3 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE Unreal Season 2 (Review)

The good, the bad, and the ugly of WWE Unreal Season 2.

WWE Unreal Seth Rollins Becky Lynch
WWE

Season 2 of WWE's controversial reality series, 'WWE Unreal', is now available on Netflix.

Across five new episodes, there is a focus on the private lives of some of WWE's biggest stars, and a look behind the scenes at what life is like for the talents who make up the world's largest wrestling promotion. Among the featured highlights of this new season, Becky Lynch and Seth Rollins show us what it's like to live as a family on the road, and there's an inside look behind last year's first-ever two-night SummerSlam PLE.

As with the first season of WWE Unreal, there is a lot to get into across the full five-episode sophomore season, and not all of it is as satisfying as fans might hope. At times, it's hard to determine how much reality is in this Reality TV exposé of life in the WWE. While there are moments that feel genuinely revealing and heartfelt, there's also plenty of revisionist history that will have fans questioning how well they themselves really remembered the events of 2025.

These are the best and worst moments from Season 2 of WWE Unreal.


DOWNS

5. Michael Hayes

WWE Unreal Michael Hayes
WWE

Michael Hayes is the ultimate company guy. Asking him to be fair and critical of WWE is like asking Burger King to give you an honest review of a Whopper. Hayes would break his back to justify any decision made by WWE, and that blind loyalty is on full display throughout WWE Unreal.

Naomi and Sasha Banks were two of hundreds of performers to suffer creative disrespect at the whims of Vince McMahon. Rather than carry out his latest ridiculous booking decisions, the pair took matters into their own hands in May 2022 by handing in their Tag Team Championships and leaving Monday Night Raw on the day of the show. The pair were presented with a plan that Naomi would pin her tag team partner in a Six Pack Challenge, only for both her and Banks to lose their upcoming PLE matches to Bianca Belair and Ronda Rousey, respectively, and so the pair unanimously decided that enough was enough.

Most fans sympathized with the champions in the moment, and continue to retrospectively, but when Naomi recounted the story for Unreal, Hayes was shown defending WWE. It has seen a massive online backlash for justified reasons. Add to this that Hayes is seen gleefully dribbling over the controversial return of Brock Lesnar at the end of Episode 5, suggesting that fans loved being surprised by that, when most were actually disgusted by the reemergence of The Beast for his alleged part in the Vince McMahon and Janel Grant case, and you have a terrible overall look for The Freebird.


4. The Idea of Pat McAfee Beating Gunther

Gunther Pat McAfee
WWE

Gunther is the envy of every wrestling promotion on Earth. A one-of-a-kind in-ring performer, the enormous Austrian is the natural successor to Brock Lesnar when it comes to being the main event scene's alpha male villain character. He is a winning machine who has set WWE records and lives at the top of the food chain.

Gunther losing his World Heavyweight Championship at WrestleMania 41 felt like a natural decision, given the fan momentum that Jey Uso had going for him and how much stock WWE had put in the Yeeting superstar to become a merch-selling behemoth. Gunther then entered a program with Pat McAfee and Michael Cole, in which he would play the schoolyard bully, taking out his WrestleMania frustrations on the lovable commentary duo who delighted in his downfall.

McAfee is one of America's most notorious broadcasters, and his willingness to accept a match with Gunther at Backlash sold him as a lovable everyman who wouldn't accept The Ring General's disrespect towards Michael Cole. Hearing Bruce Prichard pitch that McAfee should pick up a win against the record-breaking, dominant main eventer in Episode 1 of WWE Unreal was as close to insanity as it's possible to get. There has never been a clearer indication that Bruce was Vince McMahon's biggest enabler when it comes to bad booking decisions that piss off fans than this moment right here.


3. Road Dogg

Road Dogg
WWE

As one half of The New Age Outlaws, Brian 'Road Dogg' James was a star of the Attitude Era. His iconic mic work deployed during his tag team's entrance remains a work of brilliance, but WWE Unreal makes for some incredibly uncomfortable viewing as he attempts to do his job as Head of Creative for SmackDown.

Listening to him disclose his lack of ideas for the Women's United States Championship is painful, as he flounders on creative planning for a potential second run with the belt for Chelsea Green. As that particular title has suffered from bad creative and a lack of direction on SmackDown for much of its existence, it can't help but reflect badly on Road Dogg's seemingly nonexistent forward planning.

Crashing out in the writer's room as he attempts to justify a valid reason for R-Truth cutting his hair in Episode 2 is similarly awkward viewing. There must be more to Road Dogg's positive contributions to WWE, but it's hard for fans to see him be so ponderous on the company's own reality show and not feel as if he is only in a position of privilege because of his long-standing friendship with Paul Levesque.


2. Portrayal Of Fans

WWE Unreal Triple H
WWE

Wrestling fans are proudly one of the most obsessive fanbases in all of pop culture fandom. They have a 24/7 news cycle that they follow religiously, which includes a massive interest in all shows and performers, from the indie circuit and lesser-featured televised wrestlers to the biggest names in the business.

As well as being incredibly focused on the product, wrestling fans have learned to become a cynical bunch. A business that is built upon surprising the audience means the audience has learned to question everything. This couldn't be further from the portrayal of fans on WWE Unreal. Close-up slow-motion shots of excited fans with mouths agape are shown to make every decision the booking team has made look like home runs.

The idea here is to make it seem like WWE's creative team is a group of super geniuses (and Road Dogg). This portrays the writer's room to Netflix's more mainstream audience as having every fan's number. Seth Rollins' fake knee injury is sold as a swerve for the ages, but was widely reported way ahead of its SummerSlam reveal, and Becky Lynch's return at WrestleMania 41 had little of the "shock and awe" that Unreal attempts to sell. Pretending these reveals were moments that fans adored via camera tricks and production techniques shows a disingenuous portrayal of the modern wrestling fan.


1. The R-Truth Saga

WWE Unreal R-Truth
WWE

The news that R-Truth and WWE were parting ways was one of the most shocking moments of 2025. Truth was on the run of a lifetime. He had been one of the best parts of The Judgment Day's electric run in 2023 and 2024, and his comedic contributions have been so universally praised that he is without question a future WWE Hall of Famer.

Episode 2 of Unreal focuses on this contractual dispute and attempts to cast a new narrative on what led to Truth's "dismissal". The show suggests that WWE didn't believe Truth was worth the salary he was being paid, and that the company attempted to scare him into taking reduced terms by not offering to extend his contract. Triple H saying that, "Truth was never not with the company", and suggesting he had run to the internet to say he'd been fired, is a severely rose-tinted look at the incident.

TKO is a company charging fans unprecedented ticket prices. R-Truth is one of the most popular members of the WWE locker room, and unquestionably the funniest performer the company has. The idea that Unreal floats is that Truth pulled a coup on WWE. Fans would argue that they pay their money for subscriptions, merch, and tickets to watch the best entertainers that WWE can provide. To suggest Truth doesn't meet that criteria is shameful, and Unreal's suggestion that he'd somehow conned the audience into believing he'd been fired to be paid more than he is worth is an argument that's weaker than a James Ellsworth bearhug.


UPS

3. The Original SummerSlam Plans

WWE Raw Finn Balor Dominik Mysterio
WWE

One of the most interesting elements of WWE Unreal has been the whiteboard in the writer's room. A close look at this seemingly innocuous background prop has given fans some of the juiciest post-season discussion points from WWE Unreal.

A look at the whiteboard in Season 2 of WWE Unreal reveals that the original plans for SummerSlam 2025 looked much different than how the PLE actually panned out. Only the World Heavyweight Championship showdown between Gunther and CM Punk survived from the original plans for the first-ever two-night SummerSlam.

'Demon' Finn Balor was originally booked to take on his Judgment Day stablemate, Dominik Mysterio. A blockbuster encounter between Roman Reigns and Bron Breakker seemed set to happen, as well as a Bella Twins reunion to take on Liv Morgan and Raquel Rodriguez. Seeing these speculative matches is one of the most fun aspects for fans and one of the few ways in which Unreal feels like a genuine peek behind the curtain.


2. Paul Heyman's Honesty

WWE Unreal Paul Heyman
WWE

Paul Heyman is one of the most universally respected figures in all of pro wrestling. A savant who has been in the business long enough to have worked with Vince McMahon Snr., and is contemporary enough to relate to the likes of Bron Breakker and Liv Morgan, his nickname of The Oracle feels as accurate as it does grandiose. In a show that can sometimes feel like a propaganda piece, Heyman being openly critical of WWE Unreal's existence felt like a vital component to this season.

Heyman is mostly used to explain the importance of making the audience believe in what you're selling, as an accompaniment to Seth Rollins' 2025 fake knee injury storyline in Episode 3. He talks about wrestling's past, explaining that you would be beaten and ostracised from the industry for exposing the business in the days of old. He's brilliant when selling wrestling as performance art, telling the famous story of The Sandman selling an eye-injury in ECW that involved not leaving his house to preserve fans' belief that Tommy Dreamer had injured him for real.

Hearing Heyman say he's not a fan of Unreal is an important nod to the intellect behind pro wrestling. He points out that wrestling lives and dies on the audience's belief in what is happening in WWE's stories, and how that becomes a more difficult endeavor when you're giving everyone a new level of access as a result of Unreal's existence. When WWE spends a lot of Unreal pretending that the audience is gullible, someone of Heyman's stature acknowledging the dangers of giving too much away is an important and gratifying aside.


1. Iyo Sky

WWE Unreal Iyo Sky
WWE

Iyo Sky had one of the best years of her career in 2025. A lovable badass who has always dazzled fans who are in the know, Iyo went supernova last year, as she cemented her place as one of the most popular babyfaces in the company through non-stop incredible matches and off-the-chart charisma.

If there is an argument for WWE Unreal to exist, it's to sell the person behind the performer. Hard Knocks in the NFL and All Or Nothing in the Premier League are behind-the-scenes shows that work at their best when showing the human side of the athletes you watch give their all every week. WWE Unreal did this excellently with Rhea Ripley in Season 1, and does it even better with Iyo Sky in this new season.

Triple H does a fantastic job of explaining how Iyo's the nicest person ever, and the warmth he has for her in candid backstage moments is incredibly endearing. Hearing Iyo drop an F-bomb is the most quotable moment from the show to date. There are also affecting moments involving Lyra Valkyria in tears after her SummerSlam match goes awry, and a visibly distraught LA Knight after he misses a spot at Money In The Bank. If there's a blueprint for what works best to sell WWE to the casual Netflix viewer while providing diehard fans with something of substance, it's in these segments and moments that show who the men and women of WWE are away from the ring.


Contributor

Terry Bezer hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.