Every WWE Extreme Rules Main Event Ranked Worst To Best
Some should be celebrated, and some should stay in the swamp.
During its 12 year tenure, the Extreme Rules pay per view has accumulated its fair share of golden moments. It also just so happens that not all of these occurred during the main event.
Furthermore, it's fascinating how WWE have, on various occasions, failed to deliver on not only a main event's own hype, but on the standards set by previous matches of the night. Surely on paper, all they have to do is stay true to the title of the PPV. They have in theory, one opportunity in the calendar year to indulge the excesses of extremity, and do it without diving headfirst into the realms of silliness.
Those that have achieved this invariably rank as better matches. In fact, the more favourable main events of Extreme Rules also qualify as outright classics.
Whilst rankings are often subject to personal opinion, Extreme Rules tends to exemplify as well as any other pay per view how certain bookings and stipulations straight-up do not work. Simply put, some main events are worthy of the mantle, and others, are not...
And right at the bottom, there's this...
12. Braun Strowman Vs. Bray Wyatt (2020)
A main event that wasn't a match… of any kind.
Abiding by the desire to never stop providing the world with wrestling television, The Empty Arena Era is done out of no other choice. The Cinematic Era is however done by choice... and it has to go.
For nostalgic purposes alone, it may have been fun for Bray Wyatt to dig out his old persona and it may have been fun to have him step into the ring as part of a long running, multi-persona, feud with Braun Strowman. 'Where's the harm if it's just a one off?' you might say.
Instead, the higher powers saw fit to drop this match in the form of a twenty minute TV movie, which took the finest conventions of horror, ignored them completely, and created a spectacle so contrived and lacking in substance that it was only enjoyable if you laughed at the sheer implausible stupidity of it.
Should arena life ever return to normal, and people look back on the year that wrestling did its damnedest to give out to the world, it's probably best to blinker this event from existence.
11. The Miz Vs. John Morrison Vs. John Cena (2011)
Following their not exactly monumental main event at WrestleMania in 2011, John Cena and The Miz were apparently good for one more round, this time in a steel cage, and accompanied by the fun-boosting antics of John Morrison.
As one can expect, Morrison went to work and stole the show, but even the occasional high-flying Kodak moment couldn't get the crowd behind this. For the better part, the action limped along, and people grew bored.
Business picked up a little when R-Truth stepped into the fray and turned heel. It was to be the start of a long running angle where he, alongside The Miz, would become the top villains of WWE. It had a certain charm, but this underwhelming opener added little excitement to the prospect. Everyone was still salivating over the announcement of a John Cena vs. Rock WrestleMania event that wouldn't happen for another year.
It only meant that this already uninteresting match had to pull something special out of the bag to make it count. It did no such thing. Lackluster all round.
10. Dolph Ziggler Vs. Seth Rollins (2018)
Time to state an obvious fact, substantiated by the giant clock displayed on the titantron and the continuous countdown chants from the crowd: Iron Man matches are all about timing.
WWE chose to give the Intercontinental Championship main event status for one night, which was pretty sweet. This match however was disappointing, because the promise on paper was extremely high. Everybody knew that both Ziggler and Rollins, being the card carrying showmen that they were, had the potential to put on an intensive sweat-strewn exertion for the ages.
Instead, the match limped for about 25 minutes and picked up into a frantic struggle for the all important deciding point in the last five. Its consistent plodding warranted a sense of fatigue for the spectator that could not be rescued. In a 30 minute bout, it felt like 80% of that time was wasted.
Kurt Angle’s cameo stipulation at the end added, well... nothing. One distraction from Drew McIntyre and Dolph scored the victory all the same. The entire match could have been so much more.
9. Baron Corbin & Lacey Evans Vs. Seth Rollins & Becky Lynch (2019)
Here was another idea that seemed workable on the drawing board: A mixed tag match under a main event spotlight. On this particular occasion however, it just wasn't to be. In order to bring some fleeting kayfabe qualities to Seth Rollins' and Becky Lynch's real life relationship, their titles were rendered up for grabs. The challengers? Baron Corbin and Lacey Evans.
Whilst Seth and Becky's in-ring chemistry was effortlessly entertaining, Baron and Lacey seemed awfully out of place, and appeared to be there solely to put over the couples story of Rollins and Lynch. Corbin did his thing and Evans had her moments but this was simply not the setting to propel their careers in any workable fashion.
A supposed highlight came when Seth lost his cool and unleashed hell for leather on Corbin, who'd just performed an unsavoury attack on his fiancée. Whilst dramatic, people probably would have preferred to see Becky get the job done herself. It was only Corbin for heaven's sake.
Brock Lesnar turned up to cash in and squash the whole thing anyhow, as per. It neither subtracted nor provided for the event.
8. Seth Rollins Vs. Randy Orton (2015)
Following Seth Rollins' classic WrestleMania Money in the Bank steal, his bickering with Randy Orton and the internal politics of The Authority continued in steel cage format. The match wasn't really bad, but not exactly great either.
Here, we had another example of a payoff not being able to live up to the hype. The bulk of the event was a little tired, with a few hard hitting moments at the end to rescue pace. Rollins and Orton pulled off some good hits, but should have been capable of a whole lot more.
The proclaimed doorkeeper, Kane, turned out to be the irrefutable highlight of the match. Having shooed off J&J Security with relative composure, his supposed corporate guise began to waver under the responsibility of keeping the main characters of the piece in line. After finally snapping, Kane lost it and took out just about everyone. Old habits die hard, and it was a rarity to see an interesting dimension to his Corporate/Authority gimmick.
In spite of all this, the overall climax of the match left much to be desired.
7. John Cena Vs. Batista (2010)
It was 2010, and Batista was close to leaving WWE for an indefinite period, but not before undergoing an extremely bitter heel run with John Cena. Extreme Rules saw them go one on one in a Last Man Standing match, and it was by no means a half measure.
Whilst drawing from the more jittery and cowardly nuances of heelness didn't exactly become a man with the stature and physique of Batista, he did give it his all in this match. As did Cena. Both competitors' rise to main event status from their early days in OVW ran virtually parallel, so their chemistry and experience with each other made for some intuitive and beefy wrestling at this latter juncture in their careers.
The quantity of hard knocks in this match added sufficient bulk to the Last Man Standing format, and the hardcore elements made it right for the occasion. The victory was achieved by Cena gaffer-taping Batista's legs to the post, which was where The Animal remained, failing like an angry fish until the cameras cut. A bit of an undermining finish, but also sort of appropriate given the setting.
6. Roman Reigns Vs. AJ Styles (2016)
Just five months into his WWE tenure, AJ Styles was an entrenched contender to the World Heavyweight Championship, and Extreme Rules saw Round 2 of his battle with Roman Reigns to take the belt. In this match, the intensity was taken to an enjoyably high level, with both athletes bringing hard knocks to the forefront. The bout spilled out into the crowd, announcement tables crumbled, and both men looked beaten to sh*t by the end of it.
On pushing himself to the centre of attention, Roman's desperation to beat AJ also made for good storytelling as he almost, quite literally, lost face. On a downside, endless interference from Gallows, Anderson and The Usos risked making the whole affair tiresome. One interjection neutralised the other, and Reigns and Styles were brawling well enough without it. Luckily the two contenders continued to do just that.
Complaints aside, this match was as pure a definition of solid as any. Naturally, fans wanted AJ to win, but the returning Seth Rollins, in all his mean-ass heel glory, did its bit to dispel the disappointment.
5. Daniel Bryan Vs. Kane (2014)
Kane's involvement in The Authority was often sporadic and poorly conceived. Luckily, he always had great chemistry with Daniel Bryan. It was good then, that we could suspend the overall silliness surrounding this event and lock in for some superb entertainment. Sensibility was shoved to one side, and in this case, that was a good thing.
If one can overlook Kane expressing visible anguish at being hit with a big sheet of card (or whatever branded wobbly material they place over the top of the announcement table), we can call this a highly efficient display of carnage, that spilled all the way out of the arena and back again.
Daniel Bryan trundling back to the ring in a forklift and rolling Kane slowly off the edge of a pallet seemed at first like an anticlimax. Cue the flying headbutt from the heavens, and a resulting kick-out from Kane, just because more fun could be had. The flaming tables followed shortly after.
Both competitors made sure that this match was an all out crowd-pleaser. Extreme Rules delivered on its name, and the fans got their money's worth.
4. Triple H Vs. Brock Lesnar (2013)
Despite taking each other to the tea party at WrestleMania, The Beast and The Game saw fit to add extra mileage to their feud. The steel cage setting was ideal given the brutal resumes of both competitors, and as soon as Triple H unleashed a sneak attack and socked it to both Lesnar and Heyman, you knew that the hat fit.
The sense of energy throughout this match is nothing short of potent. Lesnar brought out the best in The Game and the sequences progressed from technical to outright rough in consistent measures. Triple H was able to continuously exploit a weakness in Lesnar's knee which brought a dimension of vulnerability to Brock seldom seen in any of his matches since. No squashes here, just a pacy bout and some heavy hits. By the time the chairs and sledgehammers entered the fray, audiences felt well fed.
It might be true that Heyman's interference was uncharacteristic of Lesnar's in-ring dominance, but seeing as he received as good as he gave, it all added to the fun. The entire match was big, noisy and, yes, enjoyably extreme.
3. Samoa Joe Vs. Seth Rollins Vs. Roman Reigns Vs. Finn Bálor Vs. Bray Wyatt (2017)
The 2017 Extreme Rules main event consisted of a fatal five way, with the same number of explosive personalities. The mix of talent was eclectic and the pacing worked out to be damn near perfect.
The match was rife with chemistry. Its bulk consisted of an unlikely alliance between Bray Wyatt and Samoa Joe, who steamrolled the opposition whilst awaiting the right moment to screw each other. It was neat. At the same time, Finn Bálor, being the odd one out, ensured that he'd be more than just a sore thumb, and made his presence known in mighty fashion.
It eventually boiled down to a one on one bout between Reigns and Rollins. One can criticise and say that the countless interactions between these two had stagnated their dynamic, but that's irrelevant in the case of this match. They gave it everything they had.
In short, everyone had their time to shine, and for as long as it lasted, Samoa Joe's victory was a breath of fresh air. It was a rocking good show with a satisfactory resolution.
2. Edge Vs. Jeff Hardy (2009)
In spite of the fact that, in theory, we'd seen it all before, these two veterans of high risk went out their way to remind everyone of their relevance. Extreme Rules was a brand new pay per view and needed the right main event to justify its existence... It had it.
Being experienced workers and having intuitive knowledge of each other allowed Jeff Hardy and Edge to play into fan expectations and surprise accordingly. Take the iconic mid-air spear, which was swiftly countered by a twist of fate, as a prime example of this. The match's climax, which involved Edge getting snared in Jeff's weapon of choice, the ladder, was nothing short of poetic.
It was also a marked occasion where Money in The Bank cash-ins added to the thrill rather than detracted. In the short breadth of his villainous intervention, CM Punk exuded enough personality to state himself as the new equal to Edge and Jeff. In some ways, it was a passing of the torch.
Bravo to all involved.
1. John Cena Vs. Brock Lesnar (2012)
What we have seen recently in WWE, and in no place less than Extreme Rules, is an unnecessary bombardment of stipulations and loopholes which fail to add anything besides frustration. Conclusion: The simpler things are often the better things are.
In 2012, Brock Lesnar returned and commenced his long-running tradition of pushing PG Era standards of brutality to the limit. In just a few strikes, his UFC-seasoned elbows on Cena's head blurred the lines of kayfabe and reality. Was this violent? Hell yes. Extreme? By default.
His comeback and quest for domination pretty much spoke for itself, but Cena also had his own story in this. Undergoing the first portion of his year-long sulk after losing to The Rock at WrestleMania, Cena's mission was to purge the excesses of his frustration, whilst enduring a cathartic beat-down from The Beast.
The resulting blood, rage and pain emitted during this event upheld the standard, remained bereft of cliche, and through the carnal passion of both Lesnar and Cena, became an instant match for the ages.
It did what it said on the tin, but with a level of purity nobody expected.