Randy Savage's 9 WrestleMania Appearances - Ranked From Worst To Best

From champion to challenger to...commentator?!

Before Shawn Michaels was nicknamed "Mr WrestleMania", thanks to his countless show-stealing performances at WWE's annual extravaganza, there was another WWE superstar who could always be counted on to deliver the 'match of the night' at the biggest show of the year, and that was "Macho Man" Randy Savage. Savage's 'Mania resume is filled with one "WrestleMania Moment" after another, from his technical masterpiece with Ricky "The Dragon" Steamboat, to his brutal Falls Count Anywhere match with Crush. From losing the WWE Championship to Hulk Hogan, to winning it back from Ric Flair, Savage provided countless memories across a total of nine WrestleManias during his WWE career. With WrestleMania in the not too distant future, let's take a look at each of those nine occasions when Macho Man appeared at "The Show of Shows", ranking them from worst to best.

9. WrestleMania IX: The Commentator?!

When you've been a WWE fan for any length of time, you quickly become accustomed to the baffling booking decisions and head scratching disappointments which occur alarmingly often. A good example of this would be in 1993 when WWE took one of their most beloved main event superstars, still in his physical prime and hugely over with the audience, and made him a mere commentator for WrestleMania IX. When you consider that this same performer had won the WWE World Championship in the main event of the previous year's 'Mania, the decision made even less sense. To Savage's credit, he made the best of what he was given, and his entrance into WrestleMania IX's "Roman Coliseum" should be on any self-respecting fan's 'Top WrestleMania Entrances' list. Wearing his own "Macho" version of a Roman toga, Savage was carried to the ring on a cushioned sedan, hoisted by four gladiators. If that wasn't enough, Savage was also accompanied by a group of 'Vestal Virgins', each feeding him grapes and throwing rose petals in his path. Like a boss. Throughout the night, Savage delivered some great lines on commentary and even got one of the loudest pops of the night when he finally lost his temper with Bobby Heenan and stood up to knock him out. Even when dumped behind a commentary table, The Macho Man proved he could still steal the show any time he wanted. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uBM6VVlCeYw

8. WrestleMania II: Savage Vs. George "The Animal" Steele

Savage's WrestleMania debut came during the New York portion of WrestleMania 2 against George "The Animal" Steele. While not one of Savage's most memorable outings, mostly due to the limitations of his opponent, Savage was able to deliver a highly entertaining grudge match, all built around the premise that The Animal had fallen in love with Miss Elizabeth and was trying to steal her away from the abusive Macho Man. During the match, The Animal became the first person to kick out of Savage's iconic Flying Elbow finisher, but it wasn't long before Savage rolled up the green-tongued Steele to successfully defend his Intercontinental Championship and get his first WrestleMania win. It wouldn't be the last time The Animal and The Macho Man would collide on the 'Mania stage, however. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sj6EIPu1trQ

7. WrestleMania X: Savage Vs. Crush (Falls Count Anywhere)

From Savage's first WrestleMania appearance, we move to what turned out to be his final one. Randy's last major feud in WWE began in late 1993 when his best friend Crush betrayed him and allied with Mr Fuji, setting up an intense dispute that would culminate in a rare "Falls Count Anywhere" match in Madison Square Garden at WrestleMania X. At a time when street fights and backstage brawls were less commonplace in WWE, it was pretty exciting to see the two wrestlers fighting in the locker room, throwing each other into doors and using whatever they fancied as a weapon. When it was time to go home, Savage memorably struggled for what felt like an eternity to tie Crush upside down in a pulley (even using his teeth at one point to help tie the knot) for a dramatic finish, before all his hard work untied a few seconds later and Crush slumped to the floor. Despite the botched spot (or botched knot), Crush was unable to answer the 60 second count, and The Macho Man celebrated in front of the adoring crowd as his iconic Pomp and Circumstance theme blasted throughout MSG. Who could've predicted that would be the very last time we'd see Randy Savage in a WrestleMania ring? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f858fgw4au0

6. WrestleMania VI: Savage & Sherri Sensational Sherri Vs. Dusty Rhodes & Sapphire (Mixed Tag Match)

While not on par with his previous more serious outings (which we'll get to later), WrestleMania's first intergender tag match was still highly enjoyable, mostly for the curiosity factor of seeing Sherri and Sapphire lock horns for the first time, while Jesse Ventura ripped Sapphire to shreds on commentary. And let's face it, any time you get the The Madness and The Dream in the same ring, you know you're going to be entertained. This was also the first time we saw the new "Macho King" at a WrestleMania, complete with his crown and scepter and with Sensational "Queen" Sherri by his side. All four participants worked hard, the match building to a climax in which Miss Elizabeth returned as a secret weapon in the corner of Rhodes and Sapphire, helping Sapphire to secure the win for her team. The babyface trio danced to the strains of "The Common Man Boogie" while the defeated and humiliated Savage retreated to the locker room. Definitely not Savage's finest WrestleMania outing, but once again, he did the best with what he was given.

5. WrestleMania V: Savage Vs. Hulk Hogan (WWF Championship)

Beginning with WrestleMania IV in 1988, WWE would host two back to back WrestleManias in the same venue: Trump Plaza in Atlantic City. It made for a unique contrast, watching Randy Savage leave the arena in 1988 to joyous applause as the newly crowned WWE World Champion, only to enter the same building one year later for WrestleMania V to thundering boos. Walking out in front of the WrestleMania V live audience, Randy Savage was well and truly at the pinnacle of his heel run in the WWE, morphing himself from a heroic babyface and tag team partner of Hulk Hogan into a vicious heel who'd been consumed by a paranoid rage over Hogan's friendship with Miss Elizabeth. The match was a decent enough back-and-forth encounter, fairly typical of the Hogan matches of the 80's, and like all of The Hulkster's villainous opponents in the 1980s, it was Savage's duty to take the three punches, the big boot and the leg drop before succumbing to the 1-2-3. To some degree, the loss was damaging to Savage as a main event heel, as he would never again be a serious contender for the WWF Championship until his babyface turn several years later. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PrlSz-Xxo50

4. WrestleMania IV: Savage Wins the WWE Championship (Tournament)

The closing moments of WrestleMania IV featured Randy Savage in all his glory. After winning four gruelling matches in the WWE Championship tournament, Savage ended the night with the lovely Miss Elizabeth on one shoulder, and a brand new WWE belt draped over the other. Along the way, Savage bested Greg Valentine, Butch Reed and One Man Gang, before heading into the finals against "The Million Dollar Man" Ted DiBiase. The tournament finale was filled with dramatic moments, with a fresh DiBiase being well rested after receiving a bye earlier in the night. The match saw interference from Andre the Giant, Savage missing his elbow drop, and Hulk Hogan eventually saving his friend from "The Million Dollar Dream" with a well placed chair to DiBiase's back. While we all would've preferred Savage to score a clean and decisive win without Hogan's interference (Boy, was The Hulkster good at keeping the spotlight on himself!), there's no denying that this night was one of Savage's most glorious WrestleMania moments. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jaUsMv0xmgA

3. WrestleMania VIII: Savage Vs. Ric Flair (WWF Championship)

"She was mine before she was yours, baby!". Randy had the incredible gift of making all of his feuds feel personal and heated. This was never more evident than in the Spring of 1992, when Ric Flair produced photographic evidence of an apparent affair between himself and Elizabeth before she married Savage. With the added humiliation of Flair and his Executive Consultant, Mr Perfect, threatening to reveal a naked centerfold of Liz to the live WrestleMania VIII crowd, Savage entered the Hoosier Dome that night out for blood. The arduous back and forth encounter ended when a gushing Flair tried to lock in his patented Figure Four Leglock, which Savage reversed into a roll up for the three count, securing his second WWE World Championship. The war was not close to ending, however, as the beaten and bloodied Flair took his frustrations out on Miss Elizabeth, demanding to know "What about me?!" and even stealing a kiss from Mrs. Savage. That was all Macho needed to get his second wind and launch himself at Flair, while a dozen officials tried to pry them apart. As far as MachoMania appearances go, this one had it all - blood, drama, intensity, and non-stop action. Be sure to look this one up on the WWE Network. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=meuMhN6WB1U

2. WrestleMania III: Savage Vs. Ricky "The Dragon" Steamboat (WWF Intercontinental Championship)

Yes, I can almost hear your gasp from here - how on earth does THE definitive WrestleMania classic match only come in at #2?!? There isn't much to be said about this match that hasn't already been said. It's a beautiful match, almost flawless, full of twists, turns, close calls and false finishes, with a sneaky heel, an earnest babyface, and Beauty & The Beast on the outside. When Savage goes for that fateful bodyslam and is reversed by Steamboat for a small package victory, the thunderous pop from the 93,000 can still bring goosebumps to your arms. Many years later, Steamboat would recount how weeks before the show, Savage handed him pages upon pages of notes, laying everything out for the match move by move. Clearly, Macho's thorough preparation paid off, because the bout still holds up to this day, as well as inspiring several viewers to eventually become wrestlers themselves (Daniel Bryan and Chris Jericho among them). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2rQn65xG8fs

1. WrestleMania VII: Savage Vs. The Ultimate Warrior (Career-Ending Match)

And here's the reason the Steamboat match only finished in the #2 spot. In this writer's humble opinion, WrestleMania VII is not only the greatest moment in Savage's WrestleMania run, but the greatest moment in his career - period. Savage was never better than he was in the 'Career Ending Match', and this battle with The Ultimate Warrior had more twists, turns and swerves than a Hollywood thriller. At one point during the match, Savage hit Warrior with not one, not two, but FIVE of his flying elbow drops - only for Warrior to still kick out. The look of amazement on Savage's face is just priceless. In turn, Randy would be the one and only opponent to ever kick out of Warrior's Gorilla Press/Big Splash combo, which caused his face painted opponent to almost abandon the match - and his career - in disbelief. After an intense back and forth war, the end finally came when an exhausted Warrior planted a foot on the chest of the fallen Macho King for the three count. Enraged at "losing her meal ticket", Sensational Sherri immediately betrayed Savage and literally kicked him while he was down. The post-match beating continued until none other than Miss Elizabeth leapt from her seat in the audience and ran to Savage's rescue, tossing Sherri from the ring and opening her arms to the newly unemployed Macho King. Savage accepted her, and the two embraced in a romantic reunion that brought the fans in attendance to legitimate tears. As Bobby Heenan summed up on commentary; "When he entered this ring, there were over twenty thousand people standing on their feet booing him. Now he lost the match, his career's over, he's got Elizabeth by his side, and twenty thousand people are cheering him". A true master of his craft, WrestleMania VII was Randy "Macho Man" Savage at his absolute best. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lu5Zi2HuBww How would you rank Savage's WrestleMania performances? Do you disagree with my decision to give the #1 spot to the Career Ending Match over the iconic Steamboat classic? Post in the comments below and let's discuss!

Contributor
Contributor

It ain't easy! Former Manager of Ultimate Warrior's "WarriorWeb", Former Senior Editor of Vince Russo's "Pyro and Ballyhoo", and wrestling fan for over twenty five years. Daniel's favourite wrestling memory is being in Wembley Stadium with his Grandad for SummerSlam '92.