The Original WWE Nexus 8: Where Are They Now?

You're either Nexus, or...

The Nexus Pub Shot
WWE

Holy hell, was that formation angle something.

On the June 7, 2010 RAW, NXT Season 1 winner Wade Barrett entered the fray, ostensibly to take in the main event between CM Punk and John Cena. The camera then panned to Michael Tarver, in what was a phenomenal choice; the potent visual of his obscured face foreshadowed an act of unsettling criminality. Then, the remaining six contestants assaulted everybody at ringside before circling Cena on the ring apron. What followed was a genuinely disturbing beat-down; Barrett et al. brutalised Cena and helpless ringside officials alike before laying waste to the ring itself. It was pure chaos, so vivid and heightened that Daniel Bryan was fired afterwards for choking the pitiable Justin Roberts with his necktie. The lawless atmosphere had consumed him.

This was an instant rehabilitation the likes of which John Cena would have doffed his garish cap in appreciation of; these eight men were absolute jokes 20 minutes before that segment, and emerged from it a pack of f*cking wolves.

SummerSlam 2010 consumed the remaining seven.

Following the seven-on-seven Nexus Vs. Team WWE headline attraction, prime target John Cena very easily brushed off the faction, as if seven would-be stars were the imaginary dust on his shoulder rubbed off before the five knuckle shuffle. It took him just over a minute to recover from a spot that, logically, should have seen him written off television with a concussion.

Many of his opponents on the night didn't recover at all...

8. David Otunga

David Otunga
WWE.com

One of several members of the Nexus that was never going to make it with the armband removed, denting the "buried" narrative somewhat, David Otunga, with his Hollywood body and Razzies ring work, failed to make it even with the benefit of celebrity osmosis.

In an indictment of WWE's pre-NXT landscape, David Otunga - a slow, uncoordinated, error-prone and utterly indistinct in-ring worker you could barely buy as powerful in spite of his thick physique - reigned with a version of WWE Tag Team gold on two occasions. He partnered with John Cena under duress in the storyline and, you can imagine, reality. He then struck gold alongside fellow 'New' Nexus member Michael McGillicutty as WWE attempted, halfheartedly, to recapture the magic.

Otunga, irredeemable between the ropes, was sensibly transitioned into a primarily offscreen role as the legal advisor to John Laurinaitis. His in-ring stuff relegated to glorified cameos, Otunga quietly became inactive following one last go-round of the live event loop in 2015. Retained by WWE, Otunga in the years since has bounced between commentator and pre-show panelist roles, spouting banalities that nobody ever has ever remembered.

Not to pour too much soil over the poor sod's head, Otunga was good at something: law.

Probably should have stuck to it.


7. Heath Slater

heath slater
WWE.com

Heath Slater, on reflection, managed to have the best WWE career possible (for Heath Slater).

Even in the force of destruction that was the original stable, the fresh-faced Slater stood out, and not in a particularly good way. The guy looked like he was carved to play a comedy jobber role, and play a comedy jobber role he soon did - to at times delightful effect.

There was something very grating about Slater. Maybe it was that dopey voice, and its strange ability to overcome the glottal stop, or that daft face, but Slater simply presented himself as a very stupid man, and when his mouth invariably landed him in trouble, watching somebody forcibly close it was good midcard stuff. His pronunciation of the word 'Why?' ("Wha?") often caused Michael Cole to stifle a p*ss-fit of laughter, for Slater was genuinely, brilliantly obnoxious.

But Slater was never Ellsworth-level detestable. His beaming, ever-optimistic face attracted a degree of sympathy. He was just trying his deluded best out there. There wasn't a malicious bone in his body; just a misapprehension of his own ability level that grew to become endearing.

And so, from the quality RAW 1000 bit to AH GOT KIDS!, Slater became a cherished mainstay of the WWE fabric, even if he exists now in Main Event no man's land.


6. Justin Gabriel

Justin Gabriel
WWE.com

Usually, it's WWE pitching the bird-brained gimmick to the talent, and not the other way 'round - but in the case of Justin Gabriel, the man virtually drafted his own release papers with the 'Darewolf' pitch: a daredevil/werewolf hybrid conceived, you have to think, on a pun-first, gimmick-later basis. Gabriel alleges that Vince McMahon was a fan - it was both naff, and a pun, so of course he was - but Triple H hated the idea.

In a sort of spiteful, be-careful-what-you-wish-for scenario, Gabriel did find himself behind fur, only in the guise of Adam Rose's bunny associate.

It's a shame; with the obvious exception of Daniel Bryan, Gabriel was the most naturally talented of the lot, a slick and at times spectacular talent who wrestled a style that WWE later embraced. The problem is that, post-NXT, the Indy starlets who excelled at that style relegated Gabriel in the hearts of those who once got behind him, at least on some message boards.

Happily, as PJ Black, Gabriel has reinvented himself and found a not inconsiderable level of cult fame in Lucha Underground. Though he initially took the bitter, pandering post-WWE route many travel, by singling Triple H out as the harbinger of doom, he has quietly re-entered relevance with a more humble approach.


5. Michael Tarver

Michael Tarver
WWE.com

A genuine rare nice guy, Michael Tarver, to mirror that niceness, just wasn't particularly well-equipped for the pro wrestling racket. He was a thoroughly nondescript performer.

Tarver was never swept up in the New Nexus/Corre tedium; written off television under the pretext of Wade Barrett deeming him surplus to requirements in a faction of which David Otunga was a member, Tarver was absolutely doomed, groin injury or no. Tarver was later seen hovering in background segments on RAW and SmackDown, like he didn't belong. Following his 2011 release - a suspiciously quick turnaround Tarver suspected John Cena of accelerating - Tarver then entered New Japan Pro Wrestling in 2014, incredibly, where he also didn't belong.

From the critical apex of the game to World 1-1, Tarver has wrestled in 2018 for little-known organisations such as 'Brain Buster Pro Wrestling' and 'VIP Pro Wrestling'.

Fortunately for Tarver, the banter racket of Independent wrestling has located a strange strain of nostalgia. Where the Nexus will likely never reform as a nostalgia act in WWE - really, damningly, there's little nostalgic currency in much beyond the Attitude Era - Tarver, Gabriel and Darren Young leant on their shared history during this year's edition of the CHIKARA King Of Trios tournament.


4. Skip Sheffield

Ryback WWE
WWE.com

Yip yip yip, what happened to Skip Sheffield?

The "cornfed meathead", a weird southern babyface update on Superstar Billy Graham, retired the cowboy hat following a devastating ankle injury suffered a mere three days after his faction had been similarly shattered at SummerSlam '10. If there were ever a good time to suffer a career-threatening injury, that was the time - and Ryback, for a while, had really good timing.

Repackaged as the relentless cyborg character Ryback, and heavily pushed at a time before only the coolest Independent starlets would do, Ryback transcended (justified) Goldberg rip-off accusations with a palpable belief in himself, a limited but potent throwback power game, and an ability to command a reaction from live crowds lost on so many of his peers. He enjoyed an improbably great 2012, but a short-sighted 2013 heel turn cast the difference-maker as just another guy - by which point the shifting landscape had rendered his kind extinct.

Known latterly as something of a dumbass - Ryback as Sheffield once admitted as such ("Am I the smartest guy in the world? Heck no!") - he did something particularly daft upon his release. Burying WWE on the way out, he burned the only bridge that led to relevance. A performer of his ilk was engineered only for WWE. No other promotion with any money behind it suits 'The Big Guy', hence his recent appearances for the unglamorous likes of 'Northeast Wrestling' and 'High Impact Wrestling'.

Ryback, more concerned with shifting supplements these days, can rightly claim to be among the last true draws. He headlined Hell In A Cell 2012, which broke the 200,000 barrier in an otherwise weak year.

He spouts so much b*llocks, however, that delusion, not drawing power, shapes his legacy.


3. Darren Young

Darren Young
WWE.com

Darren Young, and here comes that refrain again, was another unremarkable graduate of WWE's developmental system under the shrugging direction of the inept John Laurinaitis. Absolutely nothing differentiated Young from his Florida Championship Wrestling peers. He wrestled and even moved in exactly the same fashion as everybody else, and upon his banishment from the Nexus on the post-SummerSlam 2010 RAW, he soon found himself back on the same game show he had revolted against.

Paired subsequently with Titus O'Neil to form the Prime Time Players, they achieved (nominal) success by capturing Tag Team gold before the inevitable split. This manifested as an FCW match held on pay-per-view, at Elimination Chamber 2014, following which Young did precisely nothing. In a desperation "Why not?" gesture, the Prime Time Players reformed in 2016, and what's almost impressive is that Young and O'Neil contrived to string together an even more underwhelming singles feud after the fact.

But it was all going to be OK. WWE had plans to Make Darren Young Great Again!

Paired in 2016 with Bob Backlund as his Life Coach, this utterly bizarre Trump-inspired riff saw Backlund b*llock Young for his inability to shop correctly, or something. This invited nothing but When Was Darren Young Ever Great? jibes.

A bang-average performer without whom WWE would not have changed in the least, Young, who following his 2017 release has wrestled for the ironically named Big Time Wrestling, nevertheless deserves massive praise for coming out as gay in a regressive environment.

Statistically, he cannot be alone - but here's hoping that his bravery will one day change something more important than a classic pro wrestling match.


2. Wade Barrett

Wade Barrett
WWE.com

Nexus leader Wade Barrett came to symbolise every last tendril of WWE's modern creative malaise.

Literally buried by John Cena under a deluge of chairs following their TLC 2010 blow-off, Barrett led another faction, one of WWE's most insignificant ever: The Corre.

Following his breakout year, WWE broke him. The company threw a great deal of sh*t in Barrett's direction, none of which stuck. It's difficult to remember what happened when, exactly, so directionless was his run. He became Intercontinental Champion on...several occasions...at various points. Without looking up Barrett's Wiki, his run yields more fiendishly difficult quiz questions than triumphs. When did Barrett win IC gold for the third time? 2012? 2013? 2014? F*ck knows. Just how many entrance themes played him to arenas? F*ck knows. Barrett was a leader, a king, a pugilist, a member of a global set of super villains, a living reset button.

Barrett, ultimately, was subject to a series of half-baked experiments throughout a half-remembered haze of a career. Plagued by injuries, Barrett towards the end of his stint shredded his physique and applied it to several stiff and engaging affairs, but by then, he had been stigmatised as an also-ran.

The man marked as an odds-on future WWE Champion remains best-remembered for his hugely entertaining cackling sh*theel 'Bad News' gimmick, which had real legs - but, and here's that malaise again, it got him too over. Those legs were cut off. It's a go that it doesn't matter who we cheer or boo, etc. etc.

Inactive in the ring since his WWE days - and can you blame him? - Barrett has since lent his booming baritone to authority figure roles in Defiant Wrestling and ITV's World of Sport reboot.


1. Daniel Bryan

Daniel Bryan WrestleMania XXX
WWE.com

Daniel Bryan achieved NXT's stated aim of uncovering WWE's next great Superstar. The problem is that WWE didn't fancy him as its next great Superstar, a narrative that, paradoxically, made him WWE's next great Superstar.

Bryan excelled in the midcard following his return at SummerSlam 2010. The Miz; Dolph Ziggler; even Ted DiBiase, Jr.: Bryan gave all of his peers the best matches of their emerging careers, matches that ranged from pulsating content festivals to emotive, story-driven battles rich in heft. Perceived from that point forward as a great hand, Bryan was selected to put Sheamus, the Great White Hope, over in 2012 as World Heavyweight Champion.

The WrestleMania XXVIII squash gambit failed, spectacularly and legendarily, launching the Yes! movement. Even as a heel, the very likeable Bryan excelled as a domineering abuser character with notes of comedy - he applied an ankle lock to a teddy bear to win AJ Lee's heart - before the enforced babyface turn set him on an improbable march to John Cena's Ace stratosphere.

Fans defied Bryan's B+ Player burial - and it was a burial, because that's precisely how WWE planned to use him at WrestleMania XXX - and, by hijacking shows, forced Vince McMahon to anoint him as The Man in New Orleans.

Forced into retirement in a brutal comedown, Bryan defied impossible odds for a second time, returning to the ring this year. It hasn't quite worked out - WWE has somehow contrived to normalise the the most special, organic narrative that ever landed in its lap - but if there's one thing you don't do in wrestling, beyond take a retirement vow seriously, it is to count Daniel Bryan out.


In this post: 
The Nexus
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!