Will ALL IN Change WWE More Than CM Punk’s Pipe Bomb?

Click Magnets

All In CM Punk
wwe/all in

CM Punk spoke with such earnest hope when he warmly shared a sentiment during his WWE DVD box set about how he couldn't change the world - or at least the company - sitting on his couch in Chicago. It was his primary rationale for signing the new contract in 2011 that would ultimately be his last. With one foot already out of the company, he kicked down doors with his other after being given the closing moments of an otherwise turgid edition of Monday Night Raw.

'Raw Roulette' was the theme; a night in which the fate of all WWE Superstars was decided by the spin of a wheel as if that was somehow different the other 51 weeks of the year. Once a groundbreaking organisation, the company was by this point biliously spitting out content rather than producing it - something Punk alluded to in his iconic 'Pipe Bomb' promo. He knew he was a spoke in the wheel, and knew that wheel was part of a machine careering headfirst into creative oblivion.

But he stayed. He really couldn't change the company from his couch in Chicago, but he presumably didn't ever imagine others having a really good go at it a few minutes down the road from that very same couch. On September 1st, he could literally only watch as they gave it their best shot.

CONT'D...


WWE.com

There were no half measures taken by Punk during his instantly iconic address. Mindful of the vastly expanded internet audience, he specifically targetted widely-loathed company quirks, savaging Vince and Stephanie McMahon and Triple H as flawed gatekeepers of the day, John Laurinaitis as the disastrous emperor of tomorrow, and Paul Heyman as the stifled and suppressed past-master. He said "wrestling". He peered down the fourth wall to wave at friend Colt Cabana. He referenced New Japan Pro Wrestling and Ring Of Honour by name. These weren't red wires being errantly pulled at by a bomb disposal amateur, they were homing missiles masquerading as air strikes.

With every mention of something from the known naughty list, Punk clutched further at the heartstrings of his own audience. He turned the volume up in his echo chamber so loud that it smashed its walls and the WWE glass ceiling. It was so powerful that by the time the company made it to his Money In The Bank 2011 final destination, the journey simply couldn't conclude there.

A famous night in Chicago couldn't be the end of the story when it was the start of a revolution.

Sound familiar?

CONT'D...


Cm Punk Meet And Greet
Pro Wrestling Store

The Chicago locale isn't the only thing connecting the greatest nights of CM Punk and Cody Rhodes' respective careers.

Both won the most prestigious titles available to them in front of adoring audiences. Both were - in the moment at least - the biggest and brightest stars in their orbit. Both had auras beyond their regular selves. No spotlights within the Allstate Arena or Sears Centre had glares as strong as the spiritual shine surrounding challengers destined to dethrone champions.

Cody's blood and tear-stained face told a similar story to the kiss-blowing grin Punk couldn't shift, too. There was redemption unlike anything either had experienced up to that point. Cody basked in the celebrations whilst Punk literally walked amongst them, exiting the building through the crowd to sell the storyline that he was departing the company for good.

Indeed, both Cody and Punk emerged heroically from the chasing packs. But whilst Punk walked the immortal aisle alone, Cody was surrounded by every legend and his dog. Literally. For all their similarities, this was the biggest - and most crucial - difference.

CONT'D...


Cm Punk Triple H
WWE.com

The power of Punk's promo was barely enough to fuel his own career for the remainder of 2011. Punk had swum with sharks before, but not Great Whites like Triple H, Kevin Nash and Vince McMahon himself. He'd bullishly taken a spot the top table, but he was still only being fed scraps from the likes of a selfless John Cena and powerless midcarders like The Miz and R-Truth. This was where his grand plan fell apart - WWE exists to push stars, so Punk either had to double down on promoting himself, or stay true to his values in order to elevate others across the board.

His original campaign attempted to find work for Colt Cabana, find respect for Zack Ryder and find hope for all the other "spokes in the wheel". That campaign resulted in him staring at the lights for 'The Game' and Alberto Del Rio within months of having GQ at his house to talk to the supposed saviour of professional wrestling. Punk was attempting to do something real in a world that was every bit as fake and untouchable as he'd first suggested back in Las Vegas.

He'd have probably bloodied himself banging his head against brick walls, if he wasn't likely to face a fine for it. Cody actively derailed his battle with Nick Aldis chasing claret, but he had the freedom and fan acceptance to do so. It was literally his show - Punk received all sorts in his fat new 2011 contract, but he never got that autonomy. And he never would.

CONT'D...


Vince McMahon Cody
WWE/FiteTV

By the time he was main eventing two consecutive pay-per-views against The Rock, his record-breaking WWE Championship reign had already been undermined by months of playing second fiddle to whatever happened to be that month's real main event. A common problem in eras with more than one World Title, Punk had the ignominy of going on underneath the likes of John Cena Vs. John Laurinaitis.

Cody booked himself a million years away from the wild west main event featuring his high flying Young Bucks buddies at ALL IN, but was able to do it for the good of the show as well as his own match. It again highlights the importance of being at the top of the movement you've created instead of merely acting as the front face of it.

Punk's 'Pipe Bomb' should have lit a fuse in WWE, but if anything it only expedited the overdue exit of Punk's storyline enemy 'Big Johnny' Laurinaitis. And him disappearing from view was orchestrated predominantly by Triple H - the man that kept a thumb on countless performers until he was retired enough to nurture a new generation.

The 'change' came from one of the men Punk despised the most, because nobody changes anything in WWE unless they either have - or marry somebody with - a particular surname.

But wrestling has more than one royal family...

CONT'D...


All In
Twitter/@ALL_IN_2018

Perhaps everything Cody and The Young Bucks have done won't even penetrate WWE's weakest defences. CM Punk once referred to Vince McMahon as a "millionaire who should be a billionaire", and though that's now a factual inaccuracy, his company is one that still makes money in spite of itself. Customer-based revenue will fall below 50% of total takings by 2020, at which point the already-unfocused nature of the bloated television product may spiral even further.

ALL IN was a declaration of independents that they could all work together for a common good. It took the exceptional gamesmanship of Cody and The Bucks specifically to advance Being The Elite from travel vlog to ticket-selling series, but it took the support of talent, fans and promoters to agree to push forward together with Starrcast and the Saturday supercard itself. There's a precedent for something on the scale of ALL IN, but the less said about the politically-riddled co-promotional Superclash cards of the late-1980s, the better.

CONT'D...


CM Punk Cody Rhodes
WWE

One man alone - not CM Punk then, not Daniel Bryan now, not even Triple H from inside the walls of his developmental promotion - can transform WWE, at least not until Vince McMahon is dragged kicking, screaming and gulping into the afterlife. This was Punk's biggest misunderstanding about what was ever achievable. He couldn't even get a WrestleMania main event for himself, let alone a sustained push for Tyson Kidd et al.

Cody and co have no such chains to break. Though nothing has yet been announced as ALL IN's follow-up, they've created more than just anticipation for future shows. They've created a renewed sense of hope far beyond the excitement around CM Punk's eight days off television in 2011. They've created a new-and-improved way to make a living from professional wrestling outside of WWE. Ironically, they've created a stage big enough for CM Punk to perform upon, should he wish.

It's this stage that will define his legacy as an "agent for change" beyond WWE. Was the change Punk chased really all about the industry at large, or did the elusive 'Show Of Shows' top spot mean more all along?


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.