Ranking All 16 WWE WrestleMania Celebrity Matches

The stars come out when the lights are bright, but who shined brightest?

Johnny Knoxville WrestleMania celebrity matches ranked
WWE

Whenever you talk about memorable WrestleMania moments, it’s impossible to ignore situations involving stars from outside the wrestling world: Cyndi Lauper seconding Wendi Richter at WrestleMania I, Mike Tyson serving as the special enforcer at WrestleMania 14, or Pete Rose getting abused by Kane at three consecutive Manias: 14, 15 and 2000.

WWE’s obsession with celebrity involvement in their product dates back decades, before the first WrestleMania, but it has persisted, particularly at the Showcase of the Immortals, when the lights are brightest and at a time when the company is most trying to generate mainstream attention on the product

But some celebrities do more than just perform, manage, or serve as guest ring announcer or timekeeper. Some have stepped between the ropes and locked up with the superstars – to mixed results. Rating a celebrity match can be a difficult prospect: Applying the typical star rating system is wholly unfair, but it’s also incomplete to judge them on the star power they bring to the show.

With more than a dozen celebrity matches throughout WrestleMania’s history, it’s worth digging through the vault, reliving some of these bouts and seeing how they stack up against each other. Some have stood up to the test of time, while others have aged incredibly poorly. And then there are a few that shine far above the rest.

Let’s get to it…

14. Honorable Mention: Battle Royals

WrestleMania Colin Jost
WWE.com

Throughout the years, one of the easiest ways for WWE to involve celebrities in low-stakes matches has been to include them in battle royals. It’s tough to individually count or rank these, as they typically involve a lot of punching and kicking, and eventually being deposited over the top rope.

WrestleMania II featured the first such battle royal, a unique mix of wrestlers and NFL players during the Chicago portion of the three-city event. The big draw was future WWE Hall-of-Famer William “The Refrigerator” Perry, fresh off winning a Super Bowl with the Chicago Bears. He would be tossed by Big John Studd, but the Fridge got his revenge by pulling Studd out moments later.

The Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royals that took place at WrestleMania 30 through 35 were good spots to stick non-wrestlers, making the contests more of a spectacle than an athletic competition. Shaquille O’Neal entered the Andre at WrestleMania 32 and faced off with Big Show, while Rob Gronkowski memorably hopped the barricade (and nearly got stopped by security) to interfere during the Mania 33 Andre. (Gronk's appearance doesn't count, as he wasn't technically part of the battle royal.)

The gag hit its low point in 2019 when Saturday Night Live Weekend Update hosts Colin Jost and Michael Che entered the battle royal after taunting Braun Strowman in the lead-up to WrestleMania 35. The pair were the final two eliminated by Braun in the last Andre to take place during Mania itself.


13. WrestleMania 39: Snoop Dogg Versus The Miz

Snoop Dogg The Miz
WWE.com

Woof.

Perhaps it’s unfair to harshly judge Snoop Dogg, who was on hosting duties during WrestleMania 39 when he was thrust into the role of emergency wrestler.

Continuing a theme from the first night, when Pat McAfee emerged to challenge and defeat co-host The Miz, Shane McMahon came out that Sunday to fight his former tag partner and rival. This gave fans the instantly meme-worthy Michael Cole call of “Shane’s still got it!” just seconds before Shane-O-Mac blew out his knee/leg on a leapfrog.

With everything falling apart, Snoop stepped in as a mid-match substitute for McMahon, dropping Miz and putting him away with possibly the worst-looking People’s Elbow in history. Mercifully, it was over.

Snoop deserves a ton of credit for stepping up and competing while in a tracksuit. But this was bad, almost embarrassingly reality-breaking bad.


12. WrestleMania 27: Snooki, Trish Stratus, & John Morrison Versus Michele McCool, Layla, & Dolph Ziggler

Trish Stratus John Morrison Snooki
WWE.com

Not every attempt at celebrity synergy connects with fans. Sometimes, WWE trying to cash in on a person’s fame backfires or falls completely flat.

Witness Jersey Shore’s Snooki at WrestleMania 27, where the reality show star teamed with Trish Stratus and John Morrison to battle Michele McCool, Layla and Dolph Ziggler. The match was set up when Snooki was guest host of an episode of Raw and verbally sparred with Vickie Guerrero, who set up the intergender six-person tag.

Sadly, this wasn’t even perversely entertaining, as Snooki’s one athletic contribution, a handspring back “elbow,” was pedestrian at best.

No one came out a winner here, with McCool taking the pinfall off a comically bad Snooki splash, Trish making her WrestleMania return after a five-year hiatus, and Morrison mouthing off afterward and spiraling downward until he left the company seven months later.


11. WrestleMania 21: Akebono Versus Big Show

Big Show Akebono Sumo Match WrestleMania 21
WWE.com

You’re forgiven if you read that and said, “Who?” at the screen.

Continuing the theme of celebrity involvement being a spectacle more than a competition, former sumo champ Akebono battled Big Show in a sumo match… inside a ropeless wrestling ring. The two went through the pre-match rituals, salted the ring and locked up… for an action-packed 63 seconds until Akebono threw Show out of both rings. The pre-match shenanigans and “psych-out” antics before they made contact lasted longer than the physical part of the match itself.

Thankfully, WWE did not try to play this for laughs with Big Show wearing traditional sumo garb. One has to wonder if Vince McMahon was tranquilized or if Akebono has it stipulated in his contract that the company couldn’t make a mockery of his sport if he competed.

Akebono did go on to a lengthy wrestling career in Japan, winning titles in ZERO1 and All Japan Pro Wrestling.


10. WrestleMania 15: Butterbean Versus Bart Gunn

Butterbean WrestleMania
WWE

Nowadays, celebrity matches at WrestleMania are seen as important fixtures that are entrusted to reliable hands who can deliver the best possible product on the night.

That certainly wasn’t the case at WrestleMania 15, when Bart Gunn fought knockout artist Butterbean in what can best be described as a punishment match – an ironic term considering it was a major PPV match.

In 1998, Bart Gunn shocked the world (and especially expected winner “Dr. Death” Steve Williams) by winning the Brawl for All tournament. The shoot toughman competition was a disaster for WWE and killed Dr. Death’s aura. Gunn was rewarded by being taken off TV and brought back to fight Butterbean, who proceeded to knock Bart out in less than a minute.

That would be Gunn’s last televised match in WWE for nearly nine years, returning only for a 15th anniversary battle royal in late 2007.


9. WrestleMania 28: Kelly Kelly & Maria Menounos Versus Beth Phoenix & Eve Torres

maria menounos kelly kelly
WWE.com

Celebrities outshining wrestlers in a match are uncommon, but they do happen from time to time.

Witness the aesthetically pleasing but technically deficient tag team of Kelly Kelly and Maria Menounos, who challenged Beth Phoenix and Eve Torres at WrestleMania 28. Kelly never has been regarded as much more than as someone who tried her best but was not put in a position to succeed convincingly in the ring.

Menounos managed to sell convincingly and not look completely out of place, with Eve and Beth holding things together nicely. No one was going to mistake the face team for the Jumping Bomb Angels, but they got through the match relatively well.


8. WrestleMania II: Mr. T Versus ‘Rowdy’ Roddy Piper

Roddy Piper Mr. T WrestleMania 2
WWE.com

A fixed boxing match? Perish the thought.

One year removed from being part of one of the most important wrestling matches in industry history (more on that later), Mr. T and “Rowdy” Roddy Piper hooked up in a boxing match at WrestleMania II.

The three-round bout tried to maintain a semblance of legitimacy until the final round, when they threw wild, almost comical haymakers at each other until Piper lost his cool and slammed Mr. T for the disqualification.

Still, this contest wasn’t about looking like a super-authentic boxing match. Mr. T. still was one of the biggest celebrities in the country at the time, and Piper was still playing the perfect villain. Their match was a nice callback to the first WrestleMania while adding a little spectacle to an otherwise dull event.


7. WrestleMania 24: Floyd ‘Money’ Mayweather Versus Big Show

Big Show Mayweather III
WWE.com

Logan Paul is not the first celebrity WWE has completely misread and tried to shoehorn into playing a babyface when they ooze heel charisma.

Floyd “Money” Mayweather screams “heel” with his bravado, antics and excess. That didn’t stop WWE from enlisting him as a hero saving Rey Mysterio from a retuning Big Show. The feud featured the diminutive Mayweather and his entourage being disrespectful, with Money legit breaking Show’s nose on Raw in the build to their WrestleMania 24 match.

At Mania, Mayweather was every bit the cocky heel, drinking from his pimp chalice and relying on his entourage – and a steel chair and brass knuckles – to even the odds and finally put down Show. The match wasn’t actually that bad, but Mayweather was horribly miscast, and it’s debatable what juice WWE got out of that match.

Big Show at least got some mileage out of using a KO punch as a finisher in the wake of this debacle.


6. WrestleMania 11: Lawrence Taylor Versus Bam Bam Bigelow

Lawrence Taylor
WWE Network

In terms of no-frills singles celebrity matches at WrestleMania, former NFL great Lawrence Taylor challenging Bam Bam Bigelow has to top the list.

This was a one-on-one matchup without any real gimmicks or crutches to help it (boxing, outside interference). And Taylor held his own in an entertaining match, ultimately defeating the Beast from the East in the main event of WrestleMania 11.

The match did not set the wrestling world on fire or lead to a major revitalization of WWE in the mid-90s, but it did provide a bit of a distraction from the steroid trial a year earlier and give the company a bit of positive, mainstream press.

LT would not be seen in a WWE ring again, but fans still have to give credit to the footballer and Bam Bam for taking on such a high-pressure situation and delivering results.


5. WrestleMania 37: Bad Bunny And Damian Priest Versus The Miz And John Morrison

Bad Bunny John Morrison Destroyer
WWE

When mega-superstar recording artist Bad Bunny joined the WWE family during the Pandemic Era, many figured any in-ring involvement would be severely limited, as there was no way he would jeopardize his actual career over a stint in wrestling.

And sure enough, his brief run as 24/7 Champion was exactly what you’d expect, with buddy Damian Priest assisting him in holding onto the title. But then along came The Miz and John Morrison.

Their tag match at WrestleMania 37 defied all expectations and furthered a new standard for celebrity wrestling matches (began at WrestleMania 34 with Ronda Rousey), with Bunny clearly being well-trained to take bumps and deliver some eye-popping offense, including the often-reposted Canadian Destroyer on the floor. (To be fair, Morrison probably did most of the work delivering the move to himself, taking Bunny along for the ride.)

WEW would use this match as a template for future celebrity bouts, and Bunny would make a handful of additional appearances, including his outstanding singles match against Priest at Backlash in Puerto Rico last year.


4. WrestleMania 38: Logan Paul And The Miz Versus Rey and Dominik Mysterio

Logan Paul Rey Mysterio
WWE.com

Following the example of Bad Bunny the year before, Logan Paul made his in-ring bow at WrestleMania 38 and very quickly would exceed anyone’s wildest expectations.

Of course, today Paul is preparing to head into his third consecutive WrestleMania, this time as the reigning United States Champion, but two years ago, he was little more than a social media star mixing it up alongside The Miz against Rey and Dominik Mysterio. Logan showed flashes of the greatness we’d see during the next year-plus, and it wouldn’t come as much of a surprise later on that he would sign a contract with WWE as a wrestler rather than just being a celebrity curiosity.

This match also was notable for Miz turning on Paul after the duo won in an attempt to make Logan a babyface going forward. That wouldn’t last for too long, as it became clear that he was made to play a heel.


3. WrestleMania 38: Johnny Knoxville Versus Sami Zayn

Sami Zayn Johnny Knoxville WWE WrestleMania 38
WWE.com

If Lawrence Taylor versus Bam Bam Bigelow is the best no-frills singles celebrity match in WrestleMania history, this is simply the best singles bout of its kind.

The build to Johnny Knoxville taking on Sami Zayn in an Anything Goes Match at WrestleMania 38 was not everyone’s cup of tea, with Knoxville’s brand of comedy sometimes skewing a bit too silly even for pro wrestling. On the night, however, Knoxville and Zayn delivered one of the most highly entertaining plunder spectacles ever witnessed.

The duo used props to great effect, with the Jackass star needing every trick in the book – a bowling ball, an air horn, a giant mousetrap, and Wee Man – to overcome Sami and finally put him down for the count. Even admitted skeptics came out of the match howling with delight, happy to be proven wrong on the night.

What makes this even better is that the humiliation of that night drove Zayn to seek out the Bloodline, which kicked off an improbable storyline that culminated in the main event of WrestleMania 39 night one.


2. WrestleMania 34: Ronda Rousey and Kurt Angle Versus Triple H and Stephanie McMahon

Ronda Rousey WrestleMania 34
WWE.com

There probably should be an asterisk next to this match, if only because Ronda Rousey had already signed a contract prior to the match. In essence, she was not a celebrity wrestling at WrestleMania 34, but a full-time superstar.

Still, Rousey was a novice when she teamed up with Kurt Angle to take on the ultimate WWE power couple of Triple H and Stephanie McMahon. The four had one of the best – albeit heavily scripted and rehearsed – celebrity matches ever, with tension built throughout the match, leading to Rousey finally exploding on Triple H and ultimately destroying McMahon and tapping her out with an armbar.

The match really stands as a testament to everyone playing their parts perfectly when you consider how broken-down Angle was, that Triple H was a pure part-timer, and that Stephanie had only wrestled twice since 2003. Still, the drama was off the charts, and it kicked off one of the greatest rookie years in WWE history, with Rousey winning the Raw Women’s Championship just four months later.


1. WrestleMania I: Mr. T And Hulk Hogan Versus ‘Rowdy’ Roddy Piper and Paul Orndorff

Hulk Hogan, Mr. T
WWE.com

As a wrestling match, Mr. T and Hulk Hogan taking on “Rowdy” Roddy Piper and Paul Orndorff was not the best in-ring contest. The action was pedestrian, with Mr. T doing a serviceable job keeping up with the three wrestlers.

But in terms of historical significance, this tag team match’s impact can’t be understated. WWE gambled it all on the first WrestleMania, sold in large part on Mr. T’s celebrity – he was one of the biggest stars of the mid-80s – and the spectacle of the event. The mainstream attention the event garnered helped push WWE into the stratosphere and turning WrestleMania into an annual show that continues to grow in prominence today.

And it really all started here, with Mr. T teaming with Hogan.

As a postscript, look at the aftermath of this match. Hogan went on to become an even bigger star. Orndorff turned face, which eventually set up his heel turn against Hogan and a run of sellout shows. Piper and Mr. T would reignite their feud later for the aforementioned WrestleMania II boxing match.

That’s why you have to give the top spot to this celebrity match, and it will be difficult to see how something knocks it off its pedestal.


 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.