Every WWE PPV Of 2016 Ranked From Worst To Best
Between Fastlanes, Battlegrounds and Roadblocks, was 2016 a successful year for WWE?
Pay-per-views are supposed to represent the very pinnacle of ‘sports entertainment’; the culmination of weeks and months of build, narrative progression and apprehension, all unleashed on one special night. Over the years, WWE has added to and taken away from their yearly slew of PPV events, in an effort to keep things fresh, and create events that feel unique in their own right.
Since the advent of the WWE Network, however, the term pay-per-view has effectively lost all meaning, since such events can now be watched for a fraction of the price they once were. While this means flagship shows like WrestleMania are now more accessible than ever, it has also lead to an over-saturation of content and ever-diminishing returns.
As a result, 2016 was a year of incredibly inconsistent PPVs, often overshadowed by out-of-ring meta drama that was more interesting than any on-screen feud. The brand split threw a momentary spanner in the works, as did the revival of both the Women’s and Cruiserweight divisions, but no single PPV managed to reach for the dizzying heights of events past. Some reached, and failed, while others didn’t even bother to outstretch a hand…
15. Fastlane
While there’s plenty of room for debate with regards to the ‘Best PPV of the Year’, the bottom of the barrel will likely be unsurprising to most.
Fastlane is supposed to be the show that really kickstarts the ‘Road to WrestleMania’. The Royal Rumble might plant the seeds, but Fastlane is meant to really rev your engines in anticipation of the Grandest Stage of them All. Fastlane 2016 might as well have been called Lay-By. Or Rest Stop.
This was a show that featured Charlotte and Brie Bella’s now forgotten feud, Dolph Ziggler and Kevin Owens’ now forgotten feud, and a match in which The Wyatt Family lost to Kane, Big Show, and Ryback. Why was this allowed to happen on PPV in 2016?
You may remember Brock Lesnar vs Dean Ambrose vs Roman Reigns being decent – and it was – but it also served to kick Roman’s insane superman booking into overdrive, and hyped a WrestleMania main event nobody wanted.
Oh, and Curtis Axel defeated R-Truth in under three minutes. On the main card. On PPV. In 2016.
14. SummerSlam
On paper, Summerslam should have been a hit. It’s a Big Four event, one that boasted a fairly stacked card of big names, big matchups, stipulations and title defences, and the added drama of the post-brand-split fallout should have led to a night of high drama. Instead, we were left with a bloated, overly long show dominated by downright bizarre booking decisions, underwhelming matches, and a restless crowd.
Whereas Summerslam should have been remembered for firmly ushering in the ‘New Era’, it is mostly remembered for Randy Orton’s bleeding head, and for the introduction of a fairly crummy title belt in the Universal Championship. Opinions on the belt have since softened, but the PPV itself still conjures a sour taste in the mouth.
It wasn’t all doom and gloom; Balor and Rollins put on a decent match (if you watch it on mute), JeriKO vs Enzo and Cass was fairly fun, and AJ Styles vs John Cena is a bonafide MOTY candidate. But the quintuple-whammy of Finn’s buckle-bomb injury, the ugly belt controversy, a Reigns vs Rusev non-match, Brock and Randy’s MMAin event car-crash, and an embarrassingly underwhelming WWE Title match between Dolph Ziggler and Dean Ambrose secure Summerslam’s position as one of worst PPVs of the year.
13. Clash Of Champions
Could you remember a single match from ‘Clash of Champions’, without first having to Google ‘Clash of Champions’? Did you even remember that it was called ‘Clash of Champions’, rather than ‘Night of Champions’? The talent certainly couldn’t.
Whereas Smackdown came out of the single brand PPV gates swinging, RAW came out flailing. This wasn’t an especially bad show, it was just completely unmemorable, and featured little in the way of entertaining bouts or dramatic storytelling.
Neither the US nor the Universal title match set the world on fire, nor did the ‘Three Horsewoman’ Triple Threat between Bayley, Sasha and Charlotte. They were fine, but they paled in comparison to the match of the night: the best of 7 finale between Sheamus and Cesaro, and even that ended in a disappointing no contest.
12. WrestleMania 32
Every WrestleMania brings with it a certain sense of grandiosity. While Summerslam can’t get by on name value alone, WrestleMania can be poor, and still generate some fantastic water cooler moments. Such was the case with WM32 – a major step down from the previous year, but an oddly memorable show at least.
The New Day’s Booty O’s entrance has become iconic, even though the following match was as dry as a bone. The Women’s Triple Threat stole the show, as did the announcement that Sasha, Charlotte and Becky would be competing for the gorgeous new Women’s Title (an odd contrast to the Universal Championship reveal several months later), and Zack Ryder’s surprise Intercontinental Title win in a brutal 7-man ladder match elicited a great pop from the (alleged) 100,000 fans in attendance.
Still, the event was plagued by legends cameos, all of which happened at the expense of new talent. The most heinous of these was The Rock’s appearance, which saw him set his own name on fire (talk about symbolism), before pinning Eric Rowan in 6 seconds. All because of a stupid record.
Other lowlights include a total slog of a main event in which nobody knew who to cheer, an utter mess of a 10 woman tag match, the purpose of which was to put over Total Divas, as well as a terribly phoned-in No Holds Barred match between Brock Lesnar and Dean Ambrose, which almost single-handedly drained Ambrose of his considerable momentum and fan support.
11. Roadblock: End Of The Line
Roadblock: The End of the Line seemed to have inherited NXT’s weird TakeOver naming conventions (NXT TakeOver: The End... of the Beginning springs to mind), but very little of its flair or quality. Again, Roadblock wasn’t a terrible show, but thanks to some poor build up and some mismatched heel/face alignments, it wound up feeling more like a decent episode of RAW than a full blown PPV.
The tag division set the bar high early on, with an absolute belter of a match, which saw RAW’s resident odd couple Sheamus and Cesaro finally topple The New Day’s colossal reign. That pace or excitement was never really matched – Neville came close, when he kicked the ever loving tar out of Rich Swann and TJ Perkins, but his brilliant heel-iness was cheered, purely because it signified some actual depth and excitement arriving in the Cruiserweight division.
Elsewhere, yet another mini-Shield reunion fell a little flat, since it came at the expense of golden boys Chris Jericho and Kevin Owens, and Sasha and Charlotte finally(?) ended their lengthy feud in a match that was painful to watch in every way imaginable. Not a disaster, but a weird and slightly uncomfortable way to see out the year.
10. Hell In A Cell
Hell in a Cell featured some good matches, even some that could be called great, but the show as a whole was indicative of WWE’s most glaring problems. Namely, Hell In A Cell was a show about brand names, stipulation matches, breaking records, and ‘Making History’, all at the expense of coherent storytelling.
Three Hell in a Cell matches took place, when only Charlotte and Sasha were embroiled in a feud that warranted such an extreme bout. Roman vs Rusev was a decent match, and Seth vs Owens was arguably the match of the show, but neither felt that they benefited from, or ‘deserved’ to be competing in the Cell. While Sasha and Charlotte put on a highly entertaining if highly uncomfortable Hell In A Cell main event, its build was plagued by incoherent storytelling, shouty Mick Foley promos, and an overwhelming feeling that ‘history’ wasn’t being made, it was being repeated: Charlotte wins on PPV, Sasha wins back on RAW, and lather rinse repeat.
Throw in a heelish DQ win from babyface New Day, a dead-on-arrival Cruiserweight title match, and the slog that was Bayley vs Dana Brooke, and you have a PPV that was fine in isolation, but particularly poor in the wider context of 2016.
9. No Mercy
If there’s one thing No Mercy did better than its peers and rivals, it was branding. Focusing on The Miz and Maryse was the best decision, and the way the show’s posters and trailers mimicked perfume adverts (with Maryse’s ‘Non merci’ voiceover) was truly inspired.
The show itself was a solid, experimental one, featuring a fantastic ‘Main Event’ triple threat WWE title match as match number one, and a dull slog between Bray Wyatt and Randy Orton as the real main event. The decision to put the WWE title match on first seemed wise at first, because everyone assumed it was so The Miz vs Ziggler could go on last, considering how well their Backlash encounter went over with the crowd.
Unfortunately, this was not to be, and while The Miz vs Ziggler was the absolute standout of the evening, No Mercy’s final one-two punch of Naomi vs Alexa Bliss and Orton vs Wyatt left an otherwise good show feeling cold.
8. Extreme Rules
It’s easy to look back on Extreme Rules as one of 2016’s better PPVs. It featured two bonafide Match of the Year contenders, in the form of a Fatal Four Way IC Title match between Cesaro, Sami Zayn, Kevin Owens and The Miz, a stellar WWE Title match between AJ Styles and Roman Reigns, which ended with the long overdue return of Seth Rollins.
The former match was as fast-paced and dramatic as they come, and proved why each man has earned critical acclaim in 2016. The latter match was an absolutely brutal trade-off of near-falls and finishing moves, one that thoroughly cemented both AJ and Reigns as main event players in the WWE.
The rest of the show, however, was not so good. The Tag Title match, the Women's Title match and the US Title match were underwhelming, while Chris Jericho and Dean Ambrose put on one of the worst matches of the year, in the overly long, overly gimmicky ‘Asylum Match’.
No other show featured quite so many peaks and troughs, and its this lack of consistency that prevented Extreme Rules from achieving PPV greatness.
7. Payback
Payback seemed doomed from the start, considering its job was to follow a strange and widely derided WrestleMania, and because its advertised stars, The Wyatt Family, were not actually scheduled to appear.
It was miraculous, then, that Payback managed to be a highly enjoyable event, albeit one with some considerable flaws. AJ Styles and Roman Reigns had the first of a pair of scintillating PPV main events, Owens & Zayn, and Cesaro & Miz both put on solid bouts, and Kalisto and Ryback managed to deliver an underrated pre-show clash.
Still, the absence of the Wyatt’s hurt Payback, as did a clueless repeat of the Montreal Screwjob, and the unfortunate ‘technical knockout’ of Enzo Amore.
6. TLC: Tables, Ladders And Chairs
Stipulation-based PPVs don’t work. Unless your stipulation is the Elimination Chamber or the Royal Rumble, and that match is going to feature once on the card, shoehorning weapons and rulesets into feuds where they don’t belong is a bad idea.
Having said that, Smackdown Live managed to build enough of its feuds to the point where Tables, Ladders and Chairs (but not stairs, never stairs) felt like they were warranted. AJ Styles vs Dean Ambrose was an absolute barn-burning spot-fest, and thanks to the added interruption of James Ellsworth, it was full of high drama and unpredictable twists.
The Miz and Ziggler saw out their stellar feud in style, while Baron Corbin and Kalisto did the unthinkable: they has a good chairs match. Outside of an overly gimmicky match between Nikki Bella and Carmella, this was a solid showing, one that also saw The Wyatt Family pick up tag team gold.
5. Money In The Bank
Money in the Bank is fast becoming WWE’s second best match-centric PPV event, closely following the Royal Rumble. Both events are about earning championship opportunities, so the stakes are built in, and the looming question of when a cash in will take place makes MITB one of the most important events in WWE’s calendar.
This year's MITB match was like a fan’s wet dream – it was a high impact bout, one that featured Ambrose, Cesaro, Zayn, Owens, Jericho and Del Rio at their very best. It also managed to make an entertaining mega-feud out of a languishing and directionless mid-card, and Ambrose’s eventual win and same-night cash in was one of the most dramatic moments of the year.
While most of the card felt like filler, the titular MITB match, Reigns vs Rollins and Styles vs Cena were all fantastic displays of talent.
4. Backlash
Though we’d already seen it happen (and un-happen) before, the Brand Split did feel like a much needed wake up call for a company that was growing ever more stale with each passing month. While the cards were thoroughly stacked against Smackdown Live, they came out of the gates far stronger than their colleagues in red.
Their inaugural PPV show crowned several new champions, including the well deserving Becky Lynch as Women’s Champ, as well as the bizarrely enjoyable pairing of Heath Slater and Rhyno as tag team champs. Most importantly, Backlash saw AJ Styles dethrone Dean Ambrose as WWE Champion, after a fairly uninspiring run. It was a bold move, but one that has paid dividends in the months since.
The Miz and Dolph Ziggler also put on the surprise hit of the year, on a card wherein the only major disappointment was Bray Wyatt losing to Kane, following an Orton injury. Backlash proved that strong storytelling trumps a stacked roster every time.
3. Battleground
Battleground felt like a breath of fresh air, a sign that WWE was on the cusp of great change. Lines had been drawn, drafts had been picked, and fans were ready for WWE to enter its fabled ‘New Era’. Battleground didn’t disappoint.
Bayley’s main roster debut garnered a huge pop, and The Wyatt Family vs The New Day was a lot of fun, as was The Club vs John Cena and Enzo & Cass. The Shield Triple Threat main event was great too, particularly when Dean Ambrose picked up the win to take the WWE Championship to Smackdown.
The match of the night was undoubtedly Sami Zayn
vs Kevin Owens. An utterly intense and emotional match, filled with stiff kicks
and high-risk spots, this was one of few main roster PPV matches that lived up
to its considerable build and hype. It seems crazy that Owens and Zayn have
been fighting/teaming for so long, and can still produce magic every time they
step into the ring.
2. Royal Rumble
The Royal Rumble rarely disappoints, considering the bulk of the show is dominated by one of the most dramatic and entertaining marquee matches in professional wrestling. There's no other feeling in wrestling quite like counting down to a new Rumble entrant, and this feeling pretty much carries what might otherwise be a lacklustre show.
That's not to say Royal Rumble 2016 was lacklustre, though. While everyone predicted that Triple-H would enter last and dethrone Roman Reigns, it still generated a huge crowd reaction, as did the unbelievable sight of AJ Styles in a WWE ring, arguably the best thing to happen to WWE this year.
Royal Rumble also saw Sasha Banks return to a huge pop, declaring her intentions to face Charlotte for the Divas Championship, and a brutal Last Man Standing Intercontinental Title match between Dean Ambrose and Kevin Owens, which set both men up for greater success later in the year. The rest of the card was fairly forgettable, but the Royal Rumble match itself didn’t disappoint - it may have lacked the surprise returns of the previous year's match, but it also avoided repeating 2015's downright awkward ending, and did a great job of teasing feuds that would lead up to WrestleMania.
1. Survivor Series
Although WWE’s constant reiteration that ‘Fantasy Warfare Just Got Real’ was incredibly annoying, it actually wound up being mostly true. Survivor Series has felt like the runt of the Big Four litter for the last few years, and traditional SS matches have often been relegated to story-less lower-card filler. Survivor Series 2016 looked to change that – it featured a stacked card of traditional tag matches, Sami Zayn vs The Miz, and a shocking and controversial Goldberg vs Lesnar main event.
Each tag match highlighted the best that RAW and Smackdown Live had to offer, and while it seemed like the show had been put together simply to put RAW over, everything changed when RAW’s ‘best male competitors’ took on their blue brand counterparts.
In a match that lasted roughly an hour(!), The Wyatt Family, Braun Strowman, Dean Ambrose, Seth Rollins, Roman Reigns, AJ Styles, Kevin Owens, Chris Jericho and Shane McMahon delivered an absolute belter of a match. This was ‘fantastical’ in every sense – future feuds were teased, old rivalries and friendships were revived, and the entire thing descended into the very best kind of chaos, before The Wyatt Family (and Smackdown Live) stood tall as winners.
Your mileage with Survivor Series may depend heavily on your opinion of the Brock vs Goldberg ‘event’ (or your capacity to endure five hours of six commentators arguing about which of two colours is best), but it’s hard to argue that Survivor Series wasn’t the most dramatic and exciting PPV of 2016.