The Problem With CM Punk That No One Wants To Talk About

Signing CM Punk is a no-brainer for Tony Khan and All Elite Wrestling, BUT...

CM Punk
AEW/WWE

Signing CM Punk and Bryan Danielson should take All Elite Wrestling to the next level.

This is a unique opportunity. AEW will not have the chance to sign two of the most impactful, popular, and iconic wrestlers of the century at once (while they're still young enough to perform) again. Tony Khan must move heaven and earth to do the deals, if they aren't already done, because of the transformational potential.

In Danielson, AEW will acquire a Mount Rushmore calibre storyteller. He's one of the few wrestlers left working today who has a genuine Greatest Of All Time argument based not only on his peaks (which are Himalayan) but also his ability to squeeze a delicious glass of lemonade from even the tiniest, unripened lemons. Everything Bryan does is a must-watch; he can cram more detail into a four-minute match than many can muster in 20. If needed, AEW can use him as perhaps the most talented utility player in wrestling history, shining at the top of the mountain or elevating others down below.

Punk is a different kind of game-changer. It's impossible to tell how he'll perform as he has been out of wrestling since 2014. He's younger than you think at 42 and has had the best part of a decade to heal his ailing WWE body, but until he works a match, whether or not he can still go shall remain unanswered.

Above all else, and as great as he was in his prime, you sign Punk because of the immediate buzz he'll bring to your promotion. Not even Brock Lesnar (who is likely WWE bound anyway) would produce the same insta-boost for this specific crowd - and that's why signing Punk is a no-brainer.

The Chicagoan will immediately make All Elite Wrestling a bigger deal. The same is true of Danielson, but not to this extent.

CONT'd...


CM Punk pipebomb
WWE

CM Punk belongs in AEW.

AEW exists because WWE has spent the majority of its post-Monday Night Wars life creating a toxic relationship with its fanbase, driving off untold millions of frustrated, under-served wrestling fans whose needs and wants were no longer being served on Raw and SmackDown. Tony Khan saw a space in the market for an alternative and assembled his team of executive vice presidents accordingly. Buoyed by New Japan Pro Wrestling's surge amongst foreign viewers, the success of Chris Jericho vs. Kenny Omega I, and the failings on FOX and USA, he sought to create a product that spoke to those alienated by Vince McMahon's.

The problems that drove these viewers away became WWE canon on 27 June 2011, when Punk's pipe bomb rattled wrestling fandom to its core.

Punk's iconic promo ultimately changed more offscreen than on. The issues it so brilliantly skewered linger today. "Douchebag yes-man" John Laurinaitis is still in a position of power, part-time stars from previous eras are still pushed over potential stars from this era, and guys like Punk remain spokes in a billionaire's wheel. The pipe bomb couldn't change the product because the product is incapable of changing.

It was obvious within a few weeks that the flaws laid out in the pipe bomb weren't going away, which crushed the genuine hope it expired. Thus, the fanbase revolted harder and faster, accelerating further throughout the years, until Raw's audience had declined by more than half and demand was deemed big enough to sustain a second major American promotion.

Crediting Punk and Punk alone with the movement that birthed AEW would be reductive. Regardless, there's a throughline between 27 June 2011 and 8 January 2019, when Cody Rhodes, Chris Jericho, The Young Bucks, and more unveiled All Elite Wrestling from the TIAA Bank Field's parking lot.

In a way, Punk will be coming home if he joins AEW - and the business boost he'll bring should be as earth-shattering as the pop he'll receive if he debuts in his literal home, Chicago.

CONT'd...


CM Punk
WWE.com

There is more appetite for a CM Punk return than any other in pro wrestling right now.

Gone since January 2014, when he was unceremoniously dumped by WWE after years of misery in the world's biggest promotion, he has teased and flirted with the sport on many occasions, spurned it for mixed martial arts, and dipped his toe into the water on WWE Backstage, but never pulled the trigger. That time away is part of why this is so hotly anticipated.

Leaving at 35, so close to a wrestler's traditional prime, with so much ground left to cover, is another factor, as is the obvious appeal of theoretical dream encounters with wrestlers he has never crossed paths with before. Imagine Punk vs. Moxley in the ring or Punk vs. Kingston on the microphone. Ultimately, though, it is the devotion Punk inspires in his most loyal fans (many of whom now comprise AEW's audience) that all but guarantees a post-debut boost.

That Punk wasn't a high-drawing WWE Champion shouldn't cause much concern. This is a different fanbase, many of whom will have grown up with Punk as their pro wrestling idol. They have had 10 more years to get angrier, more tried, and more disenfranchised with what goes on in Vinceland. 10 years ago, Punk was a received remedy to McMahonism; in 2021, he will be received as a hero.

For a while, at least, Punk will spike attendances, boost ratings, and ensure AEW dominates the news cycle. Such is the power he wields.

But said power comes at a cost.

CONT'd...


Hangman Page
AEW

Hangman Page's long, winding road to AEW stardom could culminate at All Out 2021, where many feel he will defeat Kenny Omega to finally become AEW World Champion, two years after falling to Chris Jericho in the promotion's inaugural title fight.

This two-year character arc has been meticulously plotted and executed. When it is paid off, it deserves to become a touchstone in the never-ending "long-term storytelling" debate because beat for beat, it has been perfect. Every new development has sought to pull Page further away from the lukewarm crowd response he received at Fight For The Fallen 2019 (when chants of "thank you Jericho!" rang out as the supposed heel beat Page down) and closer to where he is today, from his relatable mental health struggles as an Anxious Millennial Cowboy and crippling fear of failure to the acclaimed World Tag Team Title run ascendance to the top of the singles rankings.

AEW's audience is gagging for Page to beat Omega. They're more than ready for it, and the time is fast approaching. When it happens, Tony Khan will likely have succeeded where Vince McMahon has been failing for over a decade. He will have created a new star.

But what if, as is often the case in Stamford, that new star has his shine taken by an older one?

CONT'd...


CM PUNK
WWE

CM Punk signing and debuting for AEW is impossibly huge. It will inevitably overshadow everything else going on in wrestling on the night and beyond. No matter how over AEW's other wrestlers, storylines, and feuds may be, there's no way any of them can realistically compete with this level of buzz.

If Cult of Personality hits in Chicago on 5 September, people won't be talking about the culmination of Hangman Page's character arc coming out of All Out. Two years will have been for nought. Page will be an afterthought - a secondary news story buried beneath the real headline-maker.

What we know of Punk and his wrestling philosophy suggests he'd be aghast at such a thought. Inadvertently becoming the thing he once raged against would at least partly undermine the reason he is so beloved in the first place. Thus, he and AEW must work together to mitigate this.

How do you stop a Punk debut from obscuring a Hangman Page World Title win? It's a tough question, the kind that separates the good bookers from the bad.

The 1 September Dynamite, also set for Chicago, is a fine choice to debut Punk that would also boost pay-per-view buys. Rampage on 3 September is less compelling until we know what the Friday night show's viewership looks like. The Dynamite after All Out is another option but why would you forgo the easy layup of a hometown pop?

And once you've chosen the show, what does Punk do in that spot? Cut a promo? Work his first match? Pull a Christian Cage and ceremonially sign a contract without saying a word?

Make no mistake, AEW must sign CM Punk. The promotion may never see an opportunity like this again.

But they need to be extremely careful with how he is introduced.

CONT'd...


CM Punk Annoyed
WWE

Between Bryan Danielson, CM Punk, Hangman Page's World Title surge, and whatever else Tony Khan may have up his sleeve, August and September 2021 have the potential to be historic months for All Elite Wrestling.

If all goes well, the period could fast-forward the promotion's growth to the point that Raw's ratings in key demographics, if not overall viewership, are within touching distance. This would have been unthinkable even a few months ago, let alone when Dynamite debuted in October 2019. A show that has been on the airwaves since 1993 should not have fallen this close to one that's less than two years old.

AEW, already wildly underpaid for its television deal, will then have the potential to push even further. Those who said the startup would fail within a year have already been proven wrong. Now, it has the opportunity to take its biggest leap to date.

Punk is key to that, and AEW's team have built enough trust in being able to sustain his buzz beyond the initial pop. Phil Brooks has never been the kind of guy to operate at half-speed either. If he's in, he's all the way in.

His arrival would be the truest test of the audience's devotion to guys like Page, whom they have followed for over two years now. Here's hoping this stays true.


Watch Next


In this post: 
CM Punk AEW
 
Posted On: 
Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.