Exposing The Modern Myth About WWE WrestleMania

When did the WWE's "Grandest Stage" become the company's biggest lie?

WWE

The March 1st 2021 edition of Monday Night Raw will only ever be remembered for one thing, and it's to the immense fortune of future WrestleMania opponents Shane McMahon and Braun Strowman that that's the case.

Bobby Lashley's emphatic WWE Championship victory was a significant moment for the new titleholder's character, building on a remarkably careful push that started the moment 'The All-Mighty' reunited with old Impact Wrestling pal MVP. Together, the two of them built The Hurt Business brand and rebuilt the Bobby Lashley to the point where the act as a whole was undeniable.

Having dethroned The Miz with just a month to go before the 'Show Of Shows', Lashley can confidently prepare to wrestle in one of WrestleMania's major matches, very probably against Drew McIntyre. The pairing would be a fine exhibition of WWE's once-rigid schedule still showing itself to be functional - Lashley and McIntyre had fabulous 2020s, and we as fans have always been sold on WrestleMania being as much about rewarding the year's work as it is about settling the biggest grudges.

It's with those long-respected and understood parameters in mind that we mournfully return to Shane McMahon and Braun Strowman's segment, with a premise as imbecilic as its key players, and a wholly different Road To WrestleMania that circumvents self-respect and singular success entirely.

Or - because McMahon keeps telling us Strowman wouldn't understand any of that - why any of this f*cking sh*t is about to feature on one of the most important shows in WWE history.

(CONT'D...)


WWE.com

Shane McMahon has been verbally burying Braun Strowman for weeks since returning after the Royal Rumble and booking an all-former WWE Champions Elimination Chamber without him. Strowman's anger with this exclusion was both reasonable and not.

If Braun stopped and had a f*cking long talk with himself about how his 2020 went, he might take a step back and think of 2021, politely, as a rebuilding year. But from an admin stance - and WWE love love love you to see all this as an Office Space hellscape with awful bosses and sh*tty supervisors and sterile break rooms - the belt he held last year is the WWE Championship in all but name, as evidenced by the time the colour of the strap changed when the Champion moved shows in a draft. This part of his argument was worthwhile.

McMahon disagreed. And has proceeded to go into great detail on how this 7-foot behemoth is actually a pigsh*t buffoon ever since.

Because 'The Money' isn't like the rest of us. He's a walking (and skipping) contradiction like few in wrestling history. And not just because one of his nicknames is 'The Money' and he enters a room to the strains of "Here Comes The Money" despite often trying to present himself as your down-to-earth mate and/or an edgy ex-shooter who's more fight club than country club.

Fuelled by a hedonistic mix of the arrogance and ignorance of a brat that never had to grow up, McMahon the character looks at Strowman as an opportunity to poke a bear rather than run from it. McMahon the man, meanwhile, sees past Braun entirely. He just sees pirate ship to jump off and a building with people in again.

And thus, a WrestleMania - WrestleMania, "Grandest Stage", "Show Of Shows", "Grandaddy Of Em All", that WrestleMania - feud was born. The feud is none of those nicknames. But at this point, is WrestleMania itself? And if not, what is it?

(CONT'D...)


triple h seth rollins wrestlemania 33
WWE.com

Shane McMahon gets what he wants at WrestleMania because a) his last name and b) in 2016, his return during an injury-laden WrestleMania 32 build was linked to the sale of around 20,000 extra tickets.

McMahon, like Triple H, The Undertaker, John Cena and few select others became one of those names that goes up on the WrestleMania whiteboard in Sharpie, instead of on a scrap of paper in pencil Vince McMahon loses down the sofa of the private jet. The ones that are given consideration in January because they'll definitely be on the card. This was nakedly transparent in 2014 when CM Punk was to be given Triple H as a replacement for the WWE Championship and/or slot in the main event. And again in 2018 when Daniel Bryan's amazing return was folded into 'Shane-O-Mac's unending feud with Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn.

Internally, these performers are viewed as Championships themselves - men that younger or newer talent should be thrilled to face for the size and scale alone. But this philosophy has been badly, badly exposed over the years.

Do people muse fondly on Seth Rollins' well-worked but overlong match with Triple H from WrestleMania 33, or crackle with glee at his WWE Championship win at WrestleMania 31? And on that show, Bray Wyatt didn't exactly become The Next Undertaker after getting squashed by the original. Thanks for all the hard work AJ Styles, we're putting you with Shane McMahon! The story? He's an equal and/or better wrestler than you! Welcome to the biggest night of your career!

In 2016, Rollins fostered a desire to "Redesign, Rebuild, Reclaim" after coming back from a career-threatening injury. Until Triple H Pedigree'd f*ck out of him to plant the seeds for their programme. Wyatt was off the rails by 2014 but christ would something more than a squash loss to 'The Deadman' been good for his recovery. AJ Styles debuted and won the WWE Championship in 2016. Do any of these years feel like they were well serviced by the above matches?

Your writer - and lifetime obsessive fan of this thing - isn't here to sh*t on WrestleMania, but it's time to accept what it's really all about.

(CONT'D...)


Sasha Banks Bayley
WWE.com

Bayley and Sasha Banks' 2020 rivalry was a fantastic bit of business.

The pair were joined at the hip following Banks' August 2019 return and Bayley's heel turn the following month, but the cracks between them first began to show on the road to WrestleMania 36 when 'The Role Model' looked remarkably short of Women's Championship challengers on SmackDown. Yet, in spite of their history, the potential match didn't feel all that hot. Not yet, anyway. The pandemic had thrown cold water on everything as it was, and anyway, Banks and Bayley's tensions were only really simmering. Barely even that in fact. There were no real flames to douse.

To that end, the company stuck them both in a multi-woman match, then ingeniously cribbed from another genius angle for the finish - Bayley let Sasha lose before Sasha saved the day for Bayley. This mirrored a glorious 2005 Elimination Chamber finish featuring Triple H and Batista at the same points in the story. It was the biggest signpost that the stolen glances and in-ring tells weren't an accident - this was a big angle, motherf*cker, and angles lead to matches.

The story - save for one awkward spell with Asuka, and even that ended well - got better and better. The duo won the Tag Team Championships, permitting them to carry all three brands in the dour Empty Performance Center/Full Sail era. This was more than just a broken clock getting it right twice a day. This was a broken creative machine getting it right once in a decade.

Problem was, it was August.

(CONT'D...)


Bayley Sasha Banks
WWE.com

Only, that wasn't a problem at all.

At SummerSlam, Asuka worked against both in an effort to take a belt from each of them. Banks helped Bayley retain, before the favour wasn't returned later in the night. A week later at Payback, 'The Golden Role Models' lost their tag belts to Nia Jax and Shayna Baszler in a contest gifted the best finish of the whole year. 'The Queen Of Spades' used Banks' own arm to trap Bayley and force a tap.

Again, this was a fantastic bit of business. One belt remained between them, just like all the way back in March, and there was ample evidence thanks to countless exquisite finishes that Banks could take the title given just one chance. The split finally came after the pair's rematch loss to Jax and Baszler, with the Bayley turning to show 'The Boss' that she'd been wise to her intentions all along. Great. A babyface with goals. A heel that wasn't completely braindead. A friendship torn apart by ambition and insecurity. A match virtually immune to failure thanks to the quality of the workers in the angle.

It was at this point that fans - out of love for the story and the women - pined for it to stretch until WrestleMania 37. Perhaps the kayfabe injured Banks could return at the Rumble? Or cost Bayley her belt along the way so the 'Show Of Shows' maybe? This was nice - it highlighted the respect people still pay to the 'Grandest Stage'. But the bigger picture wasn't the biggest show - it was the story and its natural conclusion.

Due simply to the calendar and not a thing more, the programme didn't time out to peak at WrestleMania, but to travel through it in April so it could flourish in October. Spotting Hell In A Cell on the horizon, WWE shaped the explosive title match to take place inside the mesh, rather brilliantly reinstalling some credibility in that stipulation in the process. Again, this was a f*cking fantastic bit of business.

Who needs WrestleMania? Not these two, and not this time.

(CONT'D...)


Shane McMahon Braun Strowman
WWE

WrestleMania - for all its majesty and pageantry - was surplus to requirements full stop when it came to one of the best and most carefully crafted WWE storylines in forever. Weeks later, the final battle between the two drew SmackDown's best rating of the year too.

For more than how it benefitted Hell In A Cell and WWE's billion dollar relationship with Fox, holding back on the big one between Bayley and Sasha Banks might have sealed the feud in WrestleMania lore, but now it existed with a lore unto itself. The proper kind too, not the sort people use to try and tie together six mindless Fiend promos.

Waiting would have been wasteful, because no matter what we think of WrestleMania, WWE themselves will always be leaning on the likes of Shane McMahon Vs Braun Strowman instead. There was no giant (or two-night) card for the match to get lost in the shuffle, or fall victim to audience exhaustion, or lose time because Triple H's motorbike entrance needs prepping.

WWE relies on mythology to sell the magnitude of WrestleMania, whilst obscuring the myth that it's the be-all end-all in the modern age. Sasha Banks and Bayley's story will be studied in years to come by those looking to replicate its refinery. Meanwhile, McMahon and Strowman's rivalry will be confined to the bin regardless of the height of Shane's fall on the night.

The only time McMahon approaches "down to earth" is midway through one of those insane stunts, and it always ends with a thud. It's not new, it's not fresh and crucially, it's not creative, but it is what WrestleMania stands for in the Network/Peacock era. By all means root for your favourites to get their big night on the big stage, but stop to enjoy the stuff along the way if they're doing it well - those are the real Moments™ that'll live forever, with or without the corporate branding.


WWE Quiz: Was It Stephanie Or Shane McMahon?

Shane and Stephanie McMahon
WWE.com

1. According To The WON, Who Was Named The Worst Non-Wrestling Personality From 2001-2003?

Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.