How This Moment Killed WWE's Attitude Era

Sh*t & Run.

WWE.com

Survivor Series season in the modern age triggers nought but tantalising tussles fought over t-shirts. WWE have taken to removing virtually every element of story across the month of November as Superstars from Raw, SmackDown and now NXT eject their brains but inject every episode with impotent brand-based rage.

It'd be funny and tragic, if the end result wasn't accidentally awesome. WWE are taken with this formula because it works in spite of itself. Since 2016, the old 'Thanksgiving Classic' has become a revived entity in the pay-per-view calendar - a monument of the chaotic second half of the decade with Champion vs. Champion matches that don't decide titles, main events made in the week leading up to the show and amazing elimination matches fought over nothing more than nights of the week.

At the start of the decade, Vince McMahon himself was ready to swing the axe over his lowest-performing Big Four pay-per-view after the elimination format was considered prohibitive to predictive purchases. Reading now like point-proving sabotage rather than an effort to actually generate buys, 2010's event was headlined by Randy Orton defending his WWE Championship against Wade Barrett, whilst the only "traditional" match was an ignoble effort to get the likes of Cody Rhodes, MVP, Jack Swagger, Tyler Reks and Drew McIntyre over by merely appearing, rather than appearing to look good.

The show's decline had indeed been endemic, but it dated back further than the drab expanse of the turn of the decade. After lighting the fuse for the most profitable period in company history in 1997, the November supershow later played host to a moment that foreshadowed the wheels falling off completely.

CONT'D...


Survivor Series 1999
WWE

Falling off, or skidding away?

The tyres screeched as a car sped out of the historic Joe Louis Arena in Detroit, Michigan with a decimated top draw left behind. Stone Cold Steve Austin had been felled by the vehicle after chasing Triple H back into the car park just hours before their triple threat main event for the WWE Championship that also included the only man "electrifying" enough to share his spot. What rotten f*cking luck, eh?!

Well, obviously not.

Stone Cold Steve Austin vs. The Rock vs. Triple H was categorically the biggest match WWE could book in November 1999, and the company knew as much. Riding an incredible commercial and creative wave so high and hard that even the recent exit of supposed Attitude Era architect Vince Russo couldn't set them back, WWE were thriving in a way Vince McMahon at his most optimistic daren't even have imagined two years earlier.

That fateful night in Montreal has been picked at to such a degree that somebody needs to "ring the bell, ring the f*cking bell" on it ever being discussed again. A watershed moment in the lives of McMahon, Shawn Michaels and Bret Hart became a landmark and a checkpoint for everything unexpectedly falling into place for an organisation that had been on the back foot for years. An act borne out of callous corporate cruelty created a company icon in Mr McMahon right as rising star Steve Austin was raging against the machine. It was perfect pro wrestling happenstance, and time and time again WWE satisfied customer thirst with payoff after exhilarating payoff.

Then, at the height of their dominance, they pulled off another screwjob.

CONT'D...


Back to Detroit, the - ahem - 'Motor City' for the "attempted vehicular homicide" of Stone Cold Steve Austin.

Well before 'The Rattlesnake' was mowed down in that car park, WWE knew they'd have to flatten the hopes and desires of the paying fanbase thanks to his bothersome neck. Eight days, in fact, was the bare minimum. The company knew a full eight days before 1999's Thanksgiving Classic that Austin absolutely wasn't good to go, yet left no clues to suggest anything otherwise on the night itself. Watching the last couple of weeks of television and the various video packages made around the match is maddening self-torture. Your writer did just that in an effort to see if memory had clouded objectivity, but no; WWE go above and beyond to talk up this enormous showdown between the three most powerful forces in the company.

So much so that they completely neglected the rest of the card. Survivor Series 1999 is 20 years old this year, yet still sends shivers down spines of those that lived through it or the poor fools unknowingly selecting it on the WWE Network. McMahon was a cheeky f*cker trying to poleaxe the event in 2010 - have a deeks at some of the stuff he considered worthy of a Big Four show a full decade earlier. Bantering off his own team on the pre-show, The Big Show defeated Big Boss Man, Viscera, Mideon and Prince Albert (in a match kept short for reasons that would later become apparent), an Eight-Woman Tag Team Match was beyond pitiful and won by The Fabulous Moolah and Mae Young, whilst a Survivor Series match pitting Gangrel, Mark Henry, Steve Blackman and Val Venis against The British Bulldog and The Mean Street Posse may be the most bizarre in concept, line-up and execution in the show's history. "Bizarre" because Davey Boy Smith was in it. But then he was also in a match with dogsh*t too, sooo...

From dogsh*t to bullsh*t, let's circle back to Austin getting hit by a car, the hows and whys of that moment, and where it all ended up just shy of one wild year later.

CONT'D...


Who Busted Becky Lynch Open On Last Night S WWE Raw Thumb
WWE

So yes, WWE sold an entire pay-per-view on a match they had no intention of delivering - and absolutely f*ck all else on the card was selling it. For all the carnage and chaos of the beloved Attitude Era, welching on their output wasn't something the company made a habit of, just as it isn't now. Vince McMahon will take pelters then, now and forever for continuing on with Over The Edge 1999 after Owen Hart tragically fell to his death early in the show, but the promoter's son-done-good knows nothing else. A ghoulish example perhaps, but even stripped of the particular context, consider that McMahon had one of the most difficult decisions of his professional life to make, and the end result was wrestling matches.

Wrestling matches were wrapped around a horrifying interview with Melanie Pillman on the Monday Night Raw 24 hours removed from husband Brian's passing. McMahon believed, perhaps with some justification, that two nights after 9/11 the world needed his wrestling matches. Eddie Guerrero died the day of a double taping, but with so much television on the line, he turned that week's Raw and SmackDown into touching live tributes to his life with... wrestling matches. The highlight-only Raw following the Chris Benoit slayings was the rule-proving exception, triggering some theories that the company knew a little more about what had happened in Atlanta than what they were legally allowed to let on.

There are thankfully fewer case studies as dark as the ones above in the current era, but McMahon's pattern remains the same. He lost Roman Reigns and Bray Wyatt to mumps in 2017 and Becky Lynch to Nia Jax's clumsy right fist in 2018, and built in monumental changes to his pay-per-view wrestling matches in order to make good on the missing parties.

This was the promoter's son-done-good actually doing good, instead of bullsh*tting his paying audience and having Rikishi run over the era's biggest draw.

CONT'D...


rikishi mick foley
WWE.com

If Rikishi feels like a footnote in the story, it's because he didn't even really exist at the start of it.

Longtime failed pushed project Billy Gunn was notably kept out of the scene featuring Steve Austin and DX before the parking lot brawl. The Rock himself would have been an easy tie-in had WWE wanted to try and turn 'The Great One' whenever 'The Rattlesnake's real life neck surgery recovery time had concluded. Rikishi infamously "did it for The Rock" before the company retconned that hot bullsh*t and it turned out he'd done it for Triple H. The Survivor Series 1999 attack didn't kill WWE's Attitude Era, but it was the first shot from a firing squad that left it riddled with bullets.

Whilst Austin was convalescing at home, WWE somehow grew beyond prior heights to even bigger ones. Discounting 2018's Saudi Arabia cash and the unimaginable television rights fees the company now command, 2000 was - by all the old metrics at least - the most profitable year in the history of the organisation. More importantly, the show f*cking ruled. Hunter and The Rock had graduated to being topliners on their own terms with a money-sh*tting mega feud, whilst the midcard soared under the watchful storyboarding mind of head writer Chris Kreski. The man replaced by Stephanie McMahon right around the time Commissioner Mick Foley fingered the giant Samoan for the wrestling crime of the century.

They tried and failed to pay off the biggest whodunnit in a generation, and everybody got caught in the subsequent detritus. Rikishi's awesome babyface run was abruptly abandoned for a push that never materialised. Austin and Rock were cooled exponentially by working programmes with him that felt like backward steps, with 'The Rattlesnake's run in particular being tepid enough that his fiscally misjudged WrestleMania X-Seven heel turn genuinely looked like the most sensible solution. Triple H escaped the worst of it, of course. But then he still goes over on pay-per-views today, so was that ever in doubt?

Next time your YouTube trigger fingers cause you to ask exactly "What about the Attitude Era?!" during another PG Raw vs. SmackDown Survivor Series, consider how WWE couldn't ever really handle it anyway. The shows, by another f*cking McMahonist miracle are better out of their control than in it.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.