Predicting The Next 10 WWE Hall Of Fame Headliners
And John Cena is NOT one of them.
If John Cena is inducted into the Hall of Fame before 2032, come back here and ask for it. I’ll buy you and your entire family first row WrestleMania tickets (on my WhatCulture allowance).
WWE’s principle for inductions is the later the better, as they want to capitalize on their stars’ entire career accomplishments and keep the post-induction in-ring involvement to a minimum. In all likelihood, John Cena, Randy Orton, AJ Styles, The Miz and the like will not be considered in the following decade. They will probably part-time for a while before full retirement and a subsequent HOF induction.
Note that since it’s difficult to gauge what AEW’s future will look like, no current member of their roster will feature on this list. It’s possible that a couple of years from now there will be an afflux of talent leaving AEW for WWE, but as of now things are too uncertain to venture guesses as to when (or if) we’ll see CM Punk, Chris Jericho, Daniel Bryan, Dean Ambrose, The Hardy Boyz, Christian or Big Show inducted into WWE’s Hall of Fame.
10. Batista (2023)
Although rumours have surfaced about
Vince McMahon possibly headlining next year's class (more on him later),
Batista is the most likely, and above all, the better choice. First of all, he was supposed to headline the class of 2020. Three ceremonies have
already gone by, and WWE can only wait so long before Dave's induction turns
into a "Legend has it X is still Y" meme. They should get it over
with before fans loose interest and turn it into a joke.
Secondly, with WrestleMania going Hollywood for the first time since 2005 (the very show whereat Batista's legend began), it's a no-brainer to have pro wrestling's biggest Hollywood success story since The Rock take centre-stage. Establishing crossover appeal between pro wrestling and the entertainment world or mainstream pop culture is one of WWE's longstanding obsessions, hence the importance of celebrating those who bridged the two.
Thanks to Triple H, WWE is the least tone-deaf it has been in years ( maybe decades?). Everybody knows this should happen and wants it to happen. It would be smart to start working on that induction speech, Hunter...
9. The Rock (2024)
2024 will mark the 40th anniversary of WrestleMania. Sorry, 2024 will be the 39th anniversary of WrestleMania, but WWE will market it as its 40th anniversary. This landmark show, which takes place in the same city - Philadelphia - where The Rock wrestled his first ‘Mania main event, and will hopefully follow on from a widely anticipated Rock vs Roman Reigns clash at WrestleMania 39. If that match happens, it will probably be Rocky’s send-off.
In other words, if WWE does not go through with this induction, they deserve to have their candy asses kicked all over Stamford.
As with Batista, this is a shoo-in. Triple H will no doubt try to make it happen, but the question mark remains on whether Dwayne’s busy schedule will allow for it. One thing is clear: just like The Rock left his heart in San Francisco, he should leave his boots in Philadelphia.
8. Evolution (2025)
In the last few years, WWE showed us what its plan is to prevent running out of credible Hall of Fame headline acts: teams and stables.
Up until 2018, there was only one two-time WWE HOF inductee in Ric Flair. Since then, Bret Hart, Shawn Michaels, Hulk Hogan, Kevin Nash, Scott Hall, Sean Waltman and Booker T have earned themselves a second ring, and all did so as part of a group. Since this strategy allows WWE to recycle the star power of former inductees and fill in the blank when there’s no individual star available, expect it to become a recurring theme in the years to come.
Evolution is undoubtedly lesser than the sum of its parts. Aside from maybe Triple H, no member had anything resembling the best years of their career during the faction’s run. In itself, does Evolution as a group deserve to headline a Hall of Fame ceremony ? That’s debatable. But what’s not, is that Triple H, Batista, Randy Orton and Ric Flair sharing stories and anecdotes for half an hour sells tickets. With the controversy surrounding the latter somewhat abated, he is getting slowly brought back to the WWE fold, and nothing prevents this induction anymore.
As one of, if not the, best of all time, Ric Flair wouldn’t be undeserving of a third HOF ring. In the case of Hunter, that’d be more controversial, to say the least.
7. Vince McMahon (2026)
Paul Levesque, for all the accusations of megalomania and hubris, is a reasonably humble man. He at least will probably have the decency of not basking in his own glory while holding executive power, much the same way his father-in-law never inducted himself into the Hall of Fame.
Now that the choice is his, though, Hunter should do just that. Granted, Vince McMahon could have an entire season of Dark Side of the Ring centered on him, and recent controversies make this one unimaginable for now, but in pro wrestling, the “persona non grata” status subsides surprisingly easily.
As for his merits, all things considered, Vince is probably the single most worthy inductee of all time. After all, how could it be that the man responsible for micro-managing almost everything to happen in WWE for the last 40 years be not acknowledged in its pantheon? He’s had a hand in everything bad that’s ever happened, yes, but also in every creative triumph: WrestleMania & Hulkamania, the Attitude and Ruthless Aggression Eras, the purchases of WCW and ECW, the WWE Network; the list is endless. For every wasted career, there’s a megastar McMahon created; for every insult to fans' intelligence, there's a fond memory he left in their hearts.
Vince McMahon is 77 years old. They shouldn’t wait too long to give him his dues, and properly close the book on him.
6. Edge & Goldberg... Again (2027)
As mentioned earlier, two-times inductees are becoming ever more common. Up until now, a talent boasted one ring for their individual achievements and one for their team successes. One thing WWE may be tempted to do, though, is reward current Hall of Famers for their post-HOF career.
It would be a desperate move, and certainly prove divisive among the fanbase, but from a kayfabe point of view, it kind of holds. Think of everything Edge did after his 2012 induction; he made a miracle comeback, won the Royal Rumble, competed in the main event of WrestleMania, contested Last Man Standings, Hell in a Cells and "Greatest Wrestling Matches Ever", and defeated the likes of Randy Orton, Seth Rollins and AJ Styles.
As for Goldberg, he won half as many WWE World Titles as he had prior to his induction, also wrestled a 'Mania main event, featured in high-profile feuds against Bobby Lashley and Roman Reigns, and recently claimed his wrestling days were numbered, but not over.
Granted, as things stand, this is an unlikely scenario. But with many WWE legends now cashing AEW paychecks, and considering the unbalance between the yearly demand in HOF box office draws and their relatively short supply, WWE may have no other choice but to resort to such sleazy, outside-the-box thinking.
5. Rey Mysterio (2028)
Rey Mysterio is probably going to be the third Ruthless Aggression Era star to be enshrined into WWE's Hall of Fame, but the roots of his fame go way deeper. Indeed, he may be a WWE legend, but he is an AAA, WCW and ECW legend in the same right. Influential trailblazer, international icon, definitely a contender for the title of Cruiserweight GOAT, it is not a dishonoring choice to follow Sami Zayn in seeing him as the GOAT, period.
Mysterio stated that his original plan was to retire at 50 years of age - as in three years' time - but that he may keep going if his body allows it. Considering the fabulous shape Rey is in, he would certainly look as decent in a ring as any wrestler in their 50s ever looked. If he spoils us with a couple more years, circa 2028 is a credible time for his HOF induction.
The good thing is that Mysterio doesn't look interested in part-timing, which means he could break with the tradition set by his legendary peers and have his last match be watchable. WWE should let him wrestle full-time until the moment comes for said farewell bout, ideally taking place at WrestleMania. He could then go out under the thunderous standing ovation he deserves.
4. Brothers Of Destruction (2029)
Told you it would be a recurring theme...
As with Evolution, here’s another group lesser than the sum of its parts. The Undertaker is a legend, Kane is a (minor) legend, but the Brothers of Destruction is no legendary tag team. Yet, for all the reasons given above, expect the company to label them as (read in Michael Cole’s voice) “one of the most devasting tag teams in the history of the WWE” and the production team to assemble another masterful video promo that makes you wonder whether they actually were. (Case in point.)
In reality, the tandem barely wrestled a ****+ match in their career, and you’d be hard-pressed to find a meaningful rivalry they’ve had with any other team. That their Greatest Matches DVD includes a bout against Chuck Palumbo and Sean O’Haire tells you all you need to know. But 'Taker and Kane have real presence and charisma standing next to each other, and listening to the two share details on working as kayfabe brothers or taking us behind the scenes of one of WWE’s most celebrated debuts (Kane’s at Bad Blood 1997) would undoubtedly be worth it.
3. Shane McMahon (2030)
Shane McMahon is simultaneously the most overrated and underrated WWE performer in history. On the one hand, he shouldn't have ever been presented as the kind of man that can hang toe-to-toe with the AJs, Kevin Owens and Sami Zayns of the world in traditional wrestling matches, or indeed, as the world cup-winning "Best in The World".
But think about this: the guy that jumped off a HIAC structure onto an announce table in front of 90,000+ people is not in WWE's top 50 selection on NotInTheHallOfFame.com, and has the likes of Sable and Kamala ahead of him. That's nonsense. Any wrestler that would've wrestled the matches Shane has against Vince McMahon, Kurt Angle, Kane, DX, Steve Blackman or Test, or taken half the crazy bumps he has, would be considered a sure-fire HOF headliner.
The lengths Shane was willing to go to to prove he belonged were almost touching, sacrificing his body and taking jaw-dropping risks time after time. He was never a good, maybe not even a solid, worker, but as an extreme brawler and spotfest attraction, Mick Foley may have been the only one better than him.
2. Paul Heyman (2031)
We are told Brock Lesnar is a shy individual. He himself has admitted to "feeling uncomfortable" when he's around "a bunch of people". Well, he will have to make do with public-speaking in front of more than a bunch, because to induct Paul Heyman it's going to be either him or Punk, and the latter is not happening.
Forget about his role in the careers of the two aforementioned gentlemen, as well as those of Taz, Rob Van Dam or Raven. Forget about running ECW and turning it into the best hardcore wrestling company of all time. Forget about making 2002-2004 Smackdown one of the best weekly programs in WWE's history. Paul Heyman deserves to be the star man of a HOF ceremony if only for how f***ing good he is on a microphone.
An unsung hero of sorts, he has been among the dozen of performers that really carried WWE throughout the last decade or so; except he did it relying only on mic skills. For this reason, Paul Heyman will be inducted into the Hall of Fame, and will headline his own class. It's not a prediction; it's a spoiler.
1. Brock Lesnar (2023)
At this point, Brock Lesnar can probably just walk backstage into an ongoing HOF ceremony, say "You know what? I feel like being inducted today", and have producers cancel the scheduled headline act right away. Hyperbole aside, Lesnar does have a HOF headliner spot waiting for him whenever he feels like leaving pro wrestling behind for good.
He may be well advised to wait until 2032, though. That year comes 30 years after his debut, 20 years after his game-changing comeback, and still leaves Brock ten years to feed us more dream matches, memorable spots and hilarious segments (one of his underrated strengths). Everything fits so perfectly that it would be a real shame if WWE don't book it that way. And in this timeline, it also takes place the year following his own induction of Paul Heyman, who then gets to do the same for Brock.
Hall of Fame predictions are not exactly a STEM discipline, but there is no fun in not sticking one's neck out. So here goes: if you want to witness Brock Lesnar's induction, cancel any plans you had in April 2032.