Every Paul Heyman Guy Ranked From Worst To Best
The Pushed, The Protected & The Punished.
Roman Reigns became Universal Champion for the first time in nearly two years at 2020's Payback, just two days after he joined up with Paul Heyman in what proved to be one of the company's biggest creative surprises in some time.
'The Big Dog' returning at SummerSlam was billed - before we knew it - as something we'd "never see coming", but it could be argued that this alliance was an even bigger shock.
Heyman's had incredible success with a variety of different talents, but his character is that of a rat that tries to lure in bigger rats so the two of them can rule wrestling as the sewer it often is. The turn means more than the return, and as shocking as it as that Roman's made the switch, there are plenty of cases where this exact move was for the best. It's the quite a few that didn't that he has to worry about.
Ranking here is based entirely on how the wrestler did with Heyman by their side, not some sort of sideswipe at their career at large. For a label that comes with a certain gravitas, it's not always been as straightforward a star-making vehicle as it may seem...
27. Curtis Axel
A stark decline for the "Paul Heyman Guy" brand before it'd be finished off completely a year later, Curtis Axel's half-baked push alongside a Heyman without both Brock Lesnar and CM Punk at the time made the second generation feel like second.
Within months, he was a goon. Protected Heyman against the returning babyface Punk got Axel TV time, but not wins.
26. Team Lesnar
Team Lesnar were all f*cking massive and 40% a bit f*cking sh*t, but what an amazing aesthetic this gang of giants really was.
With Brock Lesnar and The Big Show already in his pocket, SmackDown General Manager Paul Heyman assembled A-Train, Matt Morgan and Nathan Jones just in time for the 2003 Survivor Series in an effort to take out Kurt Angle, Chris Benoit, and the newly babyfaced John Cena.
They lost match and went their separate ways shortly afterwards, but it was a fun small window for five fun enormous wrestlers.
25. Cesaro
One of the contemporary rule-proving exceptions to the gravitas of the 'Paul Heyman Guy' label, Cesaro's relationship with 'The Advocate' was under-thought to the point where it looks closer to a burial of Heyman than a push for his client.
The working relationship wasn't ever fully fleshed out, to the point where all of Cesaro's newfound babyface momentum before their union was flushed away.
24. Dark Patriot
Under the Dark Patriot hood, Doug Gilbert didn't end up being quite as influential as brother Eddie, but did win the ECW Tag Team titles as part of Hot Stuff International with Paul E Dangerously managing them both.
Ultimately, his legacy wasn't quite as hefty as his more famous sibling's, but Heyman's presence gave the slightly listless gimmick a bit of extra oomph in that new environment.
23. The Samoan Swat Team
Paul Heyman spoke fondly of his time with the future Headshrinkers when he mocked Samoa Joe for being a Samoan outsider during his feud with Brock Lesnar. The affection was rooted in Heyman's own history.
Replacing the Original Midnight Express as Paul E Dangerously's new charges, Samu and Fatu turned a solid WCW stint alongside the 'Psycho Yuppie' into a largely successful WWE run just a few years later.
22. Hardcore Holly
Hardcore Holly's ECW 2006 run remains a somewhat forgotten element of the erosion of professional relations between Paul Heyman and Vince McMahon as the latter's reimagining of the Extreme brand continued unchecked.
There were worse choices to play mercenary on behalf of the heel Heyman, but the show was so polluted by bad choices at the time that the pairing felt like a rotten move too far - especially when Holly replaced Sabu in the Extreme Elimination Chamber.
21. Heidenreich
A noble failure, Heidenreich's partnership with Paul Heyman was nearly enough to get him over as a threat to The Undertaker and all the other babyfaces on SmackDown.
In the end, it took Heyman and 'The Deadman' to try and extract a little more from the limited but oddly charismatic big man. Coming to a head in 2005, it also served as Heyman's last full time on-screen role before the doomed 2006 ECW revival.
20. Jimmy Snuka
Jimmy Snuka's often-forgotten run in the pre-"Extreme" Eastern Championship Wrestling saw him brought together with Paul E Dangerously when Heyman was still mostly sporting reminders of his legendary WCW run.
Bringing the yuppie persona in alongside a heel 'Superfly' after recruiting him for Hot Stuff International, Dangerously added unique flavour to this unique take on one of WWE's then-most iconic characters.
19. Ryback
Paul Heyman embraced the most cartoonish aspects of his personality in attempting to get Ryback over as more than just a hired goon in the shadow of Brock Lesnar.
It didn't totally work, but there was a certain charm to how much both committed to the bit. Their desperation to destroy CM Punk was born futile, but there was a modicum of fun to be had watching their own odd relationship blossom during the angle.
18. The Dudley Boyz
A natural fit based on their shared history, The Dudley Boyz and Paul Heyman sadly only came together on screen when both acts were floundering.
Bubba Ray and D-Von were treading water on SmackDown in 2004, while Heyman's persona had failed to rebound from losing his job as SmackDown General Manager in that year's Draft. A feud with The Undertaker - most notable for the Great American Bash's Concrete Crypt shambles - sadly didn't rectify the situation.