Ranking Every AEW Surprise Debut From Worst To Best
Ranking each and every AEW surprise debut, from Jon Moxley, to Sting, to FTR... to poor, poor Miro.
It's now over two years since AEW held its first formal press conference to announce the creation of this fan favourite promotion - and what a two years it's been!
Amongst the brilliant matches and nuanced storytelling, one of the great things that AEW has had going for it is it's propensity to serve up a good ol' surprise at just the right time. In terms of shocking appearances and debuts, AEW has amassed quite the impressive collection in its relatively short lifespan. And here, the spotlight is on said surprise arrivals.
There have been some great, surprising AEW bows that aren't featured on this list, with certain caveats preventing them from being as shocking as they could've been. For example, Eric Bischoff serving as moderator between Chris Jericho and Orange Cassidy was revealed by online spoilers, while the debut of someone like Lance Archer or Eddie Kingston was announced ahead of time.
Similarly, while Paul Wight becoming All Elite caught us all off-guard, the fact that the company had a press release to announce this news means it's off the table. And while Tony Khan and Tony Schiavone turning up in paid ad space on IMPACT Wrestling was brilliant, that likewise doesn't quite fit the bill here.
With that in mind, then, here are all of the genuine surprises served up by AEW to date - all ranked from utter worst to absolute best!
14. The Dark Order
The Dark Order of today is night and day when compared to the group we saw in the first few months after the faction made its AEW debut.
These days, the Dark Order is a massively enjoyable part of the AEW product. Mr. Brodie Lee being the group's Exalted One was clearly a major part of changing the perception of the stable, yet even then it was a rough month or so once Brodie joined - with the Vince McMahon-esque skits not quite hitting the mark.
Back to the beginning, though, and the Dark Order debut was a total stinker.
Being the Elite had already teased the arrival of the Super Smash Bros., yet debuting this tandem as part of a mysterious faction called the Dark Order was met with, well, crickets. After Chuck Taylor and Trent had picked up a W over Angelico and Jack Evans at the first Double or Nothing PPV, the tease of a hug between the two teams was interrupted by a blackout.
From there, Evil Uno, Stu Grayson and a bunch of nameless, shirtless nobodies arrived on the scene - and the silence was deafening!
13. The Butcher, The Blade & The Bunny
When this particular trio debuted by laying out Cody Rhodes on the 27 November 2019 episode of AEW Dynamite, Jim Ross rightly questioned who they were and what their intentions were.
For Excalibur, he swiftly replied with, "We've got the Butcher, the Blade and the Bunny" - as if we were all being dumb by not knowing who the f**k the three were.
The AEW fan base is one viewed as a relatively 'smart' one, yet the arena that night fell eerily quiet as not even the most knowledgeable of fans had any idea who the Butcher and the Blade were, while some recognised Allie as being behind the Bunny persona.
All three of the Butcher, the Blade and the Bunny are talented performers, and Butcher and Blade in particular have an absolutely phenomenal look to them. The thing is, this surprise debut felt nothing it not absolutely flat.
It would soon be revealed that MJF had orchestrated this attack of the American Nightmare, but those first few weeks and months were a rough ride for Butcher and Blade, and the Bunny was quietly returned to being simply Allie.
12. Miro
For years, fans had been clamouring for Rusev to be given an opportunity to stake his claim as a true main event player.
Great in-ring, brilliant at being loveable or detestable, forever able to connect with an audience, a bullish, brutish look and with a unique charisma to him, the Bulgarian Brute had so many things going for him. And if WWE weren't going to give Ru-Ru the ball to run with, the arrival of AEW on the pro wrestling map had fans hopeful that the three-time WWE United States Champion would become All Elite and have his talent utilised.
While Miro turning up on the 9 September 2020 edition of AEW Dynamite was a huge surprise, the even bigger surprise was the role in which he was immediately positioned.
Inserted into an AEW World Championship feud with Jon Moxley? A powerhouse villain opposite a natural babyface like 'Hangman' Page? The unrelenting, unstoppable Nikita Koloff to oppose Cody Rhodes' Magnum T.A.? The solid, talented base for a Rey Fenix to work around? Nah mate, you're going to be a beefed-up Angry Video Game Nerd who's Kip Sabian's best man.
It's still relatively early days for Miro's AEW career, of course, yet his debut and the six months that's followed so far have been brutal. The talent to be a true top tier talent is there, but being positioned as a raging gamer tied to a low level heel is a horrific misuse of Miro.
11. Matt Hardy
The wrestling industry as a whole - much like the rest of the world - has been hugely impacted by the ongoing global pandemic. And when it comes to AEW, few wrestlers have been hit quite as hard as Matt Hardy when it comes to being impacted by the lay of the land right now.
Hardy made his AEW debut at the close of the 18 March 2020 Dynamite - the same episode which saw Mr. Brodie Lee revealed as the Dark Order's Exalted One - yet it was a debut that didn't quite click.
Part of the reason for the Broken One's AEW bow falling flat was clearly down to the empty arena, with the appearance of Vanguard 1 and Matt guaranteed to have gone down better in front of a live crowd. But away from that unavoidable issue, the whole way that the debut was handled just felt entirely hokey and majorly out of step with the sort of content AEW had served up until that point in time.
Throughout the promotion's lifespan, Tony Khan had reiterated that AEW was to be a more wrestling-driven product that wouldn't rely on the cheesy 'entertainment' shenanigans seen by other companies. But as soon as Matt Hardy began teleporting through Daily's Place, it gave off the stench of one of Vince McMahon's "this is such good sh*t, pal" segments that wrestling fans had long become disillusioned with.
While having Matt Hardy and his mind for the business in AEW was great to see, his shock debut sadly flopped.
10. Awesome Kong
The AEW career of Awesome Kong has up and down, to say the least. But when Kong made her surprise debut for the promotion at 2019's inaugural Double or Nothing, it was a major shocker that was seen as a brilliant signing for the AEW women's division.
That shock debut saw the two-time TNA Knockouts Champion become a fourth wheel in what was billed as a triple threat between Dr. Britt Baker, Nyla Rose and Kylie Rae. With AEW having promised to put a significant emphasis on its female talent, Kong was viewed as a step in the right direction for the women's division of the burgeoning promotion.
An alliance with Brandi Rhodes would follow for Kong, and the bully heel would go around collecting hair from opponents as part of what would become Brandi's Nightmare Collective.
The whole hair thing felt a tad odd, and having Brandi serve as a heel in these segments but later be featured as a babyface alongside Cody on the same shows did this act no favours. Throw in the addition of Mel and Dr. Luther, and it's no surprise that the Nightmare Collective was quietly removed from AEW TV.
Awesome Kong hasn't wrestled a match since January 2020, so it remains to be seen what lies ahead for the dominant performer.
9. Jake Hager
It's been a strange old run in AEW for Jake Hager.
The legit tough All-American grappler was one of the first major surprises that AEW pulled from its sleeve, and he even went on a six-month undefeated streak upon debuting with the company. Yet here we are, over a year on from Hager's AEW bow, and he feels every inch the afterthought he was in WWE.
Said AEW bow came at the close of the inaugural episode of AEW Dynamite, with the former Jack Swagger turning up to lay out the Young Bucks and Cody and Dustin Rhodes alongside what would soon become known as the Inner Circle.
Sure, it was certainly eye-catching to see this one-time WWE World Heavyweight Champion appear on AEW television. But while there was an initial pop to this debut, there was still that nagging feeling that, well, this is Jack Swagger.
During his WWE tenure, Hager was warmed up to be perceived as a big deal at certain points in time, yet he never truly felt like a genuine major player regardless of what the company did with him. As ever, was this simply a case of WWE not knowing how best to use a talent, and would a change of environment bring that 'it factor' to the fore'?
From what's been seen so far, Jake Hager seems destined to just be the imposing goon who menacingly looks on while others chat sh*t. Despite that, though, his actual surprise AEW arrival itself was certainly a notable moment in the promotion's history.
8. Brian Cage
Admittedly, the whole "Who can stop the path of Cage?" line was a tad too on the nose, but having Brian Cage come out as the surprise final entrant in Double or Nothing 2020's Casino Ladder Match was a welcome sight.
It had actually already been announced that past January that the Machine had formally signed with All Elite Wrestling, but the 'when' of Cage's AEW bow was completely unknown. Skip ahead to 23 May, and the former IMPACT World Champion made his presence felt in a major way.
Not just did Cage turn up as a shock entrant in the Casino Ladder offering - pulling apart a ladder upon making his way to the ring - but he decimated plentiful fools on his way to winning that bout and earning a shot at Jon Moxley's AEW World Championship.
The hulking star would ultimately come up short in his quest to dethrone Mox, but his surprise debut and the weeks that followed set Brian Cage up as being a big deal in AEW - and the handling and presentation of him so far means he's one of those wrestlers who can easily be heated up for the AEW World Title picture as and when needed.
7. Ricky Starks
At the time, it may not have been a major deal for a good portion of fans watching the 17 June 2020 edition of AEW Dynamite, but for those in the know, the surprise appearance of Ricky Starks in All Elite Wrestling was all kinds of grin-inducing.
When Billy Corgan's relaunching of the National Wrestling Alliance served up the weekly Powerrr YouTube show, those that checked out this one-hour studio-set offering were instantly won over by the unique charisma of the relatively unknown Starks.
Having departed the NWA once the promotion was forced to go on a pandemic-created hiatus, Absolute was viewed by some as being the hottest free agent in the game. Despite the question of just where this former NWA World Television Champion would land, it still came as a huge surprise to see the Stroke Daddy answer Cody Rhodes' TNT Title open challenge.
Showcased pre-match in a vignette where Starks came off as a ridiculously endearing babyface, Ricky couldn't quite get the job done against Cody on that June night. But while his kayfabe in-ring work came up short, Ricky Starks' performance here was so impressive that Tony Khan reportedly offered him an AEW contract as soon as he got backstage.
Since then, Starks has cemented himself as a pivotal part of AEW programming as a member of the nefarious Team Taz faction.
6. The Good Brothers
AEW started 2021 with a bang. Well, technically, a smash. A two-night New Year's Smash, to be precise.
For the first of these nights, the main event had Kenny Omega successfully defending the AEW World Championship against Rey Fenix. Not content with simply getting the 1-2-3, Omega, at the behest of Don Callis, was intent on ending Fenix's career. That was, of course, until Jon Moxley came out for the barbwire bat-assisted save.
In terms of shockers, though, Mox's attack on the Best Bout Machine was cut short thanks to the surprise arrival of Karl Anderson and Luke Gallows, aka the Good Brothers.
Having IMPACT Wrestling stars appear on AEW programming itself was a major deal, let alone the reigning AEW Tag Team Champions (complete with their belts!). Even more goosebumps-inducing than that, New Year's Smash Night 1 would go off the air with Kenny, Machine Gun, Big LG and the Young Bucks all posing in a familiar Too Sweet way.
To those who love their wrestling to have a sprinkling of New Japan Pro Wrestling and Bullet Club, this was the stuff of pants-tightening dreams.
5. Brodie Lee
As mentioned elsewhere, one of the biggest early misfires of All Elite Wrestling was the Dark Order.
In the past year or so, this faction has clearly been a far more enjoyable, entertaining part of AEW programming - and one of the major factors in steering the Dark Order in the right direction was the reveal of Mr. Brodie Lee as the Exalted One.
The existence of a higher power pulling the strings behind the Dark Order had been teased for months before the big reveal came on the 18 March 2020 episode of AEW Dynamite. And that reveal, of course, saw Brodie pull down the hood to show himself as the head of the Dark Order table.
Immediately, this shock reveal gave the Dark Order not only a shot in the arm, it also brought a newfound sense of legitimacy to the oft-mocked group. Lee was a powerhouse with a reputation as one of the best big men in the business, and so many fans were crying out for the former Luke Harper to be given an opportunity and platform to show what he could do away from the shackles of Vince McMahon.
The wrestling world tragically lost Jon Huber far, far too soon, but his AEW debut, and his impact on the Dark Order and the wider All Elite product will long be remembered.
4. FTR
It wasn't necessarily a shock that the former Revival ended up in AEW, but when and how they debuted was quite the surprise.
That shocker took place on the 27 May 2020 Dynamite offering, with the newly-dubbed Dax Harwood and Cash Wheeler coming to the rescue of the Young Bucks following a Butcher and Blade beatdown. Harwood and Wheeler - collectively now known as FTR - would arrive in AEW as babyfaces, although that Dynamite debut left fans with plenty of questions pertaining to FTR and Matt and Nick Jackson.
Seeing FTR turn up on the scene in a pick-up truck and swiftly head to the ring with an all-business, sh*t-kicking demeanour was brilliant. And best of all, it was at that precise moment that fans finally knew that they'd at some point be getting to see the Bucks and FTR square off.
Stirring the pot amongst the Elite, FTR would soon turn heel by turning on the iconic Rock 'n' Roll Express babyface tandem, and they'd follow that up by dethroning Kenny Omega and 'Hangman' Adam Page to become AEW Tag Team Champions.
For the first two months of their AEW tenure, Harwood and Wheeler were actually performing without formal contracts. That was quickly rectified, with the pair signing multi-year deals in July '20, and that means that AEW has one of - if not the - greatest tag team on the planet tied down to All Elite for the foreseeable future.
3. KENTA
The most recent 'surprise' to be featured on this list, the shocking arrival of KENTA in AEW was the stuff of dreams for certain wrestling fans.
When a masked figure entered the ring to attack Jon Moxley at the conclusion of last month's Beach Break special, AEW fans lost their minds when this figure unmasked to reveal KENTA; a KENTA who promptly dropped Mox with his patented Go 2 Sleep.
In terms of a hot ending, this was AEW putting on an example of how to perfectly take your weekly episodic TV show off the air - with so many questions that needed answering, and an instant need for next Wednesday's Dynamite to get here quicksmart.
Was this KENTA acting on his own to take out the IWGP United States Champion? Was KENTA working with Kenny Omega? Had, as Excalibur pondered, the break in the Bullet Club been fixed?
That buzz as a wrestling show goes off the air, that's what wrestling fans live for. And with KENTA's shocking, explosive AEW arrival, those fans were given wrestling gold.
2. Sting
One could make a genuine argument that the arrival of Sting is the most shocking moment in AEW history. While the Stinger becoming All Elite is slightly edged out on his list, the Winter is Coming arrival of this icon of the business is very much in the conversation when it comes to the biggest surprise of the company to date.
Just watching that debut back, if you don't get chills then you really do need to question whether or not this pro wrestling malarkey is for you.
Few people can lay claim to having done quite so much for the business, and in particular one promotion, than Sting. But this is someone who was now in the good graces of WWE, and who absolutely nobody expected to appear somewhere else - let alone in All Elite Wrestling.
As Cody and Dustin Rhodes, Arn Anderson and Darby Allin had been beaten down courtesy of Team Taz, the arena lights went out, a strange tune started to play, it began snowing(!) and we were then greeted with the unfathomable letters of S-T-I-N-G appearing on the tron.
It was nuts in real time, it's nuts to rewatch, and the fact that Sting's debut was arguably the hottest talking point of a Dynamite that saw Don Callis and Kenny Omega screw Jon Moxley out of the AEW World Championship and usher in an IMPACT working relationship... that tells you all you need to know.
1. Jon Moxley
It takes something truly special to edge out Sting's appearance at Winter is Coming, and that something special here is the AEW arrival of Jon Moxley.
Having given his WWE notice the day after the 2019 Royal Rumble, the former Dean Ambrose's time with Vince McMahon's sports entertainment juggernaut was to come to a close once WrestleMania 35 was in the rear-view mirror - and less than two months after that edition of the Showcase of the Immortals, Mox made his shocking AEW bow.
Of course, that first AEW appearance came in the aftermath of the inaugural Double or Nothing's main event. With a victorious Chris Jericho taunting the crowd after toppling Kenny Omega to retain the AEW World Championship, the Death Rider made his way through the crowd to drop Le Champion where he stood.
Debuting babyface laying out the cocksure heel champ? That's pretty standard. What took Moxley's arrival to an entirely different level is in how he and Omega bounced off each other.
Ever the opportunist, Mox looked to hit his Paradigm Shift on the Best Bout Machine - only for Kenny to counter this move, leading to both men brawling throughout the arena, before Moxley memorably nailed the Paradigm Shift on the giant chips set, then threw Omega to his doom.