchasaurus around ringside could be used as an excuse to change things in Christian's favour.

Aw sh*t. Here were go again.


5. FTR Suffer Another Short Reign

FTR Tony Schaivone
AEW

FTR are no strangers to the criminally-short AEW title treatment themselves. They previously held the Tag-Team belts for a measly 63 days back in 2020. This second stint with the straps will sit at a similar mark when they stroll into Double Or Nothing for a drama-fuelled match vs. Jeff Jarrett and Jay Lethal.

Will history repeat itself here? It's possible. The addition of Mark Briscoe as special guest ref certainly adds the threat of shenanigans, and the likes of Sonjay Dutt and the towering Satnam Singh will be around ringside too. If All Elite wants to give FTR an out, then they'll have plenty of excuses to do just that.

It'd be rubbish though.

Something feels right about Dax Harwood and Cash Wheeler holding those titles for a long, long time. Jarrett and Lethal have been impressive, but they shouldn't win the titles on Sunday. Fans would be facepalming themselves stupid if Tony Khan brushed FTR aside again.


4. “Unsanctioned” Gets Lost In The Mix

Chris Jericho Adam Cole
AEW

'Anarchy In The Arena' is the larger-scale brawl on tap for DoN. That could spell disaster for what Chris Jericho and Adam Cole hope to achieve in Vegas then, especially when their "Unsanctioned" match is being teased as ultra-violent. Still, veterans like this pair will know they have to be careful about stealing thunder from The Elite and BCC.

That'd be a bit selfish.

Bunging two similar-feeling brawls on the same card is nothing new for pro wrestling, but it's always risky. After all, what do Jericho and Cole have to offer that's different from 'Anarchy'? The fact it's only two guys and thus less chaotic? That's hardly juicy enough to merit the "Unsanctioned" treatment.

This probs won't be a one-and-done scenario for these boys, but they could find themselves lost in the shuffle this weekend. One solution might be opening the show with Jericho and Cole so they at least have a puncher's chance of drawing fans in.


3. ‘Anarchy’ Happens Exclusively Backstage

The Elite
AEW

Right, straight up, it's really unlikely that AEW tries this. People can say what they want about Tony Khan's company, but he recognises the value of giving live crowds a lot of bang for their buck. Regardless, there's this gnawing worry in the back of yours truly's mind that 'Anarchy In The Arena' could be a backstage brawl.

Like, exclusively.

It wouldn't be out of character for the BCC crew of Jon Moxley, Bryan Danielson, Claudio Castagnoli and Wheeler Yuta to ambush The Elite in a corridor somewhere. Then, what if fans there live for DoN start to realise that the bout isn't making its merry way towards ringside at all?

That'd be a real bummer for those excited to see Kenny Omega, The Young Bucks, Hangman Page etc. Again, it's highly unlikely to go down this way, but this guy just can't shake the cinematic cobwebs from his mind. 2020 was like a fever dream.


2. AEW Hotshots The World Title

Sammy Guevara AEW World Title
AEW

ARGH!

MJF bagging the AEW World Title back at Full Gear last November was a real landmark moment for the company. That, more so than Kenny Omega or even Hangman Page before him, felt like a true homegrown star reaching the pinnacle (ha) of All Elite's ladder. It was a feel good moment despite his heel status.

The odds are stacked against Friedman in storyline at DoN though. He's in a four-way match vs. other "Pillars" like Sammy Guevara, Darby Allin and 'Jungle Boy' Jack Perry. What if a certain Mr. Khan behind the scenes decides that this pay-per-view needs a World Title change on it? What if he puts the thing on Sammy?!

That's not meant as a diss at the 'Spanish God', but he'd be a downgrade from MJF even in the short-term. AEW has Forbidden Door to burn through before getting to Wembley and All In London, so they might reason that a brief title chase for MJF is the way to keep things purring.

No thanks.


1. CM Punk & MJF In Another Non-Title Feud

CM Punk MJF
AEW

Then, in the aftermath of MJF's title loss, what if none other than CM Punk rolls out to bask in the misery of young Max? The wrestling world would be shook if Punk was at Double Or Nothing. After all, his legal/contractual issues with AEW haven't been 100% sorted out yet, but hopes remain high he'll play a part in Collision's debut.

Jumping the gun on that would be some error.

Of course, Punk and All Elite's lawyers would need to agree on absolutely everything first. That seems far-fetched, but keep in mind - these are "nightmare" scenarios more than anything else. The sh*ttiest thing about Punk being on hand for DoN is that he'd effectively be coming back for something he's already done (feud with MJF).

AEW does enjoy big time shocks on this pay-per-view series though. It's where Jon Moxley roared into view back in 2019, for example. Could CM Punk be this show's nasty little surprise, thus putting two fingers up at Collision's launch in the process?

What else do you think must happen at AEW's Double Or Nothing 2023? For more wrestling, check out WWE Night Of Champions 2023: 10 Things That Must Happen and 6 Ups & 1 Down From AEW Rampage (May 19)!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.