The Problem With Aleister Black That No One Wants To Talk About

Aleister Black is a phenomenal wrestler, but don't bet on a prolonged SmackDown push...

Aleister Black
WWE

Aleister Black's six-month hiatus from WWE television ended on 23 April, when the former NXT Champion made his first SmackDown appearance since being drafted to the brand in October 2020.

It was a welcome comeback for a wrestler firmly entrenched on WWE's Most Misused list, travelling a similar orbit to Cesaro (pre-Roman Reigns feud) and his old tag team partner, Ricochet. Black and his cult following will be hoping his immediate future plays out more like the former's past couple of months than the latter's last couple of years.

The 35-year-old's first Tales of the Dark Father vignette (filmed by WWE the week prior) received a warm reception. Anything barring a complete disaster would have sufficed, so eager was Black's fanbase to see him return, but words and phrases like "intriguing," "interesting," and "excited to see what happens next" were thrown up as soon as the Dutchman stopped spinning his part-autobiographical, part-metaphorical yarn on funerals, dragons, and "the true rotten nature of men." The candles burning behind Black and ominous violin-led score underpinned a dark vibe befitting his character. Thematically, it worked.

Simultaneously new and familiar, it was precisely what you'd expect from an Aleister Black return promo produced by WWE's gloss factory, birthing naive hope for a prolonged push that probably isn't coming.

Book, glasses, and gothic animation aside, we've been here before.

CONT'd...


Aleister Black
WWE.com

Transferred to SmackDown via one-week Raw stop-off after he and Ricochet failed to win the NXT and SmackDown Tag Team Championships over WrestleMania 35 weekend, Black immediately took to addressing the audience (and the blue brand's roster) from a darkened room.

"But as [with] all good things, give it time and I'm sure that the world that you grew up in will have me condemned," was how the former Tommy End closed his first vignette. Whether it was Black himself or one of the dozens of reality television and soap opera writers on WWE creative, whoever penned this line inadvertently prophecised the next 18 months of Black's career.

Aleister's "pick a fight" phase was excruciating. Sat in his darkened closet, overegging his enunciation and facial expressions to meet WWE's melodramatic edict, he was a head-kicker without a purpose, sporadically working good matches with the likes of Sami Zayn and Cesaro before retreating into another vignette, never moving up the card.

Switching brands in the 2019 Draft, Black was soon asking Raw wrestlers to pick a fight with him instead. Months of ineffective, say-nothing promos disguised as "character development" followed. A lot of words came out of Black's nothing but none drove him forward. The setting and presentation were different but at its core, this was hollow screentime - all the way up to his heel turn and feud with Kevin Owens.

Things are no different in 2021. Black has presence and talks well, but his diatribes on attending funerals as a child, high-school bullying hierarchies, and other edgelord-adjacent subjects come from the same empty pen as before. The window dressing is a little different, but Tales of the Dark Father is Pick A Fight 2.0.

And it'll end the same way too.

CONT'd...


Aleister Black
WWE

Looking at Black's WWE path to date brings little hope of a resurgence.

NXT got Aleister right. Its writers succeeded where those on the main roster failed. This is true of many a Full Sail University graduate, but doubly so for Black.

The Dutchman's dark, brooding energy goes back to his indie days, when he successfully incorporate shadowy, occult-like imagery into an act as imposing for its presentation as Tommy End's hard-hitting style between the ropes. In 2016, this was successfully transplanted into NXT. There, Black proved his mettle as a potential standout in the world's biggest promotion - and it clicked. Aleister spoke little, kicked *ss often, had an industry-best ring entrance, and carried weight. He was a believable NXT Champion by the time he won it and an immensely marketable commodity when he left.

Called up in a panic alongside Ricochet, Johnny Gargano, and Tommaso Ciampa in February 2019, it was immediately clear that those penning Raw and SmackDown had no plans for Black beyond the immediate. Pick A Fight proved this, but in Paul Heyman, Aleister at least had a main roster supporter. Though Vince McMahon will never not have the final say in WWE, Heyman was a glimmer of hope for Black, Andrade, and the former ECW chief"s other reported favourites.

Though the train had come off the rails long beforehand, Paul E.'s June 2020 demotion as Raw Executive Director extinguished that hope.

CONT'd...


Aleister Black Jason Cade
WWE

The thoughtless call-up was step one in Black's unravelling, Pick A Fight step two, and Heyman's relegation step three.

"Thoughtless" is the perfect word for all of this, actually. For 18 months, Black became a guy WWE put on television for the sake of putting on television, with his feuds fleeting and lacking in any kind of rub. He went completely undefeated in singles matches between January 2019 and March 2020, and felled the likes of AJ Styles and Seth Rollins, and none of it had any meaning. None. Not once was the streak mentioned and not once was Aleister made to feel like a rising force.

So why would things be any different now that he has a big book of tales and some sepia animations?

Fundamentally, Aleister Black isn't the kind of guy Vince McMahon likes to push. He is a highly skilled wrestler with great presence when his gimmick isn't being overcooked by hacky reality television writers, owns a unique look, and an aura, but stylistically, none of what he offers would traditionally tick the boss's boxes. The Undertaker is a frequent and cursed comparison with any wrestler who carries a remotely spooky vibe, but Mark Calaway was almost seven feet tall, pal.

McMahon must be considered a barrier to Black's onscreen success because in any of these cases (where a popular, talented wrestler is perceived as being underutilised for a prolonged period by their supporters), that's what he invariably is.

CONT'd...


Vince McMahon
WWE

The Wrestling Observer's Dave Meltzer reported in November 2020 that "the people in charge don't see anything in [Black]." At this point, Aleister was a month-and-a-half into what would eventually become a half-year absence from television, kicking off following his last, definitive loss to Owens that October.

Black's wife, Zelina Vega, left the company during this period. Officially cut loose for "breach of contract" after refusing to adhere to the promotion's crippling new restrictions on third-party revenue streams, she ultimately chose a side hustle that was likely making her more money than her day job. Naturally, Vega's departure led to speculation on her husband's status in the company.

An optimist may have viewed Black's six-month hiatus as an opportunity to refresh himself, reconfigure his character, and recuperate the "minor injuries" he was reportedly dealing with during his downtime. From the same perspective, Tales of the Dark Father could be seen as a sign of WWE finally getting Black right.

History suggests that it won't be. In all likelihood, the former NXT Champion's course hasn't changed. The initial intrigue will wear off, the holding pattern will return, and depressingly - predictably - Aleister Black will be forgotten about by a boss that doesn't understand him.

Again.

CONT'd...


Aleister Black
WWE.com

That SmackDown is typically a good, solid wrestling show that strikes a stronger chord than the last time Black was on it bodes well. While the effusive analysis it receives often ignores glaring holes outwith the main men's singles division, at least the storylines involving Roman Reigns and the Universal Championship are crafted with levels of care and attention not typically associated with is worthy of praise.

To borrow a cliché, this content has Paul Heyman's fingerprints all over it. Now, Black is back on the same brand as Reigns' Special Counsel. Another sign of hope.

Keep it at arm's length. Black jumping the shark by being transformed into a full-on supernatural character with Alexa Bliss-like powers is a likelier outcome in this wacky cartoon world that paints only in the broadest strokes. WWE hasn't done well with gimmicks reliant on dark auras since The Undertaker's body started failing him in the 2010s.

Fundamentally, Aleister Black and WWE's main roster is a marriage that will always end in heartache. Admit that now to avoid disappointment when the Tales of the Dark Father inevitably becomes a clown show. A team that can't help but present its product in the most cartoonish light will never trust its audience with how the character was presented in NXT.

Let's talk about it now before throwing up our arms in another futile protest at WWE's latest push gone wrong.


Watch Next


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.