Rebooking WWE December To Dismember: 7 Ways To Make It Better

The worst WWE-produced PPV ever? It didn't have to be that way, you know...

ECW December to Dismember is bad. Like, really bad. Legendarily bad. Worst of all-time bad. Why was it so bad, you ask? There are a plethora of reasons. First, WWE only announced two matches beforehand (MNM versus The Hardy Boys and the Extreme Elimination Chamber match). The rest of the card featured matches that would barely count as passable on house shows, never mind PPV. Add to that terrible booking decisions, and you have a recipe for one truly awful show. The upshot was that the event drew 90,000 PPV buys worldwide, the lowest buyrate of the pre-Network era. Anyone who paid their hard-earned money for the event must have felt incredibly ripped-off afterwards. Fans weren't the only ones who felt cheated, as Paul Heyman had a huge blow-up with Vince McMahon over the re-writing of the show. McMahon sent Heyman home and pulled him from the creative team. It was the last time Heyman would be seen in WWE for almost six years, until his 2012 return. ECW originals Tommy Dreamer and Stevie Richards were so offended with the show that they asked to be released from their contracts (a request that was denied). Yes, the show was bad. But it didn't have to be. The WWECW roster was chock full of talented guys and gals who wanted the brand to succeed and were determined to put on a good show. Using members of the ECW roster from the time as well as a couple of special guest who were used on the show, this is an attempt to rectify what is arguably the worst WWE-produced PPV ever.

7. Danny Doring & Roadkill Vs. The FBI

It's fair to say that the team of Danny Doring and Roadkill were not in WWE's long-term plans. In fact, the former ECW Tag Team Champions didn't even team with each other, WWE instead choosing to use them as singles wrestlers. Or singles jobbers, if you will, since they were more often than not on the wrong side of a squash match. Both guys were talented and could produce in the ring, however. During the original ECW's last years, their matches were often highlights of TV and PPVs. They had crackers against other lowly teams like Simon Diamond and Johnny Swinger, Nova and Christ Chetti and the FBI. To kick off this re-booted December to Dismember, the FBI (another very talented and underrated team) would issue an open challenge, which would be answered to Doring and Roadkill. It would be a nice surprise for the ECW faithful, who wouldn't have seen this match for a good five or six years. Doring and Roadkill would go over after a competitive 10-minute match, where both teams wouldn't be instructed to 'hold back'. Believe it or not, Bruce Pritchard at one time pitched Roadkill as a potential WrestleMania opponent for The Undertaker. He was an agile big man, but let's not get carried away now.

6. Hardcore Holly Vs. The Sandman - Singapore Cane Match

Hardcore Holly versus The Sandman was scheduled to take place at the PPV, before the card got reshuffled. Holly was added to the Extreme Elimination Chamber match, replacing Sabu (causing the live crowd to chant 'bulls***') whereas Sandman was booked to do a run-in after the positively awful Mike Knox/Kelly Kelly versus Kevin Thorn/Ariel match. If we're doing this show again, this match goes back in, although this time it will be a 'Singapore Cane Match'. Sandman is never good in straight wrestling matches and, since the Singapore cane is his gimmick, it makes sense to book him in a match where he's able to use it. Holly wins in about seven minutes, since he has better long-term prospects in the company. The fans shouldn't be too miffed, if there is suitable violence with the canes.

5. CM Punk Vs. Mike Knox - Special Referee Kelly Kelly

One of the more compelling stories on ECW television over the autumn months in 2006, was the CM Punk/Mike Knox/Kelly Kelly 'love triangle'. Okay, it wasn't like it was quality drama or anything, but it was still better than drek like the Zombie or matches such as Batista versus Big Show. Considering the time invested in the story, it's incredible that Punk and Knox never really got their big blowoff match. December to Dismember, the first WWECW PPV, would be the perfect place to do it. With a couple months of solid build, fans would be interested (they were already way into Punk). As an added bit of intrigue, object of their affections Kelly Kelly would be the special guest referee. Punk would win (since he had an undefeated streak going at the time and clearly had more potential to break out) after Knox was distracted by Kelly's exhibitionist shenanigans. Big burly Mike would attack Punk after the match and march out with Kelly Kelly, to get his heat back.

4. The Hardy Boys Vs. MNM - Cage Match

MNM versus The Hardy Boys kicked off the show and was the best thing on the card by a mile. Still, although it was the best thing on the show, it wasn't a classic or anything. The potential to have a classic was there, mind, but the four combatants would need a little something extra to make their match stand out. For our retooled December to Dismember, the Hardys versus MNM stays, because why not? However, by adding a stipulation (in this case a cage match), it's a little more in keeping with the EXTREME concept. Give them twenty minutes and a lot of leeway in terms of what they're allowed to do and you're pretty much guaranteed at least a ***1/2 match. It doesn't really matter a whole lot who goes over here, but the Hardys go over, as in the original match.

3. Tommy Dreamer Vs. Test - No.1 Contenders Match

Paul Heyman was a huge advocate of the Test push of late 2006/early 07. Test was an absolute monster (and sported a comical physique considering the Wellness Policy was in effect), running through the roster and looking pretty damn dominant. He was clearly being pushed towards the title picture. Another Heyman favourite was Tommy Dreamer, who acted as the boss' right-hand man for a number of years in the original ECW. Tommy was a huge favourite amongst the ECW faithful, due to his never say die attitude and ability to absorb a tremendous amount of punishment. Shredded, violent heel against schlubby folk hero is a concept that works. Pitting Test against Dreamer, in a match that would play out similar to all those old Raven/Dreamer matches, would most likely benefit both men and could actually be quite dramatic, if it was epically booked. The match would be a No.1 contenders match, with the winner facing the ECW Heavyweight Champion at the Royal Rumble (whoever that may be - more on that later). Test would eventually win, after delivering a series of devastating moves to The Innovator of Violence. Dreamer would keep kicking out, until Test finally puts him down and out with something particularly nasty (like a big boot with a chair wrapped around Tommy's head, for example).

2. Balls Mahoney Vs. Elijah Burke

After the drama of Test/Dreamer, there's going to need to be a 'cool down' match before the main event. There are many wrestlers who could fit in this slot, such as Daivari, Stevie Richards and Rene Dupree, but the nod goes to Elijah Burke and Balls Mahoney, here. Why? Well, Mahoney was surprisingly used a lot on the ECW TV show and even took CM Punk's place in the Mike Knox/Kelly Kelly storyline (as well as being host of the cringeworthy extreme strip poker). Elijah Burke was someone WWE had high hopes for, despite apparently being awful to work with (Punk has named him as his least favourite opponent). Burke goes over in about six minutes. Short and inoffensive, and a way to let the crowd catch their breath before the main event.

1. Rob Van Dam Vs. The Big Show Vs. Sabu - ECW World Heavyweight Championship Extreme Rules Elimination Match

And so we come to our main event. The original top-liner was the Extreme Elimination Chamber match, featuring CM Punk, Rob Van Dam, Hardcore Holly, Bobby Lashley and Test. It was, at that point, the worst Chamber match ever. The action was standard and the booking really p***ed off the ECW faithful. The WWE regulars, Show, Lashley, Test and Holly, were booked as the stars, whilst ECW original RVD and the red-hot CM Punk were treated as an afterthought. Despite being an 'extreme' (weapons) Chamber match, the plunder hardly came into play at all. Bobby Lashley's win left a sour taste in the mouth, and many of those in the crowds physically turned their back on him. The December to Dismember main event needs to change. The proposed changed is an RVD/Show/Sabu extreme rules triple threat elimination match for Show's ECW World Heavyweight Championship. Sabu should have been on the show in the first place, but was removed because management weren't a fan of him in the ring (or in the back). This would be a long, almost twenty minute main event that would play off the summer RVD/Show and Sabu/Show series'. Sabu would be the first man eliminated, casting doubt over whether Big Show would walk out and retain the championship. One Van Terminator later, however, and Mr. PPV would have regained the belt he was forced to vacate after only a few short weeks back in July. It would be vindication for Van Dam (who was really behind the ECW relaunch), allows Show to leave for a much-needed vacation and sets up Test/RVD at the Rumble (and perhaps a future series with Sabu, too). Mission: accomplished. So how does this rebooked December to Dismember card sound? What would you do differently? Let us know in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

Student of film. Former professional wrestler. Supporter of Newcastle United. Don't cry for me, I'm already dead...