Hot Wrestling Takes So BAD They'll MELT Your Brain
Hey, Road Dogg: here's that attention you ordered...
Apologies in advance.
The vast majority of people who populate this list are clout goblins with a humiliation fetish. No longer able to find meaningful work in an industry that has left them behind, most of the names - not all - desperately unleash positively bewildering hot takes in order to remain relevant.
It's a trap. These people crave the attention. They want to direct traffic to their podcasts. Or, they are so bitter at tumbling into irrelevance that they cannot abide the success of AEW. Or, because they there braindead to begin with and spent the vast majority of their lives getting dropped on their head, they are as thick as hell.
The trick is to ignore these people. They can't hurt you, and if you feel a temper tantrum engulfing your brain because somebody thinks the average episode of WWE SmackDown was not in fact directed by Ingmar Bergman, it might be time to reevaluate things.
Somehow, at least two of these people remain in key upper management positions, doing their part to oversee WWE as they continue this staggering period of resurgence.
It is really cathartic to reply on occasion, though...
10. Al Snow: Dumbass
If Al Snow chopped off his own head and replaced it with the mannequin one he used to carry around, he'd probably more intelligent.
He has found himself in the news cycle of late, given that he's in charge of Ohio Valley Wrestling, the subject of the imaginatively titled 'The Wrestlers' documentary on Netflix.
Did Al title that?
Former WWF Hardcore Champion Al Snow, who was only ever prominent in the Attitude Era when working plunder brawls, thinks death match wrestling is stupid. That probably warrants an entry unto itself.
The former hardcore specialist however is awarded the dubious honour of inclusion here for what is perhaps the most monumental self-own in wrestling history. He tried to make a point about how match quality is trivial in the grand scheme of things - and that drawing money is of the utmost importance - but in doing so, he all but confirmed that his own career was irrelevant. This is a dumb take to begin with - a wrestling match can be a transcendent experience even if 300 people are in the building - but of all the people to unleash it!
Snow was an endearing midcard fixture for a while, a proto-meme wrestler, but nobody purchased a ticket hoping upon hope that Snow was going to be on the card.
In a legendary online wrestling moment, a forums legend by the name of Ian put this to him:
9. Mike Quakenbush On Orange Cassidy
Do you know who's a very relatable character perfect for a generation of people pummelled into numbed submission by the endless horrors of the 21st century?
Orange Cassidy.
He grabbed the zeitgeist. He realised that a lot of people are simply very tired. They are tired of caring because there is too much to care about. Grotesquely lopsided distribution of wealth. A culture war that nobody can win. Preventable tragedy upon preventable tragedy. The overwhelming sense that absolutely nothing will ever change and will in fact get worse.
Cassidy's nonchalance is more understandable than any other wrestler, and when he fires up - at the perfect time, always - it's more inspiring than it has any right to be. Maybe one day you'll try, and it might actually matter.
But do you know what is more relatable than that?
An ant.
Everybody knows what an ant is!
Everybody knows what a curtain is, and it wouldn’t make for a good pro wrestler. Fire Ant was a good and over act, but be realistic: it was only ever vaguely charming in a super niche context.
Disgraced CHIKARA founder Mike Quakenbush was Adam Ant, in a leaked email, that Cassidy was a no-hoper of character. Ants are where it's at, which is funny: Soldier Ant didn't just headline AEW All Out.
8. Road Dogg On Charlotte Flair & Becky Lynch
WWE is a weird company with off-putting values to a lot of people. This is a promotion that simply believes Charlotte Flair is a babyface. That's what separates WWE from the other companies. They are weird and they do not grasp that they are not normal people.
Road Dogg is a lunatic especially, and, when commenting on the events of SummerSlam 2018, he was so close to getting it. On a recent edition of his 'Oh, You Didn't Know' podcast, Road Dogg said (h/t Fightful):
"The idea was that Charlotte came in and weaselled her way in and won the title, and kind of stole it from [Becky]."
He then elaborated, criticising fans for cheering Becky's post-match turn.
"Oh my god, what are you doing? That’s horrible sportsmanship. There’s no goodness left at all. It’s all Twitter, the world is Twitter. The world is Twitter now.”
What?
Are you stupid (yes)?
He acknowledged that Charlotte weaselled her way into the match. People hated that because Charlotte was entitled, sneaky, and crafty - all qualities associated with heels. That Charlotte was an office project hardly helped. Charlotte didn't bravely and decisively win a hard-fought match.
The arrogant, detached mentality within WWE has trickled into the booking over the course of years, so of course Road Dogg defends it.
7. Eric Bischoff Says That AEW Matches Have No Story
After AEW stopped calling Eric Bischoff in for a cameo - effectively rendering him unemployable, since he made the Deep South Wrestling management team look like 1995 Paul Heyman as 'Executive Director' of SmackDown - he became a hot take guy.
Much like WCW when New Japan had nothing he could borrow, it did not go well. It did for a while - you couldn't go on Twitter a couple of years ago without reading some aggregation of his bad faith criticism - but people eventually stopped feeding the troll.
In 2021, Bischoff infamously buried AEW's ability to tell stories - at a time when they were best-in-class at precisely that. Apparently, they didn't even tell them.
The opposite was true, if anything, The old rankings-driven narrative framework meant that every AEW match had stakes and an indirect, in-built story - you win, you ascend to title contention - and even then, Khan couldn't book a single fixture without some backstage promo interruption or other. Khan was obsessed with giving every match a reason to exist, even if the pretext was unnecessary.
Easy E did backpedal somewhat when Tony Khan pointed out that WCW in its heyday promoted cold, random matches every single week. He had been clamped, but he moved the goalposts (h/t WrestlingNews.co).
"If I've ever given the impression that I thought every match on Nitro had a storyline, forgive me now. It is really about your top matches that don't have sufficient story or structure, or at least a compelling one."
This is especially stupid, considering that AEW for a long disproved the idea that PPV was dead by building several major matches over the long-term that compelled fans to pay for the blow-off. Ironically, since Bischoff is no stranger to a happy ending, he failed to pay any of his big stories off.
Compare Starrcade '97 to Full Gear 2021 and - as with March 26, 2001 - there is no competition.
6. Vince Russo Is Very Prescient
Swerve!
He did just as piss-poor a job as predicting the future as he did booking wrestling. Vince Russo is either directly responsible for or played a significant role in the death of two major promotions.
That is because he knew one trick, one that didn't work without the generational drawing power of Steve Austin, and he repeated it for about a decade and a half. Stubbornly arrogant to the point of delusion, he could not accept that trends had shifted.
While he did conduct this infamous interview with Mike Tenay in character, it's important to point out that Russo often used crucial TV time to vent and put himself over and try to convince you that you were stupid and he was a genius. Basically, everything he did amounted to "I am so smart! S-M-R-T!"
In said interview, Russo, attacking his fanbase and their demands with his big brain, remarked ""If you want lucha libres, go to Japan".
This was typical Russo, who also stated in 1999 "You will never, ever, ever, ever, ever see the Japanese wrestlers or the Mexican wrestlers over in American mainstream wrestling".
AEW x NJPW Forbidden Door, in both 2022 and 2023, slaughtered the buy amount of Vince Russo's most successful TNA pay-per-view. The latter edition was headlined by Kazichuka Okada, and karma is real: that dinosaur Russo had packaged Okada, when on excursion in TNA, as a comedy joke inspired by the 1960s TV show 'The Green Hornet'.
5. Bully Ray Questions If People Like Kenny Omega
Kenny Omega is a beloved professional wrestler renowned as one of the very best of all-time.
The atmosphere he generated at the Tokyo Dome on January 4, 2017, was unlike anything ever heard. Everybody in that building reacted to his masterpiece with Kazuchika Okada - which wasn't even the best match he had with him - with a differing level of disbelief. They were each processing their overwhelming emotions differently. Go back and listen. It sounds like the world is ending in 100 different places.
Omega's fans will watch something he does in 2023 and recall with amazement how it links back to something he did in 2012. The Golden Lovers inspire a level of devotion few others do. People in the LGTBQIA+ community adore the man for representing them. People still watch Being The Elite in 2023. That's how ardent their love is.
And then Bully Ray says this on busted Open Radio in 2021:
"Lemme ask the AEW fans this...do you really care about Kenny Omega? Or do you just care about the One-Winged Angel and his V-Triggers?
“Lemme ask the AEW fans this, wtach this... Do you really CARE about Kenny Omega... or do you just care about the one winged angel and his v triggers?” -Bully Ray
This man really doesn’t have a !*$% clue
— Finn Ⴟ Amory (@FinnAmory) July 2, 2021
The irony of course is that if somebody had asked "Do you REALLY care about the Dudley Boyz...or do you just care about watching tables get broken?", people would say "Yeah actually I just like the tables bit really".
If you took the table away from the Dudley Boyz, they have absolutely nothing. They might get a reaction when Bubba would say something typically revolting like "I hope you slip and die on your mother's tw*t slime!", but that is about it.
Name one undisputedly great match the Dudley Boyz worked sans plunder. Go on - be a fan and think about it.
4. Don't Go Into The Trenches With Disco Inferno
Disco Inferno, fittingly, knows his way around a burn. He treats them every week, or at least he used to, before most people figured out his grift.
Disco, mildly amusing for a few seconds in the mid '90s, now frequents Konnan's podcast - do you listen to it? - and makes a t*t of himself. Frequently. Looking at the absolute state of AAA, which Konnan books, listening to them criticise another wrestling promotion is not unlike Nia Jax teaching a health and safety course.
Disco has spouted so much nonsense that he probably eats via his anus, and had this to say, in July 2020, about the Wednesday Night Wars ratings:
"Who publicly predicted on the podcasts six weeks ago that @WWENXT was turning the tide against @AEWonTNT??"
Disco's argument was based on the idea that NXT, with typical desperation, had just defeated AEW in overall viewers on the promise of a title unification match.
Two things:
Subsequent to Disco's tweet, NXT only defeated Dynamite twice more in overall viewership. NXT only once, ever, defeated Dynamite in the key demo.
Also, Disco claimed it was "discrimination" not to include those aged 49+ when analysing the popularity of each show. Dynamite toppled NXT in total viewers far more often than not, and moreover, he fat-shamed AEW talents months later, and isn't that the same thing? One that didn't support his asinine, incorrect point?
3. Steve Austin And Paul Heyman Prove Even The Greats Aren't Infallible
Cody Rhodes infamously lost to Roman Reigns at WrestleMania 39.
And, while Triple H had his Heartbreaking: The Worst Person You Know Just Made A Great Point moment - the Bloodline saga actually got hotter after the fact, at least until SummerSlam - WWE could have told the story without Roman holding both World titles. His holding those titles has precious little to do with the belts, and Seth Rollins as World Heavyweight title isn't even on the best workrate title run in the company.
WWE should have switched the title. This is very clear in September, but it was clear in April too - but not to Steve Austin and Paul Heyman.
Heyman, you get it. He works for WWE and books Roman's creative. He's obviously going to think he's right, or say he's right even if he doesn’t believe his own garbage. He said: where does Cody go from there?
What?
He has a title run, the sort that happens all the time and has to happen eventually anyway, since Roman Reigns can't do this forever?
What does "where do you go from here?" even mean?
Is Roman the first ever wrestling champion?
Austin said it would have been "cliché" for Cody to win in a "storybook" ending, but he hardly volunteered to stare at the lights for Shawn Michaels because most expected an Austin win at WrestleMania 14.
2. Bruce Prichard Defends The Triple H Vs. Booker T Storyline
The Triple H Vs. Booker T programme is widely regarded as one of the worst things the company has ever done, which is some achievement, since WWE has also explored incest and murder and necrophilia and slut-shaming and heavily pushed Austin Theory.
The gist, if you were lucky enough to have not lived through it, was that Triple H said Booker T wasn't there to win the big one but rather to entertain people and dance with his "nappy hair" and his "suckas".
And then Triple H proved himself right by hitting Booker T with the match-winning Pedigree and taking 23 seconds to make the cover. If there was ever a time to do the happy ending, it was on March 30, 2003. But no.
Widely regarded, not universally, since Bruce Prichard defended it on his 'Something To Wrestle' podcast. His co-host Conrad Thomson to his credit was having none of it.
Prichard claimed that the idea - and it was a horrible one in 2001, so let's do it again two years later! - wasn't to book the racist to win (!) but to instead prove that the "ex-WCW guys" were not on Triple H's level.
Which is rather unconvincing, since Triple H didn't throw a dollar at Scott Steiner or Goldberg and told them they were only in WWE to dance for him.
1. Andy Murray Gives Himself Enough Rope
Usually, Andy Murray of WhatCulture Wrestling is a Good Taste Haver.
He's a bit of a snob, yes. You should see him make a cup of coffee. Guy thinks he's Heston Blumenthal.
But he knows what he likes, is erudite about it, and if he doesn't like something, he distances himself from that conversation. He has the ability to recognise that something is successful even if it is not to his tastes. Or at least, he does now. He prefers Tomohiro Ishii to melodrama, which might explain why, in 2018, he referred to Hangman Page as a "double serving of unbuttered toast washed down by a glass of room temperature tap water. Fine in a pinch, but dull. So, so dull."
"Page is comfortably Bullet Club's least interesting member," the Disco Inferno of Gateshead continued.
Fast-forward just two years later, and Hangman Page had evolved into the main character of All Elite Wrestling: the first serious competition to WWE in the 21st century.
Page became an explosive tour de force in the ring, with an ability to both crush abdomens with a God-tier Asai moonsault and layer his stories with the subtlest and most rewarding beats. He was also hilarious with his self-deprecating comedy - his lower third chyrons became a weekly hidden gem highlight of Dynamite - and in general, was so effective at getting over that countless people developed a parasocial relationship with him.
Look at the Full Gear 2021 buy rate and cry into your Aeropress.