Ranking Every 2018 WWE PPV From Worst To Best

A great year for WWE PPVs, but how do they compare to each other?

WWE Crown Jewel EVolution Ranked
WWE

While WWE have spent the past few weeks actively acknowledging Raw's awfulness, the company's 2018 pay-per-views fared significantly better than their ailing TV product.

This was a strong year for PPVs. A couple of duds aside, they regularly delivered awesome action, particularly in the final quarter, during which all but one controversial exception hit the mark. Were any of these events perfect? No, but you're never going to get tens from such a scatterbrained creative department, though these events did produce countless incredible highs destined to be replayed on highlight packages forever.

We'll look back on this year of pay-per-views with fondness (because net quality levels were generally high) and frustration (no matter how much you enjoyed yourselves on Sundays, WWE regularly found ways to screw it up on Monday). Such is the life of a modern WWE consumer. All we can do is hope Vince McMahon's 'shake up' promise was sincere, and that 2019's incredible PPVs aren't immediately sullied.

These 15 shows were ranked solely on their subjective quality, with no consideration for any other factors. Thus, your own rankings may vary greatly. Tell us all about it in the comments section below.

Let's get to it...

15. Crown Jewel

Hulk Hogan Crown Jewel
WWE.com

... as if you expected anything else in this spot.

Crown Jewel earns this dubious honour not because of any moral outrage, but because it genuinely stands as one of the most disastrous wrestling pay-per-views of all time. This thing was a shambles. A mess. A comedy of errors. A farce so grand, it frequently veered into 'so-bad-it's-accidentally-hilarious' territory after getting through the drudgery of the World Cup's opening bouts, none of which yielded anything greater than mediocrity.

Hulk Hogan was ushered back into the company before the only audience in the world guaranteed to cheer him. Thus commenced a night of batsh*t moments crammed with tedium, with even AJ Styles and Samoa Joe delivering a tame house show version of their previous encounters. Dolph Ziggler vs. Seth Rollins was okay, but the rest of the bouts? Nah.

Best Moment: Shawn Michaels looking significantly less terrible than Triple H, Kane, and The Undertaker in the comedic main event. His participation did his legacy no favours, but he held the bout together at times. Kane's wig falling off was incredible too.

Worst Moment: Take your pick from Hulk Hogan, Brock Lesnar squashing Braun Strowman, Shane McMahon crowning himself 'Best In The World,' and every part of the main event that didn't involve Michaels.


14. Backlash

WWE Backlash 2018 Nakamura AJ Styles
WWE.com

A turgid night of action delivered only one good match, as Backlash 2018 peaked with its very first clash, then spent the rest of the night dolloping grey, tasteless slop on the plates of a crowd whipped into a ravenous frenzy by Miz vs. Rollins.

The crowd were quickly killed. A sloppy Nia Jax performance vs. Alexa Bliss, a tedious Jeff Hardy vs. Randy Orton encounter, and the ridiculousness of Daniel Bryan facing Big Cass in his first major singles feud since returning did the job. From there, we got an awful SmackDown Women's Title bout in which Carmella spent most of her time screeching in Charlotte Flair's ear, before AJ Styles and Shinsuke Nakamura fell short of expectations once more, shattering any hope they'd ever have a 'dream match.'

Backlash wasn't a disaster, but nothing on it mattered. Nothing. It was 2018's least essential pay-per-view.

Best Moment: The Miz and Seth Rollins kicking things off with an electric Intercontinental Title clash. It still stands among either man's best of 2018, and nobody could follow them.

Worst Moment: Roman Reigns vs. Samoa Joe. A terrible main event, and a strong argument for anyone citing Roman's in-ring inconsistencies and Joe's declining athleticism.


13. Extreme Rules

WWE Extreme Rules 2018 Roman Reigns Bobby Lashley
WWE.com

A similar pay-per-view to Backlash in that almost everything that took place within its three-and-a-half-hour runtime felt inconsequential, Extreme Rules signalled the start of WWE's annual summer slump.

This PPV highlighted some of the absolute worst feuds of the year. The B-Team vs. Deleters Of Worlds, Finn Balor vs. Baron Corbin, Carmella vs. Asuka, and Kevin Owens vs. Braun Strowman comprised a horrendous opening run (with Shinsuke Nakamura's six-second Jeff Hardy squash thrown in there too). After that came the night's most Sports Entertainment-y moment, as Daniel Bryan single-handled fought The Bludgeon Brothers prior to injured partner Kane's dramatic rival. Their reunion was a fun, nostalgic moment, but the match? You've already forgotten about it.

Props to Bobby Lashley and Roman Reigns for delivering a surprisingly entertaining battle of the bruisers, but Extreme Rules was milquetoast.

Best Moment: Rusev shines in his WWE Championship match with AJ Styles, helping 'The Phenomenal One' to one of the best defences of his lengthy reign.

Worst Moment: Carmella slaughtering Asuka's aura in just over five minutes, or the bloated Seth Rollins vs. Seth Rollins Iron Man main event.


12. Super Show-Down

Shawn Michaels Undertaker Super Show-Down
WWE

Super Show-Down wasn't a bad pay-per-view by any stretch. Narrative-wise, it was the year's most pointless show, but it was boatloads of fun in stretches. Glorified house shows often are. This one gave the bumper Melbourne crowd an enjoyable day out at the rasslin', and while Triple H vs. The Undertaker was a complete mess of a bout, that the live audience lapped it up so vociferously shows it worked for anyone not consuming Super Show-Down on the Network.

Only a handful of wrestlers worked at full speed, but that didn't stop several mid-show matches hitting all the right notes, though the good-but-not-great Shield vs. Dogs of War clash fell short of expectations.

Best Moment: With apologies to AJ Styles and Samoa Joe, who worked a heated No DQ clash, Buddy Murphy capturing the Cruiserweight Championship after a riveting match on home soil was one of 2018's most heartwarming wrestling moments.

Worst Moment: Triple H vs. The Undertaker. A dud. The worst match of 2018. A blemish on both men's legacies. Conclusive proof that neither of these fossils should be anywhere near a wrestling ring together in 2018. A botch-laden disaster. An exercise in vanity and self-fellatio. This pile of sh*t was all these things and more.


11. Elimination Chamber

Elimination Chamber 2018 Braun Strowman Roman Reigns
wwe.com

Unfairly maligned for its problematic main event finish, Elimination Chamber 2018 was a solid wrestling pay-per-view highlighted by its two titular bouts.

The first-ever women's Chamber brought plenty of excitement, as Sasha Banks and Bayley came within a hair of snapping on each completely, though 'The Boss'' apparent heel turn was nought but a red herring. As for the men? They delivered an impressive spectacle. Braun Strowman single-handedly destroying every other participant en route to a final showdown with Roman Reigns was compelling viewing... until the bookers decided to derail the whole damn thing.

Elimination Chamber was marred by a mediocre midsection. Titus Worldwide weren't credible challengers for The Bar's Raw Tag Team Titles, Asuka couldn't drag acceptability from Nia Jax, and Matt Hardy vs. Bray Wyatt was a plodder. Still, this was far from the year's worst PPV.

Best Moment: Alexa Bliss' stunning post-match promo, in which she feigned a big, emotional, 'thank you for your support' speech, before wiping her crocodile tears away and spitting hot venom at the audience.

Worst Moment: Roman Reigns handily defeats Strowman, deflating his monstrous rampage in the process.


10. Greatest Royal Rumble

Braun Strowman Greatest Royal Rumble
WWE.com

The first of WWE's big Saudi Arabian shows was fine on a creative level. While the oodles of pro-government propaganda videos were as cynical as they were transparent, it largely delivered to the expected level as a large-scale house show played out before a colossal audience.

The sheer absurdity of a 50-man Royal Rumble provided much of the intrigue. It was a weird, weird affair. NXT no-names Babatunde and Dan Matha appeared out of nowhere. WWE brought in Japanese sumo Hirooki Sumi because their benefactors demanded the long-deceased Yokozuna, and he was the closest they could find. Daniel Bryan let Roderick Strong chop his chest to ground beef. F*cking Hornswoggle showed up. Braun Strowman won a giant green belt that hasn't been seen on TV since. The list of oddities goes on.

Best Moment: John Cena and Triple H take us back to the '80s with a minimalist display of everything pro-wrestling used to be. 'The Game' drew monster heat with a sneer, for crying out loud. That's crowd control.

Worst Moment: The Brock Lesnar vs. Roman Reigns cage match yields a f*ck finish in one of the year's most eyeroll-worthy 'the feud must continue!' moments.


9. Fastlane

AJ Styles Fastlane 2018
WWE

It's always nice when one of WWE's apparent B-level pay-per-view defies expectations with a breezy night of action, which is exactly what Fastlane did back in March. Not a great event, but a solid one that exceeded its minimal buzz despite a handful of oddball booking decision.

Shinsuke Nakamura was always going to overcome Rusev in the opening bout, but they worked a solid back-and-forth encounter with a hot closing stretch, and the audience were all the way into it. Two solid veteran hands in Randy Orton and Bobby Roode worked their usual bout, though they could've done with trimming its 20-minute runtime. The Usos and New Day were en route to an excellent bout before The Bludgeon Brothers ruined it. Elsewhere, the two women's bouts were Very Okay, but the main event knocked it out of the park.

Best Moment: AJ Styles defends his WWE Championship in a nutty six-pack challenge with Kevin Owens, Sami Zayn, John Cena, Dolph Ziggler, and Baron Corbin, who crafted one of the year's best clusterf*cks.

Worst Moment: An overbooked closing stretch featuring interference from Liv Morgan, Sarah Logan, Becky Lynch, and Naomi mars Ruby Riott's first big PPV singles bout versus Charlotte.


8. Money In The Bank

Asuka James Ellsworth Money in the Bank
WWE

Money In The Bank often holds a quality advantage over other B-tier WWE pay-per-views because its two titular ladder matches almost guarantee excitement. They aren't always great, particularly in this safety-first era, but they rarely fall short of expectations, and 2018 was no different.

Though Braun Strowman and Alexa Bliss proved controversial victors for very different reasons, the preceding action was on point, with Kevin Owens taking a particularly insane bump during the men's main event. Elsewhere on the show was the miraculous sight of Ronda Rousey somehow dragging excellence from Nia Jax, the best Shinsuke Nakamura vs. AJ Styles clash to date, a surprisingly fun Seth Rollins vs. Elias Intercontinental Title scrap, and the unfortunate death of Asuka.

Best Moment: Both ladder matches delivered, but the women get the nod for what felt like a make-good after James Ellsworth's interference the previous year. Speaking of people with no chins...

Worst Moment: WWE deciding to eviscerate Asuka's threat level by making her look a big, dumb idiot in falling for Ellsworth's distraction versus Carmella. She has since embarked on the road to recovery, but this was a dark night for 'The Empress Of Tomorrow.'


7. WrestleMania 34

Brock Lesnar WrestleMania 34
WWE

All art is subjective, so throwing 'your mileage may vary' down as a qualifier is often pointless, but it rings true for WrestleMania 34. Some hated it, some loved it. We sit somewhere in the middle.

This year's 'Show Of Shows' delivered plenty of riveting moments, from the electric Seth Rollins vs. Finn Balor vs. The Miz Triple Threat, to Ronda Rousey's participation in the greatest debut match in WWE history. Your writer was even fond of the derided Roman Reigns vs. Brock Lesnar main event. Still, trim 'Mania 34 of its fat, throw all the good-to-great matches together, and you're left with a strong card.

But there were problems. Boy, were there problems.

Even Asuka vs. Charlotte Flair (a minor classic in the Women's Revolution's vast pantheon) proved troublesome, as 'The Empress' had her undefeated streak needlessly swiped away. A bloody 10-year-old became Raw Tag Team Champion. SmackDown's talented tag teams were given just five minutes. The Undertaker vs. John Cena turned into a hilarious three-minute squash.

Regardless, we reckon 'Mania's bright spots were just enough to overcome the downers.

Best Moment: Daniel Bryan's cathartic ring entrance. Welcome back, sir.

Worst Moment: Nicholas.


6. SummerSlam

Becky Lynch Charlotte Summerslam 2018
WWE.com

Like most of the pay-per-views on our list, SummerSlam had its issues, with Bella oversaturation marring Ronda Rousey's Raw Women's Title win and Roman Reigns somehow emerging from a six-minute win over Brock Lesnar looking like a straight-up b*tch. That the show weighed in at about 15 hours long didn't help, either.

But when SummerSlam was good, it was really good. We'll get to its biggest talking point in a moment, but the first few hours were crammed with great action, as Charlotte Flair shoehorned her way into Becky Lynch's Women's Title shot, the returning Dean Ambrose joined Seth Rollins in his war with Dolph Ziggler, and Daniel Bryan and The Miz finally did battle in a suitable spotlight.

It was also the night 'The Man' was born. That alone ensured SummerSlam finished as a net positive.

Best Moment: Becky Lynch snaps on Charlotte Flair, kickstarting the awesome antihero run that immediately turned her into WWE's most compelling personality, most organic star, and most must-see performer.

Worst Moment: Roman Reigns' grand coronation was about Brock Lesnar screwing up by getting distracted by Braun Strowman, not 'The Big Dog's' long-expected triumph.


5. Tables, Ladders & Chairs

Ronda Rousey Asuka
WWE

With TLC, we hit the point in our rankings where WWE's 2018 pay-per-views become awesome. This was a great, great wrestling show, with several stunning highs overcoming lows like Seth Rollins vs. Dean Ambrose with ease.

The evening's two biggest bouts will be what TLC 2018 is remembered for. Understandably so, as Daniel Bryan vs. AJ Styles was a first-class showcase of what happens when you place two of the best in the world in the same ring with minimal instructions, and Asuka vs. Becky Lynch vs. Charlotte Flair saw WWE's women once again steal the show with an awesome stunt-filled showcase. With the right layout, Finn Balor vs. Drew McIntyre and Ambrose vs. Rollins may have hit this level too, but alas.

Ronda Rousey repeated her Money In The Bank miracle with another compelling Nia Jax clash, and while Natalya vs. Ruby Riott was bad, it was just as hilarious. Dead Jim Neidhart on a table, for f*cks sake.

Best Moment: Take your pick between Daniel Bryan vs. AJ Styles and the women's TLC Triple Threat. Both were outstanding.

Worst Moment: Ambrose and Rollins give in to their own vanity with 2018's most disappointing match.


4. Hell In A Cell

Randy Orton Jeff Hardy Hell in a Cell
WWE

Hell In A Cell 2018 was en route to becoming a classic WWE pay-per-view after its first four matches, as AJ Styles vs. Samoa Joe concluded the hottest opening run this company has produced all year. Unfortunately, the ensuing Miz & Maryse vs. Daniel Bryan & Brie Bella pantomime and a Ronda Rousey/Alexa Bliss match that saw 'The Baddest Woman On The Planet' selling for entirely too long slowed it down, but it was an awesome show regardless.

That image of Randy Orton twisting a screwdriver around Jeff Hardy's earhole shall remain imprinted on our memories forever, as will Becky Lynch taking Charlotte Flair's SmackDown Women's Title. What magnificent bastards.

Best Moment: Rarely do modern Hell In A Cell matches summon the stipulation's old violence, but Jeff Hardy vs. Randy Orton did. Bitter, brutal, and grisly, it was pure torture porn. Dolph Ziggler & Drew McIntyre vs. Dean Ambrose & Seth Rollins was a major highlight as well.

Worst Moment: The sole blot on an otherwise excellent card, Roman Reigns and Braun Strowman was so bad it had us wondering how their awesome 2017 feud could possibly have come from the same performers.


3. Evolution

Ronda Rousey Roster Evolution
WWE

Evolution will go down as a landmark WWE show.

Lynch vs. Flair, Shirai vs. Storm, and Baszler vs. Sane were exemplary. Rousey vs. Bella was loads better than it had any right to be. Even the opener, featuring Trish Stratus and Lita, hit the mark, with its nostalgic vibes creating an awesome arena atmosphere that was sustained for the rest of the evening. Indeed, WWE's first ever all-women pay-per-view was a triumph.

Cynics would've laughed at the mere suggestion of a show like Evolution a year ago. Now, these performers have proved they can do it on their own. Their's is the most exciting scene in American wrestling, and while Evolution wasn't perfect, it was a joyous celebration of the division's past, present, and future.

From a quality standpoint, this wasn't a contender for number one, but still strong enough to break WWE's top three.

Best Moment: Charlotte Flair and Becky Lynch's Last Woman Standing match. The greatest women's bout in WWE history? Possibly, but it was at least the best since Bayley vs. Sasha Banks in Brooklyn.

Worst Moment: Alicia Fox mistiming her pin break-up in the opener was criminal, and hung the referee out to dry. Other than that... errr, booking divisional vanguards Bayley and Sasha in a six-person tag?


2. Survivor Series

Brock Lesnar Daniel Bryan Survivor Series 2018
WWE

Choosing between Survivor Series and our number one may as well have been a coin flip, but the November show's more pronounced lows ultimately see it pipped into the silver medal slot. A man literally pissed himself for a distraction finish, for Christ's sake.

Quibbles aside, this banger PPV soared to great heights after Drake Maverick's great shame. Buddy Murphy and Mustafa Ali drew audible '205' chants for their blistering Cruiserweight Title encounter. The men's elimination match was an effective stage for Braun Strowman's dominance. Ronda Rousey vs. Charlotte Flair was as realistic a portrayal of violence as you'll ever see from WWE, and the main event was an instant modern classic, as 'The New Daniel Bryan' helped inspire Brock Lesnar to create the kind of spectacle he can still deliver when the mood takes him.

Call it 'recency bias' if you want, but your writer has Survivor Series 2018 down as one of the best shows in the event's long history.

Best Moment: Both of the last two matches were spectacular, but the main event reminded us that Daniel Bryan is still one of the greatest wrestlers of all time, despite all he's been through.

Worst Moment: Pisssssssssssss.


1. Royal Rumble

Asuka Shinsuke Nakamura Royal Rumble WrestleMAnia
WWE

The Royal Rumble's reputation usually lives or dies on the titular bout's quality. This year, for the first time, we got two of them. Both delivered on completely different levels.

The men's bout was a masterpiece of road-agenting. So well laid-out was this clash that it deserves to be mentioned among 2001 and 1992 as one of the best Rumbles ever, with the closing stretch particularly compelling. Good guys Rey Mysterio, Shinsuke Nakamura, and Finn Balor faced off against a trio of apparent boogeymen in John Cena, Roman Reigns, and Randy Orton. It boiled down to Nakamura vs. Reigns, and after a riveting back-and-forth sequence, Shinsuke's triumph over the company-sponsored golden boy was beautiful.

While the women's wasn't half as smooth, it didn't need to be. This was all about old mixing with new; nostalgia tangling with potential. Though it looked to the past, its primary function was to celebrate all that's great about women's wrestling now, and in Asuka, it delivered another crowd-pleasing victor.

As for the non-Rumble matches? Fine, though some let Jason Jordan's avoidant tactics in his and Seth Rollins' clash with The Bar work them into a shoot.

Best Moment: Asuka and Shinsuke Nakamura winning their respective Rumbles. WWE botched the follow-up, but both felt like fan service.

Worst Moment: Kane fighting for a top WWE title in 2018.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.