WWE: 10 Best Elimination Chamber Matches

It€™s been a pretty terrible couple of weeks for WWE, but something good is on the way, and I€™m not talking about Wrestlemania. I€™m talking about the Elimination Chamber Pay Per View, one of the more underrated Pay Per Views of the entire WWE schedule. Sandwiched between the two biggest shows of the year (Mania and the Royal Rumble), the Chamber doesn€™t seem to get a lot of love. But at the time of year when WWE€™s booking is at its strongest, we get great matches featuring (usually) six of the top superstars on each brand. So rather than dwell on the negative, I€™m going to channel my inner optimist and make myself feel better by counting down the 10 best Elimination Chamber matches of all time. There have been 16 total Chamber matches since the first one back in 2002, so six didn€™t make the cut. You won€™t see last year€™s Chamber match won by Jack Swagger (which ended up amounting to a whole pile of nothing), nor will you see any Chamber match that has Santino Marrella as one of its last two participants (so you€™re out, 2012 Smackdown Chamber). The Raw 2011 Chamber match barely misses the cut, because I had to look the result up as I completely forgot who was in it and who won (John Cena ended up beating CM Punk, John Morrison, Sheamus, R-Truth, and Randy Orton in case you care). The Raw Chamber match at No Way Out 2009 also misses the cut on principle, because the booking decision to allow Edge to €œreplace€ Kofi Kingston in the Chamber match because he beat him up on the way to the ring defies all types of logic. I€™ve also disqualified the Chamber match from New Year€™s Revolution 2006 because when you make the decision to have the two best workers in the match (Shawn Michaels and Kurt Angle) the first two to be eliminated, and have Carlito and Chris Masters as two of the final three, there€™s a big problem. Finally, anybody who includes anything from ECW December to Dismember on any €œbest of€ list deserves to be drawn and quartered, so I€™m sorry, Extreme Elimination Chamber, you didn€™t make it to the party. Now that we€™ve gotten the dregs out of the way, let€™s take a look at the Top 10 Elimination Chamber matches of all time!

10. Elimination Chamber 2012

CM Punk defeats Dolph Ziggler, Chris Jericho, The Miz, Kofi Kingston and R-Truth to retain the WWE Championship http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Eogws0y80-Q Believe it or not, R-Truth has been in three Elimination Chamber matches, which is a tie for 10th most all time appearances with guys like The Undertaker and Rey Mysterio. Two of those matches are on the list, including this one. What I liked about this match was the fact that these were all €œsmall€ guys (relatively speaking, of course), which at the time were representing a change in philosophy that it didn€™t matter how big you were. If you could work and were over enough with the fans, you deserved to be at the top. It helped matters that John Cena was already slated to face The Rock in the Wrestlemania main event, so the title scene on Raw didn€™t have to be bogged down with Cena€™s presence, allowing guys like Dolph Ziggler start to make their climb toward the top. The array of talent in the match allowed for unique spots, including Punk and Kingston attempting to fly at Ziggler at the same time, only to have Dolph move out of the way at the last minute and allow Punk and Kofi to crash into each other, spawning this awesome GIF. What I enjoyed the most about this night was that both CM Punk and Daniel Bryan retained their titles (which wasn€™t a complete lock), allowing the Ring of Honor alumni to walk into Wrestlemania with the top two titles in WWE. If this was the year 2005 and you told me that would happen seven years down the road, I€™d try to have you committed.

9. Elimination Chamber 2011

Edge defeats Rey Mysterio, Wade Barrett, Drew McIntyre, Big Show and Kane to retain the World Heavyweight Championship http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5Oho_2Yr8AE This would be one of the last title defenses for Edge before he was forced to retire due to chronic neck pain that was likely caused by participating in matches like these. Two parts of this match stick out at me the most. The first involved Drew McIntyre, who was extremely vicious in this match, throwing Rey through the plexiglass and kicking the hell out of people. I remember a lot of people talking about how this would be the start of Drew€™s big push, and here we are four years later, and he€™s still toiling in 3MB. At least he€™s employed though, right? The second thing I loved about this match was that the two wrestlers who started the match, Edge and Rey Mysterio, were the two wrestlers who finished, something that has only happened one other time in Elimination Chamber history. In a match that€™s designed to favor bigger men, seeing Rey make it to the finals (twice!) is really cool.

8. No Way Out 2008

Undertaker defeats Batista, Big Daddy V, The Great Khali, MVP and Finlay to earn a World Heavyweight Championship match at Wrestlemania 24 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XqP07Q5ou0Y That other match where entrants 1 and 2 lasted all the way to the end? That would be this one. Believe it or not, Undertaker and Batista were trusted to carry the load for this match, even with guys like MVP and Finlay in there who you could argue have better stamina than the two main eventers. Yes, plodding workers like Big Daddy V and The Great Khali were in this match as well, but they were dispatched rather quickly after entering the match. Both MVP and Finlay got serious exposure in this match in being able to hang with the top dogs. The finishing sequence between Undertaker and Batista was also excellent, as these two had a great series of matches in 2007 and had already developed great rapport with each other.

7. Summerslam 2003

Triple H defeats Goldberg, Kevin Nash, Chris Jericho, Shawn Michaels, and Randy Orton to retain the World Heavyweight Championship http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2couJtlry34 The ending to this match is infamous, which is why it€™s not higher up on the list, but everything leading up to the ridiculous ending was good enough to warrant its inclusion on this list. However, I feel we should address the 300-pound sledgehammer in the room when we talk about this match. Let me take you back to 2003, which was the height of Triple H animosity generated on the Internet. I€™d argue it€™s for good reason. The biggest problem with Triple H in 2003 wasn€™t that he supposedly held people down, it€™s that he was seriously injured and refused to give up the World Title, because in WWE€™s minds, they needed a long reign out of Triple H to bring legitimacy to a World Championship that was just introduced. Around this time, Trips had a serious groin injury, serious enough that he was wearing girdles as wrestling gear rather than his normal trunks. The original main event was supposed to be him vs. Goldberg one on one for the World Title, and Goldberg was going to win. However, due to the injury, there was no way that Triple H was going to be able to work a full match with Goldberg, so WWE called an audible and set up the second-ever Elimination Chamber match to allow everybody else to do the heavy lifting. So we get to the match, and leading up to Hunter€™s entry (at number 6, the last spot), it was pretty good. We got a continuation of Shawn Michaels and Chris Jericho€™s rivalry with them entering at 1 and 2, and we got some flashes of what kind of main event player Randy Orton would be in his first ever main event at the ripe old age of 23. And Kevin Nash was in there as well, I think? Anyway, when Goldberg came out at number 5, he tore through everybody with amazing ferocity. He eliminated internet darlings Jericho and Michaels, and nobody there in Phoenix that night cared. The Elimination Chamber match was supposed to be about carnage, and Goldberg gave it to them. The time was absolutely right for Goldberg to win the World Championship. However, Triple H only got in one offensive move, a sledgehammer shot to the face, which was enough for him to beat Goldberg and retain the World Title. The crowd was absolutely killed dead. The reason, I suspect, was that somebody had convinced Vince that Hunter had to drop the belt to Goldberg one-on-one for the title switch to have any sort of legitimacy. So they put off the one-on-one match another month until Unforgiven, where about 100,000 less pairs of eyes would be watching, and even less people would care. By the time Trips eventually dropped the belt, Goldberg€™s credibility was completely ruined, mostly because of his Elimination Chamber. His title reign ended up being a bust, and the belt was back on Hunter before the year was out. But again, I stress that the audacity of the ending should not take away from the excellence that preceded it.

6. Elimination Chamber 2010

John Cena defeated Sheamus, Triple H, Randy Orton, Ted Dibiase and Kofi Kingston to win the WWE Championship http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BMyCQhXdtYw Most people will probably remember the ending to this Chamber match, where Vince McMahon forced John Cena to immediately defend his title against Batista after winning the title, which was very reminiscent of Cena€™s Chamber victory at New Year€™s Revolution 2006. What makes this one different is that the actual chamber match was of very high quality. There were a lot of overlapping storylines going into this match. We were beginning to see the end of the Legacy faction as Dibiase was supposed to act as an enforcer for Orton but there was always the threat he€™d go into business for himself. Ironically, it ended up being Cody Rhodes€™s botched interference that led to Orton€™s elimination. The next storyline involved Triple H eliminating Sheamus in the middle of the match, thereby guaranteeing there would be a new champion crowned in the match. I really liked that wrinkle, and a Chamber that will be higher on this list had something similar. Oh yeah€there was also this€ With the tension now heightened, the finish of the match involving Triple H and Cena was hot, and Trips tapping out (again) to the STF got a huge reaction.

5. No Way Out 2008

Triple H defeats Jeff Hardy, Shawn Michaels, JBL, Umaga and Chris Jericho to earn a WWE Championship match at Wrestlemania 24 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-wq-r4sv874 I really like this chamber match because it featured six of the top eight wrestlers on Raw at the time (with the other two being Cena and Orton, who were in the WWE Title match on that show), and I enjoy star-studded Chamber matches with no obvious exclusions. This was right around the time where Jeff Hardy€™s popularity was beginning to come to a boil (just before he stupidly got a Wellness Policy violation and missed out on winning Money in the Bank at Wrestlemania. He lasted until the very end against Triple H and had a couple of nearfalls on The Game before succumbing to the Pedigree. This match also included some excellent wrestling between Shawn Michaels and Chris Jericho (who was still a babyface at the time) to start the match, whetting our appetites for the monumental feud they would have later in the year.

4. Elimination Chamber 2010

Chris Jericho defeats The Undertaker, CM Punk, Rey Mysterio, R-Truth and John Morrison to win the World Heavyweight Title http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cEvz8LBX_cY This gets Top 5 inclusion solely for the ending, but it€™s worth it. You knew that Shawn Michaels, after months of his requests for a Wrestlemania rematch with Undertaker being spurned, was going to do *something* in this match, but I doubt many people would have guessed he€™s come up though the Chamber itself! Oh, and did I mention Undertaker worked the entire match after being accidentally set on fire during his entrance? My respect for the Deadman just about quadrupled after that.

3. New Year€™s Revolution 2005

Triple H defeated Randy Orton, Chris Jericho, Chris Benoit, Batista, and Edge to win the vacant World Heavyweight Championship http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GwpQ6jLMIG0 This is the Chamber match we€™re not really allowed to talk about if we€™re WWE because it involved Wrestler X. We€™ll just bypass Wrestler X here. This match featured seven of the top workers in the entire company (including the referee, Shawn Michaels, who was just returning from a pretty serious knee injury). The amount of storylines in this match were crazy. First, there was Shawn Michaels and Edge. Edge had speared HBK back at Taboo Tuesday because he was jealous that Shawn got the fan€™s vote to face Triple H when he was injured, effectively turning heel. Edge speared HBK during this match, and got Sweet Chin Music for his troubles. This kick-started the underrated rivalry between the two which led to a great technical wrestling match at Royal Rumble and an even better street fight on Raw. Then there was the emerging storyline of Batista getting too good and too popular for Evolution and Triple H. Going into the match, Batista was to play enforcer for The Game (similar to how Ted Dibaise was going to for Randy Orton in 2010), and as the match came down to the final three, Randy Orton hit Batista with an RKO, and you could see Triple H start to go for the save before slumping back down in the corner, refusing to save Big Dave and letting him get eliminated. It was one of the best matches in 2005, a year chock-full of fantastic bouts.

2. No Way Out 2009

Triple H defeated Edge, The Undertaker, Jeff Hardy, Vladimir Kozlov and Big Show to win the WWE Championship http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=siFT6mS_WbY This Chamber match is one of the more underrated matches in WWE lore. Not only did they have the brilliant decision of having Edge lose his title in a fluke rollup by Jeff Hardy about four minutes into the match, which left the rest of the match with the excitement that we were guaranteed a new champion, but it had one of the greatest €œfinal two€ finishing sequences in all of the Chamber matches. With both men on Smackdown at the same time (a rarity), Triple H and Undertaker had the opportunity to go one-on-one for the first time since 2002. Both men showed what true veterans and professionals they were, and put on a classic match in its own right with several near-falls and false finishes. This would give fans a glimpse of what they would see from the two in their Wrestlemania matches two and three years later.

1. Survivor Series 2002

Shawn Michaels defeated Triple H, Rob Van Dam, Chris Jericho, Kane and Booker T to win the World Heavyweight Championship http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iOJaJPwxrDM There€™s nothing quite like the original. The setting was perfect: Madison Square Garden. The combatants were the top six men on Raw. It was going to be only Shawn Michaels€™s second match in four years in a structure that nobody was quite sure what to make of. But if anybody can put on a show and set the bar for a new type of specialty match (Ladder, Hell in a Cell, etc.), it was Shawn Michaels. Frankly I don€™t think this match would be so high on this list or as memorable if Triple H successfully defended the championship. But the fact that Shawn did win the belt after four years away is what makes this one of the most memorable matches of all time, and an easy headliner for this list. Triple H, to his credit, wrestled most of the match with a crushed larynx after RVD hit him with a frog splash from the top of the cage. The entire match, he was having trouble breathing, and yet he still managed to go through the finishing sequence with HBK and not miss a beat. So where will this year€™s Chamber match fall on this list? The competitors look to be a solid lineup, and I€™m pleased with the inclusion of Antonio Cesaro and Christian, two great workers who are underappreciated. I€™m looking forward to seeing the Pay Per View, and hopefully it will be better than the Rumble, although that€™s not really going to be a hard feat to top.

Contributor
Contributor

Justin has been writing about professional wrestling for more than 15 years. A lifelong WWE fan, he also is a big fan of Ring of Honor.