AEW Double Or Nothing 2023: 10 Things That Must Happen
Title changes, historic losses and...the promise of an AEW mega-match after Double Or Nothing?!
AEW has been doing some moving and shaking in 2023.
Tony Khan's group rocked the wrestling world by announcing a historic stadium show in the UK, then rightly crowed about huge ticket sales for All In London. Further, there's a brand new weekly TV show on the horizon, and everyone's waiting to see if the spectre of CM Punk-related drama will play a role in Collision's future.
Oh, and there's the not-so-small matter of this weekend's Double Or Nothing pay-per-view. Y'know, All Elite's "WrestleMania". Titles could change hands, wrestlers could lose for the first time, and Khan could use one of his biggest annual spectaculars to set up an episode of Dynamite. Huh? It could happen.
This is an important night for AEW. Some of the comedic flourishes laced between certain feuds must disappear, and any "ha ha" previously seen in big-time gimmick matches should sod off too. So, what needs to happen in Vegas this Sunday?
Brace yourselves for generation-defining triumphs, the announcement of something huge for TV (that'll bridge the gap to Wembley), and...a throwback to WWE TLC?! You heard it here first.
10. Jade Cargill Loses For The First Time
BOOM!
First up, it's time for Jade Cargill to see that winning streak come to an end at Double Or Nothing. She's 59-0 after whipping a few enhancement workers on last week's Rampage, but the reigning TBS Champ shouldn't make it to 60. Mark Sterling should start crying right now, basically.
Why? Well, Jade's undefeated gimmick is boring as f*ck these days. Plus, Tony Khan will never have a better challenger than Taya Valkyrie to take that belt from Cargill and move this thing on. Jade will be fine - she can always move up to the AEW Women's Title scene proper. One defeat won't destroy her company career.
Taya has survived the usual loss to Cargill by roaring back for more, and there is something to her potentially beating the champion with that 'Road To Valhalla' finish. AEW has done a neat job of teasing that, and it should happen this weekend in Las Vegas.
9. Wardlow Gets Some Stability
Hey, Tony...can we have some decorum around here?! Big Wardlow badly needs some stability, because the way his last TNT Title reign was handled? Yeah, it sucked, and so did Powerhouse Hobbs' brief run with the belt too. It'd be a huge mistake to shove that thing on Christian Cage for the sake of it here.
Cage holding TNT sounds fun at some point, but not this weekend. It's real important that Wardlow (who has been struggling to match early fan support for his "Powerbomb Symphony" stuff) gets the win in this ladder bout and starts rebuilding some momentum that previously looked lost to the sands of time.
Enough messing about, AEW.
Wardlow can even bump Luchasaurus if necessary. He's on that match graphic for a reason, surely. The dino's presence should help both champ and challenger weave in some tasty callbacks to some of Christian's most famous career landmarks, actually. Why not?
8. Christian Cage Pays Homage To TLC
Right, enough jokes about AEW constantly referencing WWE! This would be a good one, and it'd go down well with older fans who remember rushing home from school to see Edge and Christian send poor Bubba-Ray Dudley crashing through countless tables around ringside.
Man, those were the glory days, and it's time to relive them. Sort of.
At some stage during the ladder bout at Double Or Nothing, it'd be sweet to see Christian and Luchasaurus pretend Wardlow is a Dudley by repeating that glorious SummerSlam 2000 spot. Cage has such a rich history with ladders, so it'd be a shame if AEW didn't reference that.
Failing that one, maybe Wardlow himself could send both Christian and his big extinct pal through tables, then climb another ladder to grab his strap. Excalibur and the other commentators should stop short of mentioning WWE's TLC gimmick, but All Elite can defo get away with a wink and a nod here.
7. FTR Wins & Mark Briscoe Bumps Jay Lethal
Two for one "must happen" here.
Jeff Jarrett has been one of AEW's surprise packages since joining the company last November. Many folks scoffed when they heard ol' J-E-Double-F was incoming, but he and Jay Lethal formed a fine tag team that's become a credit to the product overall. That doesn't mean they should win gold on Sunday mind.
FTR literally just bagged those AEW Tag Titles at the start of April, and this second reign should act as an apology for the ridiculously-short run Dax Harwood and Cash Wheeler erm..."enjoyed" back in 2020. It'd be foolish to take the belts from everyone's favourite NWA-style traditionalists at DoN.
Mark Briscoe is special guest ref, and he'd be the perfect out for Lethal and Jarrett. They'd be mad that he counted the three for FTR, so Briscoe would finally snap and lay out his old mate Jay. That's coming - it's only a matter of time.
6. The Outcasts Come Up Short
No need for a title change in this one either.
Look, Toni Storm finally seems to have found her place on the All Elite roster alongside Saraya and Ruby Soho in The Outcasts, but Jamie Hayter should be Tony Khan's priority on Sunday night. That interim business late-last year was messy enough with chucking another title change into the mix.
Hayter also deserves to walk into Wembley Stadium this August with that title. Of course, TK might argue that Jamie winning the championship back from Storm at All In London would be bigger, but this fan firmly disagrees. He doesn't really want to see these two wrestle for a while after Double Or Nothing anyway.
The Outcasts can start targeting Taya Valkyrie instead, or something like that. Hayter needs to move on to fresh feuds, because she's been tied to Toni on and off for far too long. It's time for her title reign to experience something different, so she must win and move on.
5. Adam Cole Wins The Unsanctioned Brawl
AEW deserve a ton of credit for the hot pull-apart brawl angle they booked for last week's episode of Rampage. That's the kind of thing fans haven't seen nearly enough of on the Friday 'B' (soon to be 'C') show, so seeing some pay-per-view setup featuring big names was awesome.
Now, only one winner makes sense: Adam Cole (baby).
This or the TNT Title ladder match would be a fine choice to open the pay-per-view, being honest. Seeing Chris Jericho and Cole brawl around ringside and set the scene for more chaos to come during 'Anarchy In The Arena' sounds fun; plus, AEW might want to keep those matches as far apart as possible.
Cole winning brings him closer to hitting the heights his All Elite run has struggled to reach thus far. Also, and this is rarely lost on AEW hardcores, Jericho just doesn't need to win a lot of matches these days. He can take the 'L' then promo his ass off to recover.
4. “Four Pillars” Goes Elimination
Some fans will feel differently about this idea, because there is admittedly something snappy about one fall putting a champ's title reign in real jeopardy. However, there's also something just a little more epic about elimination-style four-way bouts, and that's the big pitch here.
Such formatting would also clue fans in on who Tony Khan really sees as the more important of the "Four Pillars". Each elimination could be taken as a snapshot view of each man's standing on the roster for the rest of 2023, in other words. Sammy Guevara would go first, then Jack Perry, then that'd leave Darby Allin and MJF.
There's something super-cool about seeing all of these young lions in such a featured spot on AEW's "WrestleMania" generally, and it'd be ace if TK could give them as much time as possible. Turning the main event into an elimination battle is the easiest way to go about that.
Time to run the gauntlet, MJF!
3. MJF Retains
Time to survive the gauntlet, more like.
Listen (trademark Max Caster), it's honestly very neat to see four of the brightest young homegrown stars from AEW's first four years of business headline a major pay-per-view like this. MJF is the pick of the bunch though, and there's no way he drops his AEW World Title on Sunday.
The walking, talking promo machine still has a lot to get through in this title reign, and he shouldn't be losing in a multi-man situation. No, it'd be better if Friedman eventually lost his strap because he was beaten fairly one-on-one by a carefully built challenger fans crave as champion.
Can anyone credibly claim Darby, Sammy or Jack deserve to supplant MJF in May 2023? Nah. The champ retaining/surviving by the skin of his teeth is the only way to go with DoN's headliner. Keep MJF's title reign intact, then build towards something massive for Wembley and All In.
2. 'Anarchy' Is Intense More Than Comedic
Last year's 'Anarchy In The Arena' battle pitting Chris Jericho's JAS vs. Blackpool Combat Club smartly steered itself away from comedy, but that hasn't always been the case with AEW's showpiece brawls. The temptation has always been there to inject a few laughs for levity, but DoN 2023's crew should avoid that completely.
It's important.
There's nothing funny about The Elite squaring off with BCC this time anyway. Members on both sides have been locked in some real vicious matches against one another; Jon Moxley alone has warred with Kenny Omega and Hangman Page in blood-soaked gimmick bouts, so trying to be cute and funny wouldn't really work.
'Anarchy' has to be 20-25 minutes of full-scale war that sets the feud up for more. Personally, this writer would put Mox, Bryan Danielson, Claudio Castagnoli and Wheeler Yuta over so The Elite have cause to get even more gritty later on.
Yes, that does mean...
1. Tony Khan Lines Up Blood & Guts
...Vince McMahon's favourite AEW match: 'Blood & Guts'!
All Elite chiefs only have the cross-branded New Japan pay-per-view Forbidden Door to go before reaching All In London and Wembley. So, given the exhibition-esque nature of June's show, they might need to bridge the gap with something special on TV soon.
The intro suggested that 'Blood & Guts' should happen on Dynamite, but what if it's earmarked for Collision instead? Imagine the excitement if TK let his new Saturday night show get started, then announced a colossal cage clash on Collision several weeks in. Is that enough 'C' words for you?
A BCC win at Double Or Nothing would set this up nicely, 'cause then Kenny Omega, Hangman Page and The Young Bucks would be motivated to seek revenge. Why not do that by deploying AEW's grittiest set piece?
What else do you think must happen at AEW's Double Or Nothing 2023? For more wrestling, check out WWE Night Of Champions 2023: 10 Things That Must Happen and 6 Ups & 1 Down From AEW Rampage (May 19)!