Why Tony Khan's AEW Nightmare Could Come True In January
A nightmare scenario could await Tony Khan and #AEW in early 2024.
While there have been plentiful positives for Tony Khan and All Elite Wrestling across 2023, there's also been some major bumps in the road for AEW. TV ratings have wavered, attendance numbers are down, talents are publicly voicing their creative frustrations (see: Matt Hardy), and there was the obvious attention CM Punk's brief return (and subsequent departure) brought with it.
Still, 2024 is now on the horizon, and Tony must surely be looking at this with nothing but a positive outlook. The majestic Will Ospreay is on the way, the ongoing Devil storyline is swirling along nicely, a refreshed heel Young Bucks should do wonders, the return of several key players - think Jamie Hayter, Thunder Rosa, PAC, and hopefully Kyle O'Reilly - is edging closer, there's the conclusion of the legendary Sting's retirement tour, and next year's All In show is already selling strongly.
Despite offering up a landscape of great possibilities though, the new year could turn sour for Tony Khan as soon as January. Yes, by the time the first month of 2024 is in the history books, one of Tony's nightmare scenarios may well have come true.
6. No, Not MJF's Bidding War Of 2024
While Maxwell Jacob Friedman departing AEW would clearly be a huge blow, that's not the topic of discussion here.
Sure, MJF has constantly talked up the Bidding War of 2024, but one has to imagine that the Salt of the Earth is already tied down with AEW long past January '24. In a kayfabe sense, Max's post-Double or Nothing 2022 walkout led to a pay increase for Friedman, but not necessarily an extension to the contract that's due to expire in January of next year.
In reality, while MJF would obviously be a huge 'get' and surely a huge success in WWE, it's tough to believe he'll be wrapped up with AEW in just over a month's time. Of course, don't expect that to be reflected in AEW programming, mind, for it would make a whole lot of sense to switch the AEW World Championship to Samoa Joe at the World's End PPV, in turn sparking chatter that Friedman dropped that title due to the uncertainty over his future.
But no, for the purpose of this article, the nightmare awaiting Tony Khan in early 2024 isn't the departure of MJF.
5. AEW As The Better, Obvious Option
Upon its launch, AEW was painted as an alternative to WWE. For fans and for talent, this was the ideal destination for those looking to avoid the nefarious, no-good ways of the Vince McMahon-led market leader. And truthfully, that was indeed the case for a good while.
From its inception, All Elite Wrestling immediately had a boost in credibility, in turn impacting perception, by having white-hot names like Kenny Omega and the Young Bucks very publicly choose to join this start-up in favour of being swayed by the money and mainstream platform of WWE. Added to that, a disgruntled Jon Moxley soon decided that AEW would be the perfect place for him to shake the shackles of that WWE environment and get the sour taste out of his mouth.
For anyone in doubt, the signing of such names indicated to the wrestling world that AEW was the place to be, and was viewed by some of the biggest stars in the industry as being a preferable option to a WWE who had essentially monopolised the industry for nearly 20 years.
Even with the recent announcement that Will Ospreay will be joining AEW in 2024 once his New Japan Pro-Wrestling deal is up, that was another example of one of the best wrestlers in the world showing his hand and proclaiming AEW as the place he sees best suited for his future - particularly with the Aerial Assassin having reportedly chosen AEW over WWE.
4. The Other Side Of The Coin
While certain talents turned down WWE in favour of AEW, one person to buck that trend by eventually going the other way, was Cody Rhodes.
A founding father of All Elite Wrestling, this one-time EVP and mainstay of AEW decided to take the opportunity to jump to WWE once his initial All Elite deal was up. And man, what a wise move that has proven to be.
Since returning to WWE, Cody Rhodes has been positioned as the top babyface in the entire promotion, has won the Royal Rumble, has headlined WrestleMania, has feuded with Brock Lesnar, has been endorsed by John Cena, and has been involved in countless other 'big time' moments and matches. Added to that, it's expected that he'll headline yet another WrestleMania when 'Mania XL rolls around; a WrestleMania where many believe Rhodes will finish his story, put an end to Roman Reigns' tyrannical grasp on SmackDown's top prize, and become the Undisputed WWE Universal Champion. And to think, Cody also faced a near-nine-month spell on the shelf as part of this second stint with the company.
Now, not everybody is a Cody Rhodes, but the American Nightmare has indicated that WWE is still an attractive proposition and is somewhere where a talent - even one associated with AEW - can thrive. We've seen countless examples over the years of WWE being hesitant to get behind a talent that's come from another promotion, and if ever the scummy temptation was there to purposely dump on anyone in that regard, surely it'd would be the person who previously slated your creative process, decided to start a rival company, and took plenty of shots at WWE once that company had launched.
But no, Cody is being valued for what he brings to the table, as reflected in the opportunities that have come his way and the way he's been positioned. If you're an AEW talent who's maybe not exactly ecstatic with how you're being used or with the direction the promotion is going, Rhodes has shown that WWE maybe isn't the petulant, grudge-holding behemoth it for so long was.
That's all without making mention of how big a deal Jade Cargill has been presented as in her fleeting appearances so far, how better a job has already been done with Brian Pillman Jr./Lexis King in NXT than was ever done in AEW, and obviously how the door is even open for a CM Punk who took WWE to court and spent a decade lambasting the company and many of those in it.
3. The Rumblings Of Potential Departures
Having seen major stars like Cody Rhodes and Jade Cargill decide WWE was a better fit for them than AEW, it must irk Tony Khan as and when any other AEW talents are rumoured to be weighing up a WWE move.
In the last year or so, there's been speculation that so many names could make the jump from AEW to WWE; be that AEW World Champion MJF, Ricky Starks, Andrade El Idolo, Malakai Black, Wardlow, FTR, Brian Cage, or even EVP and former AEW World Champ, Kenny Omega.
Some of those talents have since signed new contracts with AEW, others may well jump to WWE in 2024, and certain other stories may have been merely rumours with very little behind them. The point still stands, though; such rumblings won't please Tony Khan, particularly where it pertains to some of the biggest, most important names in his promotion.
As touched upon already in this piece, perception is a big thing in pro wrestling. If the wider perception - regardless of how much truth there is or not - is that AEW talent would rather be in WWE, that's clearly a negative for Khan's company.
2. The Many Free Agents On The Horizon
Given how WWE had a strong interest in talents such as Jay White and Will Ospreay once it became clear that those names were entering free agency, it's quite the bold statement from AEW that those two major players - two of the very best wrestlers on the planet - rejected WWE in favour of signing with AEW.
Much like White and Ospreay were once being vied for by these two promotions, there's a slew of ridiculously talented wrestlers either already a free agent or about to enter free agency in 2024. And for AEW, it could be an awful look if they miss out on some of these heavy hitters to WWE.
Of course, one such free agent is Mercedes Moné. Having been in attendance at AEW All In, plus having worked for the AEW-friendly NJPW and Stardom, it seemed an absolute given that Mercedes would sign with All Elite Wrestling once she healed from the ankle injury she suffered back in May. However, with the Mercedes-supporting Paul Levesque now steering the WWE ship, all of a sudden it becomes a genuine possibility that, rather than Mercedes Moné becoming #AllElite, we could well see the WWE return of Sasha Banks.
Elsewhere, there are those rumblings that Stardom standout Giulia is high on WWE's radar, has already visited the Performance Center, and may well sign with the market leader when her Bushiroad contract expires in March. Again, that would mark a huge coup for WWE, although one has to question how Giulia would be used in an AEW due to how poorly the company's female talent are utilised.
On the topic of female talent, the exceptional Deonna Purrazzo is wrapping up her time with IMPACT Wrestling in order to explore the free agent market in the new year. The Virtuosa has been absolutely killing it for Anthem across these past few years, and she's another who both WWE and AEW should be desperately trying to sign up.
Another person who's been killing it outside of WWE or AEW, is Alexander Hammerstone. As the former MLW Heavyweight Champion gets set to depart that promotion in early 2024, ol' Hammer is someone with such upside and has the potential to be a serious player for either WWE or AEW if given an opportunity. And with the MLW and WWE lawsuit seemingly now reaching a settlement, that should mean that Hammerstone will have his pick of the wrestling business. Likewise, the 32-year-old's former Dynasty running buddy Richard Holliday is someone who has had reported interest from WWE and AEW; attending a WWE tryout earlier this year, and also having been spotted backstage at an AEW show with his good pal MJF.
But still, while it wouldn't be ideal for AEW if they were publicly shunned in favour of WWE by those aforementioned names, there remains one name for whom it would be a nightmare for Tony Khan if they signed with WWE...
1. The Repercussions Of The Rainmaker's Next Move
For a decade now, Kazuchika Okada has been one of the greatest wrestlers walking the planet. Having long been the poster boy of New Japan Pro-Wrestling, it forever seemed unfathomable to think of an NJPW where there's not an Okada. That is, until reports surfaced that the longest-reigning IWGP Heavyweight Champion in history was toying with the idea of exploring his options in 2024.
At one point, if Okada really was looking to depart New Japan, the only plausible destination would surely be All Elite Wrestling. Now? Not so much...
Of course, AEW and NJPW clearly have a strong working relationship in place, as shown by the Forbidden Door crossover PPVs and in how each promotion has used talents from the other. As part of that, Okada has competed in an AEW ring on three occasions, most notably when facing off against Bryan Danielson at this year's Forbidden Door show.
Added to that, one of Okada's greatest rivals is AEW EVP Kenny Omega, and he's also good friends with the Young Bucks after they helped Kazuchika during his ill-fated stint in TNA back in the day. Again, all of this would point to the only post-NJPW landing spot for Okada being AEW.
However, WWE is said to be genuinely being considered by the Rainmaker right now. For the longest time, WWE's awful presentation of so many of its Japanese stars would be an instant turn-off for a true superstar like Kazuchika Okada. Under the stewardship of Paul Levesque, though, the recent use of Shinsuke Nakamura - himself a close friend of Okada's - serves to highlight this is no longer a company guided by the idiotic ideals of Vincent Kennedy McMahon.
At 36 years of age, if there ever was a time to jump to WWE, 2024 presents a fascinating proposition for Okada. While one has to think that he'd would be used as a top guy in AEW, WWE is simply a bigger company, operating on a bigger scale, and with far, far bigger name recognition across the globe.
Not to disparage AEW, but WWE is the 'big time' in terms of taking your stardom to an entirely different level, which Jade Cargill has stated is the major reason she herself decided to choose WWE over re-signing with AEW.
Should Kazuchika Okada - the golden goose of New Japan Pro-Wrestling and someone viewed as one of the greatest to ever lace up a pair of boots - opt to sign with WWE when his NJPW deal expires in January 2024, that would be a hammer blow for Tony Khan and All Elite Wrestling.
If New Japan talent see a true legend of the business in Okada clearly viewing WWE as a better option than AEW, that sets a certain precedent and, once again, furthers the perception that WWE is a far more appealing workplace than AEW right now, or at least a far more appealing workplace than WWE once was.