How Nyla Rose's Championship Win Exposed Wrestling's Diversity Problem

Nyla Rose's title win is a big step forward for diversity in wrestling, but more needs to be done.

Nyla Rose
AEW

On the 12 February 2020 episode of All Elite Wrestling Dynamite, Nyla Rose defeated Riho to become the first ever transgender wrestler to win a championship in a major wrestling company. The match itself was excellent; not only might it be the best match of both Nyla Rose and Riho's careers, but the match was probably the best women's match in AEW's short history so far.

At a nice 13 minutes in length, the bruiser Nyla Rose predictably used power moves to disarm her 98 pound opponent, who managed to fight back against her much larger foe, acting as the ultimate underdog with great strikes and high-flying offense. This turned out to be a great installment of their rivalry. These two have fought three times before: the first was back in June of 2019 in a three-way match also featuring Yuka Sakazaki, they fought on the very first episode of AEW Dynamite in a match that crowned Riho as AEW's first Women's Champion, and they were both featured in a four-way match that also featured Britt Baker and Hikaru Shida.

The Nyla Rose versus Riho rivalry flipped the typical "scrappy underdog overcoming the odds to win the big match" dynamic on its head. Sure, Nyla Rose is the biggest woman on the AEW roster, but Riho had pinned her in their first two encounters, and even though Nyla Rose wasn't pinned in their third match, Riho still came out on top. Riho was the hero and Rose was the villain, but it made sense for the villain to end up the winner.

Riho is a great wrestler, and she's definitely made a connection to the crowd, but many of her matches have been relegated to AEW's YouTube-exclusive show, and when she does get to wrestle on TV, a good majority of her matches end up being subpar anyways. It doesn't help her case that she's also the High Speed Champion in Japan's World Wonder Ring Stardom, meaning that she had prior commitments as well. For Riho's sake, it's a good thing that she's no longer AEW Women's Champion so that she can actually defend her Stardom Championship (since winning the title in August, she only defended the title once). Meanwhile, Nyla Rose is an AEW exclusive. She'll be there no matter what, and even if some of her matches have been duds, she's had a lot more higher-quality matches compared to Riho while being a part of AEW.

Of course, her win goes a lot deeper than that. Not only is Nyla Rose the first transgender champion of a major wrestling company, she's the first transgender professional wrestler many have ever heard of (me included). I take some of the blame for that because I wasn't looking in the right places. A Matter Of Pride Wrestling, Rise Wrestling, and Uncanny Attractions had been booking LGBT and gender non-conforming wrestlers as long as they have existed.


Nyla Rose
AEW

Some major companies have made efforts to be more inclusive as of late, whether through hiring LGBT and gender non-conforming wrestlers in the first place, or through supporting them if or when they do come out. WWE's Piper Niven, Shayna Baszler, and Sonya Deville are all members of the LGBT community, and Impact Wrestling's Diamante and Kiera Hogan are currently dating while being prominent members of the Impact roster. Both Jake Atlas and Mercedes Martinez, who were both some of the most popular LGBT wrestlers on the independent wrestling scene, were both recently signed to WWE as well.

When it comes to transgender or gender non-conforming wrestlers, they are a lot less visible on a wide-scale level. Australian wrestler Candy Lee, Pro Wrestling WAVE and SEAdLINNNG's ASUKA, self-proclaimed punk rock queen Jamie Senegal, and CHIKARA fan-favorite Still Life With Apricots And Pears are all extremely talented wrestlers who identify as transgender or gender non-conforming, and are killing it around the world without having appeared on (American) television yet. This is part of the reason Nyla Rose winning the championship is such a big deal. Nyla worked extremely hard for years to get to this point in her career, and when given the opportunity as a reward for her hard work, she excelled on the national level, using her platform to help those like her and educate those who don't identify the same way she does.

As a straight white cis-gendered male, I have never felt as if I didn't belong as a wrestling fan, but there are a lot of wrestling fans who feel like they don't, because bigoted wrestling fans or bigoted wrestlers themselves have made it clear that the things that the fans cannot change about themselves (and SHOULDN'T change about themselves) disqualify them from being a part of this community. Yes, I'm talking about the racists, the sexists, the homophobes, and anybody else in the business who discriminates against those who don't look or live as they do.

There are not a lot of people like Nyla Rose given opportunities to be on national television, never mind wrestle in front of thousands of people every week, so when someone like her enters the limelight, it gives people who identify the same way the opportunity to see someone like themselves on their TV screen, which is hugely important. This idea is why Kofi Kingston's title win at WrestleMania in 2019 was so inspiring; that's why the #GiveDivasAChance hashtag and the Women's Revolution were so monumental; that's why Kenny Omega and Kota Ibushi's Golden Lovers storyline worked so well; and that's why Tessa Blanchard winning the Impact Wrestling championship could have been a great moment (had she not been a total racist of course).


AEW

Diversity and representation is of course important on screen, but the groups of people making big decisions backstage could use some diversity too. When there are more than just straight white cis-gendered men in the back, wrestling companies can make better decisions that don't slight or flat-out insult an entire group; characters become more than just stereotypes, and the needs of the fans can be better addressed when people of many viewpoints and experiences have the ability to be themselves and speak their truths. There are so many wrestling fans who don't understand the power that representation holds and take the fact that so many people in the business look like them for granted. Then there are those who actively fight against representation.

The amount of transphobic comments circulating on social media following Nyla's AEW Championship win was disgusting. There is no putting it lightly: *so* many wrestling fans are bigoted. I can't even count how many people on Twitter that thought she didn't deserve the win because "she's a man” and that her opponent was at an unfair advantage because of that. No, she's a woman and you're transphobic.

Also, last time I checked, wrestling is predetermined (I do not dare say wrestling is fake because the wrestling elitists will get on my case and try to blacklist me). There is no unfair advantage because the people in the ring are not actively trying to hurt each other; instead, they're trying to put on a performance. The 98 pound Riho might have been at a physical disadvantage if this were a real fight, but ultimately, Nyla Rose was booked to win the match. She probably could have beat Riho in a legit fight, but that's not what wrestling is about.

Plus, Riho pinned Nyla Rose twice last year, so clearly, if people want to further suspend their disbelief and pretend as if the "fight" was real, then they should have had no problem in believing that Riho was actually at less of a physical advantage anyways. Remember when the 200 pound Gerard Gordeau scored a TKO victory over the 400 pound sumo wrestler Teila Tuli and knocked his tooth out of his mouth at the very first UFC event? When it comes to fighting and beating an opponent, size does not always matter!


Aew Nyla Rose
All Elite Wrestling

It would be one thing to not understand what being transgender means but still remain respectful, but it's another thing to misgender her, harass her on social media, and chant transphobic and homophobic slurs at her during wrestling events. This type of harassment is just some of the behavior that can result in the killing and the suicides of transgender people. Her wife even tweeted that as a black transgender woman, Nyla Rose has lived past her life expectancy. She's only 37 years old. In case it wasn't clear, there is something VERY wrong here, and wrestling fans are continuing to put her in even more danger than she was already in.

At a recent AEW event, a fan "Code Of Conduct" was announced, with the idea being that being mean to wrestlers or staff members could result in getting kicked out and barred from attending any future AEW events. This could be a great idea if it was made explicit that bigoted behaviors or actions towards wrestlers or staff members would not be tolerated (plus, specifying the Code Of Conduct to be about bigotry would make it more clear that booing the villains is okay, since supporting the hero and booing the villains is basically what wrestling is built around in the first).

This probably should seem obvious, but until discrimination within the wrestling business and wrestling fandom are eliminated, AEW, among other wrestling companies, no matter how big or small, should take this into consideration. This isn't a totally new idea; at multiple independent wrestling events recorded and produced by wrestling streaming service IndependentWrestling.TV, ring announcer and photographer "StepStool" Sarah has made announcements that no bigoted behavior (or any actions that threaten the safety of wrestlers, staff members, or other fans for that matter) would be tolerated because wrestling events and the wrestling community should be a safe space.

AEW Executive Vice President Cody and his wife, Chief Brand Officer Brandi Rhodes have made it clear that diversity within professional wrestling is important, and even if they could be doing more to promote diversity (such as giving the women more time to wrestle, or hiring more people of color for the ring and behind the scenes), I have no doubt that Nyla Rose, and anybody else a part of the company who voices concerns about bigotry will be protected and have their concerns addressed. Still, it is massively important for the higher-ups to outright say that bigotry is banned and will result in removal from their events. This should be simple for any wrestling company to do, but for whatever reason, it isn't.

There still needs to be a major change within the industry to ensure everyone feels accepted and safe. More people need to step up and use their privilege to help those who work extremely hard to make it in the business while being their unadulterated selves so that the industry could become even more diverse. Trust me, both the wrestling business and the wrestling fandom could use diversifying. Representation will continue to get people into the wrestling industry, and diversity will continued to make wrestling a lot more interesting, exciting - and most importantly - inclusive.


AEW Quiz: Only A True Superfan Can Name These All Elite Talents

Dustin Rhodes
Lee South/AEW

1. Who Is This?

In this post: 
Nyla Rose
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm a life-long wrestling fan who recently discovered a passion for writing. What a great excuse to watch more wrestling, right?