Why WWE Must Avoid THIS Huge Mistake Ahead Of WrestleMania 39

WWE must resist this low-hanging fruit ahead of WrestleMania 39.

Rey Mysterio Dominik Mysterio
WWE

With WWE WrestleMania 39 looming large on the horizon, the Showcase of the Immortals, as ever, also brings with it another chance to honour the legends of yesteryear with the company's Hall of Fame ceremony.

As of this writing, there are only two names confirmed for this year's Hall of Fame, with the revolutionary duo of Rey Mysterio and the Great Muta to be honoured during WrestleMania Weekend. Elsewhere, Stacy Keibler finds herself amongst those heavily rumoured to be joining Mysterio and Muta as part of the HOF's class of 2023, although an induction for Batista this year currently looks off the table due to the Animal's hectic filming schedule.

While some fans may choose to poke fun at the WWE Hall of Fame for how it has historically been constructed over the decades, for others these annual ceremonies are a genuine highlight of the wrestling calendar. As seen over those years, it can be an entertaining, engaging, oft-emotional ride getting to see an icon of the industry regaling audiences with tales of the good old days.

So, with this WWE staple once again upon us, here's why the market leader must veer against its worst instincts ahead of WrestleMania 39.

5. The Origins Of The WWE Hall Of Fame

Andre the Giant WWE Hall of Fame 1993
WWE

While there are clearly some baffling admissions, the WWE Hall of Fame has long been a pivotal part of the pro wrestling calendar.

Yes, this particular Hall of Fame and its inductees has historically been dictated by Vince McMahon, but there's undoubtedly a sense of honour and pride for those names who can label themselves WWE Hall of Famers. The point being, to the talents and personnel in the HOF, it means a great deal. Even those who have previously lambasted the WWE HOF - for instance, Scott Steiner - have graciously accepted the offer of an induction when it's come their way.

In terms of its roots, the then-World Wrestling Federation introduced its Hall of Fame back in 1993, with Andre the Giant the sole inductee that year. This creation of the HOF came just a couple of months after the tragic passing of the Eighth Wonder of the World at 46 years of age.

For the first Hall of Fame, there was no ceremony, there was no pomp and circumstance. All that fans got, was an announcement and short video package on the 22 March '93 episode of Raw to reveal that there was now a Hall of Fame and that Andre the Giant was now a Hall of Famer.

By June 1994, the Hall of Fame as we now know it came to fruition. Taking place from Baltimore's Omni Inner Harbor International Hotel, this time there was a ceremony, and, rather that just one inductee, seven names took their place in the Hall of Fame on that night. Unfortunately, the ceremony was not recorded in full, though short clips were featured on WWF programming at the time.

The Hall of Fame would continue in this form, until 1996 had the ceremony take place in front of a paying audience. However, the WWF would opt to simply put its Hall of Fame concept on hold once that '96 event had wrapped up.


4. The Axe And The Return

WWE Hall of Fame Lou Albano
WWE

The big question some of you may have, is why exactly did the WWF decide to axe the Hall of Fame after that 1996 ceremony.

One of the main reasons for that decision appears to be the financial struggles Vince McMahon's company was starting to experience by '96. With WCW at this point beginning to dominate the WWF when it comes to ratings on Monday nights, the Hall of Fame was deemed an additional, unnecessary cost.

Likewise, 1996 had seen the WWF mock its rival for spotlighting older talents such as Hulk Hogan and Randy Savage, and thus it would be tricky to then celebrate the stars of yesterday in a formal ceremony when your weekly television is dumping on the legacy of names of the past.

In terms of why the Hall of Fame even came into existence in 1993, yes, it was in part to honour Andre the Giant, but more importantly this was seen as a way to exploit nostalgia. With the product of the time being far away from the boom period of the '80s Rock 'n' Wrestling days - both in terms of ratings and revenue - it was hoped that the WWF could grab the attention of lapsed fans by winning them over by reminding them of their old favourites, such as Andre the Giant, Buddy Rogers, 'Classy' Freddie Blassie, Bobo Brazil, Pedro Morales, Ernie Ladd, Antonino Rocca, the Valiant Brothers, Jimmy Snuka, and Lou Albano - all of whom were inducted in those first four years.

Of course, the rebranded WWE would bring the Hall of Fame back in 2004, tying it in with WrestleMania XX. There was no explanation as to why the HOF was back, there was no acknowledgement of it having been away. Instead, it was just a case of "Here's Bobby Heenan, Harley Race, Billy Graham, Junkyard Dog, Tito Santana, Sgt. Slaughter, Greg Valentine, Jesse Ventura, Big John Studd, Don Muraco and, err, Pete Rose - now let's celebrate them, yeah?"

The supposed anniversary of WrestleMania was enough of an excuse to bring back the Hall of Fame as an annual event, but WWE was also now in a position where it would record the HOF and make it available to its TV broadcasters, not to mention include it on the DVD releases of its Showcase of the Immortals as an incentive for fans to purchase said releases.

Additionally, there was also now the opportunity to fully cash-in on nostalgia once more, with the promotion's marketing and merchandising game on an entirely different level than it was in the early '90s.


3. The Prestige And Rewards

WWE Hall of Fame 2004 Bobby Heenan
WWE

Regardless of the reasons for WWE opting to reintroduce its Hall of Fame in 2004, these ceremonies are genuinely important to so many of the HOF's inductees.

Sure, there are institutions such as the Cauliflower Alley Club, the George Tragos/Lou Thesz Professional Hall of Fame, and the NWA Hall of Fame that are held in high regard, but the WWE Hall of Fame is viewed as an entirely different beast.

As of this writing, there have been a total of 234 inductees into the WWE Hall of Fame, with those ranging from individual talents, to tag teams or factions, to legacy gongs, to celebrities, and more recently to the Warrior Award winners.

For the most part, the WWE Hall of Fame is a who's who of the biggest names in the history of the wrestling business. If you think of the top stars of any era, the vast majority of those have been honoured in the WWE HOF - even more so with WWE nowadays more open to inducting those major names who made their mark competing for other promotions.

As alluded to elsewhere, there is also a financial incentive for those inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame, for such an induction will usually come with a WWE Legends deal and a whole bunch of merchandise on WWE Shop for those stars of yesteryear to make royalties on. Not to mention, being featured in the Hall of Fame puts those veterans in a new spotlight when it comes to the demand for convention appearances and for signing events.

Most importantly, despite it being decided on the whim of Vince McMahon, being alongside your peers and bona fide legends is a sign of approval, a sign of respect, a sign of the influence and difference you've made to an industry that you've busted your behind to make an impact in.


2. Rey Mysterio, WWE Hall Of Famer

WWE Hall of Fame 2023 Rey Mysterio
WWE.com

Having established why the WWE Hall of Fame is such a big deal, and how so many HOF inductees legitimately helped to change and shape the wrestling industry, there are few names as worthy of a spot in any Hall of Fame as Rey Mysterio.

Of course, the Master of the 619 has now been confirmed to be entering the Hall of Fame as part of the 2023 class.

At 48 years of age, it's absolutely baffling to realise that Rey is currently in his 34th year as a professional wrestler. Considering the high-risk, high-impact style of Mysterio, it's genuinely amazing that he's been able to do what he does at such an elite level and for such extraordinary amount of time.

A generational talent, a game-changer, a trail-blazer, a revolutionary, a role model, an inspiration, an innovator, an unmeasurable underdog and mammoth overachiever in a world so often dominated by giants. Whatever way you choose to attempt to define Rey Mysterio, he's simply one of the most important wrestlers of all time.

There are not enough superlatives to throw Mysterio's way when reflecting back on his career and the stamp he has put on the wrestling business.

While some may take mild umbrage with WWE inducting a currently active superstar, getting to give Rey Mysterio his proverbial flowers and celebrate his impact on the business should be fantastic to see.

Well, that is so long as WWE doesn't make a huge mistake at this year's Hall of Fame ceremony...


1. Keep The Mysterio Family Drama Away From The Hall Of Fame

Rey Dominik Mysterio Rhea Ripley Mask
WWE.com

Yes, Dominik Mysterio and Rhea Ripley ruining the Mysterio family's Thanksgiving was absolute gold. Yes, Dom and Rhea ruining the Mysterios' Christmas was absolute gold. And yes, Ex-Con Dom and his Mami attempting to ruin Rey and Angie's Valentine's Day was absolute gold.

That said, the Mysterio family drama needs to be kept at an absolute minimum at this year's Hall of Fame.

Having a brooding Dominik shoot daggers his deadbeat dad's way from the crowd? Sure, that's fine. What we don't need, though, is Rey's big moment being tarnished by an angle designed to set the stage for Father vs. Son at WrestleMania 39.

Already, many are speculating that Rey's induction speech will be ruined by his offspring, with some suggesting that the younger Mysterio could even put a beating on Konnan. With K-Dawg expected to induct Rey - not to mention being one of Dominik's godparents - there's certainly enough emotional ties to exploit and generate further heat for Dom if such an attack took place.

Likewise, there are rumblings that something may take place with Dominik and his mother Angie in and around the Hall of Fame in order to push Rey over the edge and convince him to battle his son on the Grandest Stage of Them All.

Dominik Mysterio raining all over his old man's parade at the Hall of Fame would admittedly get plenty of heat on Dom, but it's low-hanging fruit that WWE needs to steer clear of. We're going to get Dominik vs. Rey at 'Mania 39 either way, and there's no need to run the risk of ruining such a special moment in order to get to that endgame.

Never before has WWE added fuel to a rivalry or match in such a way at the Hall of Fame, so why needlessly do so now?

If such antics do indeed play out, fans will forever think of Rey's Hall of Fame induction for whatever shenanigans took place, when instead we should reflect back on that moment being the honouring of a legend and an icon of the business.


Senior Writer
Senior Writer

Once described as the Swiss Army Knife of WhatCulture, Andrew can usually be found writing, editing, or presenting on a wide range of topics. As a lifelong wrestling fan, horror obsessive, and comic book nerd, he's been covering those topics professionally as far back as 2010. In addition to his current WhatCulture role of Senior Content Producer and Presenter, Andrew previously spent nearly a decade as Online Editor and Lead Writer for the world's longest-running genre publication, Starburst Magazine, and his work has also been featured on BBC, TechRadar, Tom's Guide, WhatToWatch, Sportkskeeda, and various other outlets, in addition to being a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic. Between his main day job, his role as lead panel host of Wales Comic Con, and his gig as a pre-match host for Wrexham AFC games, Andrew has also carried out a hugely varied amount of interviews, from the likes of Robert Englund and Eli Roth to Kevin Smith and the Russo Brothers, to Kevin Conroy and Frank Miller, to Bret Hart and Sting, to Mickey Thomas, Joey Jones, Phil Parkinson, and Brian Flynn, to many, many more. Where his beloved Wrexham AFC is concerned, Andrew is a long-standing season ticket holder and an FSA Award-winner for his time co-hosting the Fearless in Devotion podcast.