How WWE Destroy Their Own Creations

Dave Batista & Triple H tease another WrestleMania tussle, but are the company just teasing *us*?

Batista Evolution
WWE

SmackDown 1000 was a better show than Raw 25, and not just because for much of their respective tenures the blue brand's actually been a better show overall.

At January's supposed celebration, the company stumbled so often that it was little wonder they felt the need to hold their most hardcore audience hostage in the Manhattan Centre. WWE, even at it's very worst, has always been good at nostalgia. Pick your personal worst period, and there'll still be a glimmer of light within that product shining towards 'The Past' - a time where you loved WWE and it felt like WWE still loved you.

Raw 25 was a worrying sign that the company were even losing grip on how to do that right. SmackDown 1000 partially recovered it, but in the most SmackDown thing ever, won't have remotely earned an audience for it because the company couldn't be a*sed to promote it as well as the flagship's quarter century shindig.

Fans and wrestlers alike felt the anger on that divisive January night. On the company's own website, Stone Cold Steve Austin was ripping into petrified Mike Rome whilst Twitter revealed videos of infuriated fans stuck in front of a big screen in between a Bray Wyatt/Matt Hardy match and the worst Undertaker appearance of the year.

Like everything else they've conditioned fans to love, WWE were killing nostalgia - an ordinarily indestructible force, an ordinarily immovable object - in front of those best served to appreciate it.

And now they've looked to the past to potentially set up a huge WrestleMania match in the future. Is it foolish to assume it won't just be badly mishandled too?

CONT'D...


Ringmaster To Austin
WWE

A recent article on this website profiled a number of original artistic concepts for characters ahead of their WWE debuts.

There were some fascinating creations, and a sneak peek at the process provided a window into the sheer organisation of the organisation. Virtually every wrestler to ever pass through WWE has - regardless of their experiences overall - spoke to the size and scale of the company in comparison to everywhere else they've wrestled.

Though a laughable lack of employee rights for the wrestlers themselves suggest otherwise, WWE is a place of work compared to the places to work elsewhere. 1980s territory wrestlers were often dumfounded by merchandising presentations made to them upon signing, 1990s WCW escapees were motivated by "opportunity" in comparison to the hefty guarantees they'd left behind, whilst new arrivals of today can't believe they've sealed their 'dream' job having watched the show as long as they can remember.

And yet, in each of these eras, the company just hasn't been able to help itself. Why design and conceptualise toys if you can't sell them? Why prove an Atlanta braintrust right for issuing release papers? Why turn dreams to nightmares when the starting point is one of such positivity?

"Anything can happen in WWE" was always the catchphrase. Why is that true with depressing regularity rather than satisfying familiarity?

CONT'D...


Batista Ric Flair Triple H Evolution
WWE.com

On SmackDown 1000, Triple H swapped the leather jacket, jeans and DX t-shirt for the leather jacket, jeans and Evolution t-shirt, instead of a suit, because that might be confused with his Authority suit. Or his actual dressed-for-work suit. This is the schizophrenic life of 'The Game' now, but it's been like this for ages.

The cheeky b*stard only got himself on the show to bask in the reflected glory of legitimate Hollywood star Dave Batista. Evolution were never - literally never - a part of SmackDown until the celebration show, but turned up all the same because 'The Animal' was a huge part of the blue brand.

God forbid Hunter let it just be about Ba/Boo/Blue on his first time in front of a live crowd in four years. He enjoyed bantering off Damien Sandow as part of a comedy DX supergroup at the start 2012's Raw 1000 before returning later as the hardest man in the world for a scrap with Brock Lesnar. He went from Gorilla Position gaffer to wannabe Bullet Club degenerate at Raw 25. He managed here to set up a WrestleMania programme whilst another legend ended the show using his brief appearance to reference his problematic Saudi Arabia tag match next month.

He does this because he can, by the way. Nobody else gets the agency Hunter gets, and it's not about amassing title reigns now but establishing a false narrative as a cast-iron truth. The company hasn't destroyed Triple H, but he had to become the company to ensure its safety.

Can Batista - a legitimate megastar that wants one last WWE run more than he needs it - trust this same company not to bodge it?

CONT'D...


WrestleMania 21 Batista World Title
WWE

Big Dave was in great form on the show itself. He hadn't had to do his pyro-free entrance like Edge, hadn't been shoehorned into a dance break by Vince McMahon nor was he trotted out like the aforementioned 'Deadman' like an aged afterthought. But if his segment was anything at all, it was a kickoff to a build. And WWE haven't quite yet destroyed that.

'The Show Of Shows' brings out the best in the company ahead of the event itself, despite divisive takes on the supersized shows and the reliance on megastars as the Royal Rumble gives way to the Road to WrestleMania. But on the night, 'The Game' has taken occasional praise for efforts against The Undertaker and Daniel Bryan and flushed it away with overwrought and insecure displays against Roman Reigns, Seth Rollins and Sting. Overlong, overwrought and over-reliant on banter respectively, all three hugely underperformed on reasoned expectations.

Only Batista's sheer popularity stopped it happening once before. Their WrestleMania 21 main event drew one of the best buyrates in the history of the show, but Hunter's insistence on them going long in the match that night threatened to undermine 'The Animal's intensity. Two more consecutive pay-per-view jobs wiped away that stain, but Triple H has nothing to lose in 2019. Nor a reason to.

CONT'D...


ronda rousey triple h wrestlemania 34
WWE.com

In defence of 'The Game', he gave everything to ensure Ronda Rousey's debut was a Sports Entertainment masterpiece, but she's a performer that'll not only increase his bank balance as an executive but also not threaten his position as a special occasion performer. The perfect person to put over, in Hunter's eyes.

Is Batista that guy? No. Does Batista have the fitness Ronda clearly did that night? On 2014 evidence, no. But will Triple H get to boost his status at the gatekeeper of the WWE Universe (not to mention years of bragging rights by) beating a Guardian Of The Galaxy? DanielBryanChant.gif.

The segment between the pair on SmackDown 1000 successfully created buzz for the match, and this piece isn't placed as a pessimistic takedown of an angle and match with all the potential in the world. But WWE is no longer a company that makes good on potential.

Daniel Bryan's 2018 comeback had all the potential in the world and he's been pinned more times that tweets about philanthropy being the future of marketing. Braun Strowman had the potential to be The (actual) Guy, but was sacrificed - possibly beyond recovery - for 'The Guy'. Asuka had the potential to be the best NXT call-up since the the commencement of Triple H's pet project, but she was beaten and buried in under 12 months because Vince McMahon likes blonde Americans and has forgotten everything Jim Ross ever told him about interests beyond them.

Despite what you see most Mondays and a few too many Tuesdays, WWE is still at it's heart a creative entity. It's still a place for continued evolution, despite SmackDown 1000's best segment featuring a weathered fab four lining up like The Beatles on a rooftop. If matches and storylines weren't so senselessly buried under politics and pettiness, as many people might buy into the last battle between 'The Animal' and 'The Game' as did the first.

Don't Let Me Down.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.