WrestleMania 33 Review: 10 Major Talking Points
Thank you, 'Taker.
WrestleMania 33 was a success, all things considered.
Even at a bloated five hours plus, there was enough variety to wade off fatigue. Though the card was propped up by part-time stars of yesteryear, only one raised the ire with a baffling performance. There were no contrived and counterproductive burials, no bitterly unfunny backstage skits. Even The Rock stayed at home. For once, the tagline matched the event.
Match quality was largely very good. Seth Rollins Vs. Triple H probably warrants Match Of The Night honours, but it is a testament to the eclectic card that the closest competition was entirely different. No one match really approached the ***** level, but nothing was too awful. Even the sillier moments were memorable, if nothing else.
Time allocation, a repeat 'Mania offender, did threaten to engulf the show at times. Shane McMahon wrestled for twice as long as the WWE Champion. More worryingly still, with the way he was booked, you would half-expect him to challenge for it in the summer months - for Shane McMahon is the best in the world at what he does. And there is nothing he cannot do.
As good as it was, it was equally contentious...
10. Undercard Madness
Even in the post-pay-per-view Network era, the line between Kickoff and 'Mania proper is not as imaginary as some have optimistically suggested this week. The demarcation itself still conveys a message to fans: what happens before the national anthem isn't worthy of fireworks. It doesn't really factor into WWE canon - but for dubious reasons it was as controversial as anything which occurred on the main show.
Dean Ambrose retained his Intercontinental Title in an average bout with Baron Corbin, but that wasn't the real story. A man who less than a year ago wore the company's top prize had been consigned to the pre-show. It was a sobering indictment of WWE's fixation with nostalgia. Either that, or Ambrose's beyond stale babyface act. A heel turn must be in order; he has never been more irrelevant.
Before that, the most predictable instalment yet of the Andre The Giant Memorial Battle Royal didn't actually yield the expected result. Braun Strowman was eliminated, shortly after the Big Show, which apparently left the field "wide open". Poor Mark Henry apparently no longer counts as token big man.
Any notion that WWE was going to press on with building the future was doused when Mojo Rawley (he's hardly a veteran, but his upside is nonexistent) won because the interference of his mate, NFL star Rob Gronkowski, helped the event trend on Twitter.
Strowman will probably be fine - but his aura has faded since the run up to Fastlane.
9. John Cena Proposes
The John Cena & Nikki Bella Vs. The Miz & Maryse match was bizarre. The Miz dominated Cena for about seven minutes, channelling Hulk Hogan at WrestleMania X8 by encouraging a babyface turn with manic crowd appeals. Then, suddenly, after one hot tag and no offence whatsoever beyond the kayfabe weakest finisher in wrestling, Miz was put away with one AA.
Even after that abomination, which to an extent is excusable because nobody is going to remember it, the proposal angle resonated because it felt far more real than the contrived setup threatened. Nikki looked genuinely moved, scared even, and there were no histrionic tears or celebrations. The couple simply shared a tender embrace, whispering their affection to one another. It was as tolerable as it could have been.
The transition to it was actually quite awkward. Cena more or less crowed about teasing his drugged-up girlfriend about whether or not he was ever going to pop the question before actually popping it.
It was just as well Cena did next to nothing in the match. If he exerted himself too much, that gigantic diamond might have fallen out of his jort pocket.
8. Shane McMahon Is The Best Technical Wrestler On The Planet
At last year's WrestleMania, Shane McMahon went strike for strike with a man we have been conditioned to accept as the greatest pure striker in WWE history. Last night, he went hold for hold with AJ Styles, a man universally perceived as the best pure wrestler on the WWE roster.
The match layout was as incoherent as it was insulting. Styles didn't merely wrestle Styles at his own game; he was positioned as his superior. He handily out-grappled him in the opening sequences, and found mat-based counters for his devastating aerial game throughout. Styles had to resort to weaponry to snatch the advantage, and only won as a result of the widely expected ref bump.
Essentially, McMahon were it not for incompetent officiating would have emerged as the victor. He can do everything everybody on the roster can. If Shane were to wrestle Shinsuke Nakamura, he'd kick his face in. If he wrestled Braun Strowman, he'd slam him around the canvas with ease. Is there anything he cannot do? Maintain his position as a babyface, on this evidence.
John Cena received much warranted criticism for his SuperCena schtick, but Shane is even more powerful; he is Sylar from Heroes, even if we were somehow expected to receive him as Peter Petrelli.
Shockingly, Shane was the more selfish McMahon sibling on the night…
7. A Low-Key Festival
Online murmurings of the Chris Jericho Vs. Kevin Owens match have been quiet - damning the raging part-timer argument yet further.
It was the epitome of ***1/2; curiously lacking in crowd heat for the opening act, the fans only got on board when the big moves and reversals made their appearance towards the finish. It was solid to very good, and never dipped below or rose above that range.
The positioning of it didn't help. The Camping World Stadium crowd were still reeling from the AJ Styles Vs. Shane McMahon opener, which generated mixed emotions. It was a good WrestleMania midcard match. That is about the sum of it. But what does that say about 'Mania itself? Were fans exhausted from concurrently booing Shane McMahon's technical posturing and popping for Styles' bulletproof offence? Did the fact that the match go on second, second only to second last in order of prestige, reinforce the belief that it didn't really matter?
Isn't it thoroughly depressing that two talents can spend months crafting an act, acting out one of the greatest angles in company history, only to be swept up into the scenery?
6. The Women's Devolution
The first half of the barely anticipated RAW Women's Title Fatal 4-Way match was superb. Nia Jax looked like a monster - the mere sight of her three opponents approaching her tentatively did more for her aura than any amount of squash matches - and she took an awesome bump from a big boot into a double German suplex. The timing was off - she smacked the canvas with the top of her head - but the violence put it over the top.
Wrestling is ghoulish like that, but it's also beautiful. Charlotte's aerobics were graceful enough to linger in the memory on a night which, if nothing else, certainly wasn't forgettable.
Most were expecting the match to improve when Jax was removed from the fray, but the opposite happened. A combination of botches (the turnbuckle padding remained in place after Charlotte attempted to remove it) and timing issues (Banks' exit was too sudden to buy) meant the drama of the subsequent eliminations was negated.
That much of the internet fandom has barely discussed the match is a talking point in itself. Last year, the Women's Title Triple Threat match was the best match on the card. Here, the women were treated as an afterthought, even if they did get the video package treatment. They deserved so much more than this. The booking of the match, unfortunately, mirrored the booking of the division. The blue brand fared little better. James Ellsworth was more of a focal point than Becky Lynch.
Something's wrong there.
5. The Hardy Boyz Return!
This time last year, Matt and Jeff Hardy, two of the most enduring characters in all of wrestling, were treading water in TNA. Then, in early summer, Matt threw a baby doll onto Jeff in one of the most scorned at angles in recent memory.
At WrestleMania 33, months after becoming the hottest gimmick act in the wrestling world, they received arguably the biggest pop of the night when The New Day announced them as last-minute additions to the RAW Tag Team Title Ladder Match.
In a way, it was the best and worst of the so-called WrestleMania Moment, a phenomenon that has become all too manufactured and devoid of logic in recent years. If The New Day had matchmaking powers, they probably should have put themselves forward - the belts are meant to be prestigious and all that - but when the opening strains of Loaded hit, none of that mattered. The Hardyz had returned home and entered a truncated but still trademark risky as hell performance in a short but satisfying ladder match. Jeff in particular looked like he'd been transported in time from 2001.
Interestingly, Matt even indulged the crowd with some BROKEN mannerisms. Which Hardy Boyz are we getting?
4. Stephanie McMahon SELLS!
The Triple H Vs. Seth Rollins match followed the expected narrative pattern, but a classic injured babyface versus nefarious heel match had fallen at their feet. It would have been senseless to disregard it - and the predictable formula was enhanced by Rollins' excellent and authentic selling. It lacked a certain urgency, but the suspense and the genuine emotion compensated for it.
The continuity was deployed excellently. When Rollins' knee gave out during an ill-fated sunset flip powerbomb, echoing the origin of the entire, meta-textual two-year storyline, it was a genuinely heart-stopping moment - and his comebacks were timed perfectly. Rollins has struggled for acceptance as a top-tier babyface, but you wouldn't have guessed it on last night's evidence. It was a triumph of a performance.
What was entirely unexpected was the breathtaking and massively cathartic finish. Triple H, dazed from Rollins' Superkick, wandered into Stephanie at ringside and caused her to fall through a table. He was prone to Rollins' Pedigree in the only distraction finish that's ever made a fraction of sense.
Stephanie received only indirect comeuppance for bullying Mick Foley for months on end, but that's as good as it's going to get.
So be grateful.
3. Skin-Crawling Embarrassment
The WWE Title match between Bray Wyatt and Randy Orton will linger in the memory for a totally bizarre production technique.
At various points throughout, Bray Wyatt (presumably via his supernatural powers; like much of the character, there really was little explanation) Wyatt projected stock horror movie imagery onto the canvas. The first attempt succeeded in its mission to startle Orton; disturbed by the appearance of crawling maggots, Orton took refuge out of the ring. Another image, of burrowing earthworms, caused Orton to flurry to the outside, but Orton recovered from his bout of entomophobia when a final projection of beetles covered the ring. He simply dropped Wyatt with an RKO out of nowhere and captured a thirteenth World title.
The logic behind the finish was impossible to parse. Was it meant to convey that Orton had heroically conquered Wyatt's mind games? It made no sense. Orton was the Machiavellian antagonist in their storyline. He wasn't haunted by the spectre of Sister Abigail; he killed her for a second time.
Was this projection a neat update of WWE's campy sports entertainment mode, or just massively, massively lame?
Like much of 'Mania, it's up for debate - but it's beyond silly that Wyatt has evil powers and still can't use them to win a wrestling match.
2. Goldberg WRESTLES
If Triple H Vs. Seth Rollins was an expected triumph, Goldberg Vs. Brock Lesnar was an unexpected triumph. It wasn't the bloodbath Goldberg had promised, nor the ten minute match the Wrestling Observer reported twenty four hours earlier - but it was closer in spirit to the Undertaker/Batista prizefight at 'Mania 23 than it was the non-match squash debacle of Fastlane last month.
Lesnar approached his old, excellent form with a display of the fantastic selling and body language for which he doesn't receive enough credit. It was nothing out of his norm - he German suplexed Goldberg ten times in a 5 minute match - but the transitions to those suplexes were excellent, particularly his ultra-athletic leap frog spot. He expanded on his tedious one-note strategy in a dynamic, stiff and breathless match which just about excused Goldberg's mixed return. It was as good as anything he managed in WCW. The off the charts heat helped.
That surely marks the end of Goldberg's run - and on last night's evidence, it was a success.
The events of Survivor Series infuriated some, but Lesnar is more or less back where he started - and Goldberg provided much exposure, intrigue and income in the meantime.
1. Undertaker RETIRES
One of the greatest wrestlers of all time - and unquestionably the greatest character of all time - literally hung up their gloves last night.
Ever the pro, he did so on his back. After a brutal and (by design) depressing twenty-three minute war, The Undertaker removed his gloves, trench coat and hat and placed them on the canvas. He didn't just leave his attire in the ring; he left his body in there, too.
The match itself wasn't the smoothest nor the most exciting 'Taker has ever contested, but it couldn't have been. As became painfully apparent, he wasn't physically capable of it - but to his credit, and the credit of whomever helped lay it out, it was an emotional affair that generated unbearable pathos. Much like his 'Mania 25 classic opposite Shawn Michaels, an unsightly botch only added to the drama. When 'Taker's body gave out at the midway point, Reigns couldn't complete the Tombstone reversal spot. It was a sad but no less potent visual metaphor, but 'Taker created something even more powerful by design. When he attempted to perform his traditional sit-up, the groans from the crowd perfectly mirrored his slow and depressing descent. 'Taker has lost several steps, but his psychology and body language was still frighteningly advanced. He did everything he could to give Reigns the rub.
But is Roman Reigns worthy of it?
Wrestling is one big paradox. Only when he turns heel will we get a true gauge of his potential popularity.