Every Wrestler With 10 Or More Dave Meltzer 5 Star Rated Matches

The Best of the Best, according to Big Dave.

Will Ospreay
NJPW

Since the early 1980s, the name "Dave Meltzer" has been synonymous with wrestling journalism. The man responsible for the Wrestling Observer Newsletter has been the source for wrestling news for decades, and his status as the king of scoops still looks incredibly secure.

Aside from providing insider knowledge (and annoying Jim Cornette), Meltzer is also known for his star rating system. Dave has rated thousands and thousands of match on a scale of 0-5 (or higher) since the very first edition of the Observer came out, and his scores are still highly regarded and coveted by those in the industry.

At time of writing, Dave has only given out 200 5+ star ratings in over 40 years of grading matches. Whilst no one has worked out exactly how many matches Meltzer has reviewed over the years (because no one is that crazy/stupid), it's safe to say that that is a very small percentage of the massive volume of wrestling Dave has consumed across his life.

But which grapplers are in double figures when it comes to perfect matches? The following 12 competitors have all scored 10 or more 5+ star ratings at the time of writing, so let's find out who Dave's favourites are when it comes to the sport he loves.

12. Ric Flair - 11 Matches

Ric Flair NWA Title
WWE.com

An unsurprising start, The Nature Boy was part of the unofficial first 5 star Meltzer match when he took on Butch Reed at a Florida wrestling event in 1982. Flair would go onto have ten more perfect matches across his storied career, bringing his total to 11.

Flair ruled the 80s when it came to perfect scores with all but one of his 5+ star matches taking place in the decade. Yes, that is 5+ star matches, because Charlotte's Dad was part of the first ever 6 star match when he took on Ricky Steamboat in 1989. That's 28 years before a certain match in the Tokyo Dome.

Flair also owes some of his success to the WarGames format as two of his 5 star-ers came inside the dome. And one of those matches had Sid in it, so you know Ric was really working hard.

The fact that Flair is the only American on this list says a lot about the kind of wrestling Dave Meltzer likes and just how good Ric Flair was to overcome that. His technical, methodical style played right into Dave's hands at a time where matches outside of Japan struggled to impress him.


11. Shingo Takagi - 12 Matches

Shingo Takagi
NJPW

Speaking of styles of wrestling that Dave Meltzer likes...

Shingo Takagi made his name in Dragon Gate and Ring Of Honor before arriving in New Japan Pro Wrestling in 2018. One year later, he would receive his first 5+ star award from Dave Meltzer, a whopping 5.75 stars. Since that match, Takagi has added eleven more perfect or better scores to his repertoire, bringing his total up to 12.

Takagi has definitely been helped to this number by the calibre of opponents he has faced in New Japan. Tetsuya Naito, Tomohio Ishii, and Jeff Cobb are just some of the names Takagi has faced in perfect or better matches, with some of his fiercer rivals coming later in this list.

But it is ultimately Shingo's hard-hitting, ultra-aggressive style that has won him all of these accolades, especially as most of his opponents in the Junior Heavyweight division were high-flyers, allowing for an effective blend of styles.

A wrestler just hitting his prime, Shingo Takagi has already achieved so much so quickly with New Japan and is an extremely exciting prospect for the future. Expect him to be much higher on this list if we ever do a revision.


10. Manami Toyota - 13 Matches

Manami Toyota
By Jocsh3 (Own work) [CC BY-SA 3.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0)], via Wikimedia Commons

The only woman on the list, Manami Toyota made her pro wrestling debut in 1987 for prominent joshi promotion All Japan Women's Pro-Wrestling (AJW).

Toyota was extremely successful across her 30 year career, capturing almost a dozen championships in AJW and winning the fantastically-named "Tag League The Best" five times. She was also a hit at the Observer awards winning "Match of the Year" twice and "Most Outstanding Wrestler" in 1995 - the only woman to ever claim said award.

It's not surprising that the Observer loved Toyota so much; her mixture of explosive speed, hard-hitting offence, and lack of fear made her a true spectacle to watch. Couple this with the state of Western women's wrestling during the years she was performing and everything starts to make sense.

Meltzer was a huge advocate for joshi wrestling in the 90s and Toyota was one of AJW's biggest stars. She had an equally-talented field of competitors to wage war against, from Kyoko Inoue to Akira Hokuto to Aja Kong. She may not be the most famous wrestler of all time, but we all owe Mania Toyota a great debt for keeping Dave sane during a rough time for wrestling.


9. Kota Ibushi - 13 Matches

Kota Ibushi
NJPW

Kota Ibushi is another wrestler seemingly born just to make Dave Meltzer happy. A smaller, agile performer who can also match strikes with the best of them and who has a seemingly indestructible neck, Ibushi can get a good match out of anybody. Even a blow-up doll...

This might explain why Ibushi has also notched up 13 perfect or better scores in his time. Despite having his first at 2015's Wrestle Kingdom, it wouldn't be until 2018 when Ibushi hit his stride. He scored five top level ratings that year, including an astonishing 5.75 rating in the final of that year's G1.

Since then, Ibushi has become one of New Japan's most reliable big match performers, be that in the G1 or in the main event of Wrestle Kingdom. His aforementioned skills combined with his extremely affable character make The Golden Star very easy to get invested in and every year he is seemingly able to break out more and more exciting moves in his matches.

Ibushi has fallen off the radar since he lost his IWGP World Heavyweight Championship but rest assured that, when he does get back on track, we're all in for a real treat.


8. Hiroshi Tanahashi - 15 Matches

Hiroshi Tanahashi Bad Luck Fale
NJPW1972.com

One of the leading figures in the New Japan renaissance of the 21st Century, Tanahashi has carried the company as its top champion a record eight times for a combined total of almost four years. He's also won numerous secondary and tag team straps and has main evented countless of the company's biggest shows.

But what sets Tana above those with equal amounts of talent is his consistency. From his first 5 star match in 2012 to his most recent in 2021, Tanahashi has always put in excellent performances against a variety of different opponents. This would explain why he's picked up 15 perfect or better match scores across his career and why he's likely to get even more despite the fact that's he's in his mid-forties.

The comparisons to John Cena have been around for a long time, but where New Japan's Ace surpasses his American counterpart is his willingness to keep up with the changing styles of pro wrestling. Tanahashi is still a phenomenal worker with his excellent conditioning letting him put on epic-length matches with some of the best in the business.

There's a reason he's got 15 times as many 5 star matches as Big Match John.


7. Akira Taue - 15 Matches

Akira Taue
Pro Wrestling NOAH

In the 1990s, Dave Meltzer awarded the WWF just three 5 star matches. In that same decade, he awarded All Japan Pro Wrestling 29 5 star matches.

If you don't know your All Japan then some of these next entries might be a bit of a mystery to you, but let's begin with one of the company's most legendary talents, Akira Taue.

Taue was part of a group of four wrestlers (the other three of which will all be appearing later on in this list) who revolutionised All Japan and are responsible for most, if not all, of their perfect match scores. The "Super Generation Army", as it was known, was rocked to its core when Taue defected to join a rival group, but this split just led to even better matches as these two factions waged war throughout the 90s.

With 15 lots of 5 stars to his name, Taue is no slouch, but the vast majority of these matches came in tag or six-man tag affairs. He only managed one 5 star-er in a singles match, which is why he's significantly further down this list than his peers.


6. Will Ospreay - 19 Matches

Will Ospreay
NJPW

At time of writing, Will Ospreay has 19 perfect or better matches to his name and is still only 28 years old.

That means Ospreay was just 23 years of age when he had his first 5 star encounter in 2016, and he's continued to improve year-on-year - first as a Junior, then as a Heavyweight. He's got his big rivals - he's had three 5+ star-ers with Zack Sabre Jr. and four with Shingo Takagi - but he's also given younger stars their first perfect scores, including current NXT UK star A-Kid and UK indie wrestler Michael Oku.

But it's been in New Japan where Ospreay has done his best work and he has scored a majority of his stars. In the Junior division, Ospreay wowed with feats of aerial magic and put some of the best cruiserweight matches the world has ever seen. As a Heavyweight, Ospreay adapted his style perfectly, adding new offense to his arsenal to prove he can hang with the big boys.

As his 30th birthday approaches, there is zero chance of Ospreay ending his career on 19 Meltzer-approved matches. He is a once-in-a-generation talent with so much more left to give the wrestling business.


5. Kenny Omega - 19 Matches

Kenny Omega
AEW

Although not the first match to break the scale, Kenny Omega's main event match against Kazuchika Okada at Wrestle Kingdom 11 was the first in a very long time and brought about significant change in the way Dave Meltzer hands out stars.

Omega would go onto put in two more scale-busting performances with this same opponent before facing Okada one last time in a two-out-of-three falls match at Dominion 2018. That match not only capped off that epic rivalry, but it also capped off Dave's scale with an unfathomable 7 star score.

Combine these matches with the eleven other 5+ star-ers he's had in New Japan and the four he's had so far in AEW and Kenny joins Will on 19 perfect or better scores.

Few wrestling nicknames have been as apt as "The Best Bout Machine" as Kenny can't seem to help himself when it comes to churning out classics. He has command over his body in a way that other wrestlers can only dream of and his extensive catalogue of moves always gets a pop no matter how often he busts them out.

Quite simply, Kenny is one of the all-time greats. Most exciting of all, he's nowhere near done.


4. Toshiaki Kawada - 21 Matches

Toshika Kawada
AJPW

Back to All Japan now and another man who made his name in the Super Generation Army.

Toshiaki Kawada had already had two 5 star encounters before the legendary faction formed, but things got taken a whole new level when Akira Taue betrayed the group. Kawada and Taue had four 5 star matches on opposing teams and then escalated things further when they decided to join forces.

As "The Holy Demon Army", Kawada and Taue captured All Japan's tag team titles six times during their run and are easily the most dominant team in the history of the promotion. They also put on ten 5 star matches, making them the most decorated tag team on Dave's list.

Unlike his former partner, Kawada achieved great success in singles competition, picking up four 5 star ratings in one-on-one encounters. His stiff working style made him a formidable opponent and clearly appealed to Dave's enjoyment of hyper-realistic wrestling.

In total, Kawada ended his career with 21 perfect scores. Again, if you're unfamiliar with 90s All Japan, now may be the time to change that.


3. Kazuchika Okada - 22 Matches

Kazuchika Okada
NJPW

Much to Kenny Omega's dismay, the other half of that 7 star match has three more 5+ star scores under his belt than he does with a total of 22.

Kazuchika Okada owes many of those matches to another man on this list - Hiroshi Tanahashi. In total, the two reached the top of the Meltzer scale six times over a five year period, including one 5.5 star match in 2018. But it's not just Omega and Tanahashi that Okada can make magic with, as he's also had classics with Ospreay, Takagi, and Ibushi.

It's not like any of this is new information; Okada has long been regarded the best wrestler of his generation. His crisp offence, his ring presence, even the structure of his matches are all perfect and his confidence-without-arrogance attitude makes him a great fit for big matches, especially for the World Title. In short, Okada was born to be a pro wrestler.

Let's end this entry with one final comparison between Okada and Tanahashi - Tanahashi is 1 years older than Okada. That means we could have another decade of exceptional matches from The Rainmaker! Dave better start working on a new system...


2. Kenta Kobashi - 23 Matches

Kenta Kobashi Noah
Pro Wrestling NOAH

The penultimate piece of the Super Generation Army and the penultimate entry on this list, Kenta Kobashi is probably best known for inventing wrestling's most devastating finishing move, the Burning Hammer. However, he only used this move seven times in his whole career, whereas he would have a 5 star match 23 times.

Kobashi pulled out three 5 star matches in 1992, five in 1993, five in 1995, and was one of only two wrestlers to have more than one 5 star match in the 2000s, one of which was against Samoa Joe of all people. Kobashi was among those who helped put All Japan on the map and was one of the few to stay with the company following the mass walkout that led to the formation of Pro Wrestling NOAH.

Hard-hitting, freakishly strong, and absolutely terrifying to watch, Kobashi embodied everything that Meltzer wanted in a wrestler in the 1990s; a time where realism was a totally foreign concept in the West.

A true legend, Kobashi came within touching distance of topping this list. Alas, he finished just behind another All Japan icon and a man Kobashi knew very well...


1. Mitsuharu Misawa - 25 Matches

Mitsuharu Misawa GHC Champion
Pro Wrestling NOAH

The founder of Pro Wrestling NOAH, and Dave Meltzer's favourite person, Mitsuhara Misawa sits atop the star rating throne with 25 perfect or better match scores.

He picked up his first 5 star score playing the famous "Tiger Mask" character in 1985. That battle with Kuniaki Kobayashi was only the fifth 5 star match in the Observer's history and the top scores just did not stop.

The final piece of the Super Generation Army, Misawa wowed in matches alongside or against Taue, Kawada, and Kobashi throughout the 1990s. It would be his closest rival on this list, Kenta Kobashi, who gave Misawa his final 5 star match before his tragic passing in 2009 after a wrestling move went wrong.

Misawa is widely regarded as one of the most influential wrestlers of all time, helping to develop the "puroresu" style of wrestling that has become mainstream in Japan and has inspired thousands of other wrestlers across the globe. This, combined with his excellent body of work, is why Meltzer favours him so highly.

He may no longer be with us, but Misawa leaves behind an undeniable legacy of quality, one that will live on forever in the annals of the Wrestling Observer.


Contributor
Contributor

Jacob Simmons has a great many passions, including rock music, giving acclaimed films three-and-a-half stars, watching random clips from The Simpsons on YouTube at 3am, and writing about himself in the third person.