Best (And Worst) Of NXT 2016
A quick look back at 2016 for all the wrestlers down in Full Sail.
To be generous, 2016 was...a year. With all of the celebrity deaths, nation disintegration, and general terribleness one has done to their neighbors, it's safe to say that we are ready to start fresh and move on to the next year.
But before we do that and wipe our hands with the last 365 days, we should look back at the WWE's developmental territory NXT. Besides declining ratings and a lack of main event level talent - especially in the women's division - NXT had a relatively great year. The Full Sail crowds are just as crazy as ever, the tag team division has had itself a bit of a renaissance, and the TakeOver specials have been a real shining point in a PPV schedule that has been shaken up so much. Even if the main product starts suffering, you could always count on NXT to be your hour of great wrestling.
It wasn't always great though. Here's the best and worst from NXT this year.
15. Worst Surprise: The Purge Of The Women's Division
If you take a look at the past year or so, seven of the top women of NXT have been taken from Full Sail and made their way to the main roster. Although this is great for them as performers, it has left NXT's Women's division with a serious problem: who are left to be the faces of the company? Sure, there's Asuka, who has already taken up the top spot perfectly (she looks pretty comfortable up there, doesn't she?), but the rest of roster right now is pretty darn thin.
If you take a quick look at who's left, you'll see a lot of question marks more than anything definitive. Ember Moon looks great and she can go in the ring, but can she be the babyface to replace Asuka when she eventually moves up to the main roster? Can Liv Morgan, someone that NXT already has high hopes for, improve in the ring so that she can realistically compete with The Four Horsewomen?
And then there's Peyton Royce and Billie Kay, the two heels that basically took the mean girl act Emma and Dana Brooke did a year ago, and haven't done anything substantial with it. To say that the division is in good hands with Asuka as champion is a bit of a stretch, but if you have any faith in what they are doing down there at Full Sail, then I say that there is a high hope for a productive 2017.
14. Best Surprise: Joe Beats Nakamura
Surprises don't happen a lot in NXT, but this year was full of them. The Revival winning two NXT Tag Team Championships was unheard of earlier this year, as well as the call-up of Apollo Crews and Enzo and Cass after WrestleMania. But there was one surprise that I think really shook up NXT, and that came during the last NXT TakeOver in Toronto.
In a move that asked more questions than anything else, Samoa Joe beat Shinsuke Nakamura to win the NXT Championship for the second time. This does two things to NXT's narrative. Firstly, no longer do you need to go to the main roster once you drop the championship to someone else. Joe has been in NXT for a couple of years now, and it looks like he could continue to be there for a lot longer (though not likely).
The second thing it does is humanize Nakamura: he can lose. Sure, Joe gave him a low blow before the Muscle Buster, but a pin is a pin. Nakamura isn't undefeated anymore, so it is possible to see him actually lose to someone if the time is right.
Of course, NXT Osaka reversed the decision and Nakamura is the champion again, but his record still stands.
13. Worst Debut: Dan Matha
Vignettes aren't NXT's strong point. Andrade Almas' hype videos made him look like a sympathetic face, reliving the days where he was a luchador, maybe now struggling without a mask. What we got instead was a luchador babyface that had all the confidence in the world - and some of the worst in ring gear I've seen in a long time. But one debut trumped them all this year as being completely forgettable and truly terrible.
And that is Dan Matha.
You might be asking, "Who is Dan Matha?" Well, Dan Matha had hype videos for weeks, showing him as this big muscle, body builder type of athlete. And then we saw him, back acne and all, get destroyed by Samoa Joe in what was a complete waste of a segment. Joe got some good heat, sure, but what were we supposed to get with Matha? Why hype him up just to watch him get taken out so quickly and without remorse?
12. Best Debut: Shinsuke Nakamura
Bobby Roode's debut was indeed "glorious" - the pomp and circumstance of his entrance music and his Ric Flair-esque robe fitted him perfectly, and will surely translate well to a mainstream audience. But one debut eclipsed even that, and is maybe one of the best of all time. That honor is bestowed to Shinsuke Nakamura.
We had no idea what we were in for at TakeOver: Dallas. Were we going to get a watered down, Americanized version of Nakamura, or were we going to get something that was just as weird and as awesome as his stuff in New Japan?What we got was an epic string section, blinding lights, and an entrance that rivals Chris Jericho's as one of the best of all time. The match afterwards was just as incredible.
11. Needs Improvement: Liv Morgan
What do you get when you take Carmella, minus her charisma, minus her in ring ability, and add twenty times more Jersey? I guess you get what Liv Morgan currently is. With a character that is a complete recopy of another talent who was just in NXT, she already held the distinction of being unoriginal. Further still, her ring work looks incredibly stiff (like a board, not hard hitting), and is probably some of the worst on the NXT roster.
Although she has been getting slightly better as time has gone on, it's a wonder why she is getting the push that she was. Feuding with Royce and Kay when they should be feuding with Asuka is a big deal, and even fighting Asuka is a large leap forward for her standing in the Women's Division. All of this in spite of having Ember Moon, who is probably the second best wrestler in that division, basically sitting on the side lines waiting for her well deserved opportunity.
Liv Morgan needs to get better in the ring if WWE really want to use her. That and a gimmick makeover would do her wonders.
10. Most Improved: No Way Jose
Dancing gimmicks that work are just like finding a piece of hay in a stack of needles - it's almost impossible and it hurts to even look at. But that's what we got with No Way Jose when he debuted: an all day fiesta that always seemed to have a smile on his face and a song in his heart. His move set wasn't anything to ride home about, and his finisher of a baseball pitch punch was just too gimmicky for my taste.
But once he turned and got serious, everything kind of clicked. He expanded his move set to include a real finisher with the TKO, got better on the mic, and had some actual, competitive matches that showed that he was no joke. Is he a main event talent? No, not in the slightest. But his overwhelming charisma and in-ring style could take him farther than any other dancing gimmick has gotten.
9. Worst Gimmick Change: Wesley Blake
Someone seriously help me here... what the hell is Wesley Blake's new character?
Is he a metrosexual cowboy who is way too into himself?
Is he a body donna of the new era?
Is he some sort of future body builder really into keytar music?
Words cannot express how much Wesley Blake's new persona just rubs me the wrong way. It's not doing him any favors as a performer either. It did, however, give me one of the funniest moments of the year when he blew two kisses at Shinsuke Nakamura - which he caught - and stomped them to the ground. Back to the drawing boards...I hope.
8. Best Gimmick Change: SAnitY
Remember how Eric Young debuted in NXT? The show after Samoa Joe solidified himself as champion, EY came down and issued the challenge. He lost, and was never heard from again...
...Until very recently, where he, Nikki Cross, Sawyer Fulton, and Alexander Wolfe debuted together as SAnitY, a crazy, no holds barred stable mixed with some rather UNstable characters. Not only was this a great reinvention of Eric Young, this was a great re-introduction to Sawyer Fulton - who was tag teaming with 'The Curse Of Greatness' Angelo Dawkins before this. SAnitY's mission statement is simple: wreck havoc and take what they want. It's an attention grabbing gimmick, and hopefully they won't be squandered over the next year.
7. Worst Feud Of The Year: Blake Vs. Murphy
When it comes to a bad feud, one only has to look at the terrible usage of the former Tag Team Champions Wesley Blake and Buddy Murphy. After their break up with Alexa Bliss and with each other, they were basically used as two jobbers playing a game of oneupsmanship. You lost to Kota Ibushi, I'll lose to Shinsuke Nakamura. You lost to Dillinger? I'll lose to Almas.
The end of the feud was a match between the two of them, which ended with Samoa Joe destroying both men. For Samoa Joe, it seemed like a good move to take out these two former champs out. However, I was hoping for a babyface change for at least Murphy, but we instead saw the duo for the last time on NXT TV. Maybe next year they will resurface...
...Or maybe not. You just never know with NXT these days.
6. Best Feud Of The Year: Bálor Vs. Joe
To put it mildly, NXT isn't the best at creating and maintaining feuds within the show. There's usually one for each championship, and an extra mini feud just to keep the card moving. But this year especially had some of the better feud development in recent history, especially with long time talent making the transition to the main stage.
When it comes to this year in feuds, Bayley vs. Asuka definitely comes to mind, although it was rather one sided throughout. Now that he has proved human, the Nakamura vs. Joe feud finally feels eventful and must watch. However, the only feud this year that was truly epic started in 2015, and kept getting better with age.
I'm talking of course of Finn vs. Joe. For the better part of the year, these two were going back and forth over who really was the main man of NXT. Bálor had Joe pretty early on, with some great wins at NXT Dallas and London. But a house show in Massachusetts turned Joe into the ruthless champion we know of today. One cage match later and we had one of the most iconic feuds in NXT history, right behind Owens vs. Zayn.
5. TakeOver Of The Year: Toronto
Of all the categories covered in this post, this was the hardest to pick. Out of the four NXT TakeOver cards we saw this year, which was the best?
It came down to two - Dallas and Toronto. When you put it to paper, it gets even more blurred. Both had stellar NXT Tag Team Championship matches, great Women's matches, and two main events that ended the night off right. It really came down to the "filler matches". The Zayn vs. Nakamura match was an instant classic, but the Corbin vs. Aries match lacked that kind of energy to really get invested in. Meanwhile, we had the Dillinger vs. Roode match that was all kinds of great, and The Authors of Pain vs. TM61, which really showcased both teams' ability to work well together on the big stage. And at that point, Toronto had Dallas beat.
Don't get it twisted though: both were fantastic shows, but Toronto just edges Dallas.
4. Match Of The Year: Zayn Vs. Nakamura
The Revival vs. American Alpha, either of The Revival vs. #DIY matches, even Dillinger vs. Roode could all be considered match of the year candidates for the NXT brand. But none compared to the introduction of The King of Strong Style, and the conclusion of the Zayn Era.
The story was simple: Sami Zayn needed a match for WrestleMania weekend. He had just lost his spot to Samoa Joe, and felt like he deserved one more match on the second biggest stage of that weekend. So GM William Regal obliged, giving him the debuting Shinsuke Nakamura. Those two names on the same card basically sold the match itself, and what we got was one of the greatest debut matches in WWE history.
That match alone stole WrestleMania weekend, and thanks to the Network, we can keep watching it until something even more epic comes our way.
3. Tag Team Of The Year: The Revival
There are about four teams this year that you could make a case for Tag Team of the Year in NXT. The Authors of Pain have ripped through the entire roster, taking the Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic for themselves this past month at TakeOver: Toronto. American Alpha rode a wild wind of momentum entering the year, reaching its pinnacle at Dallas. They would fall a little while afterwards, but have been hot on SmackDown since the draft. When they cooled off, #DIY picked up that heat and ran with it, having multiple Match of the Year candidates and winning over the Full Sail crowd in the process.
But only one team this year went hard... all day and all night...
Yeah, The Revival are the tag team of the Year. Not only because they are the first ever two time NXT Tag Championships, but they have put up some of the best tag team matches in recent memory. Scott Dawson has always been a reliable bruiser, but Dash Wilder has really come around to be a fantastic partner both on the mat and on the mic. It'll be interesting to see when these two will be called up, because they have more than deserved that opportunity. The problem is if WWE will give them that push - so far no NXT talent has won either of the tag team championships.
2. Woman Of The Year: Asuka
I mean...who else would it be? Bayley had a good couple of months, sure, and Nia Jax was fine for her rather brief tenure in NXT, but the entire year was the reign of The Empress of Tomorrow.
Since day one of her time in NXT, she has always been treated as a big deal. Currently undefeated, she has run roughshod over the entire division (besides Ember Moon, but we have 2017 for that) and hasn't looked back. WWE had to go out and get legends to face her, and even Mickie James couldn't dethrone her.
Asuka exudes confidence - to the point of over-confidence at times - but that makes her such a great character. Her smile is dangerous, and her almost sadistic pleasure for getting slapped is something that just fits with her work. She can take it, she can dish it out, and she is the only force to be reckoned with within the Women's Division. Just imagine her on Raw or SmackDown Live...who could ever stop her?
1. Superstar Of The Year: Samoa Joe
When it comes to main event stars, NXT only really had three for the entire year of 2016. At the start, it was all Finn Bálor. His Demon King persona kept fans enamored and his in ring ability was second to none. Then he passed the torch to Shinsuke Nakamura, whose body of work in his short time in America speaks for itself. His English still needs some work, but his Strong Style speaks to the WWE fans in the best ways. Both of the men were great in 2016, but there was only one man who spent the entire year in the main event scene, and that was the Samoan Submission Machine.
Out of the four Takeover specials, Samoa Joe main evented all of them, two of which as NXT Champion. His turn as the hungry challenger was great when he was feuding with Finn, but his animalistic destruction of the entire roster when it was himself versus Shinsuke was grade A awesome. No lie, this is some of his greatest work as a wrestler since his early TNA days when he was fighting for all the belts with Kurt Angle. Samoa Joe is by far the MVP of NXT for 2016 - his ring work, promos, and overall presence was something to admire for a show that shouldn't be holding seventeen year veterans. Hopefully WWE finds room on their main rosters for him - that kind of talent shouldn't be held back any longer.
-
Do you agree with these selections? Let us know in the comments down below!