Exact Reasons These 10 Wrestlers Have Failed In WWE

"Too pro wrestling".

WWE

Despite millions of fans around the world, countless investors counting their change and more creative team members than most major Hollywood productions, WWE decisions bow to the whims of one man and one man only. This ship is Vince McMahon's, and he's the one who can make or break careers.

For the men and women here, the latter is perhaps more apt.

It's often hard to look in on the WWE bubble from the outside and know exactly why certain acts don't get the attention they deserve. Stories of McMahon-related idiosyncrasies can be as wild as they are frequent, but it's sometimes difficult to separate what's real from online gossip. After all, not many people are privy to creative team meetings or Vince's private thoughts.

Talented workers are callously discarded at a moment's notice and promising pushes are scrapped without much rhyme or reason, and (as much as it sucks to admit) WWE's roster is stuffed full of performers who are failing right now. They were preceded by others who have already suffered the same miserable fate too.

Here's why...


10. Luke Harper

Why WWE Just Released Luke Harper THUMB
WWE

Reason: Fractured relationship with Vince McMahon.

The Wrestling Observer had a field day reporting on the fact that Luke Harper wanted out of his WWE contract last year. Vince McMahon wasn't keen on letting the former Wyatt Family man and Bludgeon Brother go, but he didn't seem intent on using Harper much either. He was left rotting on the sidelines.

As the story goes, McMahon wasn't impressed by a dark match between Harper and EC3 shortly after WrestleMania 35, and all plans for Luke's return to TV were cancelled. This back-and-forth misery continued until he made a brief comeback at Clash Of Champions 2019 and reunited with his old pal Erick Rowan.

In other words, any relationship Harper and McMahon did share soured. The wrestler believed he was being kept under lock and key for no good reason, and his boss felt the want-away worker deserved to be punished for requesting his release. That's why, when Harper did ask to leave, Vince extended his contract by six months, apparently to make up for lost time when the big man was injured.


9. Tyler Breeze

Dolph Ziggler Tyler Breeze Summer Rae
WWE.com

Reason: Too similar to Dolph Ziggler.

WWE's creative team agreed to book Tyler Breeze against Dolph Ziggler when they called the selfie-obsessed heel up from NXT in 2015. The basis for the feud was solid; Breeze viewed himself as a superior version of Dolph, and the veteran wanted to put the brash upstart in his place.

Vince wasn't a fan.

According to The Observer, McMahon nixed Breeze's push quickly because he didn't think it was working or that the ex-NXT man was on Ziggler's level. Surely that was the whole point of the feud – to get Breeze on Ziggler's level with the more casual audience watching Raw and SmackDown.

Uh uh, said Vince. He believed that the obvious similarities between both men did neither any favours and squashed Tyler's push before it could really get going. That first impression pretty much sealed Breeze's fate, dashed his hopes and eventually sent him spinning back towards NXT.


8. EC3

Dean Ambrose EC3
WWE

Reason: Crappy mini-feud with Dean Ambrose.

EC3 proved in TNA that he could hack it as a top-tier superstar. Sure, that was in a smaller company than WWE, but credentials are credentials, and the heel knocked every promo opportunity out of the park. It was all part of his relentless drive to prove himself after being spurned by WWE once.

Make that spurned by WWE twice.

WWE has done precisely nothing with EC3 on the main roster aside from sticking him in a directionless mini-feud with the outgoing Dean Ambrose before he fled for solace in AEW. This escapade lasted a grand total of around two weeks, didn't help ingratiate EC3 to the WWE audience and was a shameful waste of talent.

When the rivalry fizzled out and Ambrose left, Carter III was left without any role on Raw at all and he's barely been seen since. What was the point of this? Why should EC3 get the blame for a lazy feud against someone who didn't even want to be there?


7. The IIconics

The IIconics
WWE.com

Reason: Vince McMahon didn't want those Women's Tag-Team Titles.

Sasha Banks and Bayley reportedly had to knock on Vince McMahon's door every day and badger him into creating the Women's Tag-Team Titles. When he relented, there was an air of optimism from the entire female division and fans who craved more focus outside the core singles belts.

Things got off to a hot start at Elimination Chamber 2019 when Sasha and Bayley won the new titles and made history. Things fell off a cliff after that, and it was the poor IIconics who suffered most. Suddenly, Vince realised that he didn't care a jot about the Women's Tag Titles at all, and that left Billie Kay and Peyton Royce struggling for TV time as champs.

Their WrestleMania 35 win was the only highlight of an abject 120-day reign.

The IIconics weren't viewed with the same importance as Banks and Bayley, and that's why they've gone missing. It's no accident that the tag belts themselves have been passed around a few more times and pushed into the background lately either.


6. Sami Zayn

Sami Zayn Shinsuke Nakamura
WWE.com

Reason: Atypical WWE star and AEW references.

There's a reason why Sami Zayn has become a mouthpiece for Shinsuke Nakamura, and it's not only 'cause the IC Champ needed someone to cut his promos. No, it shouldn't be forgotten that Sami lost 15 of his previous 16 matches before turning into a loudmouth manager. He was on the slide long before becoming a 'Great Liberator'.

Zayn doesn't fit the mould of a typical WWE star, but he's been able to overcome that with talent and by association with the likes of Kevin Owens.

Another reason for his slide down the totem pole was that AEW reference on an episode of Raw last May. It left Vince McMahon furious; the boss hadn't given the comment his personal seal of approval, and Wrestling Observer Radio later claimed he took Sami aside for a firm chat about why he'd mentioned the rival promotion live on air.


5. Luke Gallows & Karl Anderson

Luke Gallows Karl Anderson
WWE.com

Reason: "Not aggressive enough".

Luke Gallows and Karl Anderson have surely accepted their lot in WWE. They get to perform alongside real-life pal AJ Styles as The OC, and they've been used a little better since Paul Heyman's influence swept across episodes of Raw. Still, they're a shadow of their former selves in New Japan.

If only they were more aggressive.

New Day's Big E said on the team's 'Feel The Power' podcast that Michael Hayes expressed concerns back in 2016 about Gallows and Anderson. He said WWE were under the impression that the duo would be more threatening on screen. At no point did Hayes recognise that Gallows and Anderson were being booked in segments during which they carried fake testicles in a jar.

WWE deliberately cornered the tag-team with the sh*ttiest comedy routines they could and then shook their heads when Gallows and Anderson didn't come across as killers. Worse, the mud from those skits has stuck ever since.


4. Rusev

Rusev WWE
WWE.com

Reason: WWE don't know how to book him.

Rusev has been the stereotypical "anti-USA heel menace", a fun-loving babyface, a loving husband, a genuine threat, a jilted lover and a laid-back playboy during his run in WWE. That's a lot of ground to cover in six years on the main roster, and it proves that the company don't have a clue how to use him best.

In an interview with Lilian Garcia's 'Chasing Glory' podcast, Rusev admitted that his attempts to catch Vince McMahon's eye "never come to anything". The boss has blinkers on when it comes to the Bulgarian's talent, and he doesn't exactly see what fans seem to when they go daft for the guy.

Rusev is still over in spite of this wedding soap opera with Lana and Bobby Lashley. Think about that.

Someone with the staying power to overcome silly storylines deserves better, but he's forced to keep trying and trying to get in McMahon's good graces without much luck. Rusev's failure to become a sustainable main eventer isn't on him, it's on WWE.


3. Cedric Alexander

roman reigns cedric alexander
WWE.com

Reason: Vince McMahon cancelled his push.

It feels like a lifetime ago that Cedric Alexander was working in tag matches with top names like Roman Reigns, beating Drew McIntyre and wrestling AJ Styles on Raw. Last summer, things were looking up for the former 205 Live man. Not anymore.

Dave Meltzer said on Wrestling Observer Radio that Vince McMahon doesn't see much in Alexander and called for his push to be aborted in September. McMahon must've looked at the opportunities Paul Heyman was giving Cedric, scratched his head and decided to put a stop to it. That'd make sense, because Alexander has been relegated to working episodes of Main Event and last appeared in-ring on Raw's 8 November 2019 show against Andrade.

That three-minute loss was hardly complimentary, and he's been limited to 'C' shows and live events ever since 2019's brief shine. Not even Heyman's influence can save Alexander from Vince's whims, apparently.


2. The Revival

The Revival
WWE.com

Reason: "Too pro wrestling".

The Revival might not be long for WWE. Recent news pegs the promotion as confident about re-signing the tag-team, but other reports suggest hints are being dropped that Dash and Dawson would rather ply their trade elsewhere. It wouldn't exactly be a surprise if they fancied a crack at AEW in 2020.

Vince McMahon previously said last October that some on the roster were "too pro wrestling", and there's no doubt that a traditional tag-team like The Revival would fit into that category. They wear their old-school influences proudly, openly speak out against hokey gimmicks and work a no-frills in-ring style.

It's easy to see why they've been repeatedly overlooked then.

If McMahon isn't fond of acts that favour traditionalist elements, then he'll never be a fan of Dash and Dawson. This would also explain why The Revival are pushed into (literally) hammy matches like that 'Miracle On 34th Street Fight' against Heavy Machinery.


1. Cesaro

cesaro brass ring
WWE.com

Reason: Those damn brass rings.

Years ago, fans looked forward to the days when Cesaro's in-ring acumen would force WWE to push him into main events. Those days have never really come. Instead, Cesaro has been regularly positioned as a tag-team guy and the kind of worker who's reliable enough to have good matches without shining as the star of the piece himself.

Perhaps that shouldn't be shocking considering his own boss once buried him on Steve Austin's WWE Network podcast by saying there was something missing from the Swiss star's arsenal. Those pesky brass rings, imaginary though they are, have held Cesaro back ever since.

He's a workhorse who's there to make others look good. That's it.

It was ill-advised at the time for McMahon to publicly trash someone fans had already grown to greatly respect. Now, more than five years on from his comments, Vince still hasn't taken a chance on Cesaro as a singles force.

-

For more wrestling content, check out 10 WWE Stars Fans Refused To Give Up On and 7 Times Vince McMahon Thought WWE's Royal Rumble Sucked!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.