Ranking All 2015 WWE PPVs From Worst To Best

The bottom of the barrel to the cream of the crop.

To say the year 2015 has been a roller coaster ride for WWE would be an understatement. While there have been plenty of bright spots - the enthusiasm for the WWE Network and increase in subscriptions, NXT's surge in popularity, a increase in profits over the previous year - there have been an abundance of lows. This year has seen an unusual amount of pay-per-view events that failed to build hype and anticipation, and in the cases of the ones that did, many of those fell short of delivering. Too many rematches and controversial booking decisions led to what may go down as one of the worst years for WWE from a strictly creative standpoint. Now that every PPV is in the books, let's go back and take a look at the year's shows and determine which ones were great and which ones were...not so great. No, that's being too kind. Some of them were downright appalling.

12. Survivor Series (November 22nd)

Best Match: Roman Reigns vs. Alberto Del Rio Worst Match: Charlotte vs. Paige There isn€™t much left to say about Survivor Series that I haven€™t already said here. It was a dreadful show that did almost nothing right, which is extra depressing considering how fun the Survivor Series matches themselves used to be. Once considered one of WWE€™s €œBig Four€, the event has been surpassed by about half a dozen other shows on the calendar. Survivor Series was so universally panned for its dismal combination of dull matches and boneheaded booking that I€™d honestly prefer to pretend it never happened rather than grant it an entry on this list. The fact that WWE followed it up with the impressive TLC is hopefully a sign that they heard the negative feedback they were being showered with. Reusing the finish from SummerSlam 2013 €“ one that everyone hated when it originally happened so it wasn€™t going to get better with age €“ with a champion people liked even less than the one they awarded it to at that event was just one in a night full of mishaps. The Roman Reigns/Dean Ambrose match should have been something the company built to and presented it as a main event clash, instead it was a rushed bout on the undercard of a horrible show. Everything else on the card was either completely forgettable or actually offensive with how terrible it was.

11. Fastlane (February 22nd)

Best Match: Roman Reigns vs. Daniel Bryan Worst Match: Goldust vs. Stardust Earlier this year I wrote that Fastlane would be hard to top as the worst show of the year before imploring WWE not to take that as a challenge. As those of us who sat through the waterboarding-disguised-as-wrestling known as Survivor Series, we know that challenge was accepted and conquered. That doesn't mean that Fastlane was all that much better. The problems with this show were many; Roman Reigns picking up an obvious win over Daniel Bryan that angered the crowd, and since they knew it was coming they were dead for the entire night. The match itself may have been the best of Roman's solo career up until that point, but it didn't matter because everyone hated everything. Another big issue was the amount of screwy finishes, This card suffered from TWO rollups, a DQ and a ball shot. It was like all the most unimaginative tropes were on full display. Add to that the worst of the three Cena/Rusev bouts, a Dust Brothers clash that was an abomination and Kane and Big Show ruining everything and you can see why Fastlane sits in its rightful place near the bottom of the toilet bowl.

10. Extreme Rules (April 26th)

Best Match: Roman Reigns vs. The Big Show Worst Match: Nikki Bella vs. Naomi The PPV that is based entirely on hardcore match stipulations, it's been derisively referred to as Extreme Rematches for the fact that each year the card is filled with return bouts from WrestleMania. This year wasn't quite as bad with only two of the bouts being exact remaches. When The Big Show is involved in the best match on the card that tells you all you need to know about the quality of a show. While it wasn't as atrocious of a show as Fastlane or Survivor Series, absolutely nothing memorable took place here and other than the aforementioned Last Man Standing match with Roman Reigns and to a much lesser extent the main event cage match featuring Seth Rollins defending the title against Randy Orton, there was nothing worth going back and watching here. Dean Ambrose and Luke Harper had a decent street fight, Dolph Ziggler and Sheamus fought for what felt like the 3756 time this year in anothe rinspiring clash and the divas match may have been the worst title defense of Nikki Bella's entire reign. This was a show far removed from the standout Extreme Rules editions from years past such as the 2011 and 2012 versions. No, this was as pedestrian as it gets.

9. Payback (May 17th)

Best Match: Seth Rollins vs. Dean Ambrose vs. Roman Reigns vs. Randy Orton Worst Match: Naomi & Tamina vs. The Bella Twins Fresh off the heels of the disappointing Extreme Rules comes another massive letdown in Payback. Only the third event of its name, the show once again featured a group of rematches that were well past their expiration date. The John Cena/Rusev feud had been dragging on for four months at that point and the two men had nothing left to give each other, in addition to the audience having already tapped out on their investment. New Day took on Tyson Kidd and Cesaro in yet another technically solid bout that just served to highlight how shallow the tag team division was at the time, and Ziggler and Sheamus once again went to war and had...a match. The Ascension - who had/have no business on PPV - put forth a funereal performance against Curtis Axel and Macho Mandow and the divas match once again stunk up the joint. Naomi seems like a great person but she's the worst worker in the division and it really shows on these pay-per-view cards. The best contest of the night was easily the fatal four-way for the WWE world title, where Seth Rollins managed to retain by pinning Orton thanks to some interference from Kane. Not a bad main event but full of the usual overbooked Authority nonsense that dragged Seth's entire title reign down.

8. Royal Rumble (January 25th)

Best Match: Brock Lesnar vs. Seth Rollins vs. John Cena Worst Match: The Ascension vs. The New Age Outlaws This is a difficult one to grade, mainly because it was an abhorrent 2.5 hours of wrestling mixed in with what is, in my opinion the hands down winner for best match of the year. The Royal Rumble is always the second most anticipated event on the WWE slate, as it's such a fun concept that allows us to see all of our favorites in action and interacting all at once while also providing us with the direction for WrestleMania. But for the second year in a row WWE sh*t the bed when it came to the handling of the 30-man rumble. Much has been written and said about the decision to not only have Roman Reigns win in front of a hostile Philadelphia crowd but to include Daniel Bryan in the match as well. It's not even so much that he was in the bout; it's more so the way he was so nonchalantly and unceremoniously dumped out of the ring by Bray Wyatt like he was some random jobber. An exit worthy of Fandango, not the most popular star in the company. Once that happened the match was all downhill from there. The final two in the ring with Reigns were Kane and The Big Show and he didn't even win via a strong showing but rather he came off looking lucky to have escaped with his hand raised. The inclusion of Diamond Dallas Page and Bubba Dudley was awesome but there were less legends this year, and the action in the rumble was slow and plodding. The rest of the card was made of up run-of-the-mill tag matches that I can't even remember without looking them up, so they must not have mattered much. That main event though, that was something else. The match of the year that was 22 minutes of nonstop action, thrills and breathtaking nearfalls; it really helped put Seth Rollins on the map as a major singles player. Seeing Lesnar interact with someone other than the usual suspects he'd been booked against since his return was fantastic, and Rollins delivered in a huge spot. Cena showed why he's called "Big Match John" carrying his end of the triple threat, and everything about this match, especially the finishing sequence was amazing. Unfortunately it was akin to a beautiful lone flower growing in a field full of cow patties.

7. Night Of Champions (September 20th)

Best Match: Seth Rollins vs. John Cena Worst Match: Charlotte vs. Nikki Bella Night of Champions had a lot of potential and it was booked around being a one man show to display the gifts of Seth Rollins. Wrestling two matches in one night is a feat reserved only for the most talented of workers and Rollins is definitely that. Facing two of the sport's biggest icons - one from the past and the other the here and now - on the same show was a daunting task. Rollins would deliver, turning in two stellar performances against very different opponents. At his advanced age Sting is still capable of putting on a show, but needs someone to help carry him and Seth was game. The match was better than it had any right to be and were it not for the unfortunate neck injury that Sting sustained that likely ended his career it would be remembered even more fondly. Rollins and Cena have excellent chemistry together and this match was no different. There were other good things sprinkled throughout the card. Bray Wyatt and Luke Harper facing Roman Reigns and Dean Ambrose and The New Day vs. The Dudleys were standout bouts, and Kevin Owens began his Intercontinental championship run with a win over Ryback in a surprisingly good contest. Night of Champions falls somewhere in the middle for 2015, a good but not great event that will be remembered mostly for Sting.

6. Battleground (July 19)

Best Match: Seth Rollins vs. Brock Lesnar Worst Match: King Barrett vs. R-Truth This year's Battleground was a significant improvement over the inaugural 2014 edition of the show, which was one of the worst of that year. 2015 gave us three very good matches, including the final chapter in what was easily the best trilogy in WWE. John Cena and Kevin Owens squared off for the final time in the third bout in their classic series, which should have catapulted Owens in the upper echelon of superstars but didn't because his post-Cena booking left a lot to be desired. But he was pure money in this program, and he and John went out and tore the house down every time they worked together. Many people bemoaned the finish of having K.O. submit, but it doesn't detract from what an awesome match this was. Roman Reigns also kicked off the feud with Bray Wyatt that would serve as a bit of a turnaround for the often unfairly maligned Juggernaut. While some viewed Wyatt losing yet another feud as a questionable choice, Roman needed some strong wins to help his failing push. The two had some very good performances and this was opening salvo was an impressive round in the war to come. Seth Rollins and Brock Lesnar closed the show with a main event that looked like it was heading toward being something special before The Oldertaker showed up and kicked Brock in the balls. Still salty from his loss over a year ago, The Deadman interrupted what could have been a classic, and the match having no definitive ending hurts this PPV's ranking.

5. Hell In A Cell (October 25th)

Best Match: Brock Lesnar vs. The Undertaker Worst Match: Charlotte vs. Nikka Bella The Hell in a Cell match is lamented by many fans who feel that the concept is no longer compatible with the more family friendly PG environment of WWE. And while there's something to that criticism, this show proves that it can still work within the strict confines the company operated under. Brock Lesnar locked horns with The Undertaker in what was billed as the final meeting between the two, and although it didn't love up to the standard set by their cell bout from 2002's No Mercy, it wasn't disappointing by any stretch. It was still a stiff and brutal affair that saw blood despite the WWE's "ban" (funny how that ban doesn't apply to Lesnar matches). Elsewhere on the card Bray and Roman turned in another extraordinary performance in a string of of them for both guys, but having two cell matches on one card is a bit much as it detracts from the spectacle of the bout. To be honest, with the exception of the divas match - a running theme for main roster shows unfortunately - there wasn't really a bad contest on the entire card, and that consistency earned the show a favorable ranking.

4. SummerSlam (August 23rd)

Best Match: Brock Lesnar vs. The Undertaker Worst Match: Team PCB vs. Team Bella Putting this show in this spot may be disagreeable for some because SummerSlam 2015 was the recipient of a mixed reaction. Some fans praised the show for the quality of wrestling while others were let down by the frustrating booking and finishes. I obviously fall on the side who thought highly of the show. The main reason for that is the Brock Lesnar/Undertaker battle. After WrestleMania 30 anticipation for a rematch between the two was at an alarming low and everyone expected another lethargic slog of a match that would underwhelm for a SummerSlam main event. Luckily for us, Taker took a dip in the fountain of youth prior to the show and was able to recapture some of that magic he'd been desperately missing in his last two forays into the ring. These two beat the sh*t out of each other and The Phenom took some earth-shattering bumps that had fans legit fearful for his health, which is the mark of emotional investment. In the end the bout was marred by the wonky finish with the confusion over who won and Taker technically avenging his streak-ending loss, but the 21 minutes that preceded that b.s. ending were incredible. Kevin Owens and Cesaro also pulled off a great match that showed the two men are capable of giving us classics with the right time and circumstances, something we'll hopefully see from them in the very near future. Rollins and Cena put on a monumental performance that was probably the best of their series thus far and even the Randy Orton/Sheamus clash managed to be impressive despite both guys being the wrestling personification of "meh." WWE loves their celebrities and Stephen Amell surprised everyone with his showing in the tag team match pitting he and Neville against Stardust and King Barrett. It was arguably one of the three greatest celebrity performance of all-time and was a fun addition to the four hour card. Even the divas match was acceptable, and until WWE takes the reigns off the ladies and lets them loose that's about all we can hope for. SummerSlam wasn't the landmark legendary card it's been known to be in the past, but this year's event was a fun show with some pretty great wrestling.

3. TLC (December 13th)

Best Match: The New Day vs. The Usos vs. The Lucha Dragons Worst Match: Alberto Del Rio vs. Jack Swagger Maybe some of my opinion on this show is colored a bit by the recency of it, but Tables, Ladders and Chairs was a d*mn good show full of solid wrestling and memorable spots and moments, and in 2015 WWE that€™s really all we can ask. In much the same way as the other slate of gimmick match-themed PPVs on the wrestling calendar, WWE took an exciting concept and ran it into the ground from overexposure, but that didn€™t stop this card from being a gem. Let€™s talk about that opening match for a moment. We all know what a high bar The Dudley Boyz, Hardys and Edge & Christian set with the original TLC matches and since those bouts many competitors and have tried €“ and most of them have failed €“ to live up to the standards they set. This wasn€™t one of those occasions. The Usos and New Day went out and did exactly what the€™ve been doing for most of their tenure which is bust their tails to have a great match, and the Lucha Dragons responded in kind with what will hopefully be a star-making performance. And Kalisto€™s Salida Del Sol off the ladder and onto another one will be a staple of highlight reels forever. The rest of the matches on the card were all average to very good, but other than the opener the real star of the show was the closing segment. Roman Reigns finally snapping and unleashing a torrent of rage on Sheamus and Triple H was great viewing and hopefully a missing ingredient in getting the fans to accept him. TLC was a satisfying show with some awesome bookends that puts it near the top of this list.

2. Money In The Bank (June 14th)

Best Match: John Cena vs. Kevin Owens Worst Match: Big Show vs. Ryback When the Money in the Bank concept was first introduced over a decade ago at WrestleMania it was a fresh, exciting gimmick match that reinvigorated a rapidly staling traditional ladder match. The competitors wowed us with inane spots that we€™d never seen before and the bout became a yearly staple of WWE. But like all things, the Money in the Bank match was susceptible to overkill and that€™s exactly what€™s happened the last few years. As a standalone bout to enhance a show it€™s brilliant, but loading up an entire PPV with them is not a great idea. That being said, this year€™s Money in the Bank was one of the better shows WWE produced in 2015. The trilogy of John Cena/Kevin Owens bouts was the standout here, as it was on any card the two were booked against each other. The two have excellent chemistry together and all of their contests have been classics. The main event of Seth Rollins and Dean Ambrose facing off in a ladder match was yet another installment in their epic feud, with this match doing a lot to legitimize both men as top stars. The Money in the Bank ladder match for the briefcase was very good; not great, but loses points for giving us Sheamus with the briefcase which gave birth to Sheamus the champion, and no one wanted to see that. All in all, this was a very good show with some low points (Big Show/Ryback, R-Truth/Barrett in their best of 364 series) that fared well crtically.

1. WrestleMania 31 (March 29th)

Best Match: Roman Reigns vs. Brock Lesnar Worst Match: AJ Lee & Paige vs. The Bella Twins Chalk it up to the overwhelming spectacle of the event, but there€™d be something wrong if WrestleMania didn€™t top this list every year. The Superbowl of wrestling absolutely should be the event that is not only the most anticipated but also the one that delivers on the largest scale, and this year WWE succeeded in making that happen. While the hype and expectations were fairly low going in, the 31st edition of the sports entertainment extravaganza managed to surprise us all. Anchored by a main event that was far better than it had any right to be, the show put Brock Lesnar and Roman Reigns in the ring together and let them legitimately beat the hell out of each other for our enjoyment. The match did a lot to rehabilitate Reigns €“ though they squandered it again soon after €“ and was easily a match of the year candidate. But unlike many PPVs on this list, Mania was not a one match show. The Intercontinental championship ladder match was excellent as well, with Daniel Bryan triumphing over six other men in a brutal affair featuring some unique and genuinely hard to watch spots. Randy Orton and Seth Rollins also turned in a very good match, culminating with one of the most stunning finishes we€™ve seen this year when Orton hut the RKO while Seth was in mid-curb stomp. In year full of unspectacular middle-of-the-road shows that were easily missable, WrestleMania 31 stood out as the must-see event of the year Do you agree with these rankings? If not, give yours in the comments.

Contributor
Contributor

Brad Hamilton is a writer, musician and marketer/social media manager from Atlanta, Georgia. He's an undefeated freestyle rap battle champion, spends too little time being productive and defines himself as the literary version of Brock Lesnar.