Why Everyone Is Wrong About THIS WrestleMania 39 Car Crash
THIS 'Mania match is either going to be glorious or a disaster, but it'll be must-see.
When you look at WrestleMania cards throughout the years, it can best be described as a sports entertainment stew.
There are a bunch of different ingredients that all simmer together to produce the final product: a technical masterpiece between some of the best wrestlers in the world; an epic collision between two behemoths; aerial displays that leave you breathless; a celebrity wrestler doing the impossible inside the squared circle; and a spectacle so fantastic that, like a car crash on the side of the road, you just can’t look away, no matter how gruesome the scene.
Sometimes, matches embody more than one of those categories and become truly memorable WrestleMania moments that stand the test of time. Maybe they’re not five-star classics, but they’re the stuff that gets even casual fans and non-wrestling fans buzzing because they’ve witnessed something that they almost never have seen.
This year, we’ve got that spectacle, that car crash that should get that buzz in the stadium: Of course, that describes Brock Lesnar versus Omos.
Sure, this match already has been divisive as hell among fans – even this writer was initially skeptical – and it might be the bathroom break match for many. But when you step back, and then really dive into the particulars, you’re left realizing that this has all the makings of a good call, even if it came from the bird brain of the despicable Vince McMahon.
Were there other options that might have been better? Absolutely. This column isn’t suggesting Brock/Omos is a dream match, but it’s not necessarily the godawful disaster some people make it out to be. Let's not forget that fans crapped all over other spectacle matches like Sami Zayn/Johnny Knoxville, Logan Paul/Roman Reigns and others when they were announced, so there is precedent for minds being changed on the night.
CONT’D… (1 of 6)
For starters, let’s establish that the Brock Lesnar formula is played out. It’s been a great 11-year run, but there’s become a cheat code to Brock matches of spammed finisher sprints against a select few individuals. Quite simply for Lesnar: he gets a payday per minute worked that would make your head hurt.
And while that’s good for Brock, it’s not good for the wrestling product. When you see a Lesnar match against Roman Reigns, Bobby Lashley, Cain Velasquez, Seth Rollins or whomever stands in his way, you know you’re most likely getting an aggressive sprint of both men throwing each other around and swinging for the fences from the bell. There’s no nuance, no big strategy, just big meaty men slapping meat.
While that can make for a highly entertaining car crash itself, when you’ve seen it five or six times, the return on investment of seeing guys kicking out of each other’s finisher for five minutes diminishes quickly.
That’s not to say that Paul Heyman should scrap the formula for good, but it would be advisable to mix in a few new approaches and offer a variety. Brock has always been at his most interesting when he’s facing a variety of opponents. Think about his matches against AJ Styles and Daniel Bryan. Those were fun styles clashes (pun intended) that gave us something different.
Lately though, not so much.
CONT’D… (2 of 6)
You don’t have to look any further than the recent triumvirate of Lesnar matches against Lashley, which presented as a dream match on paper. The two never overlapped during their initial runs in WWE. They both left and won World titles in other companies. Both men found success in MMA. Still, their paths never intersected.
The feud wrote itself, particularly after WWE had successfully rehabbed the All Mighty into a killer and not a guy running obstacle courses and dealing with his “sisters.”
But after three matches, it’s safe to say that the fans have tapped out.
These clashes should have been epic: two bulls bouncing off each other and using different tactics because their usual method of overpowering an opponent wouldn’t work in these instances. (Think about Big Show versus Braun Strowman, where they actually did some chain wrestling.)
But the Brock formula didn’t allow for much deviation, so we got what we got: hard-hitting but unimaginative matches with screwy finishes. By now, the feud has got to be colder than Roman Reigns’ march to the title at WrestleMania 31… and 32… and 34.
Thus, WWE stuck a fork in Lashley/Lesnar 4.
CONT’D… (3 of 6)
So, who does that leave for Brock to face at WrestleMania?
Gunther is the obvious fantasy matchup from the active roster, and maybe we’ll get that match before Lesnar’s time in WWE is finished, but not this year.
Fightful Select has reported that there were offers made to Stone Cold Steve Austin to face Lesnar, but he declined last summer. Then came the proposed match probably everyone (including this writer) was salivating at: Brock versus Gunther. But for whatever reason, this plan also was nixed. A 'Mania match against Bray Wyatt also was considered, but plans changed again. Lashley/Lesnar is cooked.
Of all the remaining, viable opponents, who’s left who doesn’t already have concrete 'Mania plans? Braun Strowman? They haven’t faced each other in more than four years, so at least there’s a gap there. Drew McIntyre? Sheamus? Karrion Kross? All of these men would just plug into the formula. And while that might “work,” it most likely would be forgotten days after Mania when Brock is back on his farm hunting wild game.
Given a choice between a plug-and-play approach of sticking one of your hard-hitting workers in there with Brock and something that would have sideshow appeal for Mania, the choice becomes a bit more obvious.
CONT’D… (4 of 6)
Omos is nowhere near the worker of any of the men previously mentioned. He probably is the most limited wrestler Brock will have faced since he last wrestled Goldberg. So this will hardly be a technical affair. But then again, which of Lesnar’s recent matches have been?
Unlike many of Brock’s previous opponents, this challenger is going to be unique. As a first-time matchup, the question posed over and over from the announcers (and MVP) is whether Lesnar can actually throw Omos around with German suplexes as he’s accustomed, or whether he can hoist the Nigerian Giant onto his shoulders for an F-5.
Brock hasn’t faced too many men who are that much bigger than him. Big Show and Braun Strowman jump to mind, but Omos is a good half-foot taller than Braun and can see over the top of Show’s head. He also outweighs Strowman.
Omos also has only left his feet really once, against Bobby Lashley at WrestleMania 38 last year via a low-angle suplex. Brock’s entire offense is rooted in being able to manhandle and throw his opponents around like the proverbial sack of potatoes.
And that gives us the very simple story of whether this ageing combat sports veteran can rely on his go-to moves, or if he’ll have to get creative to topple this giant.
CONT’D… (5 of 6)
But perhaps the most obvious draw of this match is the pure spectacle of it all. Brock very rarely is the smaller man. In this case, he’ll be a full foot shorter and 120 pounds lighter than Omos.
You know WWE brass is salivating at the WrestleMania stare-down between Lesnar and Omos, which Michael Sidgwick accurately described as going “nose-to-navel.” They’re going to milk it for all it’s worth, while an entire stadium gasps at the size differential. (If WWE is smart, they’ll keep an actual static side-by-side between the two to a minimum until then. They could have Omos attack Brock on Raw, but don’t let them stand still next to each other – save that visual for Mania.)
Every time Lesnar goes for a German and fails, fans will rise in anticipation and fall in disappointment. When he finally succeeds in getting the Nigerian Giant off his feet, the crowd will lose their collective minds. If Brock manages an F-5 on Omos, the roof of SoFi Stadium might get blown off.
We know this is the case because we’ve seen it before. It might not be the typical Brock formula, but it’s a formula nonetheless that WWE has utilized several times in the past. Just last year, Bobby Lashley yanking Omos through a low-angle suplex sent fans into a frenzy. Imagine Brock pulling off multiple Germans and then an F-5. That’s the kind of spectacle that might even get some mainstream attention.
In the absence of any other truly unique opponents, this is the best option out there. It won’t be a “good” wrestling match, but Omos/Brock is going to make highlight reels one way or another, and it’s going to be a conversation piece. Sure, this match still could easily be a disaster on every level, but even that will be more memorable than a 4-minute spam finisher sprint with Drew McIntyre.
The best thing for fans to do is accept and embrace this deviation from the Brock formula for what it is: a car crash of epic proportions that you won’t be able to turn away from, no matter how many angry tweets you’ve fired off.