Every WrestleMania Triple Threat Match Ranked - From Worst To Best

15 three-ways at the Showcase of the Immortals, but which one tops the lot?

The modern professional wrestling fan may take them for granted somewhat, but three way matches were once extremely innovative. There is a lot of debate around where the concept started in North American pro-wrestling, with some claiming ECW popularised the match with the infamous Terry Funk v Shane Douglas v Sabu bout in 1994. Regardless of where it came from, in the 1990s it was still new and fresh. Due to the fairly modern creation of the match, there wasn't a single triple threat match (as it is known in WWE) at WrestleMania until WrestleMania XV in 1999. If you can guess who was involved in the match before clicking through the answers, your WWE trivia is on point to say the least. Since the very first one, there has been a total of 15 triple threats on the Grandest Stage of Them All. All except one has seen a championship on the line, with three of these closing out the show, although this didn't first happen until WrestleMania XX. In fact, between WrestleMania XV and XXVI, only two Manias (XXI and XXIII) have been without a single three way. Where do all of these matches stack up against each other? Some have deservedly reached legendary status, whereas some others are best left forgotten. Here is every triple threat match at WrestleMania, ranked from worst to best.

15. Jazz (c) Vs. Trish Stratus Vs. Lita - WrestleMania X-8

It is with a slightly heavy heart that I place this match at the bottom of the list, as it had the unenviable honour of following The Rock vs. 'Hollywood' Hulk Hogan at WrestleMania X-8, one of the greatest matches in the history of the event. The crowd were completely spent at the climax of that contest, and the decision not to close the show with it looks more and more like lunacy with every passing year. The three women fought over the Women's Championship, and though they worked hard they were fighting a losing battle from the start as the crowd just did not care. Take the audience reaction out of it however and you have a decent match, with Jazz anchoring everything so that the two popular women could bump off her, which they did with some aplomb. It's easy to forget just how enjoyable a performer Jazz was; she played her role in the division to perfection. She picked up the win in this match by absolutely destroying Lita with a top rope Fisherman's Suplex.

14. Hardcore Holly Vs. Billy Gunn (c) Vs. Al Snow - WrestleMania XV

If this was the answer you gave to the question posited in the introduction regarding the first triple threat match at WrestleMania then congratulations, but please get out of the house a little more. This plunderfest was for the Hardcore Championship opened the show, somewhat of an easy victory for bookers in the late 1990s. If you've seen one hardcore match from WWF/E during the Attitude Era then you've most likely seen them all, and none of the three men taking part in this bout had enough backing from the crowd for it stand out in any way. The action was also kept to the ringside area, which would become rarer and rarer as the Hardcore title got sillier and sillier. Holly picked up the win in the end after capitalising on Gunn giving Snow the Fameasser on a chair, regaining the title he had lost to Gunn just weeks prior.

13. Trish Stratus Vs. Victoria (c) Vs. Jazz - WrestleMania XIX

A year after the women had to follow Rock and Hogan, the title was defended in a triple threat match once more, although this time in a much more favourable position on the card. Victoria replaced Lita in the line up and was the champion heading into the match, leading to a much more solid contest. The bout was aided by Victoria, who can lay claim to being one of the most consistent women wrestlers of her generation. Steven Richards was at ringside accompanying Victoria for the match, and he got involved a little too often for my liking, but it did allow the heel champion to do anything and everything to keep her title. Trish was also picking up steam as a babyface at this point, and her progress in the ring was impressive to say the least. The interference from Richards would eventually backfire as he managed to hit himself with a chair via the ropes, leading to Victoria missing a Widow's Peak and Trish picking up the win one Chick Kick later.

12. Randy Orton Vs. Cody Rhodes Vs. Ted DiBiase Jr. - WrestleMania XXVI

Remember when everyone was convinced that Ted DiBiase Jr. was going to be the breakout star of Legacy and Cody Rhodes would fade away? That didn't really go as expected, did it? It was definitely safe to assume at the time, as the break up of Legacy seemed to be moving in a direction where the son of the Million Dollar Man would come out as the star. This was the logical final chapter in the Legacy story, but something was off throughout. Cody and Ted were on the same side to begin with, finally putting the boots to Orton after months of mistreatment. This obviously wouldn't last, and Cody and Ted came to blows to very little reaction. Looking back years later, it is amazing how irrelevant Cody seemed at the time. All of the expected spots were hit, including a rope-assisted double DDT from Orton to his former protégés. After punting Cody into his Dashing gimmick, Orton countered Dream Street into an RKO and picked up the pin over Ted. The wrestling throughout was more than competent, but the match did little for anyone involved. Orton stayed where he was, and Cody and Ted came out looking more useless than ever.

11. Kane Vs. Raven (c) Vs. Big Show - WrestleMania X7

The greatest WrestleMania of all time featured arguably the best Hardcore Championship match in memory. Somehow, Raven had given the division something approaching legitimacy thanks to some memorable brawls as champion, and his performance in this match against the two behemoths was first rate. He brought weapons and didn't wait for things to kick off - a sensible option when going up against such challengers. The match started hot, held together by Raven's desperation to hold onto the title. Heyman made note of leaving Show and Kane to kill each other, which seemed to be Raven's strategy. The action memorably spilled backstage, with men being thrown through walls, windows and Lord knows what else. A golf cart became involved, obviously, and eventually everything returned to the ringside area. Show threatened to chuck Raven off the stage but Kane was there with a big boot, sending both of his foes plummeting down below. He joined them with a leg drop onto Show, picked up the 1-2-3 and walked away as champion. This was as good as it was going to get for the Hardcore Championship.

10. John Cena Vs. Randy Orton (c) Vs. Triple H - WrestleMania XXIV

Three of the biggest stars of a generation were always going to be involved in a triple threat on the biggest stage of them all, but what is surprising is that Randy Orton walked in as champion and next to no-one gave him a chance of walking out as such. One interesting note to make: Randy Orton has been involved in the most triple threat matches at WrestleMania, with four under his belt. Cena gets a typically excellent WrestleMania-worthy entrance, with a high school marching band playing him to the ring. The three men put on what you would expect in a big match environment, ticking all of the boxes in front of a hot crowd at a huge show. Orton takes something of a beating throughout, and never really seemed like he is on the same level as Cena and Hunter. This made it all the more shocking when he punted Triple H in the head and picked up the win to retain his title. The match was kept relatively short (14 minutes) and was a lot more fun than one would expect from three deathly serious competitors.

9. Team Angle (c) Vs. Los Guerreros Vs. Chris Benoit & Rhyno - WrestleMania XIX

http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x7dffa_team-angle-los-guerrero-rhyno-chris_sport If WrestleMania X7 hadn't reached such heights, WrestleMania XIX would surely be held up as the greatest of all time. The talent pool that WWE had at the time was remarkable to say the least, and such that six elite workers got thrown into what was essentially a tag team title match for the sake of itself. There simply is no way that this could have been anything less than excellent. Shelton Benjamin and Charlie Haas were far and away the standout tag team of WWE at this time, and in many ways they defined the division for a while. Eddie and Chavo were really coming into their own as a team, and the individual skills of Rhyno and (particularly) Benoit meant quality was assured. This was kept regrettably short however, clocking in at less than ten minutes. This gave it a somewhat frantic feeling, which in some ways helped the bout, but it still left a sense of 'what could have been'. The pace is furious throughout, and some of the timing of the spots is particularly impressive. A nice finish too, with Rhyno goring everything in sight only for Shelton to steal the win for the champions.

8. John Cena Vs. Edge (c) Vs. Big Show - WrestleMania XXV

Much like the women's three way that started this list off, this match had the unenviable honour of following a genuine show-stealer in the shape of The Undertaker and Shawn Michaels. These are three of the biggest names of a generation however, and they managed to keep the crowd invested throughout the match. Cena gets another fantastic entrance, flanked by legions of Cena clones. Big Show took control early on, giving Edge a particularly short shrift as this was during their love triangle (of sorts) with Vickie Guerrero, an image I really do not need to return to my brain. Cena, the good guy, was actually added to this match by blackmailing Vickie with footage of her affair with Show, which he then showed anyway. What a guy! The match itself was pretty darn good however, as the three tried to add some innovative spots to the fairly tired three-way formula, and Big Show looked pretty dominant for the first time in seemingly forever. The finish was visually impressive too, as Cena managed to get both Edge and Show up on his shoulders for a moment before giving them individual AA's and pinning Show to pick up the strap.

7. Randy Orton Vs. Kurt Angle (c) Vs. Rey Mysterio - WrestleMania XXII

Another WrestleMania, another Randy Orton triple threat match. In hindsight, it is remarkable how badly WWE bungled Rey Mysterio's rise to the top. His performance and winning of the Royal Rumble was perfect, but he was then goaded into putting the shot on the line against Orton, who subsequently beat him. Rey was added back into the match, but the wind had well and truly left the sails by that point. This match really should have been a one-on-one battle between Angle and Mysterio, giving them a chance to recapture the magic of their bout at SummerSlam in 2002 and stretch it out over a longer time, ending with Mysterio's big moment. As it was, this was rushed at nine minutes and left Rey's moment somewhat flat. This might all sound a bit negative for such a lofty spot on the list, but then you must remember, this match included Rey Mysterio, Randy Orton and Kurt Freakin' Angle. How could it not be great? They knew time was short and as such threw absolutely everything into those nine minutes, with near falls and false finishes all over the shop. The crowd wanted Angle to win, but still popped big for Rey's victory.

6. Chris Benoit Vs. Kurt Angle (c) Vs. Chris Jericho - WrestleMania 2000

Before doing the research for this article, I was convinced that this match would be top five at the very, very least. I mean, come on, it is Chris Benoit, Kurt Angle, and Chris Jericho, three men who could all lay claim to being the best in-ring performer of a generation. This is as close to a dream triple threat as WWE could find at the time. This match was for the two titles that Angle held at the time, the Intercontinental Championship and European Championship. It would be a match with two falls, the first for the IC title and the second for the Euro equivalent. I completely forgot that Bob Backlund had managed Angle prior to this, and crazy Uncle Bob was the one who had put both belts on the line. Predictably, Angle goes on to lose both belts without being involved in either fall, giving him a reason to stay in the hunt for both. As with a number of matches on the list this is hurt by a lack of time, something that resonates even more here as there were two falls within 14 minutes. Still, it was Kurt Angle, Chris Benoit and Chris Jericho, so there wasn't too much to complain about.

5. Roman Reigns Vs. Brock Lesnar (c) Vs. Seth Rollins - WrestleMania XXXI

Looking back, this was the only decision WWE could make in order to save the main event of their biggest show of the year. This match started out as a one-on-one between champion Brock Lesnar and Royal Rumble winner Roman Reigns, before Seth Rollins came out mid-match to cash in his Money in the Bank contract. If you weren't aware of that then I'm surprised you are even reading this. This was all about the moment and spectacle, less about the match. Before the appearance of Rollins we had seen Lesnar brutalise Reigns with a barrage of suplexes, before Reigns began an improbable comeback and seemed as though he was able to pull it off. The crowd wasn't entirely sure what to do, not ready to accept Reigns as their lord and saviour despite the desperation of the WWE for it to happen. Enter Rollins. Even if the finish was a foregone conclusion from that point on it was still a marvel to see, and chills made their presence felt up the spines of everyone watching the event. Rollins delivered a Curb Stomp to Reigns and that was that, a moment that will live long in the memory for all who saw it.

4. Batista Vs. Randy Orton (c) Vs. Daniel Bryan

Much like Rollins cashing in was the only way to salvage the main event of last year's WrestleMania, finding a way to get Daniel Bryan into the big match of WrestleMania XXX was WWE's only hope of avoiding a full scale riot. Imagine if this had not happened. and instead we had to sit through Randy Orton vs. Batista as the main event of the biggest WrestleMania of all time? Daniel Bryan's performance at WrestleMania XXX is well-documented and highly praised, but this still doesn't feel like it does it enough justice. He single-handedly defeated all of Evolution (well, with the exception of Ric Flair) despite all of the odds being against him. He suffered a post-match beatdown by Triple H earlier in the evening, did a stretcher job in this match and yet still came out on top. It was an inspiring performance. The performances of Batista and Orton should not be overlooked either, as they toed the line between teamwork and combat extremely well. They worked together to put Bryan through a table with a Batista Bomb-RKO combo, before returning to seeing who would walk out with the belts. As the night came to a close neither man could lay claim to that prize however, as Bryan took the downpour of confetti to send the crowd home happy.

3. Edge & Christian Vs. The Dudley Boyz (c) Vs. The Hardy Boyz - WrestleMania 2000

A TLC match before that was even a thing, this was a triangle ladder match between the three teams who completely revolutionised tag team wrestling in the modern age. Edge & Christian, The Hardyz, and The Dudleyz did battle in what was seemingly a constant stream of three way matches, yet they seemed to wow the audience every single time. What these six men were doing to each other's bodies borders on the insane. An argument can be made for this being the most innovative of all of their matches. It came before the TLC gimmick, and as such what they put together in this match was truly groundbreaking. They left a trail of destruction and violence before them, with table after table being smashed in the name of increased violence. Finishers were hit from the tops of ladders, and the crowd responded in kind, losing their collective minds every time two men were suspended in the air for a moment in time. A platform was created on top of two ladders underneath the belts, and eventually it would be Edge and Christian who managed to reclaim the straps. It seemed impossible at the time, but they would go on to top this in future.

2. Chris Benoit Vs. Triple H (c) Vs. Shawn Michaels - WrestleMania XX

10 years before a scrappy undersized professional wrestler did the impossible and defeated two sports entertainers on the biggest stage of them all, Chris Benoit was performing similar miracles of his own. In a moment that many thought would never happen, Benoit made Triple H tap out to the Crippler Crossface and ended the show embracing his close friend Eddie Guerrero as two men who stood at the top of their profession. In hindsight WrestleMania XX was a pretty below-par show, with way too much filler clogging up the undercard. The main event delivered in spades however, with all three men bringing their working boots to put on a match that pushed the triple threat singles bout to previously untouched heights. There were a number of innovative spots throughout, including the memorable visual of Triple H stopping Michaels from tapping out by holding his hand up in the air. This match also featured all three men heavily, with little in the way of rest for the third man, something that plagues most triple threats. This is true until the former D-Generation X buddies put Benoit through a table, leaving them to fight it alone until Benoit returns out of nowhere to re-enter the match. What happened in the years after this has soured anything and everything that Chris Benoit was involved with, but taken as a standalone match this is as good as any main event in WrestleMania history.

1. Edge & Christian Vs. The Dudley Boyz (c) Vs. The Hardy Boyz - WrestleMania X-7

One year on from their groundbreaking triangle ladder match at WrestleMania 2000, these three tag teams somehow managed to take that blueprint and up the ante, in what became one of the most iconic and memorable matches in the history of WrestleMania. It is absolute mayhem from start to finish, with bodies, ladders, tables and more biting the dust before all was said and done. Rhyno, Spike Dudley, and Lita were added into the mix for this match, although the three didn't make their presence felt until towards the end. This didn't lessen the match at all; if anything it added new dimensions of madness to what was going on. It is all extremely difficult to follow, in the very best way. The match goes just over 15 minutes, and to say it flies by is a complete understatement. Everyone involved (including the extras) bumped like this was the last match they would ever take part in, and the list of terrifying bumps simply beggars belief. Sure, there are a lot of moments when plunder is being set up for fairly convoluted spots, but in the entertainment business who cares? These eight men and one woman put their bodies over the line in order to put on the best show they could, and good Lord did they succeed. The most iconic spot of the entire match sees Edge hitting Jeff Hardy with a spear in mid air as the latter hangs from the title belts. It is the sort of moment that lives on in video packages forever more, and deservedly so. No matter how many times it is seen, it is still an incredible moment. After Bubba Ray Dudley and Matt Hardy are sent crashing through a house of tables on the outside, Rhyno carries Christian on his shoulders to claim the straps for E&C. It is a suitably insane end to the most insane of wrestling matches.

Contributor
Contributor

Born in the middle of Wales in the middle of the 1980's, John can't quite remember when he started watching wrestling but he has a terrible feeling that Dino Bravo was involved. Now living in Prague, John spends most of his time trying to work out how Tomohiro Ishii still stands upright. His favourite wrestler of all time is Dean Malenko, but really it is Repo Man. He is the author of 'An Illustrated History of Slavic Misery', the best book about the Slavic people that you haven't yet read. You can get that and others from www.poshlostbooks.com.