Why It's Time To FINALLY Kill The Worst Trope In Wrestling
WWE needs to stop besmirching the name of one Marty Jannetty.
By the very nature of the wrestling business, there are plentiful tired tropes that are revisited with frustrating frequency.
Like any form of entertainment, sports or general business practice, when something works well, there's a habit to replicate that something time and time again to achieve further success. The danger there, though, is that the more you copy an idea, the greater the risk you have of diluting what was so great about the concept in the first place - particularly when it comes to pro wrestling or, to appease Vince McMahon, sports entertainment, pal.
WWE isn't the only promotion who lazily fall back on familiar tropes of yesteryear, but the market leader is the worst culprit for rehashing moments from the past and for attempting to put a fresh spin on something that previously worked. More specifically, WWE likes to hammer its audience over the head with narratives that may not necessarily be entirely based on truth.
On that front, here we're exploring one of the most unfounded, inaccurate tropes that WWE has slapped its audience around the face with numerous times over the decades. To be exact, this is a trope that originated on an episode of WWF Wrestling Challenge which aired on 11 January 1992...
7. The Rise Of The Midnight Rockers
Throughout the late 1980s and into the early '90s, the World Wrestling Federation had a tag team division that was forever stacked.
Across those years, tandems such as the Hart Foundation, Demolition, the British Bulldogs, Strike Force, the Brain Busters, the Killer Bees, the Nasty Boys, Money Inc. the Natural Disasters and, of course, the Legion of Doom were pivotal parts of company programming. And then, well then there was the Rockers.
Made up of Marty Jannetty and Shawn Michaels, the Rockers fully arrived in the WWF in June 1988 - following an ill-fated cup of coffee with the promotion the prior year - and soon began mesmerising audiences with their frenetic, fresh, high-flying style.
The pairing of Jannetty and Michaels first came together in NWA Central States Wrestling in 1985, and '86 would see the duo land in Verne Gagne's AWA and become the Midnight Rockers. At this point, Marty had just turned 26 years of age, and Shawn was approaching his 21st birthday. In a promotion filled with various veteran talent, the Midnight Rockers were brought in as hot young act for company.
Tag Team Title success would come twice for Jannetty and Michaels during their time under the AWA banner, and their eventual 'proper' arrival in the WWF continued the white-hot momentum of these high-fiving, granny-kissing babyfaces. While they didn't officially win any gold during their time together in the WWF, the now-renamed Rockers were forever serenaded by excited shrieks and screams as they made their way to the ring as a true all-timer of an entrance theme played throughout WWF venues.
As ever in wrestling, though, all good things have to eventually come to an end...
6. Best Friends Blow Up At The Barber Shop
Why, Shawn, why?!?!?!?!
For many young wrestling fans who tuned into the 11 January 1992 edition of Wrestling Challenge, they had their heart broken by the man who would soon become known as the Heartbreak Kid.
Of course, it was that edition of Wrestling Challenge where Shawn Michaels turned on Marty Jannetty during an episode of Brutus Beefcake's Barber Shop talk show. While it may not be quite held up to the same level of a Piper's Pit, a King's Court, a Highlight Reel, a Cutting Edge or a Kevin Owens Show, the Barber Shop has a special place in history for being the home of one of the most notable break-ups in the annals of WWE.
In a kayfabe sense, tensions had been brewing between Michaels and Jannetty in the months leading up to that fateful night, with several significant losses being down to miscommunication. As such, that Barber Shop appearance was designed to repair the fractures between this beloved tag team. Deciding he'd had enough of his partner, it was here that Shawn superkicked Marty and threw him through Beefcake's Barber Shop window.
In reality, much of 1991 had been problematic for the Rockers as the relationship between the pair started to break down. So much so, the police were called after the two got in a very real fight at a hotel one night. The only reason why no arrests were handed out, was because Randy Savage managed to convince the cops that this fight was merely part of a wrestling storyline.
Regardless, the Rockers were done and dusted, and WWF had opted to split one of its most popular tag teams.
5. From Rockers To Rivals
With Shawn Michaels turning on Marty Jannetty, the plan was for these former partners to feud across 1992 and have a high profile singles match at WrestleMania VIII.
Sure, we did get a semblance of a rivalry between the two, but those greater designs for what many presumed would be a classic feud were immediately hindered by the behaviour of Marty. Just two weeks after the Wrestling Challenge break-up aired on TV, Jannetty was arrested outside a Tampa, Florida night club for drug charges and for resisting arrest.
Unfortunately for fans eager to see Michaels vs. Jannetty, this situation caused Marty to be placed under house arrest for six months and he was subsequently released by WWF.
Jannetty would eventually be rehired and return to WWF programming in October '92, but clearly that was long, long after WrestleMania VIII and what was intended to be a show-stealer of a match between these former partners. During Marty's time out of the company, Michaels had established himself as the hottest rising heel on the roster, taking the nefarious Sensational Sherri as his manager, fleshing out his cocksure Heartbreak Kid persona, and besting Davey Boy Smith to become the Intercontinental Champion.
Granted, Marty Jannetty's return on the 31 October 1992 episode of WWF Superstars - where he came out of the crowd to appear behind Shawn as the arrogant HBK admired himself in front of a mirror - received a huge pop, but clearly this was a case of striking while the iron was far from hot.
Michaels would successfully defend the IC Title against Jannetty at the 1993 Royal Rumble in an extremely solid bout... though Marty would again be fired soon after due to allegedly being drunk during that match. Still, he would return again in May, surprising his old partner in an impromptu match that saw Jannetty dethrone Shawn as the Intercontinental Champion.
Thanks to the arrival of Diesel, Michaels would regain that title just three weeks later, and the hotly-anticipated feud between the two immediately fizzled out as the pair went in different directions.
4. The Differing Career Paths
Shawn Michaels and Marty Jannetty clearly had very different career paths once the Rockers split in January '92.
Looking back on their respective careers in WWE terms, the Showstopper can lay claim to being a two-time Hall of Famer, a four-time World Champion, a three-time Intercontinental Champion, a one-time European Champion, a six-time Tag Team Champion, and a two-time Royal Rumble winner.
For Jannetty, he has that one Intercontinental Title win against his former partner, would later finally win the Tag Team Titles with the 1-2-3 Kid, formed the vanilla New Rockers with Leif Cassidy, and had forgettable spells in ECW and WCW while Michaels was busy headlining WrestleManias.
To clarify, your writer here is a major fan of the work of Marty Jannetty, but it's the comparison between the careers of the Rockers which has caused WWE to lazily create a false narrative that comes into play whenever there starts to be dissention between tag team partners. Even more so, it's a certain section of the wrestling fanbase that likewise throw this trope around whenever they discuss the possible break-up of a tandem.
3. The 'Jannetty' Of A Tag Team
To hone in on the title of this piece, the wrestling trope that needs to die is labelling a wrestler as the 'Jannetty' of their tag team.
Of course, this has recently been referenced on NXT programming, where the split of Toxic Attraction has seen Jacy Jayne insult former partner Gigi Dolin by calling her the Marty Jannetty of their tandem. Given how Shawn Michaels nowadays runs NXT, one could well say that this was an unnecessary comment that was green-lit by HBK, but it's not the first time that WWE and wrestling fans have used the name Jannetty to throw shade at a performer.
With many fans thinking that the Street Profits could well be on the verge of a split, already online discourse has declared how Angelo Dawkins will be the Jannetty of this team when they go their separate ways. Stevie Ray, Rick Steiner, Charlie Haas, D'Von Dudley, Chavo Guerrero, Bart Gunn, Joey Mercury, Matt Hardy, and even Chad Gable have all been labelled by fans as the Marty Jannetty of their tag team in order to demean these talents and their success when compared to their partners.
Truth be told, there's some extremely capable performers amongst those listed names, and most of them went on to have successful careers once their respective teams were split up.
2. Why The Jannetty Comparisons Are Lazy
The way that WWE and fans throw around the Jannetty term, it's done in a way that's supposed to lambast a performer as being an untalented wrestler who was only decent in a tag team due to the abilities of their partner. It's basically saying, "Marty Jannetty was the s**ts, was completely carried by his partner, and so too is Wrestler A of Generic Tag Team #1".
That statement, to borrow a word from the playbook of the late, great Mr. Perfect, is bogus.
Don't let the WWE narrative or online chatter fool you; Marty Jannetty was a phenomenal worker.
Jannetty was a fantastic in-ring talent before he ever teamed with Shawn Michaels, was a fantastic in-ring talent during his teaming with Michaels, and was a fantastic in-ring talent after his pairing with Shawn was over. A healthy Marty Jannetty was one of the very best, smoothest wrestlers in the then-WWF during his tenures with the company in the 1980s and '90s.
If you needed to get a great match out of a bang average wrestler, Marty was one of those talents - much like a Shawn Michaels or a Bret Hart - that WWF management could turn to. During their time together, the Rockers were absolutely equals in terms of wrestling talent and their ability to connect to the audience.
Of course Shawn Michaels completely ran with the ball and took himself to an entirely different level upon turning heel and embarking on the singles ranks in 1992, but Marty Jannetty likewise had the potential to be a genuine breakout babyface singles act following that split.
1. Where Did It Go Wrong For Marty Jannetty?
As mentioned, Marty Jannetty was a brilliant worker who legitimately had the in-ring ability to become a major player for the WWF in the 1990s - especially at a time when the company was giving main event opportunities to traditionally 'smaller' guys like Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels.
So, why didn't Marty reach the heights of his former partner or at least achieve more singles success than just one sole, brief run with the Intercontinental Title?
The truth of the matter is that Marty Jannetty's talent was never the problem and played zero role in what many perceive as being a fumbled career. Instead, it was Marty's habits away from the ring that caused Jannetty to not fulfil his vast promise.
At the biggest moment in his career, when the Rockers had split and Marty and Shawn were on a collision course at WrestleMania, Jannetty's arrest and subsequent firing put the breaks on that momentum and rivalry. Upon returning to the promotion later in 1992, Marty would again soon be fired to his own personal behaviour. Rehired in mid-1993, the next Jannetty run with the then-WWF lasted less than a year, and a return in late-'95 lasted barely 12 months.
Even a surprise rehire of the veteran Marty in 2005 was cut short due to another arrest, and a further shocking return in 2006 fell flat when Jannetty was once more fired due to a court order that prevented him from travelling outside of the state of Florida.
In reality, referring to a tag team wrestler as the Marty Jannetty of a pairing should mean they are a hugely talented grappler, one of the best in-ring workers of their time, but ultimately a flawed person hindered by their own personal demons. Regardless, throwing that 'Jannetty' name around as an insult is something that WWE needs to never do again.
Never forget, Marty Jannetty was absolutely great. Unfortunately, Marty Jannetty was and is also a tragically flawed individual whose demons have often gotten the better of him.