The Undertaker's WWE Career: 9 Ups & 5 Downs
The Dark Days may be nearing their end, but they will live on forever.
Three decades in any profession is no small feat but in a career as physical as wrestling it's nearly unheard of - especially when it means three decades of working for the same promotion. No, it doesn't happen often but, like the supernatural character he portrays, The Undertaker is a once-in-a-lifetime competitor.
It sounds like hyperbole but it's not. 'The Man From The Dark Side' has defied the norm since he first walked through that curtain in November 1990, pulling off feats that a man of his size should never be able to and single-handedly putting together a legacy that is damn-near mythical at the same time.
It's not all been gravesides and tombstones for Mark Calaway but you would be hard-pressed to find another superstar who has consistently performed at such a high level for such an extended period of time, and that in itself is a microcosm of why he was the perfect man for The Undertaker.
As we celebrate 30 years of 'The Deadman' and his impending retirement at Survivor Series, let's take a moment to reflect on the career of the man we call 'The Phenom', documenting the good, the bad, the dead and the moments that will live forever.
First, the negatives...
Downs...
5. The Giant Slayer
Early on in his career, 'The Deadman' had something of a reputation for being a giant slayer - and it was a well-earned reputation at that, because as soon as Vince McMahon introduced a new monster into WWE, you could damn sure bet that they would cross 'Taker's path.
But the larger-than-life bouts would only ever look good on paper because the in-ring limitations of the monsters meant that 'Taker would have to work hard to get a good match out of them - something that was virtually impossible for him to do in the early '90s because of the constraints of his slow-moving undead gimmick.
We never really knew the greatness 'The Phenom' was capable of when he was lumbered with these slow, plodding affairs. Of course, it got much easier when he adopted his MMA fighting style but why creative ever felt the need to revisit those days throughout his career is still pretty baffling.
4. Making Things Personal
Seeing Mark Calaway open up about his career on The Last Ride docuseries has been wonderful because it felt like we were finally getting to know the man behind 'The Deadman'. However, WWE's previous attempts to lift the veil between Calaway and 'Taker were less successful.
The American Badass persona remains a divisive subject for fans (and we'll get to that later) but the evolution felt natural and managed to sustain the aging character in a brand new era. The parts of it that didn't work so well, however, were when creative attempted to bring his personal life into it.
Again, the notion of this once-demonic supernatural creature having a personal life wasn't going to sit well with some but that's not what we're here to talk about (though it was a bit jarring!). No, the problem was the disturbing stories they came up with when venturing there.
Having DDP be the stalker of 'Taker's then-wife Sara ruined the WCW star's dreams of ever making it in WWE while the attempt to paint 'Big Evil' as an adulterer in his feud with Brock Lesnar fell flat and risked diluting this sacred character.
Thankfully, 'The Deadman's return exorcised all that.
3. Trying To Recreate The Past
When you've been around as long as 'The Deadman', you're bound to find yourself revisiting some old haunts from time-to-time. We've seen it happen many times throughout his career as he's crossed paths with old rivals for a second time or pulled an old trick on a new challenger. Unfortunately, WWE felt the need to take that much, much further in recent years.
You remember how he lost to Roman Reigns in a moment trying too hard to be the end of The Streak? What about how he and Triple H faced each other for the 'last time ever' six years after they 'ended an era' in a five-star battle?
An incessant desire for the aging veteran to turn the clock back in his twilight years saw the creative team attempt to recreate the magic of his glory days just so that they could have him put over another star or sell out another super show. But the man simply couldn't live up to those expectations and these unnecessary attempts to make him do so risked turning him into little more than a nostalgia act.
2. Ending The Streak
The moment in which Brock Lesnar snapped The Undertaker's undefeated streak at WrestleMania XXX will go down in history as one of the few where it genuinely felt like time stood still.
It's an incredible moment, yes, but it's also an incredibly divisive one - and not necessarily one that feels like it ever needed to happen - especially now that we know 'Taker was supposed to go over until Vince randomly changed his mind on the day of the show.
It was a moment that broke a little bit of 'Taker's aura and the fact that he continued to compete for six years after the Streak's loss rendered it completely unnecessary, but not quite as unnecessary as the rub it gave to Brock Lesnar when 'The Beast' already had an awe-inspiring reputation. And it seems WWE realised that a little too late and the cheap attempt to recreate the moment with Roman Reigns three years later is proof of that.
Maybe Roman should have beaten him the first time, or better yet, maybe 'Taker should have retired with The Streak intact.
1. The Post-Streak Misfires
The biggest problem with stripping The Undertaker of The Streak was the fact that it led to a number of years where WWE wasn't really sure what to do with the legend - something that had almost never happened before.
It seemed like WrestleMania's Phenom had died with The Streak, but even though he had lost a step, the real problem was the fact that WWE almost always booked him in the wrong programs. Over the past seven years, he's been shoehorned into super shows with legends past their prime, stuck in the middle of McMahon family drama for no reason whatsoever and forced to revisit his glory days so that he can only prove why he shouldn't be wrestling 30-minute matches anymore.
Of course, none of this applies to 2015 - which was, without a doubt, the greatest Undertaker year of the past decade - but, that aside, the post-Streak years weren't kind to 'The Phenom'.
Now, for the positives...
Ups...
9. The Greatest Character In WWE History
There are many deserving candidates when it comes to picking the greatest WWE superstar ever (and The Undertaker is certainly one of them), but when it comes to the greatest character in WWE - and, indeed, wrestling - history, 'The Demon Of Death Valley' is alone at the top of that list.
He was awe-inspiring right from the very first moment we laid eyes on him, with the hat, coat, ghoulish make-up, Paul Bearer and overall presentation going a long way in portraying him like this larger-than-life comic book character. And that only served as a foundation for some of the more theatrical aspects that would come in later years like the mind games, the blackouts and the lightning strikes.
Speaking of which, what solidified The Undertaker's status as WWE's greatest character was his ability to adapt. The zombie-like mortician would never have worked in the Attitude Era so he evolved into a Gothic Lord of Darkness that spoke in tongues and sought to sacrifice people. And he would do the same again throughout his second decade, humanising him with the American Badass persona before bringing it all back together for a hybrid version of 'The Deadman'.
Unquestionably the richest character in WWE history, The Undertaker has stood the test of time.
8. The Late '90s
The more it became clear that 'Taker was destined to be a big time player, the more it became clear that he needed to drop certain aspects of his character. With that, he began evolving throughout the mid '90s, freeing himself of the shackles of the slow-moving mortician and showing audiences what he was really capable of in the ring - something that set the stage for an absolutely incredible run in the immediate future.
The late '90s were very good to 'The Phenom' as he transitioned into the Lord of Darkness persona and found his way into the main event scene a lot more often. A big time player of the Attitude Era, he not only proved that The Undertaker could exist in a less corny product, he enjoyed multiple WWE Title reigns, formed the Ministry of Darkness and had epic feuds with the likes of Bret Hart, Stone Cold Steve Austin, The Rock and, of course, Mankind. He also played a major part in introducing us to Hell In A Cell and was directly responsible for the iconic structure's success.
There was, however, one vital piece of this puzzle that we've yet to talk about...
7. Brothers Of Destruction

We already know there would be no Kane without The Undertaker - 'The Big Red Machine' was, after all, introduced as 'The Deadman's brother - but we don't talk enough about how we may not have an Undertaker without Kane. Of course, 'Taker would still exist - he went for seven years without any mention of a Kane - but it's hard to imagine where his career would have went if his fiery other half hadn't showed up when he did.
Though he had broken free from the shackles of the New Generation era's 'Deadman' gimmick, WWE did have a tendency to stick him in similar storylines on repeat. Kane's arrival changed that, giving him a long form story that, for once, made him seem mortal. And those cracks in his supernaturally hard exterior made him a much more engaging character.
It's well-documented that the first Undertaker/Kane rivalry is the best piece of epic storytelling WWE has ever done, but the pair's story didn't stop there. They remained in each other's lives for the remainder of their careers, forming the 'Brothers of Destruction' as they dominated the tag team division and crossing each other to renew that rivalry throughout the next decade.
The Undertaker's story is that much richer because of Kane and it's hard to know if he would have achieved the legendary heights he did had it not been for 'The Big Red Monster'.
6. Longevity
Dwayne 'The Rock' Johnson once said that nobody has performed at such a high level for such a significant period of time in the way that The Undertaker has. John 'Bradshaw' Layfield spoke on commentary about how it was 'literally phenomenal' that one man could compete for so long and 'still be going strong'. It's a feat that sounds almost impossible, but 'The Deadman' made it possible.
This man regularly performed to an incredibly high standard throughout the first two decades of his career (before going part-time in the third one). He's been part of WWE for all of its major eras and has pretty much been sewn into the fabric at this point. No matter how long you've been into wrestling, you know of the almighty Undertaker - not as a figure from a time before yours but as a haunting spectre that could make his presence felt at any given moment. That in itself is a testament to 'The Phenom's ability to remain relevant.
For three decades, he has been at the top of the WWE food chain and this kind of longevity is completely unparalleled. It's a lengthy career that, like The Undertaker himself, is simply one of a kind.
5. The American Badass
The importance of evolution was never more clear than it was when 'Taker adopted his American Badass persona in 2000. No doubt a divisive reinvention at the time, it still sparks debate as to whether or not it was a wise move on the part of the legend to become the motorcycle-riding, shades-wearing, bandana-clad biker, but looking back now, it's hard to chalk it up as anything but a success.
The World Wrestling Federation was moving past the gimmicks of yesteryear, so even with 'The Deadman's evolution into the Lord of Darkness carrying him through the Attitude Era, he needed something more grounded for the company's venture into Ruthless Aggression. The biker persona was the answer to that and the fact that he had teased that evolution a number of times throughout the late '90s made the transition that much smoother.
Sure, he wasn't at his best physically during this stint and his in-ring work suffered as a result, but the gimmick change allowed him to thrive in a more realistic era and it doesn't receive enough credit for essentially shaping the superior version of 'The Deadman' that emerged after its demise.
4. The Perfect Undertaker
The reason that the American Badass worked during his era was the same reason the Deadman wouldn't have: He was realistic. So when it came to returning him to his darker roots in 2004, changes had to be made to the original character.
A hybrid of the very best of his previous personas, 'Taker now entered the arena like the mortician, dropped out the lights like Deadman, stuck out his tongue like the Lord of Darkness and beat the living daylights out of you like the American Badass.
The fact that the version of 'The Deadman' that returned at WrestleMania XX stayed with 'Taker for literally half of his career really does speak volumes and it enabled him to excel in a more 'realistic' WWE than the early '90s while also reintroducing the company to some much-needed theatrics. Oh yeah, and it also gifted him with the absolute best period of his in-ring career...
3. The Streak
Without The Streak, The Undertaker still would have enjoyed an incredibly fruitful multi-decade-long career and earned his spot on the Mount Rushmore of professional wrestling. With it, however, he set himself apart from everyone else and achieved a status of near-godliness at the Showcase of the Immortals.
The sheer notion that an already-unstoppable monster became that much more invincible on the biggest night of the WWE calendar was a thoroughly compelling one and it formed an almost-supernatural aura around 'Taker and, indeed, WrestleMania as hopeful challengers signed up to become the man to break The Streak.
The Streak was more important to WrestleMania than any championship - something that was aided by the quality of matches 'Taker and his respective opponents would pull off - and that says a lot about how much of a life of its own it took on. And it's such a shame that 21-0 never evolved into 27-0 ahead of his retirement.
Speaking of high-quality 'Mania matches...
2. Five-Star Phenom

'Taker already had a pretty legendary career halfway through his three-decade stint but there was something unearthly about the fact that it wasn't until he entered his '40s that he found his prime. He had already enjoyed what we thought was his prime between late '96 and '98 as he put on some cracking matches with Shawn Michaels, Bret Hart and Kane but his recreation of that between 2006 and 2009 far exceeded that.
A lot of that had to do with the fact that WWE had finally figured out how to use him best, reuniting him with wrestling machines like Kurt Angle and smaller, more agile athletes like Rey Mysterio and, of course, Shawn Michaels. But a lot of it was also down to his own capabilities because for every technical masterpiece with Michaels, there were also brutal barn-burners against bigger men like Batista and Triple H and an underrated SmackDown gem against Kane.
In the best shape of his life, this 'Taker earned his 'Phenom' moniker, defying odds, injuries and age to deliver consistently high quality matches - and his string of WrestleMania showdowns between 2007 and 2013 were all 'Match Of The Year' candidates, strengthening the prestige of The Streak and adding a new layer of brilliance to his already phenomenal career.
1. The Cornerstone Of The WWE
Many of us get caught up over the fact that The Undertaker was never what many like to call the 'face' of the company (though you could make an argument for him being one the multiple faces of both the Attitude and Ruthless Aggression eras) but the truth is that he was far more important to WWE than that.
Over the last three decades, the faces of the company have come and gone, with the likes of Hulk Hogan, Stone Cold Steve Austin, The Rock and John Cena dominating their respective eras. The Undertaker, however, was present for - and dominated - every one of them.
He may not have been in as many consecutive main event matches in any one era as those guys, but he was always circling the main event scene, engaging in high profile feuds throughout his entire career and sporadically dominating the main event when required to. And, more than that, he would be willing to lose whenever WWE needed to put over a huge star - because the-powers-that-be knew that a win over 'Taker meant far more than any championship could.
The Undertaker has been the cornerstone of WWE for 30 years, guarding the very foundation upon which the company is built by guiding it to safety in troubling times and doing what's best for business in the good ones. And that's far more important than being a short-term face.
His legacy really does speak for itself. Thank You, 'Taker.
WWE Quiz: How Well Do You REALLY Know The Undertaker?