If WWE Was Being Honest About The Shield

Carrying the burden.

The Shield reunite
WWE.com

The Shield is what Donald Trump mistakes the F-35 fighter plane as: a transparent vehicle.

WWE have reformed the faction to hide in plain sight the launch of Roman Reigns’ run with the Universal Championship. But then, that’s what The Shield was all along. It was both a transparent vehicle and driving force of artistic brilliance. Roman Reigns was always The Guy, even in late 2012. CM Punk was infamously told to make Roman look strong a year after this had already become very apparent.

The Shield’s intra-match strategy prophesied Roman’s ascent as a singles player. Dean Ambrose was the unhinged rash who disoriented his opponents. Seth Rollins was the projectile missile who targeted them with precision airborne strikes. Roman was the man who let out the war cry and won the wars for his team. That was the impression we were left with: Roman was the all-powerful match-winner.

Can The Shield double as something genuinely amazing once more, in this post-‘Anybody-but-you-Roman’ 2018 landscape?

This week's RAW reformation angle was as odd as it was cynical as it was, just barely, a somewhat audacious success. The underlying unease was unshakeable, however, because the cynicism was not exclusive to Roman. To accept the reunion as something organic, we were expected to suddenly abandon our understanding of the babyface heel/dynamic in a strange new vacuum.

CONT'D...(1 of 4)


Roman Reigns Wins Universal
WWE.com

It’s all too selective to avoid suspicion. Ordinarily, this dynamic is incredibly stark. Insultingly stark. In WWE, heels are almost invariably unable to win via conventional means. They walk away from matches when the challenge becomes too much. They intentionally disqualify themselves in acts of cowardly desperation. They rely on the interference of their associates to scrape victories. Babyfaces, in cartoonish comparison, are honest to a fault, and to an extent that depicts them as hapless, more often than not. This is the narrative world WWE has created. Anything else feels alien to it. Anything else feels as contrived as the original contrivance. The centre cannot hold.

We are beaten over the head with this rule. When it is broken, we pay attention, and it is telling that Roman Reigns, once again, was afforded the luxury of becoming a singular case. The lines are drawn with such permanence that any blurring becomes too difficult to accept as a logical development. The Shield’s reformation wasn’t a mere shock; it was a glitch in the matrix.

It makes some sense from a character perspective. Roman, Dean and Seth share the same roads on the RAW brand, and as babyfaces, they’re headed in the same direction. They are united by their history and a renewed friendship forged through testing experience. They are brothers, and brothers look after their own. But must we rely on head canon generosity? This is The Shield. They were once beyond reproach as an act. Even questioning or bargaining the brilliance of WWE’s biggest creative triumph of the PG Era feels like a diminishment of it.

They are also reunited on Monday by the original mission statement, not that this helps, really. Their sense of justice was always warped. Ultimately, as heels, they were vultures ready to serve their own needs. And, on RAW, as babyfaces, they did just that, contradicting their own character arcs a week prior as a result.

CONT'D...(2 of 4)


The Shield Raw
WWE.com

Reigns blasted Brock Lesnar for months. He wasn’t a fighting champion. And then, 24 hours after he won the Universal Title he insisted he would defend, against all comers, any time, any place, he orchestrated a plan to avoid defending the title against Braun Strowman. Strowman claimed contendership fairly, it should be noted.

Rollins meanwhile grew apoplectic at fighting the same stacked odds in his one-man war against Dolph Ziggler and Drew McIntyre. Ambrose returned by his side in a rebalance of justice. And then, just seven days later, The Shield dealt Braun Strowman an injustice. This isn't good guy behaviour. It isn't bad guy behaviour. It's whatever Vince McMahon feels he needs to do to get Roman over as a babyface.

Braun Strowman is no mere man. He is, as we are reminded, the Monster Among Men, which might—but does not quite—excuse the three-on-one beat-down. Roman fought bravely against Strowman, one on one, just last year.

Strowman isn’t the babyface here, either. Somehow, we’re expected to receive his “face-to-face” cash-in declaration as an act of honesty when, in reality, he’s doing the exact same thing the cowardly heels have done for 12 years: he’s watching, and waiting, ready to prey upon a weakened opponent. Strowman is an indestructible force who thrives on competition. Very little of any of this follows the established narrative - so how are we to receive a more ambitious extension of it?

It’s all uneven and contradictory. And, because WWE elsewhere is so deadeningly simplistic, this doesn’t translate as a new frontier of nuanced, shades-of-grey storytelling. And that’s because it isn’t. It’s selectively muddled. Everybody can hear the Big Dog whistle.

The timing is as suspicious as the dynamic. The Shield so obviously didn’t reform as some autonomous choice. The faction reformed only to obscure Roman’s lack of popularity. WWE isn’t getting away with it. When WWE goes to such drastic lengths to remove focus from its focal point, how else are we meant to receive the development, other than smoke and mirrors? That is literally what this is, but in the process, with some irony, the magic is gone.

CONT'D...(3 of 4)


The Shield Honest II
WWE.com

The Shield were once the incredible answer to WWE’s main event star deficit. Now, true to WWE’s unspooling narrative, they invite nothing but questioning. This all feels like Survivor Series 2017 booking. Absolutely nothing holds up to scrutiny, and yet, the star-on-star clashes yielded several blockbuster moments that allowed us to enjoy it as an empty spectacle. And that’s what this is: moment-to-moment Michael Bay booking in defiance of a once-rich wider narrative.

For this reformation to work, it must act not as a platform for the Roman Reigns push, but the WrestleMania-sized Triple Threat sequel to Battleground 2016. That match was very good, but something of a missed opportunity even before the opening bell rang out.

Seth Rollins recently expressed a desire to at last distance WWE from its brigade of part-time Legends. This could be achieved, if Roman Reigns vs. Seth Rollins vs. Dean Ambrose headlines WrestleMania 35. All of this would make sense, and drive something legendary, if WWE were to lean on the idea that Roman Reigns is leaning on his brothers to funnel their popularity. Dean Ambrose is the key here. He is the disenfranchised, fiercely loyal brother marginalised to the fringe, time and time again. Rollins is the fandom’s Guy. Surely, this should drive within him a sense of resentment set to combust on the Road to New Jersey.

The Shield aren’t good guys. They’re not bad guys. They’re just the Guys.

This nonsense won’t stick, much like it didn’t stick for Roman Reigns. They’ll doubtlessly wrestle several high-octane thrillers in the autumn months. But the very second Roman enters the fray, the fandom will jeer him, and then cheer him the very second he is joined by his brothers for the Triple Powerbomb spot. This should spark something within Rollins and Ambrose. The symbolism of their literally propping up prone opponents for Roman to destroy is something WWE should mine to make genuine poetry from a plot hole-ridden novel. Only by acknowledging and abandoning the pretence can WWE make something of this.

This might yet happen, and only then can we believe in The Shield reunion.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!