It's Official: WWE Has Never Been Worse
Kevin Owens Vs. Seth Rollins going to a 25 minute count-out: this WWWF as the Content Era SUCKS.
That is a hyperbolic statement, possibly informed by the recency bias of having to actually endure Monday Night RAW in a professional capacity, but WWE has never felt worse.
Looking at other, awful periods of WWE's modern history as a comparative exercise yields decent counter-arguments that can themselves be countered. 1991 was a critically panned year, in which business went down the sh*tter, but the intricacy of the road to WrestleMania VII and shockingly high match quality in the main event picture worked between Sgt. Slaughter, Randy Savage, Hulk Hogan and Ultimate Warrior was excellent, if you could put the whole 'murica bullsh*t aside. 1995 was a dismal, small-time vibe plagued with sh*tty matches as Vince substituted steroids for lard in a less illegal attempt to present his favoured large men. Even then, he knew how to book - Barry Horowitz was pushed in a better story then several world-class talents are now - and the more lithe super-workers wrestled excellent matches that actually meant something to their careers. This is a vital distinction.
Early 1999 was the WWF's commercial peak, but a critical nadir. The gothic bullsh*t and dumbf*ck plotting infected the main event scene, and the undercard standard was wretched, but Steve Austin and the Rock worked as many iconic angles as strong, purposeful matches.
2004 may well be the most overlooked sh*te year in WWE history. The roster was in flux, 'Ruthless Aggression' was simply the same "edgy" Attitude Era rebadged, and SmackDown had fallen from its shockingly good 2003 peak. Even then, amid the Kenzo Suzukis and the Heidenreichs and the same overtly fake format, WWE felt worth the investment. By the end of the year, John Cena and Batista really did exude potential megastar auras.
CONT'D...(1 of 6)
2019 was atrocious in an inexplicable way.
Vince had long since lost it, with his Two out of Three Falls obsession, and the year played out like his promotion had finally got what it had asked for. Dead crowds watched on as stigmatised midcard acts were forced to recite The Rock-adjacent scripted material and very little made sense from one week to the next. Planet's Champion Daniel Bryan was an exceptional aberration, and WWE promoted some excellent matches under the "look at the f*cking roster, it's impossible not to" principle, but it was mostly sh*te. It was so sh*te, in fact, that every week generated a new inadvertently hilarious development to dunk on. Rowan's doppelgänger! Rowan's spider! Jesus Christ how rubbish was Hell In A Cell, eh? WWE, for the worst of reasons mind you, remained worthy of discussion. People still gave a sh*t about it. The product was often compared to the WCW scene of 2000. What WWE is in 2021 is somehow worse. It is a tundra of interest.
The worst thing about the WWE of 2021 is that few seem to still give a sh*t about it. The chronically awful sh*t that WWE churns out is simply too dull and familiar to bury. WWE's generally dire output doesn't even make headlines. A champion ate a pin again. The opening verbal segment lasted too long and the dialogue was fake. Several disqualification finishes happened on the same show. If any of this happened on Dynamite, people would experience a f*cking meltdown.
WWE ritually does just incredibly stupid things, but the kicker is that it is entirely expected now.
CONT'D...(2 of 6)
The very second Nikki ASH and Rhea Ripley won the RAW Women's Tag Team titles, they started losing. In WWE, being a champion makes you worse, somehow. This is unfathomably stupid! It's like a soldier being less effective on the battlefield after they've armed themselves. And because this nonsense has prevailed for so long, investment is futile. You know it's going to be sh*t. It can't not be sh*t. It is the show's nature to be sh*t. That which isn't sh*t - yes yes you all like Roman Reigns, careful about making him into the rule-proving exception - is almost guaranteed to become sh*t at some sh*tty point or other.
WWE in 2021 is simply a drab type of crap, and Vince McMahon has stumbled upon a new formula to make it even more low-effort and pointless. His new trick is to make a match with a DQ finish leading to some angle or other 25 minutes long, for literally no other reason than it's easier for him to not book anything else. 25 minutes of Kevin Owens Vs. Seth Rollins on telly just to get to Big E's interference spot, Jesus wept. Here.
What do the following matches have in common?
Bret Hart Vs. Steve Austin, March 23, 1997. The Undertaker Vs. Edge, March 30, 2008. Chris Jericho Vs. Shawn Michaels, March 30, 2003. Daniel Bryan Vs. Kofi Kingston, April 7, 2019.
If you answered "they're the most fondly-remembered matches from that year's WrestleMania show," you'd be right. But another answer is:
CONT'D...(3 of 6)
All four matches were shorter than yet another Seth Rollins Vs. Kevin Owens match on RAW that didn't even have a proper finish. It took Charlotte Flair three weeks prior to that 20 minutes to just give up and get herself disqualified against Bianca Belair. It's like Vince is booking Ring of Honor during its various eras of shark-jumping indulgence, booking long matches for the sheer sake of it, and the man doesn't even consider himself a wrestling promoter. He's delirious all right, but he by his own admission is not a "booker". A "booker" is wrasslin' stuff!
Then what the f*ck is a 25 minute wrestling match?
Vince is doing this - this being ultimately worthless quote-unquote Good Wrestling - because it's easier to do that than book a show. This is a particular disgrace since RAW and SmackDown are automatically bad. It's not hard to book RAW. A bot can do it, it's that formulaic. All he has to do is programme two or more performers together, instruct a hack to write some reason why they might want to fight, scribble a red pen through the hack's work, book the match, book no finish to the match, and then book the match again. He can't even do this multiple times per show in November 2021, leading to 22 minute four-man tags.
WWE is an inconvenience to itself. Other than keep Roman Reigns strong, they never seem to want to do anything.
The issue is pronounced during the Survivor Series build, as it often is.
CONT'D...(4 of 6)
Wrestlers that represented different brands three weeks ago suddenly care about representing their new brand, even though there's no storyline reason to do so, and they're not even teams because they're booked to wrestle one another in the build. A lot of people, once upon a time, got into the WWF because they were thrilled at the prospect of Hulk Hogan mowing down the immovable object or facing his ultimate challenge. Nowadays, the wide-eyed six year-old is presumably expected to ask if Aaliyah can co-exist with her teammates after first fighting with them. And then being removed from the team. After first being introduced with no character as simply "from NXT". A programme on which she has barely appeared in years.
That action figure is presumably not going to sell too well.
Excessively long WrestleMania-length matches that do the job of an angle; the same over-scripted sh*te that everybody in wrestling other than WWE management thinks is toxic, much less the fans; a chronically normalised crop of top stars who feel like they've occupied similar positions for years (and literally have in too many cases); no sense of trust generated in all but the least discerning ultra-hardcore belt replica base; almost complete secondary title devaluation: this company is just the absolute pits, and this article has barely covered a certain, popular trope.
CONT'D...(5 of 6)
They might as well rename the company Can They Co-WWExist? for how frequent this atrocity of fiction is. That's a mouthful that barely makes any sense, making it not remotely dissimilar to 98% of what gets said on television.
Seriously: beyond the genuinely excellent portrayal of and performance by Roman Reigns, what's worth watching in this company when you consider the fact that the work ethic of its talented roster is ultimately futile? They constantly ruin everybody. Big E is already a bit of an aloof - at best - babyface. Bianca Belair loses all of the time and has gained nothing from the Becky Lynch programme. Much of the WWE dot com 'Superstars' page looks like a pile of missing kid milk cartons littered across the graveyard next door to the middle-aged cul-de-sac of forever homes. SquaredCircle isn't an accurate barometer of anything, much less fan engagement, but the friggin' Dark Elevation thread was more popular than the RAW thread last week. WWE is a waste of time, and fewer and fewer people are wasting their time with it.
It used to be actively annoying when WWE f*cked things up, which they've done for two decades at this point. Then it used to be funny.
Now it's just like taking the bin out: the most mundane, dreaded task imaginable, one that is horrendous for the environment but is just something that is done as a matter of course.