CM Punk’s WWE Return: 10 Nightmares That Could Come True

How long will this WWE honeymoon period between CM Punk and Triple H last?

CM Punk Triple H WWE
WWE

Interest in CM Punk's WWE return ranges between people wanting to see their hero headline huge shows like WrestleMania and others rubbing their evil little hands with glee wondering when things will blow up behind the scenes. There is a sense of inevitability about that whether you're pro Punk or against him.

The man's track record precedes him, after all.

Is Triple H about to live the same nightmare Tony Khan did? Probably not exactly the same one. Regrettably, there was a general feeling of inmates running the asylum for a while over in AEW, and that lack of leadership shouldn't be as much of an issue on the WWE side.

There are tricky moments on the horizon though. Everything feels all shiny and new again for Punk on the E side, but that's unlikely to last forever. What happens when the honeymoon period is over? What's more, could others on the roster sheets reject Hunter's bold move and seek pastures new themselves?

None of these things are impossible. This is the absolute worst that could occur during Punk's WWE reprise. Look in his eyes, what do you see? A divisive personality...

10. His Return Is "Too Safe"

CM Punk WWE
WWE.com

This is a valid concern following Monday's episode of Raw.

Punk stood in-ring to close out the show and pretty much said he was going to toe the party line like never before. Obviously, he didn't outright say those words, but the man might as well have graciously thanked Triple H for the opportunity and promised to be a good boy for the duration of his new contract.

Here's the thing: Some fans out there adore CM Punk's rebellious streak. They like that drama and intrigue follows him everywhere he goes, and they're looking forward to more of the same (within reason) in WWE. Anything else could be deemed "too safe" by those people, and that won't satisfy them.

This is a tough one for Trips to get right. On one hand, he needs to make sure Punk knows what's expected of him and who he represents. On the other, stripping away all the fire from Punk is like telling peak era 'Stone Cold' not to use middle fingers.


9. WWE Misses The Obvious ‘Mania Play

WrestleMania XL logo
WWE

The WrestleMania rules have changed since the last time CM Punk worked the biggest show of WWE's calendar year. Now, 'Mania has been super-sized to two nights, and that means his chances of headlining the thing have vastly increased. Surely, surely Punk will get a headline berth come April 2024.

What if he doesn't?!

That'd be a clanger from WWE. It's possible that Hunter gave his new hire assurances before Punk put his name on the dotted line again in the first place. Also, CM vs. Seth Rollins (middle finger thrown up by the latter at the tail end of Survivor Series and all) is the kind of story that writes itself and would be perfect for the top spot on either night in Philadelphia.

Punk fans the world over won't be thrilled with WWE if they stick him in the mid-to-upper card at 'Mania and he doesn't get to finally close one of those elusive supershows. No, no that headline slot has to happen. The guy's sanity might depend on it!


8. Other Ongoing Concerns Are Ignored

LA Knight
WWE.com

WWE has done a masterful job of turning Max Dupri into the kind of worker fans would accept as a Royal Rumble winner. LA Knight himself deserves the bulk of praise, because it's he who reached for more brass rings than Sonic has gold ones, and he's smashed every chance Triple H has given him during this push.

Similarly, GUNTHER has been on a tear as the longest reigning Intercontinental Champ ever, and many long to see what he'd be capable of further up the card in main events. Does CM Punk landing back in the E diminish those acts in the eyes of WWE creative?

Possibly.

There are only so many top spots available, and WWE's roster is bursting with ongoing concerns Trips has to focus on. Roman Reigns, Seth Rollins, Cody Rhodes, Jey Uso, Drew McIntyre and now CM Punk are only some of the many who'll need to be creatively satisfied.

That could, rather unfortunately, spell disaster for someone like Knight heading into WrestleMania season.


7. Fans Turn On A Mega-Push

CM Punk WWE
WWE.com

Pro wrestling fans are fickle.

That's not some internet writer building a lofty podium and looking down on anyone. The guy writing this is as guilty as anyone! Traditionally, we're a spoiled bunch, and we tend to occasionally reject things we bloody well asked for in the first place. Roman Reigns and John Cena spring to mind there.

Look above to see an interesting sign behind CM Punk on Raw. It references Jack Perry's "cry me a river" comment in AEW, and has Punk's name scored out. Sure, that's just one fan in a sea of thousands, but it's gonna be tough to maintain the same kind of fervent positivity for CM's return long-term.

Fans could even turn on the man and rebel against WWE's presentation. That'd be nothing new, but it would be a shocker for someone like Punk who regards himself as a man of the people fighting against corporate machinations on their behalf.

Listen out for some boos if his babyface push is relentless.


6. WWE Books Another Screwjob

Triple H Vince McMahon June 27 news thumbnail
WWE.com

It's true that Vince McMahon has less say in WWE business than before, but he's like the little red devil constantly popping up on Triple H's shoulder. Although 'The Game' has creative say, it's fanciful to imagine he doesn't privately seek advice from his father-in-law at least every now and then.

Montreal Screwjob rip off part 8,776 incoming then, baby.

Publicly, Hunter has told the press how he and CM Punk squashed their remaining beef recently. That might be true, but there's still business to do, and every personal issue is ripe for storyline use. So, imagine a world in which Trips screws Punk out of a title like Vinnie Mac did (for real) to Bret Hart back in 1997.

No, nobody actually wants that. Yes, most would prefer that the screwjob trope was put to bed without supper permanently. WWE loves it though, and there's always a slight chance they'll go for broke with another version of an overplayed classic.


5. A New Shield Debuts

Shield Masks
wwe

Admittedly, the word fanciful could be used for this thought too.

The Shield's original purpose was tied to CM Punk before Roman Reigns, Seth Rollins and Dean Ambrose became a true standalone unit doing their own thing. That's something to keep in mind, especially if WWE wants to try some blasts from the past during Punk's company reprise.

Picture this: Punk is a cutting a promo on Rollins during their feud, then the old Shield theme suddenly starts playing. Looking up, CM sees three wrestlers in the old skull-style face masks walking down the steps through the crowd. Shield 2.0 would be born.

Three different wrestlers would be under the masks, obviously, but their tactics would be pretty much identical to what came before. Anyone thinking this sounds too far-fetched should remember that WWE has hit the repeat button on their own booking before.

A 'New Shield' would be too much for some to stomach.


4. AEW References Galore

CM Punk
AEW

WWE deliberately steered clear of any chat about CM Punk's most recent employer during his comeback at both Survivor Series and on Raw. There were no "shoot"-style comments from Punk, the commentary team or any of the other wrestlers about AEW, and that's a good thing when one stops to consider the alternative.

If only All Elite showed the same restraint.

The sheer number of WWE name drops and references on AEW programming became something of a running joke for a while, and there'd be no need for Punk to bother going there. Sadly, resisting temptation forever could prove too challenging once creative (and Punk himself) starts to run out of ideas.

Legally, Punk has to be careful what he says about Tony Khan, The Young Bucks, Kenny Omega, Hangman Page, Jack Perry etc, but there's nothing stopping him from cracking inside jokes with a wink and a nod. He shouldn't though, because it wouldn't achieve anything.


3. Backstage Drama Dominates

WWE Survivor Series CM Punk
WWE.com

Was Punk looking down at his watch on Survivor Series to signal "clobbering time", or is he ticking down the seconds until another backstage drama hogs the headlines? The man himself would probably roll his eyes at this, but wrestling fans expect those antics from him now. Such nonsense has followed him around, and he has been a common denominator in all of it.

Sad, but true.

It'd be a dream if this second go at WWE life went off without a hitch behind the curtain. However, if reports start popping up of Punk getting into arguments with other wrestlers or members of management, then few will actually be shocked to hear it.

Punk has to do everything in his power to keep things clean. This WWE comeback must be remembered for epic matches, fiery promos and on-screen greatness, not high school-esque drama and all that other silly nonsense.


2. There’s A Messy Real-Life Fight

Triple H CM Punk WWE Survivor Series 2023
WWE

Worse, things could get physical.

Tony Khan lived a PR nightmare once CM Punk started throwing hands with The Elite backstage after All Out 2022. The media scrum had been bad-tempered enough, but then things boiled over when The Young Bucks, Hangman Page and Kenny Omega took exception to some of the things Punk had said.

No promoter wants a real backstage fight on their hands. They're few and far between in modern pro wrestling as it is, and WWE prides itself on a professional backstage environment. Triple H will not tolerate anyone scrapping for real in his locker room or behind the curtain at shows, basically.

Could a fight break out? Well, yeah, but only if management doesn't step in before punches get thrown. Things going to the extreme is totally avoidable, and something WWE higher-ups must be mindful of. They don't want wrestlers fighting backstage at WrestleMania mere minutes before a big match, put it that way.


1. He Causes Others To Quit

Drew McIntyre Seth Rollins
WWE.com

It's honestly hard to know for certain what's true and what's kayfabe regarding this whole Seth Rollins and Drew McIntyre being angry stuff. Wrestlers have worked the media before, after all, and everyone will surely be eager to make as much money as possible in the long run.

Still, if the reports are accurate, then a few might make that cash somewhere else.

Triple H was playing a bit of a dangerous game by keeping cards close to his chest regarding CM Punk. If guys like Seth and Drew definitely didn't know he was coming in, then that's risky. One reportedly detests Punk, and the other's contract is ticking down heading into the most crucial period of the financial year.

Hopefully this doesn't happen, but what if Punk's arrival eventually causes others to think about heading elsewhere? WWE's loss could be AEW's gain, in short. Again, never rule this sort of thing out in wrestling.

Which other nightmare scenarios could come true during CM Punk's WWE comeback? For more like this, check out 3 Ups & 3 Downs From AEW Rampage (Nov 25 - Results & Review) and 10 New Directions For WWE After Survivor Series: WarGames 2023!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.