6 Backstage Wrestling Politicians Who Never Drew A Dime

Stars that literally weren’t worth the hassle: featuring Shawn Michaels and more…

Randy Orton Politician
WWE

In the dark world of professional wrestling, and this is the case in the wider entertainment industry, there is a rule that is as unfair as it is cast-iron: if you are great, you can get away with virtually anything. Even former WWE owner Vince McMahon would surrender his self-appointed alpha status, if losing a power play meant making money.

You can be a difficult perfectionist. You can be an egomaniac. You can be unreliable. Sadly, in too many cases, you can be abusive. Provided you are a special talent capable of generating revenue and interest, you will still get pushed, even into the role of top star. In fact - mainly in years gone by, since there’s too much corporate money flooding into WWE and AEW for one pivotal star to act the big shot - the top star was always a politician. You had to be. If you weren’t good enough at acting in your best interests, you got screwed. Look at Bret Hart. 

Hulk Hogan was a politician. He was smart enough to know that he could not outright bury everybody he perceived to be a threat, but he found many clever, insidious ways, like the time he treated the Ultimate Warrior’s win over him as a cruel act of God. Hogan was blunt with it on occasion, too. He once no-sold Vader’s finish and cast Ric Flair as one eighth of the Dungeon of Doom, just to let everybody know who was running wild in WCW, Jack. 

Steve Austin spared some of his peers the embarrassment, mainly because he was too smart and or paranoid to work with Marc Mero and Jeff Jarrett in the first place. Austin did think better of passing the title directly to Triple H at SummerSlam 1999. Triple H spent every subsequent second of his career playing the kicked cat.  

Chris Jericho was clever in AEW. When he reached a point at which a second World title reign was never going to go down well, he repackaged himself as a main event gatekeeper. He legitimised AEW - genuinely - so it was up to him to do the same for the talent. Jericho was the guy a wrestler had to beat to prove themselves worthy of the breakthrough. If they weren’t, Jericho could point to the fact that he wasn’t the booker, and when they didn’t, it was time to try again - ensuring that Jericho, not the opponents he “put over”, made it to the next pay-per-view cycle. Chris Jericho’s old ‘Demo God’ nickname wasn’t based on nothing, and his segments even performed well on TV when the go-away heat was at its most intense in the arena. 

But which wrestlers had no claim whatsoever…?

6. Randy Orton

Randy Orton WWE 2009
WWE.com

Randy Orton looked so much like a star, in Vince McMahon’s eyes, that he was going to be presented and coddled like one, even if the metrics didn’t indicate that he was much of a star at all. 

WWE’s monopoly distorted the idea of draws and stars forever. In effect, provided they didn’t pull alarmingly low numbers or destroy the baseline, a wrestler could be marketed as a star, and most fans would simply accept it. How could Randy Orton not be a star? He has headlined countless Premium Live Events and won 14 World titles. 

Randy Orton wasn’t much of a politician, granted. His bad reputation in wrestling mostly derives from his history of obnoxious, disrespectful behaviour and angry, abusive outbursts. He was a vandal, an unprofessional nightmare, an impulsive liability in front of fans.

He’s always held a degree of influence, though, and has seemingly wielded it on occasion. Allegedly instrumental in the immediate firing of Mr. Kennedy - Orton was the recipient of a scary, botched backdrop suplex on the May 25, 2009 Raw - Kofi Kingston might not have been demoted to the midcard had Orton not screamed that he was “stupid” over and over again in a match held a year later.

Orton, as one of the most decorated World champions in history, was pushed heavily by WWE for longer than most wrestlers ever. In 2026, he is more over than ever - without really being involved in the main event picture - but this wasn’t always the case. WWE’s version of events clashed with reality. As part of this relentless initiative, Orton was cast as the top babyface on SmackDown throughout 2011. He dropped the World Heavyweight title to Mark Henry at Night of Champions on September 18. The week prior to the switch, WWE recorded its worst weekend house show business of the year; attendance rebounded slightly with Henry on top. 

The September 23 SmackDown drew the highest rating (3.26 million) in months. This was no anomaly; Henry was a consistent TV draw; SmackDown frequently exceeded 2 million viewers during his reign, where that had only happened twice between WrestleMania and Night of Champions. 

As of early September 2024, a WWE NXT show for which Randy Orton was advertised, set to emanate from the Enterprise Center in his hometown of St. Louis, Missouri, had sold just 2,104 tickets before it was hastily moved to the far smaller The Factory at the District in Chesterfield. As difficult a challenge as it was for Orton to draw a big crowd under the NXT branding, he failed. 

Randy Orton is what happens when you are able to control the narrative. 


5. JBL

JBL Undertaker
WWE.com

With his lightspeed push, John Bradshaw Layfield, at least until the crowning of Jinder Mahal, was the most inexplicable WWE Champion ever. 

Unlike Mahal, who afforded absolutely nothing, JBL had a few things going for him at least. While his matches were largely terrible, he could deliver the required main event-level drama when turning blood effects on against Eddie Guerrero and John Cena. If the content of his promos was cheap and ugly, the delivery was fantastic. He had a great nasty bellow in him. He mastered the art of playing the blowhard who thinks he knows what he’s talking about because he can shout the loudest. Also, what a finisher: by default, even his worst matches as champion, those that resembled elongated 1998 midcard bouts, had a great ending.

JBL was not a draw. The best thing you can say about him is that his presence felt less surreal as he grew into the role. But he wasn’t a draw. TV ratings patterns didn’t budge when Eddie Guerrero dropped the title to him, and JBL’s first brand-exclusive PPV main event - against the Undertaker at No Mercy 2004 - drew 140,000 domestic buys. That number is pathetic - the worst since In Your House: Ground Zero (136,000) back in September 1997. 

There are different ways of playing the political game. JBL wasn’t known for undermining potential locker room threats, nor was he accused of entering deliberately subpar performances that would reflect poorly on his opponents (probably because nobody would be able to tell the difference). 

JBL, however, was known as a career-long suck-up and yes-man. He took it upon himself to ingratiate himself with the upper management boy’s club by terrorising the greener lockers in the dressing room. JBL’s job, and he did it, allegedly, through the threat of sexual assault, was to weed out the “primadonnas”. JBL was the guy who curated the desired atmosphere of fear. 

A brutal and sadistic office henchman, JBL was the sycophant who endures in political circles longer than the people who want to do good. 


4. Jeff Jarrett

Jeff Jarrett nWo 2000 WCW
WWE.com

Triple H is not included here - but he is a dishonourable mention. 

He was the ultimate wrestling politician, so he is as well-qualified for inclusion in this list as Vince McMahon is for hell. Legitimising his case further, Triple H was nowhere near a draw big enough to warrant the longest main event push in WWE history. However, in 2005, Triple H set a WrestleMania PPV buy record, outside of a boom period, because people wanted him to see him lose a World title. He did the same thing for B-level pay-per-views, too; until the never-to-be-repeated pipe dream that was InVasion drew 775,000 buys, Backlash 2000 broke the record for a non-Big Four event with a staggering 650,000. WrestleMania 19 didn’t even do that well. You can argue that the Rock drew that number - not that he would have pulled it with Mr. Ass - but you can’t argue with those results. 

Jeff Jarrett in his relentless NWA World Champion era was nicknamed ‘Triple J’. He earned it because, like Triple H allegedly did, Jarrett used his “stroke” to rip and tear through the locker room. Dixie Carter presided over the company Vince Russo booked, but really, Jeff Jarrett ran it.

Jeff Jarrett always thought he was great enough to main event, jumping around the 1990s to achieve that goal, and you can half-see why. He was one of the best rookies ever when he broke out - almost in the Kurt Angle or Jun Akiyama class - and he’s considered one of the most solid and safest pros ever. But he wasn’t very big, and he wasn’t on the level of smaller peers Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels. When Jarrett did get the opportunity, he became a meme for not drawing. He didn’t draw in WCW, but then again, nobody did; wrestlers with a strong history of drawing prowess, like Sting and Goldberg, were rendered valueless in 1999 and beyond. 

Early adopters of TNA were vehement in their disgust of Jarrett’s constant quest for heat and bored of his ceaseless crowd brawl matches. Jarrett, no stranger to the NWA title either side of it, underwent his own lengthy Reign of Terror between June 2, 2004 and May 15, 2005. Fans were particularly angry when Jarrett didn’t drop the title to Monty Brown at Final Resolution ‘05. That was the moment Jarrett could no longer justify his spot as some sort of gatekeeping need. Who cares if Monty wasn’t “ready”? The fans believed in him, and if he wasn’t, you switch the title back. 

Jarrett’s loss to Sting at Bound For Glory 2006 drew between 55,000 and 60,000 buys. That is some number when you consider how difficult it is to do anything notable in the shadow of post-2001 WWE. Fair play to Jeff for his role in pulling it. Jarrett however didn’t have to bring fans into the Impact Zone, entry for which was free with the price of admission to Universal Studios, so it’s literally impossible to determine whether he was a draw or not. This isn’t helped by the fact that they used to make memes about how little the Impact ratings changed week-to-week. 

Jarrett legitimised TNA, which is sort of oxymoronic, but you get the meaning. He didn’t draw fans to it as a talismanic top star, or anything, but while he deserves inclusion here, conversely, he probably deserves more plaudits in retrospect. 


3. Shawn Michaels

Shawn Michaels 1997
WWE.com

Shawn Michaels thought nothing of burying his peers in the pro wrestling brotherhood if it meant that he could eliminate any threats to his main event position. He was also so self-interested that his nose would stream and his red eyes would itch whenever he came into contact with almost losing a title. He felt something coming on when it was time for the Dudes With Attitudes to drop the WWF Tag Team championships. In reality, Diesel was days away from winning the WWE title. He could hardly lose a lesser belt to Sparky Plugg. But if you track Shawn’s first singles run, between 1992 and 1998, you’ll note many more good excuses. 

In fact, it took the Undertaker threatening to break Shawn’s ass in half for him to finally do a proper job in a title match for the next Hulk Hogan at WrestleMania 14. Shawn would later publicly embarrass the actual Hulk Hogan, at SummerSlam 2005, in revenge for doing the job. Shawn undermined Vader, at SummerSlam 1996, throwing a mid-match conniption fit over a timing error. Shawn - and this was horrific even by the standards of wrestling politics, but is rarely talked about, since it was overshadowed by the Montreal Screwjob - petitioned to win the European title from Davey Boy Smith at One Night Only. The Bulldog had vowed to win it in honour of his dying sister. Davey probably shouldn’t have talked so adamantly in the build, even if he was set to win the match originally - but it was still an awful thing to do on Shawn’s part. He didn’t need the lowly, tertiary belt, and it meant nothing to him. He dropped it to Triple H in a sham comedy match that the DX buddies only pretended to wrestle in. So how did Michaels get away with it? 

(Bret Hart has a somewhat homophobic explanation, claiming that Shawn performed sexual favours for Vince McMahon in order to be the top guy and behave unchecked. Jim Ross has called BS on that.)

It’s not as if Shawn was a box office draw; if anything, the opposite was true. Shawn had one exhibit to justify his ego: on March 17, 1996, he teamed with Diesel in a match against Bret Hart and the Undertaker that both set a record high house show gate and sold out Madison Square Garden. This was the first non-PPV sell-out since the mid-1980s. Thought to be a good omen ahead of his WWF title win at WrestleMania 12, fate instead told him to suck it. Shawn was a poor draw. His main event against Vader at SummerSlam was a disaster. Drawing just 157,000 buys, this was down 30% from SummerSlam 1995. And Mabel headlined that show. 

1997 was meant to be bigger than most Royal Rumble shows. In a way, it was. On top of the titular attraction, Shawn Michaels was going to win his WWF title back from Sycho Sid in his hometown of San Antonio, Texas. The 60,000+ attendance was very much inflated - 20,000 of the 48,000 who actually paid did so using $5-7 coupons with Taco Bell orders - and the show was down 27% from Royal Rumble 1996 on PPV. 

In what Bret might deem a karmic twist of fate, Shawn went on indefinite hiatus as soon as the WWF exploded in popularity at WrestleMania 14, and returned in 2002, unable to arrest the tumbling downfall.


2. The Hurt Syndicate

The Hurt Syndicate Shelton Benjamin MVP Bobby Lashley
AEW

Shelton Benjamin is almost the definition of a solid hand. 

Standards were lower in the 2000s. WWE was the only major operation in the United States, by which time Vince McMahon had lost both the ability and the necessity to build new stars. Fans projected top star potential onto many wrestlers who were very good, but not intangibly great, because there were so few options. Benjamin was not especially charismatic, and could not talk, but he had a banger in him at a time when the banger was still rare and special. Impressive longevity, meant to be a swell guy, but he was not and is not a pro wrestling star. Bobby Lashley is, at least to a further extent. 

When he won the WWE title on the March 1, 2021 Monday Night Raw, he initially proved a modest ratings hit with the male 18-34 demographic. His YouTube clips sometimes ranked #5 from that given week’s episode of Raw, which was hardly great for the WWE champion. Lashley held the belt for 196 days in 2021: the year in which AEW Dynamite, for one hot summer, closed the gap. Lashley did not haemorrhage viewers, and was not exactly responsible for Vince McMahon’s weekly creative atrocities, but you can’t call him a great draw, either, even though some of his quarter hours yielded standout numbers compared to the rest of the show. 

Lashley’s big title loss to Big E on September 13, which only happened as a result of Dynamite’s narrow key demo win the week prior, wasn’t a draw. In fact, Dynamite (0.44) eked past the Raw demo number again (0.43). A once-in-an-era set of circumstances informed this aberration, and the inaugural Monday Night Football show annihilated Raw, but the number was still really bad even with that context in mind. MVP was never a big draw, either. 

Collectively, the Hurt Business were pushed big on Raw, in 2020, when WWE reached the bottom. The ratings had never been worse. (The pandemic hardly helped, granted.) Fans were sympathetic. The booking was typically abysmal, which was a particular shame, since the stable looked so much like stars. Hardcore fans bemoaned the missed opportunity on seemingly every other Reddit thread. MVP also sensed that the Hurt Business boasted huge potential. He constantly questioned why the stable was de-emphasised and broken up. He couldn’t let it go - so much so that the faction, minus Cedric Alexander, made its way to AEW as the Hurt Syndicate in 2024. 

The early run was awesome. They picked the coolest possible synonym for the trademarked ‘Business’; Shelton Benjamin was booked very strong early, thus avoiding the designated jobber stigma; the World Tag Team title win over Private Party was a chest-pounding elongated squash.  

At some point, though, the idea that the Hurt Syndicate should be a big deal was conflated. Without boosting business in any appreciable way, dreaded stories followed the Hurt Syndicate around. Bobby Lashley Vs. Swerve Strickland didn’t get a rematch. MJF was booted from the group in such a way that “abruptly” was a synonym for “suspiciously”. (Dave Meltzer subsequently reported that an unnamed core member did not want MJF involved.) Various reports buried MVP and his Miro-style ex-WWE guy ego. If this was overstated - MVP is said to be very generous with advice - he did not help himself by constantly talking over his rivals, and even his stablemates (!), in awkward promo segments. If all this chat was inconclusive, the finish to the World Tag Team title three-way at Forbidden Door was almost incontrovertible. 

Brodido dethroned the Syndicate in a three-way match by pinning FTR. The holders did a 1990s-style non-job. It didn’t matter much in the end, since fans loved Brodido regardless, but come on. That’s as sly as it gets. 

On the subject of that ex-WWE guy ego…


1. The Modern Ex-WWE Club

Miro AEW
AEW

Some dishonourable mentions to complete the list. 

WWE is incredible at brainwashing. It takes some fans a while to look past the production values of a new company, when they first grow angry at WWE’s booking and wish to seek out an alternative. How good can it be, really? The word-of-mouth is strong, and the critics rave about it, but it looks like sh*t!

Some WWE fans never make that breach. They either stick with WWE, even if passively, or they end their journey with wrestling there and then. WWE has for years marketed itself as the recognised global leader. At this point, WrestleMania is more important than money to the vast majority of pro wrestlers, who are almost more susceptible to this level of conditioning. 

Nixon Newell - allegedly - was unhappy with a 2025 AEW Collision booking, so much so that she and tag team partner Miranda Alize walked out of the taping after trying, and apparently failing, to finagle their way into getting more minutes (the title does not specify whether the wrestlers were any good at playing politics). 

Malakai Black - again, this is all alleged, you will have to take the professional wrestler’s word for it - was said to not have enjoyed getting pinned. It must be nothing more than a coincidence that Malakai took the pin on a once-per-year basis. 

Similarly, Miro was said to have the dreaded “I’ve been in WWE, I refuse to job in this rinky-dink mud show” attitude too, which might explain why he was only cleanly defeated by Sammy Guevara and Bryan Danielson in singles action. Probably just a coincidence again, though. Miro actually did well as TNT champion, quarter hours-wise, but he - allegedly! - acted like Andre the Giant under Vince McMahon, Sr.

If those alleged rumours are to be believed, both men had their phones on silent when asked to do a job. Again, though, those near-immaculate win/loss records, suspicious for two wrestlers never considered PPV headliners, are probably just coincidental.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!