Predicting WWE's WrestleMania XL Cards 1 Year Out

WrestleMania returns, retirements and AEW leaps; predicting WWE's supershow one year out!

WWE WrestleMania XL 40 Roman Reigns The Rock
WWE

It's been a quiet week in pro wrestling.

Seriously though, WrestleMania 39 was just the tip of the iceberg. WWE merged with UFC, Vince McMahon is back running amok making all sorts of changes, and Bad Bunny might be set to headline a company pay-per-view. What next? Cats and dogs living together? MASS HYSTERIA!

It takes a brave soul, then, to go deep into the weeds of WWE creative (somewhere Vinnie Mac would never go) and predict what might happen at next year's supershow. 'Mania 40, eh? You might be wondering how the annual pay-per-view powerhouse reached this point - WWE is going XL in 2024, perhaps in more ways than one.

This list predicts WrestleMania returns and retirement matches. It also suggests that one of AEW's biggest homegrown stars could be set to follow Cody Rhodes' example by jumping over from Tony Khan's world into Vince's bold new... Endeavor.

Then, there's the not-so-small (potential) implementation of those UFC legacy stars and Hollywood favourites coming back for one last hurrah. Is this what 'Mania XL's card will look like come 6-7 April next spring?

It could be...

10. AJ Styles Vs. Edge

WWE WrestleMania XL 40 Edge AJ Styles
WWE

There was a far away look in Edge's eyes as he celebrated a thumping HIAC win over Finn Bálor at 'Mania 39. It's almost like the 'Rated-R' legend knows he won't get to experience that sort of thing many more times. Someone else watching the career clock tick down? One AJ Styles.

They'd be perfect opponents. Yes, again.

Both guys did to battle at WrestleMania 38, but the circumstances were different back then. Being brutally honest, they kinda got lost in the shuffle a wee bit too. Would that change with another go-around? Maybe/maybe not, but it'd be great to see them go out on dual highs by producing an absolute banger.

AJ wasn't even featured on this year's cards, which is a shame considering he must be close to calling time on an epic run. So, 12 months from now, stick him in there with someone else on the cusp of retirement and say, 'G'wan, lads - improve on 2021!'.


9. Bron Breakker Vs. Sheamus

WWE WrestleMania XL 40 Bron Breakker Sheamus
WWE

GUNTHER has rightly earned praise for his performances since becoming Intercontinental Champion, but nobody develops in wrestling alone. Sheamus played a huge part in elevating the Austrian to new heights by putting on several sensational matches with him, and that shouldn't be overlooked when fans are dishing out praise.

The justification for this match is that Sheamus could do the same for Bron Breakker. He should be jumping up from NXT fairly soon, so Bron might've already bedded in on Raw/SmackDown by the time 'Mania XL rolls around. If so, cool. If not (and there are never any guarantees NXT > main roster leaps will work 100% of the time), then a match vs. Sheamus could help him.

Let these lads beat the sh*te out of one another.

A good 15-20 minutes of super-stiff carnage would endear Breakker to casual fans the same way trading meaty chops with Sheamus did for GUNTHER. Also, selfishly, your writer just wants to see Bron hit some Steiner-esque suplexes.


8. Bianca Belair Vs. Rhea Ripley

WWE WrestleMania XL 40 Bianca Belair Rhea Ripley
WWE

WWE has already set the table for this by having Rhea Ripley warn Bianca Belair that she's coming for her at some point in the future. That "future" should be 'Mania XL. Of course, that depends on whether or not creative can really pad things out with other stories or even wait that long.

The women's division isn't exactly bursting with excellent challengers for either champion right now. Rhea is about to find that out now she's SmackDown Women's Champ; Ripley will be handed the same string of boring 'B' feuds Bianca has been for almost a full year over on Raw.

Slow-burning both until 'Mania 40 could be fun though, and there's every chance Belair will drop her strap long before then. A heel turn would follow, and then WWE can set about the task of prepping her for a run at Rhea.

Just imagine the kind of epic this pair could produce when it matters most.


7. Charlotte Flair/Becky Lynch Vs. Ronda Rousey/Shayna Baszler

WWE WrestleMania XL 40 Becky Lynch Charlotte Flair Ronda Rousey Shayna Baszler
WWE

Yes, Becky Lynch and Charlotte Flair as partners.

Their on/off friendship behind the scenes has been a big story in WWE circles for years now, but there's nothing making a boatload of money together at Wrestle-sh*tting-Mania can't fix. Surely that'd be enough for Becks and Flair to patch things up and go into the show with a common goal.

Part of the prediction for this match is that Ronda Rousey and Shayna Baszler supplant Lynch and Lita as Women's Tag-Team Champs, then dominate that division for an entire year. Becky's entire purpose would be roaring back at the ex-MMA stars, but being unable to take them down...until Charlotte stopped by to offer a hand.

It'd be an emotional moment for sure if Lynch and Flair repaired their splintered friendship on WWE's grandest stage; that'd be especially true if their frost was used as part of the narrative heading into 'Mania XL.

Soft 'Two Horsewomen' vs. 'Two Horsewomen' scenario too.


6. Randy Orton Vs. Matt Riddle

WWE WrestleMania XL 40 Randy Orton Matt Riddle
WWE

Again, like with Rhea Ripley vs. Bianca Belair, this hinges on just how much patience WWE's writers are willing to show between now-'Mania XL. Here's the thing: Randy Orton has been benched since May 2022, and Matt Riddle also took some time out due to personal problems between December 2022-April 2023.

So, in other words, an RK-Bro reunion on TV would feel fresh again. WWE could easily ride that out for six months or so even if Randy manages to launch his own comeback soon. Alternatively, keep Orton on hiatus until later in the year, then have him come back for some WrestleMania build.

Realistically, Randy would have to be the one turning. RK-Bro's whole thing is his varying levels of tolerance for Riddle's nonsense, so it wouldn't make much sense if Matt suddenly went rogue for the sake of it. Nah, have Orton drop him with a cruel RKO, then go, go, go.

Beating his old partner would be one hell of a showcase for Riddle.


5. Seth Rollins Vs. MJF

WWE WrestleMania XL 40 Seth Rollins MJF
WWE/AEW

Ooft!

Naturally, there's a fair amount of wishful thinking about all of this. MJF's AEW contract expires in January 2024, meaning WWE would need to act fast if they wanted his 'Mania match to mean something. Some will point to Cody Rhodes popping up as a surprise at 'Mania to shoot that plan down, but...MJF doesn't have the tenure of someone like Cody.

He'd be a completely fresh face to many in WWE's core audience, so hype would be a real must. Seth Rollins, who has become akin to a gatekeeper for the company and is very-much a veteran now, would be the ideal man to welcome Friedman into the family by putting on a stunner with him at 'Mania.

Yeah, this is a stretch considering MJF is the current AEW World Champion. Professional wrestling in 2023 is f*cking crazy though, so don't go scoffing at ideas like this just yet. Who says 2024 won't be even more bizarre?


4. Sami Zayn Vs. Kevin Owens

WWE WrestleMania XL 40 Sami Zayn Kevin Owens
WWE

If DVD boxsets were still an ongoing concern for WWE, then one detailing the feud/friendship involving Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn would be 87 discs long. Another bout between the pair would play before jokes like, 'This is KO vs. Sami part 8,762', but that's fine.

There's no way they get out of this current Undisputed Tag-Team Title run without one turning on the other though. Well, they might drop the titles then turn, but it'll happen before 2023 is out. The smart money would be on Owens, because it always seems to be him who becomes the more aggressive of the two and plays heel.

Besides, Sami only just turned baby again a few months ago.

This could even be a Universal Title showing if Triple H convinces Vinnie Mac to split the World Titles again. Would it be outlandish to pitch that KO headlines a third consecutive WrestleMania, only this time against his oldest friend in the biz?


3. Conor McGregor Vs. Brock Lesnar

WWE WrestleMania XL 40 Conor McGregor Brock Lesnar
WWE/By Kremlin.ru, CC BY 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=88590876

"Who the fook is dat guy?" isn't something many WWE fans would say if Conor McGregor rolled into town for a few scraps. A couple of UFC legacy fighters will probably stop in for some tasty paydays on the WWE side now this Endeavor deal is over the line, and McGregor could be one of the biggest.

Conor vs. Brock Lesnar sounds like money.

It'd be an interesting premise to MMA fans too; Brock has history in UFC, so even people who traditionally turn their noses up at wrestling would be intrigued to see what might happen when he's nose-to-nose with McGregor. Ooh, the drama. Or, maybe "ooh, the buyrate" would be more accurate.

WWE wouldn't be bothered by the size difference between Conor and Lesnar either. They'd be too busy being swept away by the mainstream media interest, and would happily flash their drawers at any top outlet that'd give them coverage for such a match.


2. Cody Rhodes Vs. GUNTHER

WWE WrestleMania XL 40 Cody Rhodes GUNTHER
WWE

Watch and see as this wonderful fantasy clash is totally ruined by Vince McMahon decreeing that GUNTHER should be renamed 'Gunner Baumgartner' and immediately relegated to NXT where he'll live out his days wondering what could've been. Seriously though, this match needs to happen eventually.

Cody Rhodes and GUNTHER showed what's possible back at January's Royal Rumble, and it'd be a massive miss for WWE if they didn't book them in a proper one-on-one bout. By 'Mania XL, GUNTHER could've (in theory) worked a program vs. Brock Lesnar and become the longest-reigning Intercontinental titleholder in company history.

That'd set him up nicely for a crack at new WWE Champ Cody.

There's the other side of this coin; Rhodes would've beaten Roman Reigns for the WWE Championship by the time everyone marches on to Philly, meaning his collision vs. GUNTHER could be for the promotion's top prize.

It could even come at the end of a three-match series if that suits better.


1. Roman Reigns Vs. The Rock

WWE WrestleMania XL 40 Roman Reigns The Rock
WWE

There are those who don't think WWE putting The Rock and Roman Reigns in a ring together "would be a good idea". That's genuinely something this guy has read on social media over the past few days, and it's a head-scratcher. Does that person realise just how much attention Dwayne Johnson commands?

It's a no-brainer.

No, Rocky might not be the one to end Roman's Undisputed Title reign (split those titles and distribute them to hardworking full-timers instead), but he absolutely should have a match with his cousin. WrestleMania XL is the right time to make that a reality - that'd give Dwayne a chance to free up time on his busy schedule too.

Who cares if Rock would be booed by WWE hardcores when the bell rings? He's been there before, and the marquee value of the bout is worth doing just for the posters and promos alone. This would be a fine headliner for either night, being honest.

What matches do you think could be on WWE's WrestleMania XL card? For more like this, check out 10 Things Post-WrestleMania 39 Raw Told Us About WWE's Future and 10 MAJOR Changes Coming To WWE Following UFC Merger!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.