Violent & Bloody AEW Matches That Made Us SICK!
Kenny Omega: more hardcore than Tommy Dreamer.
On the Full Gear 2019 go-home episode of Dynamite, Jon Moxley promised the audience a level of "glorious" pro wrestling violence "the likes of which this country has not witnessed in decades".
As with much of AEW's early messaging, it was barely-coded subtext. The actual point Mox made was that his Lights Out match with Kenny Omega wouldn't be a WWE-style hardcore match. They'd go much further than the odd kendo stick shot and table spot. There would be barbed wire. There would be glass.
There would be blood.
AEW's history is awash with claret - too much, many feel. The promotion has calmed down somewhat; last year, in an object-defeating exercise, Mox bled so often that he became a meme. The audience had become desensitised to violence. Part of AEW's current problem, the bleak extent to which domestic business is soft, lies in the fact that the audience is desensitised to everything: match quality, the shock jump debut, the novelty of major arena competition altogether.
Even in 2023, when that audience has seen everything, AEW is still capable of conjuring that visceral feeling of sickening violence so compelling that you can and cannot stomach it at the same time.
The violence - still - is glorious...
10. Blackpool Combat Club Vs. Best Friends, Eddie Kingston & Penta El Zero Miedo - All In: London
Stadium Stampede III was not as chaotic nor as epic as the first Anarchy In The Arena match, nor was it as as spectacular as the second, but it was probably the nastiest crowd brawl of the three.
The first AITA match was an impossibly great exercise in controlled chaos. The second was more staged, lacking that ungodly intensity, but - as you'll discover - it was sickening in its own way.
The third, lacking in novelty, compensated with the sheer level of violence.
In an iconic visual, one that lovingly toyed with the contrast of Wembley's über-mainstream backdrop, Penta planted skewers in Jon Moxley's head. The reaction when Mox tapped the skewers with his finger, allowing them to bloom, was incredible. A huge swell of awe-inspired disgust reverberated around a gigantic monolith of a packed stadium.
Before the chaos of the finishing sequence, in which - and this is a feature - the director could not cut between the brutality quick enough, the key sequence relied on the annihilation of Trent. In order to draw Sue into the save, Trent had to get wrecked, and get wrecked he did.
When Mox swiped at his legs, after Trent collided with a suspended ladder skull-first with the quickness of a light switch, the subsequent beat-down was so cruel and relentless that Mox, too good for his own good, was received as a true heel for the first time.
9. The Elite Vs. Blackpool Combat Club - Double Or Nothing 2023
Again: Anarchy In The Arena II, while outstanding, was not as magic as the first, ultra-chaotic match.
Much as the reunion of Kenny Omega and Hangman Page was euphoric to those who fell in love with AEW in its first year, nothing could touch the iconic visual of Eddie Kingston, doused in blood, shuffling to the ring with a gas can. That sequence was something beyond perfect. Eddie - and how impossible was this? - looked like he wanted to kill a man. You can't just do that in a wrestling context. You must be some degree of genius as a worker to pull that off.
The second match however was, quite literally, a blast: Matt Jackson working a secret explosion spot with a bomb-laced superkick to Jon Moxley's face was such an inspired idea.
Built around the Elite slowly coming together again with roof-raising tandem offence, prior to the finish - which proved that the Blackpool Combat Club, by relying on Konosuke Takeshita, could not match a united Elite - Matt Jackson built on his shoe Lore. It was removed from his foot, and in an exceptional gross-out moment, that foot was planted into thumbtacks.
This induced a revolted shudder. Everybody has stepped on a plug, and everybody felt his pain vicariously.
8. Best Friends Vs. Santana & Ortiz - Dynamite,
Much latitude was extended to the closed-set Daily's Place era of AEW Dynamite.
It wasn't the same, at all, but people wanted it to be OK. In a weird sort of way, it worked. There was no alternative, which helped. Everybody was stuck, and to his immense credit, Austin Gunn was such a convincing super-fan plant. His energy at ringside was, in a not insignificant way, as important to AEW as some star signings.
The wrestlers-as-plants gimmick was never more convincing than during the first Parking Lot Fight between Best Friends and Santana and Ortiz. You could believe they were losing their collective minds because you were too. The layout - and the degree of violence - was astonishing.
It was a masterpiece, the absolute pinnacle of pandemic wrestling. Beyond the original Terry Funk Vs. Jerry Lawler Empty Arena match, it was the only closed-set spectacle that truly worked outside of that context.
It was a frenzied, disgusting brawl, one that deftly incorporated wrestling sequences without ever feeling even remotely contrived. The hybrid was seamless. Using the bumper of a pick-up truck as a platform for a tornado DDT was inspired, as was hiding a crowbar above the rim of a wheel. That DDT was taken on concrete, too. Absolutely brutal.
Every splatter into glass looked and sounded utterly vile. The echoey confines of the lot also lent an aural horror to the match: every metallic clink reverberated throughout your bones.
A triumph. An incredibly painful triumph.
7. Kenny Omega Vs. Jon Moxley - Dynamite, May 10 2023
Your favourite wrestler, a wimp, bumps on their back. They, feeble and weak, want to spread the pain across a large surface area.
The real best wrestler, Kenny Omega, bumps on his perineum because he is a beast.
In an awesome spot that looked even more deranged and committed for it going awry, Omega attempted to smash Jon Moxley out of the cage with a V-Trigger. He however did not legislate for AEW's very weird cage. Already unreasonably tall, there is a thin albeit solid steel bar a quarter of the way up each wall.
Why?
Who the hell knows, but when the gimmicked bit of mesh blew open, Omega did not fly out of the ring and onto the floor; he instead landed taint-first on said bar. This was one of the most wince-inducing spots in AEW history.
Compounding that, the rest of the match was also phenomenally violent, since Omega and Mox have told a long-term story of their killing one another, and in one particularly sickening (read: awesome) moment, Omega placed a chair wrapped in barbed wire over Mox's back.
When he performed a double foot stomp, the force of the strike caused the wire to drag and scrape across Mox's back.
6. Chris Jericho Vs. Nick Gage - Fight For The Fallen 2021
For a wrestler who is supposed to be an artless death match merchant, Nick Gage is actually great.
Even if he wasn't, he exudes such badass presence that it wouldn't matter. Gage is a wrestler better experienced than analysed, but even then, he knows what he's doing. He knows how to evoke a deep, visceral response from the audience.
Case in point: the pizza cutter.
People hate this. People are disgusted by this. People, when they see it, want this sick filth banned.
It is a weapon easy to work with that is only visually horrifying, and people act like it will turn anybody's head into Abdullah the Butcher's overnight after one (1) application. This obviously is not the case, but the pizza cutter works on a different level to, say, a chair or table. You've used a pizza cutter. You can feel the fear, since it's likely you've come close to slicing off the tip of your finger when hacking up some frozen monstrosity with a breadstick masquerading as a crust. Nick Gage knows the spaces between moves as well as anybody.
The match was also sickening as a result of its liberal, disgusting - and exhilarating - use of glass. Glass carries an altogether different threat in that it could really mess somebody up if things went awry.
5. Thunder Rosa Vs. Dr. Britt Baker - St. Patrick's Day Slam 2021
One of the best matches in AEW history, Thunder Rosa Vs. Dr. Britt Baker was absolutely shocking.
A women's main event? On Dynamite?!
Yes, but beyond that, the extent of the violence was unsettling. It didn't lack for spectacular set-pieces, but it was a match better for its tone and sense of struggle; even when doing something as simple as re-entering the ring, Baker was smothered by Rosa. There was nothing clean here. She scratched at and shoved Rosa away just to find enough space to throw a thrust kick at her jaw. The masterpiece of the AEW women's division, every second counted.
One sequence in particular churned the gut. More so than a brutal collision into a ladder, the sort of thing that adrenaline could override in the moment, watching Rosa tear her own back up in thumbtacks to reverse the Lockjaw into a pin attempt was shudder-inducing. The spot put over her sheer will to win in a match that can often act as an excuse to perform cool spots.
Nasty and attritional, the violence was not always glorious - but all the more effective as a result.
4. Cody Vs. Dustin Rhodes - Double Or Nothing 2019
Very few weapons were used in what remains a timeless AEW masterpiece.
Cody Vs. Dustin Rhodes was a seminal match. There are few things better than watching something become unforgettable in real time. You didn't just not look at your smartphone during it; you forgot your smartphone existed. The two brothers locked the audience into a spell. They captured so many feelings - panic, hope, despair, even laughter - in an ultra-dramatic tale of a cocky younger brother getting a literal spanking off his heroic, but doomed, sibling.
The sickening element, for once, had nothing to do with rampant bloodlust. Quite the opposite: fans were sick to their stomachs watching on, nervous at Dustin's jelly-legged, blood-soaked plight. He lost a great deal of blood. The canvas looked like the floor of an abattoir.
But Dustin sold his end to perfection using the dark arts. Every tiny movement held enormous meaning; even as he lifted his shoulder off the mat when trapped in the figure-four, the fans erupted, relieved that he was not actually dead. This was a pure extraction of drama. The very simplest things mattered to a profound degree.
Sickened with fear, the AEW production crew captured people who were in tears at the match.
3. The Elite Vs. Blackpool Combat Club - AEW Blood & Guts 2023
As with every modern WarGames match, the Elite Vs. Blackpool Combat Club was overlong and baggy and undermined by too many ideas. That the big blow-off to a feud that never felt all that urgent and personal to begin with almost existed to set up the main event of a Ring Of Honor pay-per-view didn't help the lack of purpose, but AEW promised - and delivered - Blood and Guts.
Jon Moxley looked like he had been mutilated with multiple sharp objects, and that's because he had, but the visual was more consistent with a gore-fest horror flick than even an ultra-violent plunder brawl. He was smothered in the stuff, as if buckets had been thrown at him from point blank range.
Again, the match at times felt like an excuse to do a spot-fest with weapons, although the way in which it was all sequenced was deeply impressive. The plunder was expertly assembled to make it seem as though Nick Jackson, in a hardcore update of his awesome hot tag, had happened upon piles of broken glass on which to lacerate the faces of the BCC.
In the best spot, Kenny Omega took a Mox John Woo dropkick into a screwdriver tip board. That was an excellent idea; it's an old carnival trick, one that dovetailed into a key theme of the programme, and was safer than it looked in the gruesome moment.
But the real sickening moment followed moments later, when Omega scraped his arm on the way down. From his mad scramble, he looked as though he'd shredded his flesh for real.
2. Kenny Omega Vs. Joey Janela - Dark, October 15 2019
Kenny Omega thinks more deeply about his craft than any other wrestler.
Sorry for the bathos here, because it seems to not be very thoughtful at all, but sometimes, the most inspired ideas are very simple, and on of all thing an episode of Dark, Omega took a bump on the underside of a table. The visual and noise of his upper body colliding with the flat metal legs was grotesque.
Now, if you think about it, the surface area aspect notwithstanding, this wasn't all too dissimilar to a wrestler taking a chair over the back, which tends to happen on every single episode of mainstream US television wrestling - but it was so novel that it looked and somehow felt more painful than it perhaps was in reality.
The match wasn't especially deep nor intricate. A simple back-and-forth duel designed for the Omega character to train himself in Jon Moxley's specialist genre - each had defeated Janela under the same stipulation, rendering the Full Gear Lights Out match more unpredictable - this was still notable for the sheer "That must have absolutely sucked to take" factor.
Built around executing spots on narrow blunt objects - like the upright row of chairs pictured above - Omega and Janela might as well have taken turns bumping on a roadside curb for 26 minutes. Gross and a bit wasteful, since it should have happened on Dynamite, but intoxicating all the same.
On the subject of Full Gear 2019...
1. Kenny Omega Vs. Jon Moxley - AEW Full Gear 2019
This match was so sickening that Dave Meltzer momentarily turned into Gandhi. He despised how bloody and violent it was - rating it ****1/2.
Jon Moxley's wife, Renee Paquette, took to Twitter to register her disgust. She could not believe what she was seeing and seemed to not endorse it.
Complaints were made to the local athletic commission!
It's almost quaint how naively the match was received, which isn't to say it wasn't incredibly dangerous or unsettling. It's not as if taking a bump on a mousetrap board looked like a walk on crunchy leaves on a chilly autumnal day.
Still, the magic was in the work: real, flesh-tearing barbed wire was used early. The barbed wire used on the spiderweb contraction on which Omega bumped - the "great artist", as Mox called him in the build - was heavily gimmicked. But by that time, in a classic wrestling grift, the lie was much easier to believe when you had been shown a glimmer of the truth.
Cute in places - Mox did in fact literally chain wrestle Omega - it was horrendous(ly awesome) in others. A long fight, so gruelling that only something awful could decide it, something awful did.
Omega - who took a Tiger Driver '91 and didn't think much of it - recalled with horror on WOR the bump he took on the exposed wooden boards when missing a Phoenix splash.
The collision was so sickening that it was as if he'd been thrown ten storeys to the ground below