Why WWE Will Save Cody Rhodes From Burial

Fear not, Cody Rhodes will be absolutely fine after his WWE WrestleMania 39 loss to Roman Reigns.

WWE WrestleMania 39 Cody Rhodes
WWE

Well, the main event of WrestleMania 39 Night 2 certainly caused quite the stir, right?

As the returning hero desperate to do his daddy proud and win the prize that Dusty never could, Cody Rhodes was on a mission to dethrone Roman Reigns to become the new Undisputed WWE Universal Champion at the Showcase of the Immortals. Granted, the Tribal Chief had run through major name after major name as part of his ridiculous run atop the WWE mountain, but surely Cody's story and the momentum behind him meant that the American Nightmare would be the one to finally bring an end to Roman's reign of destruction.

To add further weight to this match-up, Cody's family and Brodie Lee Jr. sat ringside for what was sure to be Rhodes' crowning moment. What an emotional scene awaited the watching millions at the end of the match, as Cody held aloft the Undisputed WWE Universal Title, excessive pyro rocked SoFi Stadium, and confetti poured down from the rafters...

Welp.

After 34 minutes, WrestleMania 39 concluded with Roman Reigns pinning Cody Rhodes 1-2-3 in the middle of the ring after nailing a spear following interference from Solo Sikoa.

The immediate reaction to this from many was baffled bewilderment; this was Cody's moment, and WWE completely dropped the ball on making Rhodes a made man on the Grandest Stage of Them All.

While 'Mania may not have been ideal, here's why Cody Rhodes is going to be just fine from here on out.

7. The Long And Winding Rhodes

Cody Rhodes Clapping
WWE.com

As of this writing, Cody Rhodes is a 17-year veteran of the professional wrestling business. Truth be told, Cody's time in the industry obviously dates back way past his formal in-ring debut in 2006, with his father being the legendary Dusty Rhodes, his brother being Dustin Rhodes, and Cody taking his first bumps back when he was just 12 years of age.

The career of the American Nightmare has been a long and storied one, yet he is still only 37 years of age. From WWE developmental, to the main roster, to Legacy, to Dashing, to the Rhodes Scholars, to Stardust, to TNA, to Ring of Honor, to PWG, to New Japan, to even being a founding father of an entirely new mainstream promotion...

The point being, Cody Rhodes has done a hell of a lot in a hell of different guises throughout his career to date.

Upon shockingly departing AEW at the start of 2022, it soon became apparent that Cody was returning 'home' to WWE. Given how petty WWE has often been accused of being, what did the market leader have in mind for Rhodes? Would his public frustrations about previous creative decisions be held against him? Would the emergence of AEW be held against him? Could WWE really let all of those digs from Cody and his AEW cohorts slide? Was he being brought back just to be embarrassed?

Those concerns were ultimately unwarranted, with Cody's WrestleMania 38 appearance immediately placing him on the road to the promised land of the WWE main event scene.


6. A Story Left Unfinished

WWE WrestleMania 39 Roman Reigns Solo Sikoa Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

The very first time Cody Rhodes cut a promo after his WWE return last year, he made it abundantly clear that he was focussed on winning the Undisputed WWE Universal Championship.

While Dusty Rhodes had plentiful championship success over the decades, the American Dream was never able to capture WWE's top prize. Dustin Rhodes, aka Goldust, is a three-time Intercontinental Champion, but he likewise was never able to win 'the big one' during his several stints with the market leader. As such, Cody was on a mission to win the Undisputed WWE Universal Title for his family name, and more specifically for Dusty.

The American Nightmare's mission may have been derailed due to a torn pec, but Rhodes returned at this year's Royal Rumble, won the titular men's bout, and cemented himself a spot against Roman Reigns for the greatest prize in the industry.

With the Tribal Chief on a truly generational, all-timer of a run that has seen him topple any and all challengers - such as Sami Zayn, Kevin Owens, Drew McIntyre, Sheamus, Riddle, Goldberg, Shinsuke Nakamura, Bray Wyatt, Braun Strowman, Cesaro, Daniel Bryan, Edge, Rey Mysterio, and Jey Uso - it seemed that Cody Rhodes would "finish the story" by being the one to finally topple the Head of the Table at WrestleMania 39.

To the surprise of many, WWE opted to have Reigns retain against Rhodes at 'Mania 39.

But what about Cody's story? Why wouldn't WWE pull the trigger on his World Title win? Why wouldn't they cement Cody as a major player? Why would they not capitalise on Cody's huge momentum and groundswell of support? And worryingly... does this mean Cody Rhodes is the next Lex Luger?


5. Lex Luger 2.0

lex luger yokozuna
WWE.com

Heading into WrestleMania 39, many suggested that a loss for Cody Rhodes would result in Rhodes' WWE career plummeting in much the same way that Lex Luger's did post-WrestleMania X.

With Luger having debuted in the then-WWF as the villainous Narcissist at the 1993 Royal Rumble, the former WCW World Heavyweight Champion would be switched babyface by the middle of the year. Specifically, it was the 4th July '93 where Lex became the All-American good guy, slamming Mr. Fuji's Yokozuna aboard the USS Intrepid and then embarking on a cross-country tour that largely centred on waving the flag, kissing babies, and hugging grannies.

As Hulk Hogan's days with the company looked to be coming to an end, Luger was modelled to be the Hulkster's replacement. Thus, he was put up against Yoko at that year's SummerSlam, where he challenged for the sumo's WWF Championship. A bizarrely celebrated count-out victory - as in, Lex up on people's shoulders as the locker-room emptied and streamers rained down - from the one-time Horseman was the end result here, but Luger would eventually get another shot at Yokozuna and that prize at WrestleMania X.

Of course, Lex would come up short again at 'Mania - losing by DQ - ahead of Bret Hart being the one to dethrone Yokozuna as WWF Champion later that night.

Once WrestleMania X was in the rear-view mirror, Luger's stock dropped massively, the experiment with him as a top guy had flopped hard, and brief feuds with Crush and Tatanka were followed by Lex teaming with Davey Boy Smith as the incredibly bland Allied Powers. Famously, the Total Package would return to WCW in 1995, re-debuting for the promotion on the inaugural episode of WCW Nitro.


4. The False Comparisons

Lex Luger Cody Rhodes
WWE

Yes, there are clearly similarities in how both Lex Luger and Cody Rhodes were stars whose supposed crowning moment was looming large on the WrestleMania horizon, but that's where any such comparisons should stop.

Sure, Luger and Rhodes both ultimately came up short at the Grandaddy of Them All, yet the WWE career paths of the pair will absolutely veer in vastly different directions. As mentioned, Lex slumped his way down the card and out of the company in the aftermath of his big 'Mania loss, but there were several key factors in that.

Firstly, Lex Luger was never the organic top babyface of the then-World Wrestling Federation. Luger had been handpicked by Vince McMahon to be his next top star in the same jacked-up, tanned, All-American mould as Hulk Hogan. The fans had never chosen Lex for this role, and instead the majority of the company's fanbase were eager for Bret Hart to be the guy at the top of the mountain.

Never was the want of the fans more apparent than at the 1994 Royal Rumble. With WWF management starting to have doubts over whether they'd made the right call by going all-in on Lex across the second half of '93, the decision was made to have Luger and Hart be co-winners of that Rumble. In doing that, the company could gauge the fan reaction to each talent, and thus it was clear that more fans were cheering on the Hitman than they were Lex.

For Cody Rhodes, he is currently the top babyface in WWE due to how organically over he is with audiences. Yes, the machine has clearly got behind Cody and presented him as a main event act, but the fans are absolutely with the American Nightmare. That fanbase will still continue to vehemently support Rhodes in the aftermath of his 'Mania 39 loss, for this is a star who has been incredibly popular since he returned to WWE last year.

Unfortunately for Lex Luger, the truth is that there was never a level of natural fan support to warrant him being a top WWE babyface in 1993 and into '94. As such, when Luger came up short at WrestleMania X, few were clamouring for him to remain in the main event scene and World Title picture.

By no fault of his own, Lex was placed in a false position. For Cody Rhodes, that absolutely is not the case.


3. Cody Rhodes, Workhorse

Cody Rhodes The Miz
WWE.com

While the attempt to get Lex Luger over as a top babyface was based around presentation and personality, Cody Rhodes has far more tools to get himself over with a fanbase than the Total Package ever had.

This article isn't designed to be a hit-piece on Luger, and the New Yorker very much is a legend of the business who had huge success and put on many great matches, but Lex himself would have to admit that he was nowhere near the in-ring worker that Cody is.

The American Nightmare has of course used presentation and personality to get himself over, yet Rhodes has also long endeared himself to wrestling fans for his ability between the ropes. By his sheer workrate and technical prowess, Cody can have a crowd in the palm of his hand and get you emotionally invested regardless of who he's standing opposite of in the ring.

For Luger, he simply didn't have that ability. If there was a great storyline at play or he was facing an elite worker such as a Ric Flair, a Ricky Steamboat or a Barry Windham, sure, Lex would clearly have an audience invested in what they were seeing. The difference is, the sheer workhorse nature of Cody Rhodes means fans are invested in what he does regardless of story or the skill level of his opponents.

Of course, it also helps that Cody is one hell of a promo, which is yet another string to his bow.


2. The Story Continues On

Cody Rhodes is sad
WWE

As Cody Rhodes detailed plentiful times in the build to WrestleMania 39, his mission is to "finish the story" and climb to the top of the WWE mountain.

Yes, Cody came up short at this year's Showcase of the Immortals, but why does that mean his quest has ended in failure? As ever, the story continues on; it's not like in AEW where it was bafflingly decided early on that the American Nightmare was no longer eligible to challenge for the promotion's World Championship. There's nothing stopping Rhodes from earning himself another shot at the Undisputed WWE Universal Title or even demanding a rematch after the shenanigans that played out towards the finish of his 'Mania war with Roman Reigns.

Cody's story is far from finished; it's just zigged when we all thought it would zag, in turn creating a new chapter that still has the same endgame in mind.

One has to remember, WrestleMania 39 was Cody Rhodes' first ever televised World Title match in WWE. With a huge fanbase behind him, major merchandise numbers to his name, and clearly unchallenged as the top babyface in the company right now, Cody is cemented as a permanent main event player and World Title contender.


1. The American Nightmare's Dream Becomes A Reality

Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

Cody Rhodes will be a World Champion in WWE.

Whether it's the Undisputed WWE Universal Champion, the WWE Champion, the WWE Universal Champion, or some other moniker for the company's top prize, the ascension of Cody is, no pun intended, undeniable.

Rhodes is clearly viewed as a big-time player by WWE, as reflected by his TV presence and his positioning since he returned at WrestleMania 38. But let's face it, Cody's time as a true main event player in WWE has consisted of a calendar year in which he was absent through injury for six months.

The Seth Rollins feud was brilliant, but Rhodes' time in the World Title scene has 'only' been a little over three months, with those months chronicling Cody's Royal Rumble win and his subsequent zoning in on Roman Reigns. In the grander scheme of things, the American Nightmare has merely had a cup of coffee in the WWE main event picture... but after these first few sips, Rhodes is primed to continue swigging that coffee back for years to come.

Any notion that Cody Rhodes was buried at WrestleMania 39, any notion that he will plummet down the card because of WrestleMania 39, well, they're just misguided, kneejerk reactions to the lay of the land.

Rhodes may not have defeated Roman Reigns on the Grandest Stage of Them All, but he went toe-to-toe with the Tribal Chief in a 30-minute war and only lost due to outside interference.

Cody will be fine from here on out, Cody's story to become World Champion is still very much in play, and truth be told, Cody will likely still be the one to bring Roman's generational run as Undisputed WWE Champion to an end. Just because the second-generation star's American Dream didn't happen at WrestleMania, doesn't mean it won't happen at all.


Senior Writer
Senior Writer

Once described as the Swiss Army Knife of WhatCulture, Andrew can usually be found writing, editing, or presenting on a wide range of topics. As a lifelong wrestling fan, horror obsessive, and comic book nerd, he's been covering those topics professionally as far back as 2010. In addition to his current WhatCulture role of Senior Content Producer and Presenter, Andrew previously spent nearly a decade as Online Editor and Lead Writer for the world's longest-running genre publication, Starburst Magazine, and his work has also been featured on BBC, TechRadar, Tom's Guide, WhatToWatch, Sportkskeeda, and various other outlets, in addition to being a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic. Between his main day job, his role as lead panel host of Wales Comic Con, and his gig as a pre-match host for Wrexham AFC games, Andrew has also carried out a hugely varied amount of interviews, from the likes of Robert Englund and Eli Roth to Kevin Smith and the Russo Brothers, to Kevin Conroy and Frank Miller, to Bret Hart and Sting, to Mickey Thomas, Joey Jones, Phil Parkinson, and Brian Flynn, to many, many more. Where his beloved Wrexham AFC is concerned, Andrew is a long-standing season ticket holder and an FSA Award-winner for his time co-hosting the Fearless in Devotion podcast.