Casting The Roddy Piper Film

Sam Rockwell As Rowdy Roddy Piper? Alison Brie As Cyndi Lauper?

Sam Rockwell Piper 2
WWE/WhatCulture

While mainstream audiences seem to be turning away from professional wrestling at an alarming rate, the wider world has seemingly never been more interested in the dark stories that accentuate the industry's history. Dark Side of the Ring has shown that, and an increasingly large list of biopics seems to be on the horizon. According to director Kyle Newacheck, a Roddy Piper film is almost certainly around the corner.

One of pro wrestling's greatest characters, 'Rowdy' Roddy Piper left a trail of bloody noses and shocked audiences behind him, whether as a detested heel in the '80s or as a beloved badass babyface a decade later. Piper died in 2015 but he will never be forgotten.

Casting a Roddy Piper film is no easy task, such is the tremendous range of personalities that made their mark on his life. Wrestling history is littered with characters that were so successful because of how unique they were (and are), so finding the right people for those roles is no easy task.

Still, good to give it a go, if only for the charm in trying to find someone to accurately portray Greg 'The Hammer' Valentine. Such opportunities don't come around every single day.

10. Stanley Toombs - David Arquette

David Arquette Scream 4
Dimension Films

Roddy Piper's rebellious nature was developed early on, and it was a spiky relationship with his father that set the future Hot Rod on the road to international superstardom. Real name Roderick Toombs, Piper grew up in Manitoba as his dad (Stanley Toombs) worked for the RCMP (the Mounties, not The Mountie), a difficult arrangement that made for a fractured relationship. It is only somewhat ironic that Piper won his only singles championship in WWE by defeating The Mountie.

The final nail in the family coffin came when Piper was expelled from school for carrying a switchblade with him, an event that eventually saw Roddy leave home and live in youth hostels for a while. Little is known about his father outside of these vague details, but it is clear that any story about the rebellious Hot Rod must start with this relationship.

There are few actors with as intimate an understanding of the professional wrestling business than former WCW World Heavyweight Champion David Arquette, a formerly-maligned performer who has experienced something of a renaissance in recent times (culminating in the tremendous 'You Cannot Kill David Arquette' documentary). Arquette would be a great pick for this potentially grating role.


9. Kitty Jo Dittrich - Brie Larson

Unicorn Store Brie Larson Grapefruit Kale
Netflix

Roddy Piper and Kitty Jo Dittrich got married in 1982 and remained together until his death in 2015, a depressingly rare example of a major pro wrestler from the '80s who didn't leave a trail of broken marriages in his wake. Piper's private life remained largely private, as the Manitoba-native concentrated more on cultivating a public personality than allowing the curtain to be drawn back at all.

Mrs Roddy Piper might not have featured much in Hot Rod's professional life but her presence isn't going to be ignored in the biopic. Not a huge amount is known about Kitty Jo, which makes casting her very tricky indeed. With little understanding of personality to go on, how do you set about finding the right individual to portray this stabilising influence on Piper's life?

With that in mind, you can put together a laundry list of names who can fill the role. Elisabeth Moss? Saoirse Ronan? Brie Larson? You can't really go wrong with any of them but my vote is going to the latter, largely because of the mirrored desire to keep a private life private.


8. Hulk Hogan - Chris Hemsworth

Chris Hemsworth Hulk Hogan
Netflix

Let's face it; if the film happens to be about someone who was a big deal in '80s WWE, Hulk Hogan is going to play a major role. Not actual Hulk Hogan, but someone portraying the Hulkster. This is particularly true when it comes to 'Rowdy' Roddy Piper. It can be argued that the feud between Piper and Hogan was the first beef that thrust WWE well and truly into the mainstream.

Piper and Hogan were on opposite sides of the ring for the main event of WrestleMania I, Piper the classic heel and Hogan the ultimate babyface, with their respective tag team partners. The two would lock horns many more times throughout their careers, all the way up until the late '90s and the Monday Night Wars.

Who should play Hulk Hogan? As Chris Hemsworth is already down to play Hogan in that biopic, than why not have the Avengers star double up and portray the leader of the most powerful force in the universe in this film too? It seems like a no brainer. Unless Hemsworth makes a mess of the Hogan role, obviously.


7. Andre The Giant - Paul Wight

Big Show Andre
WWE/WhatCulture

If its a story about 1980s professional wrestling, Andre the Giant has to be involved. Roddy Piper and Andre didn't really cross paths on too many occasions, with only one televised singles match in the history books, but Andre is a historical presence that is too big to ignore. Even if he's hanging around in the back of shots or drinking legendary amounts of beer in a post-show blaze, Andre the Giant must be in the film.

Finding someone to play the monolithic Roussimoff is no easy task, but the wrestling business has groomed a ready-made option. The Big Show was originally booked as Andre's son and has frequently been touted as the ideological successor of wrestling's great giant. Casting Show as Andre in the Roddy Piper film seems to make all the sense in the world.

This is particularly obvious, as Andre likely wouldn't have much of a speaking role in the movie. It is the physical side of things that really matters here, and Big Show is the closest thing the modern world has to The Eighth Wonder of the World.


6. Greg 'The Hammer' Valentine - Rich Sommer

Rick Sommer Greg Valentine
WWE/WhatCulture

The rivalry between 'Rowdy' Roddy Piper and Greg 'The Hammer' Valentine is just about as legendary as it gets, an iconic feud that culminated in objectively the greatest dog collar match in the history of dog collar matches. The feud lasted two years, with the good friends perfecting their battles and improving their game between the ropes as a result. When you think of Roddy Piper rivalries, Greg Valentine is at the top of the list.

Casting 'The Hammer' isn't the easiest thing in the world. In classic Hammer style, it isn't a starring role but it needs to be taken seriously. Valentine was an old fashioned professional wrestler, one built like a tank made out of beef and with a no-nonsense face that oozed toughness. You won't find many blokes that fit that bill sending headshots to studios.

Still, Rich Sommer kinda looks like Greg Valentine, right? It remains to be seen whether the Mad Men star could get in the sort of shape that Valentine was and an even bigger question whether he can reproduce the tough guy vibe, but that face is half the battle.


5. Mr T - Winston Duke

Mr T Winston Duke
WWE/WhatCulture

Their feud may have culminated in one of the worst WrestleMania matches in the history of the show, but the beef between Roddy Piper and Mr T was a generation-defining one. It helped make that first WrestleMania the game-changer that it was, and it carried all the way over to 'Mania 2. We can forget the miserable match at that show and focus instead on the fascinating story that spanned those shows.

Piper and T famously didn't get along, to say the least. You could say the two 'hated' each other, to the point where the boxing match at WM2 was the forced end of the feud because of fears of legal ramifications. Piper despised T's apparent disrespect for the pro wrestling industry and he wasn't the sort of character to let that slide. It all fizzled out in the end, but this is an integral part of Piper's career and the development of pro wrestling.

Who should play Mr T? Quinton 'Rampage' Jackson got the gig for the 2010 remake of 'The A Team', but a whole decade has passed since then. Winston Duke has been a breakout star of the last few years and has the physical charisma and tough demeanour required to accurately portray ol' B.A. Baracus.


4. Ric Flair -  Zac Efron

Zac Efron Ric Flair
WWE/WhatCulture

It might not be a popular casting move, but Zac Efron gets the role of 'The Nature Boy' Ric Flair. The former High School Musical star has fleshed out his repertoire in recent years, playing roles as varied as Ted Bundy and Philip Carlyle. The days of Efron being a boyish charmer and nothing else are long gone.

Roddy Piper and Ric Flair are Mount Rushmore characters of the same era. When Flair moved to WWF in 1991, it was no great shock that he immediately feuded with Hot Rod, a continuation of a partnership that thrilled fans in a most vitriolic era. It was Flair who eventually inducted Piper into the WWE Hall of Fame, calling Roddy the 'most gifted entertainer in the history of professional wrestling'.

Some readers might question the age difference here, but it is important to remember that Efron is the same age today as Flair was in the early '80s. Throw in Zac's energetic charisma and undeniably punchable face (a must for any self-respecting heel) and you've got a natural fit for the Dirtiest Player in the Game. Disney to Ted Bundy to Ric Flair is a pretty bizarre career arc too.


3. Cyndi Lauper - Alison Brie

Cyndi Lauper
coolinthe80s.com

Cyndi Lauper and the wacky world of professional wrestling go way back, and Roddy Piper was there from the get-go. Lauper was an integral part of the Rock 'n' Wrestling Collection, the embracing of mainstream culture that saw Vince McMahon's travelling roadshow go nationwide. The relationship worked both ways, of course, and Lauper was able to call upon a motley crew of characters from pro wrestling to embellish her chaotic persona. Piper starred in the video for 'The Goonies R Good Enough' alongside Captain Lou Albano and plenty more wrestling wackos.

Lauper and Piper had great chemistry on-screen, working closely together in the build to that fabled first WrestleMania, although Lauper featured alongside Wendi Richter at that show. It has been argued that Lauper's famous 1984 appearance on Piper's Pit kickstarted the WWE we know (and, erm, love) today. You don't tell the story of Roddy Piper without giving that famous time some shine.

The COVID-19 pandemic might have stopped GLOW from making it to a fourth series but Alison Brie has shown that she has the chops to bring together that most magnificent of combinations; outlandish 1980's style and the wackier side of professional wrestling.


2. Vince McMahon - Bradley Cooper

Vince McMahon Bradley Cooper
WWE/WhatCulture

'Who will play Vince McMahon?' might just be the most commonly asked question in all of wrestling biopics. The fingerprints of Vince McMahon are all over professional wrestling like no other industry and those same prints are found on the careers of the men and women who gave their lives to its development, Roddy PIper included.

With that in mind, who plays Vince McMahon? The role needs to marry together Vince's boyish charm and a ruthless streak, straddling the line between a would-be jock desperate to fit in and a cold-blooded businessman looking to obliterate all the competition. These aren't easy boots to fill.

Despite spending more time behind the camera than in front of it these days, Bradley Cooper still feels like a good fit for the young Vince McMahon. Cooper has been in-line to play Vince in the past and the frequency with which his name comes up for the role isn't a coincidence. He also remains aesthetically young enough to pull it off, although it is easy to forget that Cooper is only a few years older now than Vince was at that first WrestleMania.

And if we need someone to portray latter day Vince, I can't look past Harrison Ford. Obviously.


1. Roddy Piper - Sam Rockwell

Sam Rockwell Piper
WWE/WhatCulture

Someone has to play 'Rowdy' Roddy Piper, obviously, but who? Hot Rod was one of a kind, a once in a generation personality who transcended the industry that made him a star, a mainstream name whose charisma and energy dragged professional wrestling from the underground to the mainstream. Those aren't boots that anyone should feel confident about filling.

Piper wasn't your conventional pro wrestler. He didn't look like a tough guy, he didn't look like an athlete, he didn't look like a bodybuilder, but he managed to rise above those preconceptions to become one of the toughest men in the history of the industry, no small feat. An unconventional pro wrestler demands an unconventional actor in control.

Sam Rockwell gets my nod, as much for his manic energy as his ability to veer between a despicable bad guy and an endearing hero. Roddy Piper ticked both of those boxes in his long career, to say the least. There are no shortage of talented actors in Hollywood who could play the role, but the maniacal eyes of the former Best Supporting Actor Oscar winner win out for me.


Contributor
Contributor

Born in the middle of Wales in the middle of the 1980's, John can't quite remember when he started watching wrestling but he has a terrible feeling that Dino Bravo was involved. Now living in Prague, John spends most of his time trying to work out how Tomohiro Ishii still stands upright. His favourite wrestler of all time is Dean Malenko, but really it is Repo Man. He is the author of 'An Illustrated History of Slavic Misery', the best book about the Slavic people that you haven't yet read. You can get that and others from www.poshlostbooks.com.