The Undertaker's WWE SummerSlam Matches Ranked From Worst To Best

Caskets, cages and cells - 'The Deadman' knows how to throw the biggest party of the summer.

X Pac Undertaker SummerSlam 1999
WWE.com

SummerSlam is almost upon us and, with stars like Goldberg and Trish Stratus returning to the ring, there was even a point when it seemed like 'The Phenom' himself, The Undertaker, would show up at the marquee event to face off with Drew McIntyre.

While that certainly doesn't appear to be happening now, it does give us the opportunity to reflect on the legacy that The Deadman has built at WWE's second-biggest pay-per-view of the year.

'Taker may be considered WrestleMania's Phenom, but over the course of his near-three decade career, he has also had his fair share of major matches at SummerSlam. In fact, there was once a time when he was a regular part of the 'Biggest Party of the Summer's furniture, as he appeared at 14 of them without a single break.

With that in mind, let's look back on each of his summer showdowns and, while we're at it, rank them from worst to best.

16. Vs. Giant Gonzalez - SummerSlam 1993

The Undertaker Giant Gonzalez SummerSlam 1993
WWE

It's well-documented how uneventful and dull 'The Phenom's match with Giant Gonzalez at WrestleMania IX was, but it's often forgotten that the pair's rivalry continued well past that infamous clash, culminating at SummerSlam in a 'Rest In Peace' match.

This one was undoubtedly a much easier watch than their 'Mania showdown, but it still didn't offer much outside of endless pummelling on the Giant's part in a short-lived bid to portray The Undertaker as powerless without Paul Bearer.

Speaking of Bearer, it was his mid-match return that provided the silver-lining here as the sight of the beloved manager brought the dead crowd back to life and made the ending stretch somewhat enjoyable.

It's just a shame that the-powers-that-be couldn't think of a better way for 'Taker to win than four clotheslines and a flying one for good measure.


15. Vs. Kamala - SummerSlam 1992

Undertaker Kamala
WWE.com

While The Undertaker's entrance into Wembley Stadium is considered among his all-time greatest moments, there is a reason that his clash with Kamala at SummerSlam 1992 is not.

A short affair that consisted of nothing more than incredibly slow attempts at brawling and a lot of retreating on Kamala's part, it felt longer than it actually was. Moreover, the disqualification ending that came only three minutes into it undoubtedly left everyone feeling a little short-changed.

Though there were some awe-inspiring moments, including 'Taker's Chokeslam to 'The Ugandan Giant' (one of his first to a bigger man) and the post-match stalk up the aisle, this ultimately felt like a wasted opportunity.

Nobody was expecting a classic, but it could have been a lot better than what we got.


14. Vs. Underfaker - SummerSlam 1994

undertaker undertaker
WWE.com

The Undertaker's return at SummerSlam 1994 provided 'The Deadman' with one of the most legendary moments of his entire career - and it certainly wasn't his dull drawn-out zombified main event contest against, well, himself.

Fresh off an epic return and clad from head to toe in awesome new attire, it was a new chapter for 'Taker, but not even that (or the two undead morticians in the ring) was enough to resurrect the crowd - who had gone completely silent during the bland battle.

Undertaker's slow gimmick held him back from showing what he was really capable of during the first few years of his career, so you can imagine how bad it was to watch two slow monsters uppercut each other in and out of the ring for nearly ten minutes.

The entrance and the triple Tombstone spot were amazing - everything in between was completely forgettable.


13. Vs. A-Train - SummerSlam 2003

WWE SummerSlam 2003 The Undertaker A-Train
WWE Network

Taking place towards the end of 'Taker's run as Big Evil, his match with A-Train was a clear example of how the creative team were running out of ideas for American Badass Undertaker. Caught in Vince McMahon's crosshairs again, 'The Phenom' ended up spending the second-biggest event of the year in battle with the man he had already pinned at the biggest event of the year.

Unfortunately, the match itself was rather dull, as 'Taker's kayfabe rib injury meant that the slower A-Train controlled the majority of the match as he endlessly pounded away on the affected area. It did pick up in the closing moments but, by then, it was too little too late.

Though it wasn't horrible, it was completely uneventful and, other than Stephanie McMahon's post-match return, nothing about it justified its placement on the SummerSlam card.


12. Vs. Test - SummerSlam 2002

WWE SummerSlam 2002 The Undertaker Test
WWE Network

'Taker met Test in a physical fight at SummerSlam '02 that was set up with little build-up, but given that the latter was in the midst of his Unamerican persona while the former was the American Badass, it made sense.

The problem here is that, on a card full of game-changing matches, it just kind of exists. It wasn't bad but finish aside, there was nothing that made it feel like anything other than a match you could have seen on a random episode of Raw or SmackDown - and if you had, you probably would have enjoyed it more.


11. (With Kane) Vs. DDP & Kanyon - SummerSlam 2001

Undertaker Kane Summerslam 2001
WWE.com

A match that has gone down in infamy simply because of the way both Diamond Dallas Page and Kanyon were treated by WWE, the Steel Cage clash between those two superstars and the Brothers of Destruction (for both the WWE and the WCW Tag Team Championships) was about as one-sided as you can get.

Marred by the controversial storyline in which Page stalked 'Taker's wife Sara, the WWE creative team ensured that it was impossible to root for the former WCW star even if you were a fan - which is why the overwhelming majority of us cheered when we saw him being decimated by The Undertaker and Kane at SummerSlam. It was a punishment that the character of DDP deserved... the man himself, however, did not (and neither did Kanyon).

Not a bad match, it was entertaining at times and undoubtedly produced the right result, but it was far from what it could have been - and unfortunately the damage to Page and Kanyon's WWE careers was irreversible.


10. Vs. Kane - SummerSlam 2000

WWE SummerSlam 2000 The Undertaker Kane
WWE Network

Look, this one wasn't pretty and it sure as hell wasn't a wrestling masterpiece, but did anyone really expect it to be?

By this point, The Undertaker and Kane had fought each other all throughout 1998, fought each other slightly less in 1999 and then crossed paths in 2000 again. By now t's safe to say we had seen every variation of an Undertaker and Kane match possible... until we saw this.

A short, to-the-point brawl, the pair ravaged each other with soup bones and steel steps in a surprisingly violent affair that benefited the story they were trying to tell. They were no longer supernatural creatures engaging in a mystical battle for supremacy, they were two big dogs looking to tear each other apart - that's exactly what they achieved here, and 'Taker's quest to unmask Kane added an urgency to the already brief battle.

Every 'Taker/Kane match was getting progressively worse than the previous one, but this was short, sweet and made them both look like monsters in a short space of time. Mission accomplished.


9. Vs. JBL - SummerSlam 2004

Undertaker JBL SummerSlam 2004
WWE.com

Relatively fresh off his return to his 'Deadman' persona, 'Taker resumed his quest for the WWE Championship - a quest that led to JBL. However, while the pair were part of one of 2004's most enjoyable long-running storylines, their first one-on-one contest wasn't exactly a show-stopper.

A long drawn-out big-man fight that was rather light on the brawling, it was clear that the-powers-that-be were determined to book JBL strong, but this ended up hurting the flow of the match as it leaned in his direction a little more than it needed to.

Furthermore, the DQ finish felt a little too far-fetched because, considering how much he wanted the championship, and the fact that he's the freakin' Undertaker, it was hard to buy that 'Taker would resort to hitting JBL with the gold - especially when he didn't introduce the belt in the first place.

All that aside, the post-match Chokeslam through the limo was amazing, and did a great job of reinforcing that things between these two were far from over.


8. Vs. Kama - SummerSlam 1995

Kama Undertaker
WWE

By mid-1995, the hold that 'The Phenom's gimmick had on his career was beginning to loosen, and as a result, we were allowed to see more of what the brawler beneath was really capable of - and that's where his Casket Match clash with Kama at SummerSlam comes in.

The fact that 'Taker couldn't wait to tear off his hat and coat before tearing into Kama was an example of just how much he was evolving, as that sudden motion changed the complexion of the match itself - immediately telling us that, despite what we had seen before, this wasn't going to be a typical gimmicky Undertaker/Casket Match.

It was incredibly long and drawn-out and, although it wasn't a wrestling classic, it was still highly entertaining as it gave us the chance to watch not one, but two, supreme fighting machines brawling for all that they were worth in a bid to put the other one down.

Without a doubt, the hardest fought match of 'Taker's career at this point - and a highly enjoyable one at that.


7. (With Big Show) Vs. Kane & X-Pac - SummerSlam 1999

Undertaker Kane
WWE.com

Undertaker's alliance with Big Show in mid-1999 may have been rather short-lived (and random considering that it followed the Ministry era), but it did produce this tag team gem, as the gargantuan pair sought to prove their dominance over Tag Team Champions Kane and X-Pac.

The match ran for a respectable 12 minutes but, during that time, the action never stopped as all four superstars consistently tagged in and out, keeping things fresh before all hell broke loose - something that allowed 'Taker to have some great exchanges with both Kane and X-Pac.

The story here was X-Pac's attempts to use his monster to stand against two other monsters and, although he came incredibly close to overcoming the odds, he was unable to withstand the wrath of 'Taker and Big Show - a narrative that was beautifully reflected in the action.

A cut above your average tag team match, this was one that felt every bit like the pay-per-view offering it was supposed to be and, more than that, it was just non-stop fun from beginning to end.


6. Vs. Randy Orton - SummerSlam 2005

WWE SummerSlam 2005 The Undertaker Randy Orton
WWE Network

'Taker and Randy Orton produced some absolute classics throughout 2005, including their initial WrestleMania bout, their pay-per-view worthy SmackDown match later that year and their feud-ending Hell In A Cell clash.

Then you have the pair's less-talked about collision at SummerSlam 2005 - a match that took place after Orton, upset that he couldn't kill the legend of The Undertaker at WrestleMania 21, decided to renew the rivalry over the summer.

While this one didn't quite meet the high standard of any of those aforementioned contests, it was still a strong offering, with a predictably screwy finish in order to allow the feud to continue - and ultimately reach greater heights. More than that, it was nice to see 'Taker getting consistently paired with younger, faster athletes at SummerSlam who could bring out the best in him - something Orton was great at.


5. Vs. Stone Cold Steve Austin - SummerSlam 1998

WWE Championship SummerSlam The Undertaker SummerSlam 1998
WWE

In spite of the fact that both The Undertaker and Stone Cold Steve Austin are two of the greatest of all time and that they have wrestled multiple perfect matches throughout their respective careers, they never quite clicked in the ring the way you would've thought they might. That said, they came ever so close to doing so at SummerSlam 1998.

Meeting in the electric environment of Madison Square Garden, the WWE titans unleashed hell upon each other in a compelling, physical brawl that rarely stopped from start to finish - earning every last bit of that physical exhaustion they both showed by the conclusion.

It was almost as if somebody had lit a fire under them, as they both fought like they were out to prove that, yes, they could deliver a show-stealer - and that leg drop table spot has gone down in history as one of 'The Deadman's most incredible feats of athleticism.

It's a shame that Austin got concussed so early on in the bout, as this started off with the makings of a five-star classic. That being said, even though it fell a little short of that, it was a hard-hitting battle that undoubtedly sent the New York fans home happy - and one that belongs among the greatest main events of the Attitude Era.


4. Vs. Bret Hart - SummerSlam 1997

Undertaker Bret Hart HBK
WWE.com

The Undertaker main-evented his second SummerSlam in 1997 when he defended his WWE Championship against Bret Hart and, well, let's just say that it was a vast improvement over his previous show-closer.

In the height of his 'Lord of Darkness' persona, he was completely free of the shackles that came with his original gimmick and this ultimately allowed him and Bret to put on an absolute cracker of a main event in New Jersey.

From Bret's desperate attempts to cut down the mighty Undertaker to Shawn Michaels' inclusion as the special guest referee, the match was enriched with real storytelling which only got better as the action told its own story at the same time. The fact that it was incredibly heavy on Bret action highlighted that as, no matter what the 'Hitman' did, he couldn't take the Sharpshooter-breaking 'Phenom' down. The real irony lay in the fact that, in the end, he wasn't the one who pulled it off.

A long hard-fought classic, and undoubtedly one of the best main events in SummerSlam history.


3. Vs. Mankind - SummerSlam 1996

Bearer Undertaker Mankind SummerSlam 1996
WWE.com

The best thing about the feud between 'Taker and Mankind was just how physical it got right from the offset. Though essentially an undead zombie, 'The Deadman' was still portrayed as the more logical of the two simply because of how unhinged his new foe was - and that ultimately made the Boiler Room the perfect environment for their SummerSlam altercation.

As most of the action actually took place in the boiler room, there weren't any stunning wrestling moves here (though were we really expecting any?), but the exceptional camerawork made up for that as the invasive close-up shots of both the action and 'Taker's search for Mankind made the whole thing an uncomfortable watch.

With two-by-fours, ladders and a ton of jump-scares, this was a somewhat over-the-top but ridiculously fun brawl that only characters like 'Taker and Mankind could pull off. Furthermore, they sold it all so well as, watching them limp, crawl and drag their way to the ring, you almost feel the fatigue radiating from them.

Capped off by Paul Bearer's shocking betrayal, this was one of those rare occasions were everything just came together as the Boiler Room Brawl ended up enhancing the already-great Undertaker/Mankind saga.


2. Vs. Brock Lesnar - SummerSlam 2015

Brock Lesnar The Undertaker SummerSlam 2015
WWE

Brock Lesnar may have ended 'The Streak' at WrestleMania XXX, but that was far from the end of his story with The Undertaker, as 'The Deadman' sought vengeance the following year at SummerSlam.

Given how badly things went for the concussed 'Phenom' at Mania, expectations were low for the pair's long-awaited rematch. However, they didn't just exceed those expectations, they blew them out of the water.

Unlike the previous encounter, the SummerSlam bout was treated like the revenge-driven shootout that we all wanted to see from these two and, as a result, they never held back. It was a brawl, a slugfest and all-out war as the kings of two different generations threw everything they had at each other in order to reign supreme.

Moreover, it told a tale of redemption for 'The Phenom' as the aging gunslinger defended his yard like he had something to prove and, in doing so, he did prove that there still fight left in the tank. A resurrection of a performance if there were ever one, 'Taker fought like 'The Deadman' of old and, together, he and Lesnar pulled off one heck of a main event - one that even the controversial ending couldn't take away from.


1. Vs. Edge - SummerSlam 2008

undertaker edge summerslam
WWE.com

The ending to what was, without a doubt, one of the greatest rivalries in SmackDown history, The Undertaker's Hell In A Cell showdown with Edge at SummerSlam 2008 was everything that it should have been - and so much more.

Taking place in the midst of 'Taker's phenomenal 'Deadman' resurgence period, he was in the best shape of his entire career and moved around the ring like it was still 1996. This made him a great opponent for Edge and, like they had proven so many times throughout the year, when the two of them were in the ring together, something magic happened.

With a Chokeslam through two tables, a Spear, a camera to the skull, a con-chair-to and a Tombstone Piledriver, 'The Phenom' put an end to the feud in hellacious fashion (while giving the Rated-R Superstar a ton of receipts for everything he had done to him over the previous year), and if anything, this match was proof that the Hell In A Cell concept could still work in the PG Era.

One of the best matches of The Undertaker's career, it was a fitting end to the incredible feud.

-

What was your favourite Undertaker match at SummerSlam? Tell us in the comment section below.


WWE Quiz: Can You Name The Undertaker's Most Obscure Opponents?

Undertaker Tugboat
WWE.com

1. Who Is This?

Contributor
Contributor

Michael Patterson is an experienced writer with an affinity for all things film and TV. He may or may not have spent his childhood obsessing over WWE.