Predicting The Next 10 AEW Stars To Jump Ship To WWE

After years of WWE stars switching sides, it looks like the shoe is finally on the other foot!

Chris Jericho WWE Raw Is Jericho
AEW/WWE

Since Tony Khan and his elite set of friends decided to create their own wrestling promotion in 2019, AEW has been the land of opportunity. It has been the number one destination for any wrestler who has been overlooked by their former employer, despite being immensely talented. A certain trend has emerged over the years that basically goes: WWE Star is released, 90 days pass, surprise ‘landscape shattering’ debut, former WWE star is #AllElite, cue the Tony Khan fanboy freak out.

But not everybody can be a champion, not everybody can be at the forefront 100% of the time. As a result, some stars fall by the wayside, thus they look elsewhere. This sort of situation is what caused so many WWE stars to jump over to the All Elite side of the border, but now, with the complete 180 that the Stamford-based juggernaut has taken in the last month, it could become the opposite really quickly.

Multiple wrestlers have come out recently and expressed concern with the way that AEW is run, sighting 'communication issues' as the reason behind their dissatisfaction with the company, and some even have gone as far as to request their release. That sort of stuff can set a precedent, and when there is now an alternative that looks greener on the other side, the floodgates could potentially open.

10. Dustin Rhodes

Dustin Rhodes
AEW

Blood is thicker than water is a saying as old as time itself, and the Rhodes family understands the importance of blood.

Dustin and Cody have crossed paths several times in the ring, none more famous than their encounter at AEW's first ever PPV, but even outside of the ring the brothers are never that far behind each other wherever they go. This was made evident when Dustin was one of baby brother Cody’s first priority signings to the new All Elite fed. The man formerly known as Goldust has been an excellent hand on deck for AEW, performing the role of an established veteran who is always happy to put over the next up-and-coming talent and make them look like a million dollars in the process.

However, now that ‘The American Nightmare’ finds himself back on the WWE side of the border, and the fences have been mended between the Rhodes family and WWE, it is only a matter of time before ‘The Natural’ is offered a lot more money to do the exact same thing he’s doing right now. Not to mention the fact that a Hall of Fame induction would be a part of the deal, as well as a lifetime position as a Performance Centre coach. Those two features alone would be enough to convince the 53-year-old to make the jump, let alone the pull of his younger brother wanting a family reunion.


9. Samoa Joe

Samoa Joe ROH
ROH

Samoa Joe and Triple H have a close relationship, which is well known at this point. One only has to look to the way Joe was immediately rehired by Triple H in 2020 after Vince McMahon fired the ‘Samoan Submission Machine’ out of nowhere as a part of the bulk pandemic ‘budget cuts’.

Now that Joe is under contract with Tony Khan’s revitalised Ring of Honor promotion, ‘The Game’ will only be hungrier to get Joe back again. Despite the fact that Triple H will have to wait to get his hands on the ROH Television Champion, it is only a matter of time before the chants of “Joe is gonna kill you!” ring out from a WWE crowd.

While his services in the ring are still and always will be a hot property, his abilities outside of the ring should be highly appreciated as well. The Orange County native can not only wrestle circles around most of the world, but he can also commentate, train and most likely produce better than most as well. This is all due to the ‘Samoan Destroyer’s impeccable knowledge of wrestling and brilliant business mind. Joe is a smart man, the former three-time NXT Champion knows that WWE is the better path for him in the long run, especially now that Vince isn’t steering the ship.


8. Miro

Miro AEW
AEW

Hear ye, hear ye, come one, come all, let us celebrate in the most glorious of ways, for today is RUSEV DAY! Boy, wouldn’t that pop the ceiling off of any given Raw or SmackDown taping?

The man now known as Miro in AEW was once known as one of the many missed opportunities that WWE managed to stuff up. But is he soon about to become known as one of the very few missed opportunities that AEW stuffed up? When first bursting onto the scenes of the All Elite landscape Miro was in a bad spot, paired with Kip Sabian as a goofy heel gamer character was not the way fans wanted to see their ‘Bulgarian Brute’ presented.

Fortunately, this was corrected and he is now ‘The Redeemer’ and has enjoyed a lengthy TNT Championship reign, being probably the last wrestler to actually bring prestige to the floundering mid-card belt. But since losing the title, he has been directionless and pretty much stuck in catering, causing people to wonder if he would be better off in WWE, with Miro himself even liking a tweet that suggested such a thing. If this sort of treatment keeps up it would probably shock nobody for Miro to want out of his contract and run back to the company that at least kept him busy, no matter how silly the storyline was.


7. Paige VanZant

Paige VanZant
AEW

Paige VanZant has some serious money-making potential. The mixed martial artist-turned bareknuckle boxer has both the legitimacy and the IT factor that could make her seem a credible threat to any wrestling women’s division in the world. AEW recognised this pretty early on after her guest appearances on Dynamite as a part of the Inner Circle vs. American Top Team feud and signed her up to a contract.

However, money talks. Quite simply, WWE has both more money and a bigger platform to offer the woman who is aptly nicknamed ‘12 Gauge’. Plus, WWE is no stranger to signing former MMA competitors, as they have always had a fascination with the UFC and quite enjoy turning legit fighting stars into credible wrestlers. One has to only look at their track record with the likes of Ken Shamrock, Shayna Baszler and, most famously, Ronda Rousey all achieving success within the squared circle under WWE’s banner.

PVZ has the looks, she has the charisma and with a bit of training she’ll have plenty of ability to boot, it won’t be long before WWE comes calling.


6. Buddy Matthews

Buddy Matthews
AEW

Buddy Matthews is no longer the wrestling world’s ‘Best Kept Secret’ and has been tearing it up since WWE let him go. The Australian is in both the shape of his life and on the cusp of entering his wrestling prime at the age of 33, yet he has been pretty underutilised in AEW so far.

Buddy is easily the most out-of-place member of The House of Black, and the most dispensable. Clearly, Tony Khan doesn’t have huge plans for him if he is happy to let Matthews roam around the world taking his own bookings every week despite the fact that Malakai Black’s stable is a key player every week on Dynamite and Rampage.

Even in WWE, Matthews was used on TV more frequently, and that is saying something because, other than his time under Seth Rollins as his disciple, the one-time Cruiserweight Champion was a veteran amongst the catering rooms. Considering that Triple H has always seen the value of Matthews’ in-ring talent, most notably making him a major focal point of 205 Live when The Game was in charge, ‘The Juggernaut’ knows that he would be more than taken care of in the new WWE landscape.

Couple that with the fact that being in WWE would mean he has the same schedule as current squeeze Rhea Ripley, making the jump would be all too more desirable for Buddy.


5. Private Party

Private Party
AEW

Not many AEW talents can say they have gone backwards since the promotion's inception, but Private Party can.

The talented team of Isiah Kassidy and Marq Quen danced onto the screens of All Elite fans in the early days of the company’s 2019 launch, with unbridled amounts of both intensity and promise. It was clear why the young duo was hand-picked by The Young Bucks when they went on their tag team signing spree for Khan’s company. A shock win over The Bucks themselves came soon after, and it appeared as though the Brooklyn natives were going to be a focal point of the company’s tag division for years to come.

However, Private Party hadn't been withing a sniff of the Tag Team Title picture throughout their stints with the Andrade/Hardy Family Office. Even know, with a shot at Keith Lee and Swerve Strickland's gold coming up as of this writing, this opportunity feels long, long overdue.

Kassidy and Quen, like many of the young All Elite talents, need more experience to truly flourish. But unfortunately, they just won’t be getting that with AEW’s three hours of television per week. A move to WWE would be perfect for the tandem, as they are both still in their mid-20s and have plenty of time to become a future great tag team.

Not to mention, NXT 2.0 would be the ideal place to practice Private Party's more character-driven gimmick, rather than AEW’s ‘I am a good wrestler’ sports-orientated presentation.


4. Chris Jericho

Chris Jericho
AEW

There is no single other wrestler in history that has managed to stay as relevant and at the top of their game longer than Chris Jericho. Whenever he feels as though his act is getting stale or the promotion he works for has become stagnant, Jericho reinvents himself and moves on. In the last five years alone, he has gone from the keeper of The List in WWE, to ‘The Painmaker’ in NJPW, to ‘Le Champion’ in AEW.

But now, Jericho has taken a back seat as his career begins to wind down, which is fair enough, but at the end of the day, do you really see the Canadian retiring at an All Out... or at a WrestleMania? After all, he is a self-proclaimed Vince McMahon guy, so we all know where his loyalties lie deep down.

There have been clues to this jump happening in the last year as well, and we aren’t just talking about his landmark appearance on WWE Network’s ‘Broken Skull Sessions’ with Steve Austin, either. Lately ‘The Demo God’ has toned down his verbal jabs at WWE and their ‘stupid ideas by bad creative’ and has had nothing but nice things to say about the Stamford-based promotion.

Chris Jericho clearly wants that WWE Hall of Fame nod and doesn’t want to burn that bridge, so expect Y2J to reinvent himself once again and embark on one final run under WWE contract.


3. Adam Cole And Britt Baker

Adam Cole Britt Baker
AEW

If only Triple H had taken over WWE’s creative this time last year, he most likely wouldn’t have told Adam Cole that he was going to be brought to the main roster to simply be a manager. Thus, Cole would probably not have left the company (amicably, mind you) and joined up with his All Elite pals in Jacksonville.

However, since the very first day that he walked into Full Sail University, the ‘Panama City Playboy’ was Triple H and Shawn Michaels’ boy. The DX pair bent over backwards to make sure Cole was always presented as a megastar and was the face of the Black and Gold brand until the day that he left. You best believe that the second his AEW contract runs out he’ll be tabled a ginormous amount of money to return to Stamford. Of course, if Cole is to go anywhere, it would most likely be a two-for-one deal; to sign him, you need to also sign long-time partner Britt Baker - and vice versa!

Given how long they've been dating, one has to imagine that Adam Cole 'Bay Bay' and

One may assume that marriage will eventually be on the horizon for Adam Cole ‘Bay Bay’ and Dr Britt Baker, and the couple will want to be on the same schedule going forward. So, if WWE is able to offer the pair that, as well as allowing both to continue their respective Twitch and Dentistry projects, similar to how they let Cody Rhodes continue his side projects, then there is no reason why the All Elite power couple can’t make the jump.


2. Wardlow

Wardlow TNT Title
AEW

Is there anything about Wardlow that doesn’t scream WWE? He is a giant among dwarves in a company that actually, refreshingly, embraces the small stature of workhorse wrestlers and prefer them to the muscular meat heads of generations past. But WWE, traditionally, has been the land of the giants, so there is no surprise that they are extremely interested in signing the Cleveland native.

Me may not be overly tall, but Wardlow is big - very big! - he looks like a star, walks like a star and can go in the ring with the best of them. Sure, his promo abilities probably need a bit more work, but there are plenty of people in the gorilla position at any given WWE event that can help him with that. Yes, AEW clearly have big aspirations for him, as he currently holds the TNT Championship and is desperately trying to regain some of the title’s former prestige, but would you blame the man for picking up the phone if WWE came calling?

The 34-year-old himself hasn’t ruled out the possibility of working with WWE in the future, and that is because he knows that the door will be open. It will simply be up to him if he walks through it or not.


1. MJF

MJF AEW
AEW

MJF is better than us and we know it. Perhaps Tony Khan doesn’t quite know it, but Triple H definitely knows it.

We haven’t seen Maxwell Jacob Freidman on our television screens since his infamous pipebomb-style promo back in June, and nobody knows when we will see him back, or if when we do next see him if it will be on TBS or the USA Network.

Max clearly knows his worth, his promo made that obvious, so he knows that WWE will be able to provide him with that said worth, as well as provide him with the platform that allows him to truly shine. The ‘Salt of The Earth’ is rumoured to have aspirations beyond wrestling as well, such as acting; an avenue that is more likely to open up for him if he is to be known as a WWE Superstar, compared to an All Elite Wrestler.

So, if Tony Khan was to genuinely grant MJF his release, if the tensions between Khan and Friedman actually do exist and this isn’t just one big work, Triple H will be the first name to pop up on the 26-year-old’s phone.


Contributor

Just an Australian wrestling fan who grew up admiring the sport that we all know and love. All round wrestling fanatic, wouldn’t mind if you just sat down and listened to his humble opinions on the wrestling world.