AEW Dynasty 2024: 10 Nightmares That Could Come True
This would be the WORST thing Tony Khan has ever done. He'd ruin AEW Dynasty!
Well, here goes.
Exploring the absolute dirt worst that could happen on AEW's next pay-per-view stings a little more than usual due to the current strength of the roster. Tony Khan has a world class lineup of wrestlers at his disposal, but he's been far too preoccupied with WWE "hate" and CM Punk chatter to focus on developing their characters or concentrating 100% on build towards Dynasty.
Will that come back to bite the boss? This article (rather predictably given the nightmare element) says yes. There's a case to be made that All Elite Wrestling could've done without adding another PPV to the schedules - they've got Double Or Nothing coming up next month, which is traditionally AEW's biggest tentpole event. You wouldn't really know it due to all the outside noise.
Khan's obsession with biting back at WWE to anyone who'll listen put cracks in the build towards this show. Things could get worse for the company if that chaos continues this weekend. That nonsense and a boatload of other nightmare fuel is included here.
Please, please, please say none of this is going to happen in St. Louis. Please?!
10. HOB = Afterthought AGAIN!
In his quieter moments, Malakai Black must be gazing over at Triple H’s WWE and wondering if he’d make a splash second time around. The dude’s making money in AEW, but (other than Julia Hart nabbing the TBS Title) his House Of Black faction has been booked into oblivion. They’re just not as threatening or credible as they should be.
It’s a problem Tony Khan doesn’t seem keen to fix.
At Dynasty, Black, Brody King and Buddy Matthews face Adam Copeland, Eddie Kingston and Mark Briscoe. It’d be a surprise if HOB came out on the winning end, and they could feasibly end up as jobbers to the stars for the babyface trio. What else is new for these lads, eh? They’re closer to Social Outcasts than Judgment Day at the moment, which sucks to see.
The main core in House Of Black can’t seem to force their way into important positions on the card. They’re consistently overlooked in favour of others, and that has to be doing Malakai’s head in. He came to AEW nearly three years ago to do great things. Everyone’s still waiting to see them.
9. Mercedes Mone Causes A Non-Finish
The artist formerly known as Sasha Banks has been chuckled at by some accounts on social media for tumbling TV ratings since she joined the company. Whilst it’s hardly fair to pin all of that on her, it is slightly worrying and flies in the face of AEW sounding the trumpets over new signings. Surely, if anything, Mercedes Mone was brought in to bolster viewership.
Recently, Mone has been semi-involved with the TBS Title picture, so there’s a chance she’ll pop up at Dynasty during Julia Hart vs. Willow Nightingale. The usual “House Rules” Julia’s matches sport mean Mercedes and/or Kris Statlander will likely get involved. If they do, then expect some sort of screwy non-finish.
Boo to that.
AEW fans like definitive finishes to their pay-per-view bouts. It’s something the promotion has been protective of in the past, and there’d be some scattered booing if Mone and Stat forced the ref to throw Willow’s title shot out completely just so Khan could get to some sort of multi-wrestler match at Double Or Nothing.
8. Thunder Rosa Beats Toni Storm
The chances of either Mariah May turning on mentor Toni Storm or ‘Timeless’ ditching her protege skyrocket with each passing AEW show. It’s clear to everyone who watches weekly that Toni vs. Mariah is coming at some point, and a few fans circled DoN 2024 as the possible tipping point. If that’s going to happen, then look out for shenanigans at Dynasty.
It’d be a mini-crisis for the women’s division if Toni dropped the belt to Thunder Rosa though. That’s no indictment on Rosa’s skills, but more of a complaint against the idea of stripping Storm of her title right now. Her old-timey gimmick has been a breath of fresh air for the division, but management could be tempted into booking May to accidentally cost her boss and thus force a split.
Hopefully not.
Y’see, Toni doesn’t need to lose her championship to facilitate that plot point. She and May can splinter without any title changes, but AEW’s decision makers might disagree. Plus, and this is something several have pointed out previously, Tony kinda owes Thunder an olive branch. Look out, ‘Timeless’!
7. The International Title Fix Is In
WCW fans of yesteryear will remember how p*ssed off everyone got when Hollywood Hogan and Kevin Nash revealed they’d been in cahoots all along during that disastrous “fingerpoke of doom” stuff in early-1999. The angle instantly made a mockery of a hot storyline, and is credited as one of the worst moments in the promotion’s downfall.
Be very careful, AEW.
OK, so Roddy Strong and Kyle O’Reilly going back to being best buds isn’t on the same scale as the nWo, but O’Reilly has a genuine chance to emerge as a breakout babyface in the upper-midcard should he remain at loggerheads with Strong. If AEW plays the old ‘swerve all along’ card, then you can score another non-finish for Dynasty, and that won’t go down well at all.
It’s far-fetched, but stranger things have happened than these old NXT mates coming back together as a united front. Kyle joining the Undisputed Kingdom and giving Adam Cole another weapon certainly isn’t out of the question. It does suck compared to the alternative (a feisty O’Reilly face run) though.
6. Okada’s First Full Time PPV Is Weak
Dynasty obviously won’t be Kazuchika Okada’s first AEW pay-per-view. He worked matches at Forbidden Door in 2022 and 2023, but those were treated more like special appearances/one-offs than anything else. This weekend’s supershow is the Japanese favourite’s first as an All Elite full-timer, and it’s important the company bends over backwards to give that a special feel.
Kicking off the card vs. PAC is one option, because at least then fans would be rowdy and into the match. What if Okada’s first full-time PPV showing comes across as just another match on the card though? That’s a nightmarish thought, one that should keep hardcore wrestling purists awake at night.
Okada should never come across as “just another match on the card”.
AEW is pretty guilty of doing that to workers. They come in with lots of hype, then momentum fades as Tony Khan’s dream match booking plays to diminishing returns or he flat out doesn’t know what to do with them creatively. Okada was also sought after by WWE, and he’s bigger than “just another wrestler”.
5. Samoa Joe Crushes Swerve Strickland
Nobody wants to see an emotional Swerve Strickland on Dynamite next week, at least not for the wrong reasons. If Swerve shows up as pictured above and cuts an heartfelt promo about failing to capture the AEW World Title, then it’s a long road back. Things would be even worse if Samoa Joe is booked to run straight over the top of Strickland in short order.
Look, this World Title match isn’t Dynasty’s priority. Joe is a placeholder as champ, and everyone knows it. If top brass aren’t ready to take the belt from him this weekend, then he’ll start to chip away at a potential headliner’s credibility. It’s vital that Swerve gets to look like the man against Joe, because he’s the future.
AEW would be committing creative suicide by trying to copy what WWE did with Cody Rhodes between WrestleManias 39 and 40. Those were unique circumstances, and it’s fair to say Swerve putting on the puppy dog eyes after failing to seize his moment won’t carry as much weight.
Again, the company must be careful here.
4. Tony Khan Tries To 'WrestleMania X8' The Title Bout
Uh oh.
At ’Manias X8 and 25, WWE tried to force the World Title bout into the main event position despite fans being blatantly more interested in other matches. Triple H vs. Chris Jericho wasn’t a patch on Hogan vs. Rock in 2002, and Trips was at it again vs. Randy Orton in 2009 when everyone knew HBK vs. ’Taker was the main attraction.
AEW has a similar sort of dilemma heading into Dynasty. No, Will Ospreay vs. Bryan Danielson isn’t on par with the superstardom in those WWE classics, but it is the current showdown countless fans want to see most. Samoa Joe vs. Swerve Strickland couldn’t hope to follow it, basically, so Tony Khan shouldn’t even bother trying to find out.
Sure, the World Title is a promotional centrepiece, but Dynasty is more about Ospreay testing himself against Danielson than anything else. Swerve can still have his big celebration on the undercard. However, it’d fall slightly flat if AEW expected he and Joe to follow Will and Bryan in the headline slot.
3. The Dream Match Is A Letdown
This is a horrible, horrible thought.
It’s often taken for granted that AEW’s finest will deliver the goods on pay-per-view and put together unbelievable dream matches in their sleep. That pressure even extended to Will Ospreay’s battle with Chris Jericho back at All In London last summer, and this is the same Jericho most deride as over the hill today. That doesn’t matter. The bright lights are on...deliver!
This fan has clocked a good few comments on socials already predicting that Ospreay vs. Bryan Danielson will be the “best wrestling match ever”. Talk about pressure. Living up to that will be some challenge, and it’s why Dynasty’s featured bout might end up being considered a slight letdown after the fact. Unfair? Yes. The way it is? Also yes.
Whether Ospreay wins or not (and he should), this fantasy epic could turn into an AEW-led anticlimax for the ages. Think that pyro business between Kenny Omega and Jon Moxley more than Cody vs. Dustin back when this promotion’s three letters were the freshest thing in the biz.
2. Loud CM Punk Chants Blight Dynasty
If booming “CM PUNK! CM PUNK! CM PUNK!” chants do fill the Chaifetz Arena in St. Louis on Sunday, then Tony Khan only has himself to blame. He was the one who put Punk’s name back on the lips of AEW fans everywhere by airing backstage footage from Wembley on Dynamite. That ridiculous decision can be tarted up as build for FTR vs. The Young Bucks, but no.
It was a dreadful call.
Pro wrestling crowds are known for their rebellious streak, especially in the modern era. People delight in trolling companies and loudly letting them know about it. In other words, Punk’s name could become a problem at Dynasty. Ospreay vs. Danielson? “CM PUNK!“. Swerve winning the World Title? “CM PUNK!“. You get the idea.
There should be a quick meeting before the show to outlaw any GTS-style moves too. That’d only encourage the masses to remind Tony just how stupid it was to use his company’s valuable TV time to focus on wrestlers who work elsewhere. Things could get even more miserable too...
1. “CM Punk” Gets Involved
Right, no. No, Tony Khan wouldn’t be this daft, would he? Picture the scene: The Young Bucks are about to pull down the AEW Tag-Team Titles when some extra wearing a CM Punk mask hits the ring and stops them. Or, maybe Matthew and Nicholas will employ this extra to help them win - in effect saying that Punk finally apologised to them.
Urgh.
Being totally honest, this writer isn’t exactly high on AEW’s product or Tony Khan’s leadership right now, and so he can’t completely rule out something this asinine. If Tony dares make CM bloody Punk (again, a dude who doesn’t even work here anymore) the main talking point at Dynasty, then he’ll be shooting himself in the foot with both barrels.
We get it. The Bucks are trolls with this EVP stuff, but Punk’s name doesn’t need to be dragged back up after Dynamite’s recent silliness. Full focus should be going on a potentially cracking ladder match between two top tag-teams, and yet...AEW might not be able to resist another dig.
What other nightmares could come true at AEW Dynasty? For more wrestling, check out WWE Draft 2024: 10 Roster Trades That MUST Happen and AEW Dynasty 2024: 10 Things That Must Happen!