How WWE Could Get Much Better (By Removing One DISASTROUS Flaw)

Including a statistic that would blow Dana Brooke’s mind…

Kazuchika Okada
NJPW1972.com

This may aggravate or not resonate with those of you who resent the comparison or don’t follow New Japan Pro Wrestling, but its top star - Kazuchika Okada - is in the midst of a drastic and unprecedented character arc.

This isn’t an NJPW > WWE argument. A supporting argument by way of context follows:

From June 19, 2016 to June 9, 2018 - two full calendar years, more or less - the Rainmaker reigned supreme with the IWGP Heavyweight Championship. The reign charted Okada’s path from Ace to God; Okada successfully defended his crown a record 12 times rendering him, mathematically, the most powerful storyline force in the legendary history of the company.

In parallel, Okada reached another uncharted stratosphere of critical acclaim, having wrestled arguably the greatest pro wrestling matches ever, opposite Kenny Omega, and a string of mere A+ bouts against the likes of Hiroshi Tanahashi, Katsuyori Shibata, and Zack Sabre, Jr. His body language reflected his brilliance to a repellent extent. Okada toyed with his opponents with withering slaps to the head. High on his own hubris, he even, at Wrestle Kingdom 12, debuted a new flared trouser aesthetic.

The ostentatious look mirrored his attitude; nobody else could pull off such a look, and nobody could touch him - until Omega did so, over the course of 65 gruelling minutes, in what was presented as nothing less than the fight of his life.

The loss has charted a new path, one both wonderful and strange. The new Okada enters the G1 Climax, balloons in tow (!) with an almost unsettling childlike exuberance. He is adorned in red and black. His greatness is in symbolic danger of bleeding out. He remains very much in contention to win the tournament, but as evidenced through a series of ingenious, ballsy, disjointed and intriguing performances, in which he has intentionally performed as such, he isn’t quite at his level.

Okada has lost both his Championship and his mind. To reclaim both, he must wear the gold that defines him once more by way of emerging victorious from the most competitive and arduous tournament in the pro wrestling arena because, in New Japan Pro Wrestling, there is no automatic rematch clause to invoke. There are too many well-established, genuinely deserving challengers in his way.

CONT'D...


Samoa Joe
WWE.com

When he eventually enters the ring, adorned once more in his gold and purple colour scheme, it will make for an iconic moment. That moment is still to come. For now, he must complete his long, strange trip.

Okada is lost in the sea of his mind because he is literally adrift from the accomplishment that defined him. There would be no heft to any of this, no fascinating character development, were he able to simply compete for it a mere month later.

Say AJ Styles loses the WWE Heavyweight Championship to Samoa Joe at SummerSlam. He may sell shock, disappointment, even anger, if Joe wins through underhanded means. But how hard is all that to buy, equipped with the knowledge that he can simply challenge for it once more at Hell In A Cell less than a month later? Okada’s loss has shattered his psyche. For AJ, any loss would represent an inconvenience he can recover from at his convenience.

Convenience is the word. The automatic title rematch clause is a convenient staple of WWE programming the Network model has exacerbated to numbing effect.

The storytelling device breeds repetition in a literal sense. We are presented with the same old matches on an habitual basis because, under the new model, it is no longer incumbent on WWE to present fresh matches to drive pay-per-view revenue. And, while WWE dresses windows with “Extreme” stipulations, the reckless regard shown to continuity and the rules means they aren’t often enforced. They are only enforced if it is convenient - if, following Backlash 2018 for example, the company intends to prolong, yet again, a featured rivalry - Styles Vs. Shinsuke Nakamura, in this case.

WWE does this to pad out the bloated TV schedule. Episodic TV is a strange paradox, in how it sustains WWE commercially, but kills it creatively. Adding to the monotony, this trope is in full effect across both RAW and SmackDown.

Everything feels the same all of the time.

Consider this eye-bleeding statistic...

CONT'D...


Brock Lesnar Roman Reigns
WWE.com

Including Kickoff matches, WWE between Royal Rumble and Extreme Rules has promoted 78 PPV matches in 2018. Including those previously presented on TV, an insane 34 of which were rematches. That is 10 off half, and countless others that weren’t rematches in themselves yielded a rematch on the next TV cycle. When you consider that, of the remaining 44, several were multi-man matches or thrown-together dark tags, there is very little true difference.

The über-lame “Best of Both Worlds” dual-brand marketing tactic sought to correct the issue, but it has only intensified it. At both Backlash and Extreme Rules, WWE promoted no less than seven rematches on each pay-per-view.

WWE, then, is an objectively stale product, hardly helped by the rapid rate at which these rematches occur. It is a deadening blur of the same old sh*t. Of course it’s going to stink.

At SummerSlam, once a major show on which WWE promoted new, exciting matches to present it as a major show, three rematches are scheduled at time of writing: Braun Strowman Vs. Kevin Owens, Dolph Ziggler Vs. Seth Rollins, and Brock Lesnar Vs. Roman Reigns. And, given that Finn Bálor and Baron Corbin across Extreme Rules and RAW are - yes - 50/50, a a lifeless rematch seems certain for the Biggest Party Of The Summer.

The automatic title rematch clause removes any dramatic heft from the main roster product. Wins and losses don’t matter because they are determined, arbitrarily, at the whim of the erratic and forgetful Vince McMahon and his short-term mindset. They also do not matter because they hold no emotional weight.

What is lost can simply be won again.

CONT'D...


Rusev AJ Styles
WWE

The automatic title rematch clause depicts its babyface performers as morons. Asuka, at both Money In The Bank and Extreme Rules, was too preoccupied by James Ellsworth to put Carmella away, even when he was rendered literally helpless dangling from the titular shark cage. At the same event, Dolph Ziggler retained his Intercontinental Championship in an Iron Man match versus Seth Rollins. Really, it didn’t matter how many falls Ziggler won by on the night, though the number was already preposterous enough in itself. There is always another fall to come.

Why didn’t AJ Styles simply do what everybody on Reddit and Twitter told him to, and wear a cup?

If a heel interferes in a title match, either intentionally disqualifying their charge or costing the babyface the win, the babyface is awarded a further opportunity. There is but one end, theoretically, to the repetition: a wrestler, having initially lost a title, cleanly pins their opponent on two consecutive occasions.

All performers, irrespective of alignment, are portrayed as indistinguishable. They might lose one week, and win the next. There is no consistency. They are just there, all of them, including Roman Reigns.

It strips the onscreen governing structure of any purpose. What is Kurt Angle even doing? Why is he retconning all of his match results? Isn’t he, as a babyface, meant to fairly gauge those results and determine which of his performers has earned the “opportunity” to progress further up the card? A godd*mn algorithm could book fresher, more purposeful matches than him.

The WWE Championship match at Extreme Rules was borderline shocking, in that AJ Styles cleanly defeated Rusev at the first attempt. A heel earned contendership, and lost in an intelligently laid-out bout in which he succumbed to clever strategy. Styles didn’t lose because he had the attention span of a goldfish. Reinforced by the definitive win, he looked ahead to his next challenge while Rusev, having lost a match that mattered, is in the midst of character development. He has processed the loss, and seeks to change himself as a result.

This should be the new norm. The old one fosters an infuriating, reciprocal relationship: when WWE presents the same content, over and over again, the only response is to level the same old complaints, over and over again.

End the clause, repair the relationship.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!